Abstinence Only, abstinence only AIDS funding, africa AIDS, africa AIDS aid money, aids, AIDS aid money, George Bush, President Bush
Abstinence Only, abstinence only AIDS funding, africa AIDS, africa AIDS aid money, aids, AIDS aid money, George Bush, President Bush

In Africa, Bush Wants AIDS Plan Renewed

JENNIFER LOVEN | February 17, 2008 03:30 PM EST | AP

Compare other versions »

digg Share this on Facebook Huffpost - stumble reddit del.ico.us RSS

DAR ES SALAAM, Tanzania — President Bush rejected proposed Democratic changes to his prized AIDS relief program, issuing a challenge Sunday to Congress to "stop the squabbling" and renew it as is. Tanzanian leader Jakaya Kikwete made an impassioned appeal for the same thing, saying thousands in his country would orphan their children if U.S. lawmakers do not act.

There is broad support in the Democratic-controlled Congress for the anti-AIDS spending that has become the largest-ever international health initiative devoted to one disease, so there is not much danger of failing to continue it.

But with the program expiring this year, a political and ideological showdown is brewing in Washington over the initiative's terms and size. Bush hopes that putting real, grateful faces on the program _ moms and dads controlling the disease and children who were born HIV-free to infected mothers, all because of U.S.-funded treatment _ would strengthen his hand in the debate.

The president's three-night stay in this vast East Africa nation takes him to a part of the continent that is important in the U.S. fight against terrorism. The bombed-out former U.S. Embassy in Dar es Salaam still stands as a stark reminder of deadly attacks in Tanzania and Nairobi, Kenya, in 1998.

The visit to Tanzania is the longest of Bush's six-day African trip and longer than usual for the president anywhere. The stay and the celebration of a new five-year $698 million U.S. aid pact were intended as goodwill messages to Tanzania's large Muslim population.

It seemed to work. In contrast to the protests that often greet him at home and abroad, Bush repeatedly received enthusiastic receptions in Tanzania.

Thousands of people lined his motorcade route from the airport Saturday night. A large and spirited crowd waved U.S. and Tanzanian flags Sunday as he walked into the graceful, oceanfront State House for meetings with President Kikwete.

Thousands more people crowded along Dar es Salaam's dusty and rutted streets as Bush went from event to event. Special local cloth was woven in honor of Bush's visit; his picture was emblazoned across ever-present shirts and sarongs.

A billboard advertisement in downtown for a Kilimanjaro Casino poker tournament offered a coincidental but telling message: "A little bit of Texas in Dar," it said.

"Different people may have different views about you and your administration and your legacy," said a grateful Kikwete after he and Bush signed the aid deal. "But we in Tanzania, if we are to speak for ourselves and for Africa, we know for sure that you, Mr. President, and your administration, have been good friends of our country and have been good friends of Africa."

Democratic presidential candidate Barack Obama, who is black and whose father was Kenyan, is a sensation in Africa. Africans say they avidly follow Obama's campaign to succeed Bush.

But Bush seemed surprised that Obama's name would come up during this victory-lap journey that is celebrating some of his only foreign policies that make him popular.

"It seemed like there was a lot of excitement for me, wait a minute. Maybe you missed it," he joked during a news conference, speculating that a question about Obama was put to Kikwete instead of him because it was well known that "I wouldn't answer."

Kikwete appeared to get the hint, declining at Bush's side even to discuss the prospect of a man with African roots becoming president of the United States.

"I don't think I can venture into that territory, either," Kikwete said. "The U.S. is going to get a new president, whoever that one is. For us, the most important thing is, let him be as good friend of Africa as President Bush has been." Bush's term ends next January.

The President's Emergency Plan for AIDS Relief, known as PEPFAR, has raised the number of Africans on anti-retroviral treatments from 50,000 to 1.2 million.

Democrats want to strip requirements that one-third of the money go to abstinence-until-marriage programs and that some groups sign anti-prostitution pledges.

Some Democrats also say that Bush's request for $30 billion over the next five years, twice his original commitment of $15 billion, is too little, and would merely continue the program at the current year's ramped-up levels. Congress has put nearly $19 billion into the program so far.

Republican leaders say the Democratic changes could derail renewal of the program, and Bush made clear he agrees.

"I understand there's voices on both ends of the political spectrum trying to alter the program. I would ask Congress to listen to leaders on the continent of Africa, analyze what works, stop the squabbling and get the program reauthorized," the president said, the caws of peacocks occasionally punctuating remarks delivered in the blazing sun. "I happen to think the current policy is reasonable. After all, it's working."

Later, Bush said that Amana Hospital was the best exhibit he could imagine for his argument. Strolling through the complex of low-slung buildings and sun-drenched courtyards, Bush met HIV-positive patients and doctors in the facility's AIDS treatment wing, funded in part with money from his AIDS program.

"I'm very lucky," said Tatu Msangi, who was tested for HIV while pregnant, received treatment and delivered a healthy baby, Faith, who sat in her lap while she spoke. "Me and Faith have a bright future ahead."

Later, after separate events in Dar es Salaam to promote the program, first lady Laura Bush sounded less worried than her husband about its legislative future. "I don't think there will be a problem," she told reporters.

Kikwete said the program has allowed thousands of children such as Faith to avoid suffering the deaths of parents. "My passionate appeal is for PEPFAR to continue," he said.

Though Tanzania is one of the poorest countries in the world, it is gaining international investors, has among the best growth rates in sub-Saharan Africa and, as the home to striking Mount Kilimanjaro and the Serengeti National Park, is seeing tourism rise. There is little internal strife, though there are some worries about the political ambitions of semiautonomous Zanzibar, and Tanzania also is absorbing refugees from the postelection fighting in Kenya.

The U.S. aid deal, approved in September and signed in a ceremony Sunday, is through the Millennium Challenge Corporation. That Bush initiative limits U.S. development assistance to nations that embrace democracy and free markets, fight corruption and invest in education and health. The Tanzanian deal is the largest so far in the program and is focused on helping to build roads, make electricity more reliable, and increase access to safe drinking water.

"Our trip here has exceeded my expectations," Bush said in a dinner toast at the State House. On the lawn afterward, the leaders were treated to an energetic, whooping performance by traditional African dancers with feathers, bells, drums and flutes.

Comments for this post are now closed


 
Comments
120
Pending Comments
0
iPhone App Promo

Want to reply to a comment? Hint: Click "Reply" at the bottom of the comment; after being approved your comment will appear directly underneath the comment you replied to

View Comments:
Page: 1 2 3 Next › Last » (3 pages total)
- research I'm a Fan of research 291 fans permalink

Finkleberry

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 04:05 PM on 02/20/2008
- GH I'm a Fan of GH 8 fans permalink

The requirements are that one-third of the money being spent on the preventative portion of the program go for abstinence programs, not one-third of the money of the program.

Specifically the “U.S. Leadership Against HIV/Aids, TB and Malaria Act of 2003” mandates that 20% of the total budget allocated be spent the prevention of HIV, with 1/3 of those funds to be directed towards the abstinence issue.

The correct analysis would be that the requirements are that 6.7% of the money goes to abstinence-until-marriage programs. The difference here in the readily available facts and that which has been widely misreported for quite some time now is quite significant and worthy of some degree of investigation, or at least soul searching.

It would seem that this rather consistent inaccurate representation of such a monumental global life saving effort is self-perpetrating. In the very limited reporting of the Bush initiative over the years (In May, 2006, Newsweek wrote that only 3% of voters were even aware of the program – Newsweek did not actually report on the program, mind you), few articles are written and few interviews are conducted in which criticism over the "one-third abstinence" is not either directed at the program or in which it is solicited from the reporter from a guest. The media has been quite successful here in their agenda; few people have learned about the program, and most of those who find out about it are deeply troubled, because of misinformation pushed by the media. Fortunately for President Bush, one small fact stands tall - millions of lives have been touched and perhaps millions will be saved from HIV/Aids, Malaria and TB.

AS Bill Clinton once said, wish I'd done something this big when I was President.
David Corn, The Nation, has a similar view, in "Too Little, too late.: http://www.alternet.org/columnists/story/13632/

Additionally, The PEPFAR has already distributed some 1.9 billion condoms (since 2004).

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 11:59 AM on 02/19/2008

This abstinence only policy failure is not limited in our aid to AIDS-ravaged Africa. It is a staple of sex education in America. Imagine teaching someone to drive by telling them not to get in the car. I do HIV testing for young people and am required to tell them about abstinence. But you better be sure that I point them to the condom jar on their way out the door. With half of all new infections in the US occurring in people under 25 years old, and with STDs on the rise, it is time we allow our young people, and everyone including Africans, access to condoms and real education about how to protect themselves.

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 06:09 PM on 02/17/2008
- RedRooster I'm a Fan of RedRooster 21 fans permalink

One word sums up the idiocy of George W Bush - "simplism"

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 04:14 PM on 02/17/2008
- research I'm a Fan of research 291 fans permalink

Too tempting....

The one word....

"too simple"

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 08:27 PM on 02/18/2008
- homas I'm a Fan of homas 3 fans permalink

Bush can't abstain from screwing the American people.

Africa: Thanx for the money. We love you.

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 03:42 PM on 02/17/2008

If only your hideous parents had abstained.....

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 03:12 PM on 02/17/2008
- FogBelter I'm a Fan of FogBelter 293 fans permalink
photo

Focusing on abstinence in regards to combating AIDS is just another way of saying ...

Let it Spread.

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 02:46 PM on 02/17/2008
- wndrwrthg I'm a Fan of wndrwrthg 39 fans permalink
photo

Abstinence should be a part of sex education, but only small part. There is not much you can do, other than tell people "don't fuck around". A comprehensive program aimed at all aspects of sexual education including the use of condoms is what is needed. As an aside, the article tells of thousands lining the motorcade route cheering bush. Amazing, in Africa they can line the route, but here in America we cannot even get within a hundred yards of him. I know, I know, these were hand picked crowds,

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 02:22 PM on 02/17/2008
- research I'm a Fan of research 291 fans permalink

Agreed.

Condoms.

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 08:28 PM on 02/18/2008
- GH I'm a Fan of GH 8 fans permalink

Condoms? The President's program has distributed 1.9 billion condoms since 2004. I suspect this may have something to do with over a million lives being saved.

And the abstinence is a very small part of the massive program, approx. 6.7% of the funds is required to go here. It's 1/3 (abstinence) of the 20% (preventative) of the total - not 1/3rd of the total. The media keeps the lie alive, for negative political impact. Too bad they are not more concernced about saving lives.

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 11:52 AM on 02/19/2008
- mommadona I'm a Fan of mommadona 183 fans permalink
photo

"OH Yeah..and 'thou shall not kill' - got that?

That's from my "main man" Jesus....yeah....he's my 'main man'....I'm 'in like Flynn' with him, so you better just listen up and listen good, got that?"

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 02:19 PM on 02/17/2008

If only his parents had abstained.

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 02:10 PM on 02/17/2008
- OlongapoEd I'm a Fan of OlongapoEd 36 fans permalink

It never fails...point out unpleasant realities about Christians and/or Christianity and somebody is almost sure to try to kill the messenger. I haven't seen it overtly done here, but one favorite way of dealing with criticism is to argue along the lines of, "Oh, but *those* people aren't *real* Christians!" I have seen both Militant Reactionary Christians and "progressive Christians" do the same thing. I suppose it's part of their deep-seated need to promote the fallacy that "Christian = good person". Sophistry about the size of the subset that promotes abstinence cannot change the reality that it has been a *major* theme of Christian teachings throughout Christian history. So, if their perfect god made us, and if he wants us to be good, why isn't everyone abstinent...why do humans misbehave so often and in so many ways? Logically one shuold conclude that their god either deliberately made humans so that they would misbehave so much or that he does really lousy work.

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 01:53 PM on 02/17/2008
- OlongapoEd I'm a Fan of OlongapoEd 36 fans permalink

I misspelled "should"...the horror...the horror!

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 01:54 PM on 02/17/2008
- Mojane I'm a Fan of Mojane 11 fans permalink

In his case, abstinence didn't work, aborting him would have done us a world of good, and short of that, flushing at birth would have been merciful.

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 01:49 PM on 02/17/2008
- Ohg I'm a Fan of Ohg 5 fans permalink

Bush is just so totally incompetent. If he has taught us anything it is how important our job as voters is in selecting the leader of the free world. So what are we looking for? What is the job anyway?.....
http://thefiresidepost.com/2008/02/18/what-is-the-job-of-president/

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 01:16 PM on 02/17/2008
- springsm I'm a Fan of springsm 54 fans permalink

I don't know where Bill Gates is on this, but millions have gone for the malaria/HIV-AIDS prgrams in Africa from his foundation. Bush is lavishing up the praise but then he squashes the good message by insisting on "abstinance". My gawd..the fool. Push the Christian right agenda in a world he doesn't even know with unattainable results. This is his legacy that he is working on..for the one positive thing he can say. And what about all the money promised to the inner hill country for the Pakistani poor and the Afghani poor. Didn't happen. And the insurgent islamic extremists are buying their way in. So much for bush and his so called generous help. I am very glad for what the money they have received has done tho. No denying that one.

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 01:25 PM on 02/17/2008
- OlongapoEd I'm a Fan of OlongapoEd 36 fans permalink

Christians in general have been touting abstinence for, oh, as long as there have been Christians. It has been nearly 2,000 years since the death of Yeshua ben Yosef, and what has Christianity accomplished in the way of promoting abstinence? Not much. It could easily be argued that Christianity in general has been a spectacular failure as a moral force, but that is another discussion. Yes, there is a theoretical case to be made for abstinence, and I would say that it is certainly a good idea for minors, but in practice, touting abstinence too often becomes an excuse for moralistic posturing. I have concluded that far to many people don't actually care whether or not promoting abstinence works...it allows them ample opportunity to pose as some sort of paragon of virtue (i.e., Theological Correctness). Human nature being what it is, many people will have sex whenever they can (why is it that the alleged creations of an alleged perfect god misbehave so often and in so many ways?). If you expect to have any concrete results from programs to prevent the spread of unwanted pregnancy and STDs, then as far as I am concerned, abstinence can only be a small part of those programs.

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 01:13 PM on 02/17/2008
- springsm I'm a Fan of springsm 54 fans permalink

It is ignorant to say "Christians in general" on this. It is one style of christianity and not all christians buy into that. One thing tho that has happened, disease and pregnancy prevention is on the minds of Christians..and probably everybody else with half a mind. Don't paint Christians with the same brush..that is offensive and terribly wrong. I do believe that progressive Christians know how impractical absentince is. Gracious.

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 01:29 PM on 02/17/2008
- pleeezzze I'm a Fan of pleeezzze 6 fans permalink

Actually, if christians really practiced abstenence, we'd have run out of them a Looong time ago !!
Too bad that was'nt "before Bush" !! He's never practiced it in any form drink,sex,drugs !!!

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 01:36 PM on 02/17/2008
- chirps I'm a Fan of chirps 23 fans permalink

Knucklehead strikes again!

Hurry November.

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 12:36 PM on 02/17/2008
Page: 1 2 3 Next › Last » (3 pages total)
Comments are closed for this entry

 You must be logged in to comment. Log in  or connect with 

Connect