Sam Stein

BIO

Sam Stein

The Huffington Post

Mystery Deepens: Several Recipients Of Anti-Mormon Calls Are Romney Staffers

November 21, 2007 09:32 AM


stumbleupon :Mystery Deepens: Several Recipients Of Anti-Mormon Calls Are Romney Staffers   digg: Mystery Deepens: Several Recipients Of Anti-Mormon Calls Are Romney Staffers   reddit: Mystery Deepens: Several Recipients Of Anti-Mormon Calls Are Romney Staffers   del.icio.us: Mystery Deepens: Several Recipients Of Anti-Mormon Calls Are Romney Staffers

Yet another connection, albeit an indirect one, now ties Mitt Romney's presidential campaign to the recent spat of anti-Mormon phone calls made in New Hampshire and Iowa.

Several recipients of the calls, which raised questions about Romney's Mormon faith and military deferments, are prominent supporters of the former Massachusetts governor.

Marshan Roth of Fairfield, Iowa, who is paid $500 a month as a GOTV (get out the vote) consultant for the Romney campaign, received a call on this past Wednesday night. Rose Kramer of Dubuque, Iowa, who co-chairs Romney's Iowa faith & values steering committee and is a $1,000-a-month GOTV consultant, received a call either that same day or a day earlier, depending on conflicting reports.

Roth and Kramer are now the third members of Romney's Iowa campaign to have publicly acknowledged received the calls. Ralph Watts, a state representative in Iowa, who also backs the former governor, was one of the first people to come forward.

And yet, during subsequent press interviews, neither Roth nor Kramer disclosed the positions they held on Romney's team. In fact, as several other reporters have pointed out, both individuals drastically downplayed their campaign associations. And in an interview with the Salt Lake Tribune, Roth took the opportunity to lash out against Sen. John McCain, the presidential candidate initially thought to be behind the calls.

"It was sick. It really was. It made me just furious," Roth told the paper. "If you didn't know enough about McCain, you'd think he was the white knight coming in on his charger saving the world and that Mitt Romney was tantamount to the devil."

The fact that three people on Romney's Iowa campaign staff found themselves on the receiving end of these controversial calls has led to suggestions that the candidate or organization behind the survey wanted it to go public. (Romney supporters were far more likely to come forward as the questions asked were offensive to the candidate they support).

However, the possibility exists that Roth, Kramer and Watts were all contacted by sheer coincidence. There are, to be sure, thousands of Iowa supporters for Mitt Romney among the state's caucus goers. The phone call survey undoubtedly contacted more than these three. As Kevin Madden, a spokesperson for the governor, noted, "I expect it's a statistical probability that any voter could get called."

But it also cannot be ignored that, even after the scandal surfaced, the actors involved were often in Romney's camp. Justin Hart, who serves on the Romney For President National Faith And Values Steering Committee and is a blogger at MyManMitt.com, was the only person contacted by a source in Western Wats for comment.

This Wednesday morning, Hart again weighed into the fray. Tracking down both Roth and Kramer, he was able to confirm that they received the calls, phoned their local Romney office, told their stories, and were then referred to the press. Whether or not Western Wats deliberately targeted the two Romney staffers, in anticipation that they would go public, is something likely to be determined by the New Hampshire Attorney General's office, if it chooses to investigate.

Update: TPM Election Central's Greg Sargent confirms with Romney spokesman Kevin Madden that Madden did not disclose the campaign affiliations of Roth and Kramer when he referred them to reporters.

Update II: An interesting take from a well-connected Republican:

"You wouldn't do this to yourself unless you wanted it to be known. So, what better way to do it then to orchestrate with people who are supporters of yours and then make sure that people know about it by the mere fact that you have them call your own staffers... If this is true [that Romney is behind this] his campaign has created a real problem for himself. The base supporters are not really wedded to him and now you have Huckabee ascending and he is just as acceptable for a lot of these people, as Romney. [Huckabee] becomes an acceptable alternative for people repelled by this mini scandal."

Comments for this post are now closed

 
Comments
88
Pending Comments
0
iPhone App Promo

Want to reply to a comment? Hint: Click "Reply" at the bottom of the comment; after being approved your comment will appear directly underneath the comment you replied to

View Comments:
Page: « First ‹ Previous 1 2 3 Next › Last » (3 pages total)

Of course Romney is behind the calls.

That's a foregone conclusion.

What everyone wants to know now is when is he (Romney) going to apologize to McCain?

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 06:19 PM on 11/21/2007
- zull2 I'm a Fan of zull2 40 fans permalink
photo

These calls are straight up from Guiliani. He's playing a hamfisted game in the spirit of Karl Rove...essentially, playing McCain off Romney.

Which is funny too, because I hear they all have a bigger worry in Huckabee there in Iowa. But if they go after Huckabee, they risk ticking off the SocialCons.

And people think it's rough on the Left...the games they're playing there on the right make the mild cattiness between Clinton, Edwards, and Obama look like mild jabs between old pals. The top three on the right have been so brutal and made such a mess of it that they've got no prayer of winning now. The SocialCons are split between those who accept Mormons and those who don't, the neocons are split four ways between Guiliani, McCain, Romney, and Paul...that's a verifiable mess. The only way Bush was able to get 49% of the vote in 2000 was to consolidate as much from both the socialcon and neocon camps as he could...and even then he almost lost. In 2004, he had to rely on a few momentarily scared moderates who voted conservative because of fear tactics, smear tactics, and terrorism...and that, along with all that money for targeted negative ads, still only got him 51%. How can any Republican even dream that they could win this election with this big a mess?

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 05:17 PM on 11/21/2007

What's obvious is that MittWeed the DickWeed genuinely believes he's smarter than anyone else; why else would he create such an easily-disproved scenario? Telephone lines and donors: who would be smart enough to check those? Granted, the major media has been giving MittyPat a big wet kiss up to now, so he probably didn't see this coming. Then again, this story didn't come from the major media.

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 04:55 PM on 11/21/2007

It's The Devil doing it (Bush can't run again, so not Rove). Maybe it is Rudy!!! Jack Out.

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 04:29 PM on 11/21/2007
- Rrhain I'm a Fan of Rrhain 14 fans permalink

Picking nits:

It's "sheer" coincidence, not "shear."

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 03:55 PM on 11/21/2007
- mimsnpips I'm a Fan of mimsnpips 13 fans permalink
photo

I really doubt McCain was behind the calls. He has one or two scruples left in there somewhere.
Since Mitt will never ever be the repug nominee I can only think someone inside his own campaign is behind it. Or just another kook out there.
..next story please..

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 03:51 PM on 11/21/2007
- VOTER I'm a Fan of VOTER 201 fans permalink
photo

The Canine Society has voted.

Mitt's campaign is guilty of attempting to get

sympathy votes.

WOOF WOOF BOW-WOW!

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 03:38 PM on 11/21/2007

Since Mitt has zero chance of being President, attacks against his campaign, even if self-inflicted, are irrelevant. Meanwhile, MSM is declaring victory in Iraq again this month. Whack-a-mole has temporarily deserted Baghdad for Afghanistan, Pakistan and Kurdistan. So now, if we can spare a few troops from Iraq, we can rush some more fingers into a few of the dikes other leaks. Or we could finally get smart, declare Asia a Jewish State and go home.

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 03:33 PM on 11/21/2007
- stlrfan I'm a Fan of stlrfan 2 fans permalink

Mittwit=Bullshit

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 02:35 PM on 11/21/2007
- Cid I'm a Fan of Cid 4 fans permalink

The Bush Administration:

Redefining "Torture" and "Democracy" since 2001.
.

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 02:26 PM on 11/21/2007
- Ramus I'm a Fan of Ramus 31 fans permalink

smells like Rudy

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 02:19 PM on 11/21/2007
- Northlite I'm a Fan of Northlite 10 fans permalink

Mitt Romney has proven himself to be a serial liar whose ambitions warrant saying and doing anything that he thinks will advance HIMSELF, which is all he cares about. When he ran for governor here, he told us repeatedly that he would defend gay rights and a woman's right to choose. More than any other candidate, his values are shallow to non-existent. He showed us in Mass. that he did not care about us. He doesn't care about the people of this nation--He only cares about MITT. He is a proven serial liar and this time it looks like he will get caught. What a shallow man he is.

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 01:42 PM on 11/21/2007
- NABNYC I'm a Fan of NABNYC 99 fans permalink

Karl Rove supposedly did something very similar in a Texas election. Rove was working on the campaign of some good old boy who was headed for defeat. Then a few days before the election, the good old boy politician "discovered" that "someone" had planted a listening device in his office. Of course the suggestion was that it was his opponent. Good old boy won the election.

As soon as there was time to actually investigate the claim, it was discovered that the battery in the listening device would last for 8 hours maximum, so unless someone was sneaking in and out every 8 hours to change the battery, it looked like the whole claimed "bugging" was nonsense. Made up by Rove? To make the other politician look dirty?

Did Mitt copy something out of Karl's playbook?

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 01:29 PM on 11/21/2007
- Simone I'm a Fan of Simone 6 fans permalink

Marshan Roth - is paid $500 a month.
Rose Kramer - is a $1,000-a-month consultant.

He's buying support. Too bad he can't get people to actually volunteer for his campaign.

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 01:23 PM on 11/21/2007

I Think its the Clintons sounds just like some of thier crap.

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 12:47 PM on 11/21/2007
Page: « First ‹ Previous 1 2 3 Next › Last » (3 pages total)
Comments are closed for this entry

 You must be logged in to comment. Log in  or connect with 

Connect