Obama: McCain's Foreign Policy Stance "Incredibly Naive"

digg Share this on Facebook Huffpost - Obama: McCain's Foreign Policy Stance "Incredibly Naive" stumble reddit del.ico.us RSS

The Huffington Post
First Posted: 05-20-08 05:27 PM   |   Updated: 05-28-08 05:12 AM

I Like ItI Don’t Like It
Obama Naive

Obama is continuing to push back hard against John McCain's foreign policy attacks. In a interview with Wolf Blitzer this evening, Barack called the Arizona's senator approach to Cuba "extraordinarily naive."

Obama referenced a series of quotations from McCain in early 2000 where he spoke favorably about normalizing relations with Cuba, a stance that Obama holds and that McCain criticized during a speech in Florida today, saying: "the only person who has flip-flopped on this issue is John McCain."

Obama continued to return to the greater theme that McCain's foreign policy represents a continuation of George Bush's tenure, raising again the fight over Iran that broke out last week when the President obliquely referenced Obama in front of the Israeli Knesset.

It is a sign that both candidates feel the issue of foreign policy is working on their behalf, with each eager to paint the other as lacking judgment. Today, Obama even echoed McCain's language, calling the senator naive:

When it comes to Cuba, what he is now saying is essentially the policy we've pursued for 50 years and the Cuban people are not more free.


And the notion that we would keep doing the same thing over and over and over again when it doesn't work and that somehow is a sign of toughness is extraordinarily naive, I think does a disservice to the Cuban people.

Watch the video:

CNN

Read the transcript of Obama's interview with Wolf Blitzer:

OBAMA: I have to say, first of all, Wolf, his charges aren't serious. That's the problem. I have never said that I was prepared to immediately normalize relations with Cuba. The only person who has flip-flopped on this issue is John McCain who in 2000 said that he would be prepared to start normalizing relations even if a whole host of steps have not been taken. That is a reversal from the position he is taking now.


And what I have also said is that I will be willing to engage in direct talks with Cuba. Now, I know that John McCain likes to characterize this as me immediately having Raul Castro over for tea. What I've said is that we would set a series of meetings with low level diplomats, set up some preparation but that over time I would be willing to meet and talk very directly about what we expect from the Cuban regime. And so John McCain keeps on making these statements that simply aren't based on anything I've said.

Story continues below
advertisement

BLITZER: He says that you would be ready, in his words, to sit down unconditionally for a presidential meeting with Raul Castro. Those were his words.

OBAMA: And what I've said is I would be willing to meet without preconditions but with a lot of preparation and this is the same argument that we've been having with respect to Iran. This is the same argument that we're going to be having throughout the next several months should I end up being the Democratic nominee.

John McCain essentially wants to continue George Bush's policies of not talking to leaders we don't like and not talking to countries we don't like. It has been a failed policy. Iran is stronger now than when George Bush took office. Partly because he engaged in a war in Iraq that John McCain facilitated that has strengthened Iran.

The fact that we haven't talked to them has not had them stand down on nuclear weapons. It hasn't led them to stop funding Hamas and Hezbollah. It hasn't stopped them from threatening Israel and so what I have said is we should open up direct talks.

By the way, George Bush's own secretary of defense, Robert Gates, has indicated the same thing. I believe the same thing - I believe that the same thing is true when it comes to Cuba and I believe, by the way, that the same thing is true with North Korea. That's one of the few areas where we've seen some progress, primarily because the Bush administration reversed its policy of not having direct talks with these rogue nations and we've actually started seeing some progress. Prior to that, North Korea developed a series of nuclear weapons.

BLITZER: There seems to be some confusion whether you would be willing, personally, as president, to sit down, without preconditions, with Ahmadinejad of Iran or other Iranian leaders. Is your openness to a meeting with Iranian leaders inclusive of Ahmadinejad?

OBAMA: I think this obsession with Ahmadinejad is an example of us losing track of what's important.

I would be willing to meet with Iranian leaders if we had done sufficient preparations for that meeting. Whether Ahmadinejad is the right person to meet with right now, we don't even know how much power he is going to have a year from now. He is not the most powerful person in Iran.

And my expectation, obviously, would be to meet with those people who can actually make decisions in terms of actually having them stand down on nuclear weapons or stopping funding Hamas or Hezbollah or meddling in the affairs of Iraq.

But the bottom line here, Wolf, is that John McCain wants to pursue policies that George Bush has pursued for the last eight years with no success. When it comes to Cuba, what he is now saying is essentially the policy we've pursued for 50 years and the Cuban people are not more free.

And the notion that we would keep doing the same thing over and over and over again when it doesn't work and that somehow is a sign of toughness is extraordinarily naive, I think does a disservice to the Cuban people. That's the kind of break from the Bush administration that I want to initiate when I am president of the United States.

Obama is continuing to push back hard against John McCain's foreign policy attacks. In a interview with Wolf Blitzer this evening, Barack called the Arizona's senator approach to Cuba "extraordinaril...
Obama is continuing to push back hard against John McCain's foreign policy attacks. In a interview with Wolf Blitzer this evening, Barack called the Arizona's senator approach to Cuba "extraordinaril...
Report Corrections
 
Comments
77
Pending Comments
0
iPhone App Promo

Want to reply to a comment? Hint: Click "Reply" at the bottom of the comment; after being approved your comment will appear directly underneath the comment you replied to

View Comments:
Page: 1 2 Next › Last » (2 pages total)
- fourex I'm a Fan of fourex 14 fans permalink
photo

Poor John McCain, first Gates says we should talk to Iran, and now Israel says they are talking to Syria. How long can McCain cling to the Bush 'no diplomacy' policy?

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 11:10 AM on 05/21/2008
- dadw5boys I'm a Fan of dadw5boys 256 fans permalink
photo

McCAIN BLOWING SMOKE!!!!!!!!!

BIG SUGAR will never allow normal relations with Cuba the price of Sugar would fall thru the floor. Like in Mexico sugar cost are 10 lbs for $0.50cents. Of course it is comes in a plastic bag not paper bags.

Big Sugar will not give up all those tax write offs and all those direct checks from the U.S. Treasury either.

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 07:43 AM on 05/21/2008
- rosal I'm a Fan of rosal 302 fans permalink
photo

I always knew Obama was not going to be gentle with McWorse. When he didn't attack Clinton, people said he was "weak". I knew he was going to come swinging. He just didn't want to attack a fellow Democrat. Nice to see somebody taking the high road, and winning! May this be a lesson to many.

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 12:55 AM on 05/21/2008

Unlike Clinton, Obama was actually considering the greater good of his party. For Obama to have attacked Clinton would have lead to a further division in the Democratic Primary, almost ensuring that McCain wins the Presidency.
Clinton has plenty of skeletons in her closet, every time I have watched Obama take Clinton's often misrepresented attacks without replying in kind I have grown even more respectful of him.
People might hate his speech in which he didn't disown Rev. Wright, but having spent the formative years in a half African American school I understand his perspective that ignoring the truth solves nothing. That is a problem we have to deal with, acting as if it does not exist solves nothing.
Like Clinton's gas tax rebate. No real answers, all the economists agree, but she doesn't care, she can score political points with it.

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 01:29 AM on 05/22/2008
- Tropiholic I'm a Fan of Tropiholic 18 fans permalink

Mccasket is a tired old dinosaur, living in the past, the distant past. It's time for him to run along now, he has nothing new to offer anyone in this country.

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 12:33 AM on 05/21/2008
photo

McCasket...there's one I haven't seen before.
McSame, McPain, McGramps, McBush, even McC***...
I think we should have a contest to see who can come up with the best Mc ___ name. :)

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 11:25 AM on 05/21/2008
- aristippe I'm a Fan of aristippe 13 fans permalink

If Bush attacks Iran on the eve of the general election will Obama apologize to the Iranian people? McCain might have that Ace up his sleeve.

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 11:16 PM on 05/20/2008
- JimR I'm a Fan of JimR 36 fans permalink

If Bush attacks Iran on the even of the general election, Obama might win in a landslide.

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 09:28 AM on 05/21/2008
- wbwbruce I'm a Fan of wbwbruce 4 fans permalink

If Bush attacks Iran on the eve of the general election.
He should be Imprisoned for the rest of his natural life.

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 10:45 AM on 05/21/2008

This man has got a handle on what world policy needs to be... he has learned from the masters of historic diplomacy... I doubt that Bush or McCain could accurately draw a world map if pressed upon it... This is who we need to restore America's standing in the world...
Why do you think that Bush's trip to the Mideast was a failure??? They are laughing at us!

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 09:57 PM on 05/20/2008
photo

And the US has 57 states.

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 11:23 AM on 05/21/2008

Bush's trip to the MidEast was a failure because they really aren't to blame for the oil prices. The bigger problem comes with the fact the Federal Reserve is basically printing money out of thin air to loan to the banks that already lost billions.
It is called inflation.
Then you can look towards the other major problem of the oil industry, the environmental lobby's attacks against oil refineries. What many people do not understand is that it doesn't matter how much oil there is if you have insufficient refining capacity.

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 01:37 AM on 05/22/2008
- lennix I'm a Fan of lennix 6 fans permalink


McCAIN IS DANGER OUT DATED AND THINKS MIGHT IS THE ONLY THING THAT PEOPLE UNDERSTAND IF WE PUY HIM IN THE WHITE HOUSE BUSH WILL LOOK LIKE SHIRLEY TEMPLE

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 09:09 PM on 05/20/2008
- dadw5boys I'm a Fan of dadw5boys 256 fans permalink
photo

I agree he would want to be a larger terror on the world than Bush just to prove his manhood.

Thats what I get from him. He act like being President will make him all powerful. Wake up fool that Republcian Dictatorship is about to bite the dust. We will no longer tolerate the destruction of the USA ny you and your cronies.

The American people will have their country back in November; so hide your ill gotten gains and get ready for a smack down!

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 07:54 AM on 05/21/2008
- Marrigan I'm a Fan of Marrigan 3 fans permalink

Sen. Obama needs to challenge McCain's understanding of the U.S. relationship with Cuba. And when I say "relationship", I MEAN relationship. Are most people aware that when McCain talks about an embargo against Cuba, that he's being deceitful? The U.S. exports (at least) $350M/year and that 20 states have initiated trade missions to Cuba; the most recent being Texas and New York last month. The NY trade mission was organized by NYS Ag & Markets and included ag & business folks from apples to wine.
Google "NY trade mission, Cuba" (news and web) and you'll be amazed at the largely unreported trade delegations eager to export to Cuba. Obviously these Americans can't travel to Cuba without visas, so when McCain and the Administration talk tough about Cuba, they're posturing. I guess from their viewpoint, trading isn't the same as "talking".

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 08:08 PM on 05/20/2008
- Grunty1 I'm a Fan of Grunty1 208 fans permalink

Trading makes rich people money
Talking might allow the poor in Cuba to benefit, and we couldn't possibly have that

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 08:33 PM on 05/20/2008

McCain's foreign policy posture is not only "incredibly naive," it is post-dated and anachronistic to the sensitive bargaining demands of the new international system that has reduced the arrogance of brute military prowess into ignorance of immaturity and archaic posturing of negative significance. Indeed, the foreign policy stance of McCain is not only anachronistic; it is defeatist and scornful. It will lead to further miniaturization of America in the international system.

What is wrong with the mill of American democratic politics that continue to brew politicians of yester-year?

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 07:36 PM on 05/20/2008
photo

Because your mindset is wrong and has failed time and time again. In a perfect would your ideas might work. That world doesn't exist at this time and it probably never will as long as there are countries like Iran that yearn to commit genocide.

Remember Osama was under indictment while he continued to attack us. The Japanese were in negotiations with us until the day before they attacked us. Kennedy was perceived as weak which contributed to the missile crisis.

The European Union has been in discussions with Iran for years but Iran is still building a weapon. Has that worked?

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 11:32 AM on 05/21/2008
- OrionGal I'm a Fan of OrionGal 10 fans permalink

Fred Kaplan has some great articles and books out right now.

Read what Mr Kaplan has written -

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 12:28 PM on 05/21/2008
- abouttime I'm a Fan of abouttime 19 fans permalink

Respectfully Huffpo, I disagree with this assessment: "It is a sign that both candidates feel the issue of foreign policy is working on their behalf, with each eager to paint the other as lacking judgment."
If it us true that McCain thinks this, where did you get it from?
There is NO WAY of knowing what goes on his head, because he demented. He is "Out there in fairy land".

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 07:10 PM on 05/20/2008
- PackyJ I'm a Fan of PackyJ 15 fans permalink
photo

As long as he NEVER refers to John McCain without including George Dubya Bush in the same sentence, Obama should win in a walk in November.

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 06:54 PM on 05/20/2008
- Sheridan1 I'm a Fan of Sheridan1 2 fans permalink

KBAR - the Rasmussen poll shows that it's early in the campaign. Those people want McCain 2000 - but what we have is McBush 2008.
I will let someone elses words work for me here:
May 19, 2008

I was John McCain's Navy Flight Instructor --- in formation tactics and air-to-air-gunnery. I could write a book about this man. Suffice to state, I shudder (and I'm fearless) at the nightmare thought of this man becoming our next President and Commander in Chief. I am not alone as to this man's former shipmates, instructors and senior officers --- as to who and what this man is really all about. Although politics is really theater and the best performing actor gets to stay on the main stage --- sort of like American Idol only much more dangerous to all living things --- the performance and the make-over (re-invention) of this man is currently matched only by that of former LTC Oliver North, USMC (Ret.). Together on the same ticket, these two clowns would be real crowd pleasers in this sorry day and age of liars, banal dummies and limp-headed performers.

Thanx for having the guts to put the real deal information on the site re: John Sidney McCain III --- since the mainstream media is much too lazy to put the real story on McCain out there for the rest of their lazy consumers.

Best regards,

CDR Jerry K. Loeb, USN (Ret.)
Palm Desert, CA

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 06:49 PM on 05/20/2008

Only means that a large number of people are naive about winning a war....

How do you win a war in Iraq?? When the borders cannot be sealed and Iran and foreign fighters are actively killing American soldiers, how do you win such a thing....

This is how we "won" the war in Vietnam. I remember friends in the British Army in 1977, the Royal Green Jackets, sitting in London before deployment to Northern Ireland. They understood that they were going there to possibly die against an enemy during "The Troubles" with no clear path to winning the "war"....

The longer we stay, more Americans will die for nothing.

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 06:47 PM on 05/20/2008
- Canaris I'm a Fan of Canaris 2 fans permalink

Careful about that "Iran is actively killing American soldiers" thing. It might be true, but it is going to take more than the Bush administration saying it is so before I believe it. You recall the saying about fool me once, shame on you....

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 07:10 PM on 05/20/2008

Iran is playing both sides and has it in with the winner no matter what regime takes over. All we are doing is repeating the Soviets' mistakes in Afghanistan.

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 09:17 PM on 05/20/2008
- dadw5boys I'm a Fan of dadw5boys 256 fans permalink
photo

What you might not realize is that Iran is busting over with HIGHLY EDUCATED and young workers. They could spill into Iraq and devolpe one very highly productive society if Iraq ever opened their borders andf allowed these workers in.

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 07:59 AM on 05/21/2008
- harriscrl3 I'm a Fan of harriscrl3 191 fans permalink

OUTDATED Obama thats what you want to say. Dont be AFRAID if it makes him sound OLD HE IS TOO OLD!!! He needs to get his butt into the 21st century or we are going to HELL.

Carol

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 06:43 PM on 05/20/2008
- onenation I'm a Fan of onenation 4 fans permalink

McBush isn't showing his niave side, it is his recorded message side. The right wing of the repubs thinks it is right and demands their message be delivered. I think it will be a blessing when the Repubs loose and the Sean H's have to blame the Real Republicans and they finally rebel.

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 06:40 PM on 05/20/2008
Page: 1 2 Next › Last » (2 pages total)
Comments are closed for this entry

 You must be logged in to comment. Log in  or connect with 

Connect