Megan Fox Or Fallen American Idol Carly Smithson: Who's Hotter? (POLL)

Megan Fox has been named FHM's sexiest woman and Carly Smithson made it to the final six on
"American Idol" before getting eliminated. It's a battle of the brunettes, both sprinkled with tattoos.

Who's hotter?

• Megan Fox
• Carly Smithson
• Too hard!
• Neither.

Fox on the left, and Smithson on the right.

Comments

[julieeiluj]

I think the most beautiful woman in the world was a rape victim in the Congo that, after some time of healing and counseling, smiled again.

[SteveS]

Jason and Brooke should have been gone a long time ago.

I thought Carly screamed Jesus Christ Superstar. I just didn't like it. It seems the rest of the planet did though. I do think she is a good singer, and loved her cover of Heart, but not JC Superstar, that was just plain screaming.

Hopefully Jason and Brooke are the next two to go, although Syesha seems to be the one this year to keep hanging on by a thread. I don't know why, she's really good.

David Cook for the win!

[brend]

Jason was by far the worst, then Archallita, and really any of the others. I think Carly was head and shoulders over any of them, and I hate bodypierceings and tatoos, but she was by far the best and has been since the show started.

[SharonB]

I agree with you. It was unbelievable when Carly got voted off. Jason stays and Carly goes??????
After singing, "Jesus Christ, Superstar" like she did?????
After Jason sang "Memories" like an idiot???
Him standing there rolling his eyes and sticking out his tongue... bah!

I think there are a lot of 12 and 13 year old girls with speed dial on their phones.