Study: Conservative Talk Radio Responsible For Death Of Immigration Reform

Politico   |  Mike Allen   |   August 20, 2007 09:07 AM


stumbleupon :Study: Conservative Talk Radio Responsible For Death Of Immigration Reform   digg: Study: Conservative Talk Radio Responsible For Death Of Immigration Reform   reddit: Study: Conservative Talk Radio Responsible For Death Of Immigration Reform   del.icio.us: Study: Conservative Talk Radio Responsible For Death Of Immigration Reform

Opposition from key talk radio and cable TV hosts "helped kill the immigration bill in Congress," a study out today concludes.

"What listeners of the conservative talk radio media were hearing, in large part, was that the legislation itself was little more than an 'amnesty bill' for illegal immigrants, a phrase loaded with political baggage," it says.

Comments for this post are now closed

 
Comments
96
Pending Comments
0
iPhone App Promo

Want to reply to a comment? Hint: Click "Reply" at the bottom of the comment; after being approved your comment will appear directly underneath the comment you replied to

View Comments:
Page: 1 2 Next › Last » (2 pages total)

I don't care who stopped it because the immigration bill was flawed. It was not the death of immigration reform. It was the death of immigration reform that would not work.

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 10:26 AM on 08/21/2007

It is obvious that both the Democrats and Republicans want the Latino votes and neither mind pandering to groups that want more free government supplied and tax payer funded benefits to law breakers.

It is no wonder why this country is so screwed up all the time.

To hell with the Mexican, the North American Union, and anyone that does not speak English or refuses to learn English in the US.
We also do not want that horrible Trans Texas corridor or the secret society group the Beiderbecks getting involved in ruining the country.

Texas Governor Rick Perry is meeting with them to fast track the Trans Texas Corridor. In the worst case would run from central Mexico to the larger cities in Canada. If that happens, there will be no control of any immigration.

Then the country will be more in the toilet than it is currently. There will be bloodshed in the streets and at the Southern Border to keep the law breaking / drug smuggling / grey market garbage out.

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 09:57 AM on 08/21/2007

Thank God for Lou Dobbs and the Minutemen. Someone need to protect our border from the invading herds of wretched refuge. The governemnt is horribly corrupt and it is up to the US citizent to stand up for justice in fighting lawlessness and the broken southern border. Join in the cause by boycotting all things in Spanish.

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 09:40 AM on 08/21/2007

Immigration laws very-much exist to PROTECT the immigrant from the ruthless exploitation .. slavery .. to which they are otherwise routinely subjected.

Most distressing to me is the fact that none of the official proposals are really OFFERING these people a path to Citizenship. It is only a path by which they would continue to be exploited, and exploitable.

I would cheerfully pay ten cents more a head for lettuce, if ...

Let's be frank here: slavery, obviously, has NOT gone-away from the agricultural fields of this country. Not in a hundred and forty years.

For their protection as human-beings as well as our own, "if you are here, you must be legal; otherwise you must not be here. Those who bring you here illegally and harbor you and employ you are breaking the law." But that's not what the policy makers want: they want slav... ahem, "guest workers."

Wrong. Wrong. Wrong.

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 09:18 AM on 08/21/2007

The biggest problem with conservative talk radio is that it encourages idiots who don't know what they're talking about to express their "opinions" anyway, and as we all know, opinions are like assholes, everybody's got one. Many of the posters here are ample proof of that.

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 11:42 PM on 08/20/2007
- CLR I'm a Fan of CLR permalink

Fact: ILLEGALS cost US tax payers BILLIONS.
Fact: ILLEGALS are sucking our educational and health care systems dry.

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 12:29 AM on 08/21/2007

Fact: Illegals contribute to social security system with out ever being able to reclaim what they contributed.

FACT Employers of Illegals contribute to Social Security with out ever having claim to it.

FACT Illegals are already here and aren't going to go away.

FACT: Illegals make it possible for you to eat out in restaurants at costs you can afford.Purchase produce at dirt cheap prices...

Fact: Illegals are exactly like you and me. We love our familys and we just want to be able to give them a home and sustinance.

Fact: They were here before you were! This is their land too! We stole the west from them.


Deal with those facts.
BTW, I think you are a liar with your "facts"

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 12:05 PM on 08/21/2007
photo

Where I live, a woman who was to have been deported 10 years ago recently lost her 4 year old son to murder. Even though she was to have been tossed ten years ago, immigration agreed to let her leave the country to bury her son in her homeland and then RETURN to the United States.

I have no problem if you are here legally to work. I understand that many illegals work as hard or hard when they are here, and many of them pay taxes. But the fact remains that people who are here LEGALLY have trouble getting the social services they need.

Of course, some Republicans support amnesty because this is a huge cheap labor pool that won't complain too strenuously.

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 11:20 PM on 08/20/2007
photo

Oh, gee, I thought it was all the Democrats fault Bush's bills don't get passed.

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 10:34 PM on 08/20/2007

Some people "study" too much, and obviously get paid far too much money to do it.

"Freedom of speech" never de-railed any public policy that was actually worth its salt to begin with. But "freedom of speech" DOES have a remarkable ability to slice through layers of bulls*it in very short order.

When in our forefather's generation "huddled masses yearning to breathe free" came to our shores, they all knew they would land on Ellis Island. And they all knew that if they didn't meet the immigration requirements they would be deported without having once set foot upon the shores of the Promised Land. But they also knew that if they DID pass muster, it would BE "the Promised Land."

What do we offer our neighbors from the Country to the South? Only the opportunity to remain "huddled masses," working as slaves (oh, let's call them what they ARE...) in our artichoke fields, never to improve their lot.

Is -this- the best that America can offer to the world ... today?

No, I didn't think so either.

And if a radio host (or anyone else) "calls a spade a spade," that's called Freedom of Speech. If you are the emperor and you have no clothes ...

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 10:32 PM on 08/20/2007

... then the person who said, "Look, He's Naked!"

.. did not DISROBE you, now did he?

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 10:33 PM on 08/20/2007

I wanted to work with the poor..the working people who were having a hard time paying for health care...but what I got was working for ILLEGALS. The poor Americans? Oh no....you work as a waitress, and need our help? Forget it. We tell you we can't take you because you make a couple bucks too much. I'm dead serious. I got fooled into thinking that I could help those in my country who needed a little help. What I got instead was slaving over a bunch of spanish-speaking illegals...who don't report income, and who EXPECT the best for free. You know what? I'll shut up, but I'm quitting this job and going to work for a hospital who takes only INSURANCE..because I can't help my fellow citizens. It's impossible. Thanks, and i'll shut up about it.

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 10:02 PM on 08/20/2007
- Peg I'm a Fan of Peg permalink

beachy you're full of s**t.
If you're a nurse stay the h**l away from real people. You sound like one of the biggest racists in America. If someday you fall ill, and perhaps end up in a nursing home, where it may be that only those "dirty Mexicans" will take it upon themselves to care for you, I hope they'll be more compassionate than you seem to be.
Read your posts then imagine showing them to your boss (maybe I'm your boss) or your children, maybe your parents, or siblings. Would you be proud or embarrassed? Your answer may give you some insight into how you'll spend your last days on earth.

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 11:22 PM on 08/20/2007
photo

Right wing hate radio can be very influential ..with dire consequences


Radio Mille Collines

Rwanda Tribunal Finds Media Executives Guilty of Genocide

By Anthony Dworkin

In a landmark verdict, the war crimes tribunal for Rwanda has convicted three media executives of genocide for inciting people to take part in the wave of killing that swept across Rwanda in 1994. The defendants were found guilty for their use of a popular radio station and a newspaper to inflame hatred against the country"s Tutsi minority and to direct and encourage the campaign of slaughter.

Around 800,000 people " primarily Tutsis, along with some moderate Hutus who defended them " were killed during a few months in Rwanda in 1994. During the genocide, RTLM frequently broadcast statements inciting people to kill Tutsis " at one point telling its listeners, "We must finish with them, exterminate them, sweep them from the whole country¦" The station also alerted its listeners about locations where Tutsis were taking refuge, and incited them to pursue named individuals. In the words of Philip Gourevitch, author of the book "We Wish to Inform You That Tomorrow We Will Be Killed With Our Families," the station"s message "was unambiguous and was acted on."

http://www.crimesofwar.org/print/onnews/rwanda-print.html

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 09:10 PM on 08/20/2007

DO YOU CALL THAT REFORM??? The future of America does not look worthy of love, but worthy of leaving it. Call it white-flight or brain-drain or quality-depreciation. I'm outta here, sooner's better than later. Oh yeah, & don't forget to turn off the lights. All politicians - white, women, lawyers, young to old or rich - are the all poor. So start the revolution without me (& make it worldwide)!

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 08:24 PM on 08/20/2007


Bye

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 08:41 PM on 08/20/2007

I have been working in landscaping for 32 years. At first I worked with mostly " white guys"...then gradually it became all hispanic. What I have learned: The immigrants were harder working, more honest, modest, and much more reliable than most of the white fellas I worked with...As a woman in the field, I got greater respect from the hispanic co-workers than the other guys.

And remember this.... 7.55 % of their wages PLUS a matched amount from the employer goes into the social security fund every week.

Illegal or legal. The US gov't takes in billions and billions of SS funds from these hard working people and their employers... and the illegals will not be collecting any of it. Where in the hell has all that money gone?

If SS is going bankrupt...it's not because of the illegals....
Perhaps our fed gov't steals... oops... I mean borrows it....

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 08:08 PM on 08/20/2007
- hjo4 I'm a Fan of hjo4 permalink

It sad that you have respect for people who have willingly broken our laws and disrespect our Great Nation.It's obvious our laws mean nothing to you.Oh fyi,illegal aliens cost the American taxpayer more money than they'll ever contribute to this country.What is so wrong for us to ask that people immigrate into our country legally?

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 08:55 PM on 08/20/2007

their contribution to the community and to the economy is tremendous...I live amongst and welcome their love of family and their work ethic. These are deeply religous people. People who have suffered deep poverty. I think many americans are afraid of anything different. Does it scare you to think of yourself as a minorty? Well, guess what... we whities are a minorty and its getting smaller. I see a time when all the races have been blended like a fine wine. The best of all people.

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 09:06 PM on 08/20/2007

A question for all you anti "amnesty" people. What is the solution you propose? It's easy to be "anti". Give me a solution. What to do with the many millions who are here already here working and raising their children?

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 07:55 PM on 08/20/2007

Way back in the 80s Ronald Regan got a "one time only" amnesty for illegals with the promise of tighter border security. This is just history repeating. It was PROVEN not to work. One sign of insanity is to keep repeating a behavior and expecting a different outcome.
What I don't understand is the apologists for the criminal tresspassors (illegals) propose no solutions themselves. Are you saying that the USA has no right to national borders? My solution? Enforce the laws already on the books. Maybe make them tougher. Put people who hire illegals in jail. If it's a big corporation-the CEO in jail. If that happened I assure you the illegals would stop coming because no one would hire them. The illegals already here would probably leave, if they could not get work. No need to hunt them down and deport them. They'd leave on their own.

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 08:07 PM on 08/20/2007

"What I don't understand is the apologists for the criminal tresspassors (illegals) propose no solutions themselves. Are you saying that the USA has no right to national borders?"


I agree that the one time amnesty didn't fulfill Regan's promises... but here's where I differ with regan. I would erase the borders..once and for all...
Now, I know, The USofA and all other countries do now have the "right to national borders"...but a big part of me wonders,where were the secure borders when europeans moved in on the natives in 1608. I don't remember what the immigrant quota was then...anyone recall?
Also, as a left coast lib, I seem to remember the earlier inhabitants here were hispanic or even russian or inuit,But we all did the westward ho thing...So now, after a century or so the scene is returning to those days and everyone calls FOUL...This land is not our land unless "our" means all of us. Think globally...
I hope I didn't shock the kids with the left coast librul talk.


    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 09:00 PM on 08/20/2007
- hjo4 I'm a Fan of hjo4 permalink

Give me a solution. What to do with the many millions who are here already here working and raising their children?
We enforce the current immigration laws on the books, hold employers legally responsible for hiring illegal aliens.Deny all benefits to illegal aliens (they shouldn't be here anyway).It will not be pleasant or attractive but we are a nation of laws and people must be held accountable for violating them.We treat our own citizens no different when holding them accountable for committing crimes, why not illegal aliens.If life is made uncomfortable for them,the laws enforced they will leave voluntarily.The 14th amendment must be re-visited and changed denying citizenship to children of illegal aliens.That's how we can begin to solve the illegal invasion of illegal aliens.

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 08:45 PM on 08/20/2007

'Immigration reform' is a euphemism for 'we'll leave the gate unlocked for ya', and nothing less. For the last 25 years or so, there's been what sure looks like deliberate negligence practiced at both our borders, long, long lists of companies busted/being busted for hiring people using fake ID, rolling drug labs, counterfeiting, gangs, you name it, the common denominator has been flaky border policy, and even flakier enforcement of that policy.

Bienvenidos a la Union De America Del Norte, El Presidente Senor Bush presiding! Viva! Viva! Um, yeah...viva whatever...

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 07:11 PM on 08/20/2007

Have you ever seen the photos of GWB in his hat that says Jefe? I think that says it all. Bush is quite OK with illegals as long as he's part of the Jefe (boss) class.

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 07:50 PM on 08/20/2007

We used to have a huge migrant population from Italy and Ireland. What happened? Ireland and Italy became decent places to live. Mexico is a beautiful country with warm and pleasant people. The rich few take everything and make the situation in that country intolerable for the majority. Same for many of the countries that the illegal (and legal) immigrants come from. But don't worry, once Bush and his pals have finished turning the USA into a third world country by transferring all the wealth and power to the Financial Aristocracy, nobody will WANT to come here. It will be as big a hole as thier own countries already are. Problem solved. Heck of a job George.

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 07:07 PM on 08/20/2007

The difference was there was no NAFTA in Ireland and Italy to keep wages low and keep immigration flowing.
Repeal NAFTA, vote Kucinich.

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 01:16 AM on 08/21/2007
Page: 1 2 Next › Last » (2 pages total)
Comments are closed for this entry

You must be logged in to reply to this comment. Log in  or  Connect