Jason Linkins

BIO

Jason Linkins

The Huffington Post

WaPo's Cohen: McCain More Trustworthy Because He Was Taken Captive

digg Share this on Facebook Huffpost - stumble reddit del.ico.us RSS

June 24, 2008 04:41 PM



It's difficult to know whether his latest column is a part of his ongoing attempt to prove himself more ironically humorous than Stephen Colbert or if it's just another entry in the "Most Out Of Touch Columnist in America" contest, but this morning's effort from Richard Cohen truly defies description. The thesaurus simply does not list enough variations on "inane" to do the trick.

Cohen has apparently drunk deeply of the anger-arousing Kool-Aid that the McCain camp has been pimping, and is full of outrage at Senator Barack Obama for choosing to operate within a system of public financing that benefits his own campaign, as opposed to a system of public financing that benefits McCain's campaign. Cohen says that Obama has thus "moved his bottom line." There's also some straight up balderdash about "socialist realism language" that won't make any sense at all, even if you opt to have a bag of ball peen hammers dropped on your head.

And if you are wondering if Cohen is aware of McCain's long history of flipping and flopping, you'd be surprised to learn that he is, going so far as to document a partial litany of offenses:

In some recent magazine articles, I and certain of my colleagues have been accused of being soft on McCain, forgiving him his flips, his flops and his mostly conservative ideology. I do not plead guilty to this charge, because, over the years, the man's imperfections have not escaped my keen eye. But, for the record, let's recapitulate: McCain has either reversed himself or significantly amended his positions on immigration, tax cuts for the wealthy, campaign spending (as it applies to use of his wife's corporate airplane) and, most recently, offshore drilling. In the more distant past, he has denounced then embraced certain ministers of medieval views and changed his mind about the Confederate flag, which flies by state sanction in South Carolina only, I suspect, to provide Republican candidates with a chance to choose tradition over common decency. There, I've said it all.

Actually, Richard, you've missed a few items. If you really want to collect them all, you should include his reversal on Roe v. Wade, his reversal on embracing Sam and Charles Wyly, his reversal on his stance on Grover Norquist, his reversal on torture, his reversal on ethanol, his reversal on Bob Jones University, his reversal on "100 Years in Iraq," and his reversal on gay marriage. Additionally, Richard, you should clarify: when you cite his flip-flop on offshore drilling, do you mean the first one? Or do you mean today's admission that offshore drilling would only yield "psychological benefits?" Connect that keen eye of yours with the fingers that type your columns, why don't you?

Oh, and there's also that whole matter of McCain strenuously opposing the decent and honorable G.I. Bill for months, only to swoop in and attempt to take credit for it when its passage became inevitable. And why not include the little matter of McCain attempting to rip off the public through the very public finance vehicle that's currently got you at sixes and sevens?

Yes, why not? Well, the reason why not, dear readers, is because Cohen thinks McCain deserves credit in spite of all of these detriments because years ago, he was a prisoner of war.

But here is the difference between McCain and Obama -- and Obama had better pay attention. McCain is a known commodity. It's not just that he's been around a long time and staked out positions antithetical to those of his Republican base. It's also -- and more important -- that we know his bottom line. As his North Vietnamese captors found out, there is only so far he will go, and then his pride or his sense of honor takes over. This -- not just his candor and nonstop verbosity on the Straight Talk Express -- is what commends him to so many journalists.

Naturally, I have no need, want, or desire to suggest that McCain was anything less than laudably valorous in Vietnam, but I have to nevertheless point out that I've known plenty of people in this world in whom my trust has been well invested despite the fact that none of them (to my knowledge) were ever held captive in a Vietnamese POW camp. McCain will run for President in 2008 as a candidate that's completely unrecognizable from the McCain who ran in 2000. Given the numerous instances of McCain following the path of least resistance on the way to pure political expedience, I'm afraid that the only way his time as a POW relates to how "far he will go," is that it's reasonably certain that his attempts to win the White House will stop short of treason.

Having familiarized myself with Barack Obama's platform, I can report that the candidate has a very strong and overt "anti-treason" message. But Obama should definitely allow himself to be caged and tortured to satisfy Richard Cohen.

 
Comments
98
Pending Comments
0
iPhone App Promo

Want to reply to a comment? Hint: Click "Reply" at the bottom of the comment; after being approved your comment will appear directly underneath the comment you replied to

View Comments:
Page: 1 2 3 4 Next › Last » (4 pages total)

Okay, let's get this straight - it seems MC crashed 3 planes (this might not be unusual but he might not have been the best pilot). Being captured seems consistent with his low ranking in his graduation class - he might not have been at the very bottom but he was close to it. Yes, he suffered as a captive of the VC and maybe he deserves the label "hero". I'm not certain of this myself.

Cohen is nothing more than a Mc surrogate. Along with Brooks, Broder, Holly Bailey and more. His half hearted effort at appearing impartial was pathetic, as is he. Man Crush.

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 10:22 AM on 06/25/2008

From "John McCain: The Manchurian Candidate"
After being periodically slapped around for "three or four days" by his captors who wanted military information from him, McCain called for an officer on his fourth day of captivity. He told the officer, "O.K., I'll give you military information if you will take me to the hospital." -U.S. News and World Report, May 14, 1973 article written by former POW John McCain

McCain was taken to Gai Lam military hospital normally unavailable to American POWS. (U.S. government documents)

"Demands for military information were accompanied by threats to terminate my medical treatment if I [McCain] did not cooperate. Eventually, I gave them my ship's name and squadron number, and confirmed that my target had been the power plant." Page 193-194, Faith of My Fathers by John McCain.

Nov. 9, 1967 (U.S. government documents) Hanoi press began quoting him giving specific military information.

Given the circumstances one can't be too critical, but war hero?, future president? I think not.

Military code of conduct, "When questioned, should I become a prisoner of war, I am bound to only give name, rank, service number, and date of birth. I will evade answering further questions to the utmost of my ability. I will make no oral or written statements disloyal to my country and its allies or harmful to their cause."

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 10:02 AM on 06/25/2008

Neither Obama or McCain are trustworth.

www.
votenader
.org

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 09:08 AM on 06/25/2008
photo

Cohen is in the AIPAC barrel, still doing penance for this

http://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-dyn/content/article/2006/07/17/AR2006071701154.html

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 08:14 AM on 06/25/2008
photo

Five long grueling years as a prisoner of war makes him more like the Manchurian Candidate than the Republican Candidate, the man is obviously suffering from horrific memories, which has made him an angry bitter old man.

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 08:12 AM on 06/25/2008
photo

Repors vary from other POWs whether the years were as grueling as we have bddn told. He offered to help the enemy in return for medical care for injuries from his crash landing after 4 days of capture and made 32 tapes for the enemy over the next three and a half years. He got much better treatment on release from the US military than fellow soldiers who suffered way more for a much longer period of time, and cooperated less.
http://www.usvetdsp.com/smith_mc.htm

Then he upset vets by getting everyone's POW/MIA records locked away including his own after the bill passed 401 -0 in Congress and he blocked it in the Senate. Makes you wonder doesn't it?
http://news.aol.com/political-machine/2008/02/02/why-did-mccain-block-release-of-pow-info/
http://www.eworldwire.com/pressreleases/18074

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 11:01 AM on 06/25/2008

Cohen is a closet Republican/ conservative, he just avoids coming right out and saying so. He's inclined this way in other of his columns, too. Sometimes I read him only to see what kind of twisted logic and confusion he's coming up with this time. He wants to take conservative positions without seeming to take conservative positions; he says, then backtracks. It only ends up a mess.

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 07:33 AM on 06/25/2008

Now don't get me wrong, in war people can't always avoid being taken prisoner, or worse, but I would probably not exist if my Dad in WWII had not stayed calm, used his head and stayed free to fight another day. Along with a few other men he had been inadvertently left behind during the night and awoke to find himself (on a hill) surrounded by the Japanese. One guy went to start shooting but Dad stopped him. Just one shot would had alerted the enemy as to these men's position and they would have been wiped out or had to surrender as they were very out numbered. They stayed still for several hours until it was safe to move on. Took nerve. Thanks, Dad.

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 07:29 AM on 06/25/2008

I respect your fathers service and happy that he was safe and able to bring you into the world. I am sure you would also respect that my husband is serving now and has served in Kosovo,Afganistan, and Iraq. But, lets be honest, this does not qualify them to be POTUS and makes them better then the average civilian. I think they should be respected for their courage and service to their country. But, their service should not put them above criticism, especially when the world may disagree. In the case of McCain this has become a problem. Everyone is so wrapped up in hero worships that they cannot see that this guy will do more harm then good, and the MEDIA is afraid to call him out on his crap.

McCain is so...ummm....hight on the high and mighty pedestal that he will not see that the American people disagree with him, and he will always think he is right. He is just another Bush.
Please thank your father for his service to our country, and I can only imagine the hell he went through.

Hoorah!

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 08:33 AM on 06/25/2008

I agree with you entirely. I hope your husband returns to you unharmed. Not only should those bravely serving their country be respected but their families who also sacrifice.

My dad passed away a few years ago just before his 84th birthday. During his time abroad he saw many terrible things and had nightmares for years but I'm glad to say he also appreciated life and was very tolerant. I think he realized that governments wage war and that at heart we are all human-beings with more in common than our different cultures would indicate. I see that quality in Obama.

I hope you and your husband have a wonderfully long and happy life together.

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 09:45 AM on 06/25/2008
photo

Yet another great one!

Thanks Jason Linkins.

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 06:29 AM on 06/25/2008

That is the most specious reasoning I have ever heard.
If anything it makes McCain less trust worthy. Especially since he would do the same and worse to people who may be innocent.
McCain has flip-flopped and flipped again on EVERY important issue.
How can any reasonable person trust a man who changes his position constantly in order to gain power.
McCain has less integrity than Bush.

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 06:16 AM on 06/25/2008

McCain waves his patriotic service in our face & claims to be the true patriot, while he stiffs our veterans and votes against any meaningful support for returning vets.

McCain is an elitist. He got his ... he's the offspring of 2 Navy Admirals, a spoiled rotten surfer boy, left his invalid wife for a beautiful filthy rich woman and treats her like crap in public. He covered up her drug use & theft, and now uses her wealth to sidestep campaign finance rules. I could go on.

Please define patriot.

No real patriot would turn their back on vets. Such betrayal is beyond excuse or comprehension.

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 03:24 AM on 06/25/2008

Richard Cohen and Jeff Gannon (aka Guckert) seem to have at least one thing in common -- they know how to "fluff" their favorite boys.

Can't attack Georgie because he's keeping us safe from the terr'sts (and he and Karl and Scottie needed a little "relief" now and then, didn't they?) Johnny M just needs to be stroked now and then, Cindy or Lindsay (especially puckering Lindsay) or Joe will do.

Just watch those bodily fluids, sir. Might lose your strength, your secret MoJo. You're big, you're bad, you didn't make that videotape, sir.

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 07:06 AM on 06/25/2008

I'm sorry, but I don't accept political commentary from anyone who was not a POW. Richard Cohen, you are dismissed.

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 02:33 AM on 06/25/2008
photo

My Vietnam vet theory about presidential candidates. I think McBush is the third person to run for president that was a Vietnam veteran. So far Vietnam vets are 0-2 (Gore and Kerry) while candidates that avoided Vietnam are 4-0 (Clinton and Bush II). I really think people unfairly look at Vietnam vets as losers because the Vietnam War was the first war America lost. This could always be a coincidence because not every correlation is equivalent to a cause and effect relationship. If McBush is not elected Vietnam War vets would be 0-3 which again may be based on many other factors but you would have to wonder if people at least on a subconscious level hold the loss in Vietnam against Vietnam vets. My older brother was a Vietnam Vet and I have absolutely no personal animous against them.

Interestingly since 1950 Korean Vets were 1-2 in presidential elections (Carter and Dukakis). World War II Vets were 9-4 (Eisenhower, JFK, LBJ, Nixon, McGovern, Ford, Reagan and Bush I) though Reagan did not serve in combat. Non-veterans 4-4 (Stevenson, Goldwater, Humphrey, Clinton and Bush II) as we know National Guard troops seldom served in Vietnam.

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 02:27 AM on 06/25/2008
photo

My wife had an interesting perspective about McBush being a POW.

What makes a POW a war hero? She has a great point. All McBush has proven is that he is a survivor. It's not like he saved lives or even completed a great mission.

I'm a cancer survivor only to become permanently disabled 10 years later because one of the chemo drugs I needed to survive cancer irreparably damaged my heart and I was literally minutes away from death twice. Some of my friends and coworkers said how brave I was but in reality survival is just an instinct.

The fact is I think people make too big a deal out of McBush surviving and it does not automatically make him a war hero. He has made a whole career off of his war record and it definitely does not automatically give him the personal qualities to be president.

In fact I think it makes him a worse leader because too many people think he is beyond criticism for not supporting the troops by not supporting legislation like the new GI Bill and having a terrible record in voting for veterans issues. His whole life is based on this sanctimonious belief that he is above criticism.

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 01:47 AM on 06/25/2008

"... In fact I think it makes him a worse leader..." because there is psychological damage post-POW, an inevitable fact. Also - McCain's entire perspective is military - a world unto itself, out of touch with the rest of the population and concerns of the nation. War bravado is good on the front lines of combat, but NOT, NOT, NOT in a leadership position!

Read McCain's bio -- his toddler tantrums - holding his breath until he turned blue, and parents having to toss him into a tub of ice water to bring him around; not the making of a team player. That's self-destructive defiance. His real claim to heroism is the fact that he did not accept early POW camp release offered via his famous Admiral father & Grandfather. He would be toast if he accepted it, so instead saved his military reputation. But he's not the only POW survivor!! He is one of the privileged ones. Many REAL heroes came home to no family, no support, no arms & legs, and no future. Those survivors are the war heroes we should celebrate - not the spoiled misogynist who degrades his wife in front of his macho cronies.

BTW, I hear whispers of the RNC yanking him out in August under the guise of returning skin cancer, and throwing Mitt or Rudy back in to replace him. We need the elections police on high alert to keep things kosher.

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 03:13 AM on 06/25/2008
photo

Your wife trivialized something that she will never survive - a prisoners camp in Vietnam.Comparing a cancer survivor with a POW survivor is ridiculous at least, you HAD all your medical needs fulfilled,you had all your family support, you had all your friends, you had your TV and movies, THEY DIDN'T have nothing but their resilience and trust in their comrades and country. And MOST of them never flinched to torture. They are HEROES in my book! Now if you want to look at McCain imprisonment from this perspective, if he really was one of the above, this is another issues.

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 08:39 AM on 06/25/2008
photo

So is THAT why they treated Kerry and Max Cleland like s**t, because they weren't POWs?

Ok.

Aside from this line of thinking, the other sorry thing is some people will actually BELIEVE this garbage.

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 01:25 AM on 06/25/2008
photo

Okay, I do not feel the least bit grateful for his service! It was substandard, folks. He crashed FIVE planes due to pilot error. Bummer he got caught, but if the plane hadn't crashed, he wouldn't have much to wave in front of our faces.

I honor the service of the kids in Iraq and Afghanistan who joined the service mostly to have a better life with some job skills and college money...and then they find out they've been shafted by their government. One tour after another, poor medical care once they're of no use any more, and then there's McCain, who says veterans shouldn't get increased college money, because then they'll just quit when their enlistment is up. I don't honor this turkey one little bit.

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 01:18 AM on 06/25/2008
Page: 1 2 3 4 Next › Last » (4 pages total)
Comments are closed for this entry

You must be logged in to reply to this comment. Log in  or  Connect