False Obama Muslim Rumor Spread Quickly And Widely Throughout The Internet

digg Share this on Facebook Huffpost - False Obama Muslim Rumor Spread Quickly And Widely Throughout The Internet stumble reddit del.ico.us RSS

Huffington Post
First Posted: 06-28-08 08:11 AM   |   Updated: 07- 6-08 05:12 AM

I Like ItI Don’t Like It
Obama Car

The false rumor that Barack Obama is a Muslim spread quickly and widely throughout the internet. Obama has launched a website, FightTheSmears.com, to help combat this falsehood, along with others that crop up on the internet. The Washington Post today has an extensive article detailing how the rumor first appeared. An Obama supporter and scholar, Danielle Allen, received an email calling Obama a Muslim, and having met the Senator while working as a dean at the University of Chicago, and knowing the claim to be baseless, she was determined to discover how it started and how one could stop it.

The e-mail landed in Danielle Allen's queue one winter morning as she was studying in her office at the Institute for Advanced Study, the renowned haven for some of the nation's most brilliant minds. The missive began: "THIS DEFINITELY WARRANTS LOOKING INTO."


Laid out before Allen, a razor-sharp, 36-year-old political theorist, was what purported to be a biographical sketch of Barack Obama that has become one of the most effective -- and baseless -- Internet attacks of the 2008 presidential season. The anonymous chain e-mail makes the false claim that Obama is concealing a radical Islamic background. By the time it reached Allen on Jan. 11, 2008, it had spread with viral efficiency for more than a year...

...As an Obama supporter -- she had met the senator while she worked as a dean at the University of Chicago -- it made her angry. And curious.

"I started thinking, 'How does one stop it?' "


The man Allen found who takes credit for the first posting of an article falsely asserting Obama is a Muslim is a man named Andy Martin.

Martin, a former political opponent of Obama's, is the publisher of an Internet newspaper who sends e-mails to his mailing list almost daily. He said in an interview that he first began questioning Obama's religious background after hearing his famous keynote speech at the 2004 Democratic National Convention. In an Aug. 10, 2004, article, which he posted on Web sites and e-mailed to bloggers, he said that Obama had concealed his Muslim heritage. "I feel sad having to expose Barack Obama," Martin wrote in an accompanying press release, "but the man is a complete fraud. The truth is going to surprise, and disappoint, and outrage many people who were drawn to him. He has lied to the American people, and he has sought to misrepresent his own heritage." Martin's article did not suggest an association between Obama and radical Islam.


Martin was trying to launch a Senate bid against Obama when he says he first ran the Democrat's name by a contact in London. "They said he must be a Muslim. That was interesting to me because it was an angle that nobody had covered. We started looking. As a candidate you learn how to harness the Internet. You end up really learning how to work the street. I sort of picked this story up as a sideline." Martin said the primary basis for his belief was simple -- Obama's father was a Muslim. In a defamation lawsuit he filed against the New York Times and others several months ago, Martin says that Obama "eventually became a Christian" but that "as a matter of Islamic law began life as a Muslim" due to his father's religion.

Read the full report from the Washington Post.

The false rumor that Barack Obama is a Muslim spread quickly and widely throughout the internet. Obama has launched a website, FightTheSmears.com, to help combat this falsehood, along with others that...
The false rumor that Barack Obama is a Muslim spread quickly and widely throughout the internet. Obama has launched a website, FightTheSmears.com, to help combat this falsehood, along with others that...
Report Corrections
 
Comments
504
Pending Comments
0
iPhone App Promo

Want to reply to a comment? Hint: Click "Reply" at the bottom of the comment; after being approved your comment will appear directly underneath the comment you replied to

View Comments:
Page: « First ‹ Previous 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 Next › Last » (10 pages total)
- 2351 I'm a Fan of 2351 3 fans permalink

If I were a muslim, I would be offended by the way my heritage is used to hurt people. Only in the USA. It just shows us to be idiots. So what if he were a muslim. Just what would that mean. I have really been shocked with the election season this year. It is really silly season. Voters are just not given any credit for having any sense and many people have their minds changed about an issue or person because of silly rumors started by grown people who many call christians. Many christians disappoint me. I'd be more afraid of some of the christians that I know than I would be of some muslims.

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 09:02 PM on 06/28/2008
- zizi I'm a Fan of zizi 3 fans permalink

Thank you.

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 11:15 PM on 06/28/2008
- MrsPeel I'm a Fan of MrsPeel 56 fans permalink
photo

Agreed. There's an old adage: "The GOP never makes the mistake of overestimating the intelligence of the average voter."

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 12:15 AM on 06/29/2008
- Oldtt I'm a Fan of Oldtt 37 fans permalink
photo

It was H.L. Mencken who famously said: "Nobody ever went broke underestimating the intelligence of the American public."

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 06:27 PM on 06/29/2008
- StillIRise I'm a Fan of StillIRise 573 fans permalink
photo

I agree. However, it is equally offensive when people suggest that they will vote for Obama's "white side," as if something is wrong with his "black side." There is nothing wrong with being Muslim or black. The only thing wrong are the people who see it as something wrong. These are the people who think that by insisting that he's Muslim or diminishing him because of the color of his skin, they are SMEARING him, but seeing it as a smear emerges from biases of their mind and from their heart. Not too long ago, someone said that America is a racist nation, and that person was attacked for being hateful and anti-American. I realize now that it was the racists themselves who were attacking him. Their fear of anyone who is different, be it race or religion, is a very frightening way to live and makes it a very frightening world in which we live.

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 01:47 AM on 06/29/2008
photo

The Clintonistas didn't originate the rumor, but once it was out there, they egged it on, by not immediately confronting it and repudiating the people who were spreading it.

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 07:59 PM on 06/28/2008
- Oldtt I'm a Fan of Oldtt 37 fans permalink
photo

Same criticism as saying that Obama did nothing to halt accusations of racism against both Clintons, neither of whom have a racist bone in their bodies.

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 06:16 PM on 06/29/2008
- nukemind I'm a Fan of nukemind 15 fans permalink

I don't get why his religion matters anyway, but he's not a Muslim. Who cares? Besides, even if he was, what difference would it make? Hell, I'd take a moderate secular Muslim from Turkey over a fundie like Bush or Lieberman anyday.

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 07:43 PM on 06/28/2008

Attacks against Obama spread just as quickly as Obama's underhanded attacks against Clinton. Not any faster, and not any slower.

"Morality is simply the attitude we adopt towards people whom we dislike."
Oscar Wilde

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 07:13 PM on 06/28/2008
- dagnew I'm a Fan of dagnew 18 fans permalink

I don't recall Obama making 'underhanded attacks' against Senator Clinton. Did he ever spread any untruths about her? Enlighten me. I do remember her saying that Obama wasn't a Muslim....­that she knew of. That remark was quite underhanded.

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 07:56 PM on 06/28/2008
- tbrnotb I'm a Fan of tbrnotb 19 fans permalink

Still bitter that Clinton lost. Let it go. Join us, vote for McCain or sit it out. We don't care. We're tired of these little "pouting posts". Hillary did her part with numerous "underhanded attacks"..­...it was an election for Christ's sake! What did you expect a white glove tea party?

Oh, that Oscar Wilde quote works both ways, honey!

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 08:10 PM on 06/28/2008
photo

i dont recall obama attacking clinton ever

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 08:50 PM on 06/28/2008
photo

I don't either. He was always a gentleman. I was proud of him for not engaging in the mudfight. The worst I've heard anyone name was the "Annie Oakley" comment, and I thought that was kind of funny. There is a big difference between accusing someone of being something that is not true (the "elitist" flap, and the "Muslim" flap) and accusing someone of pretending to be something they are not (gun-touting Hillary as Annie Oakley).
The attacking was done by both Obama supporters and Hillary supporters, and I don't think the candidates can be held responsible for what other people say.

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 01:07 AM on 06/29/2008

Isn't this the teapot calling the kettle black, literally. Yu think this let's the Clintons off the hook. They "may not" have generated the e-mails, but they did nothing to discount them, they actually joined in on the bandwagon, with their sly inuendos. They were no better than the ignorant person inciting this rumor.

They carried those slanderous persnal attacks with doctored photos dipicting him as a muslim. The photo that darkened his skin color and the photo in the gifted dress garb from a family friend. These are the sly inuendos they thought would work for them. It only gave ammunition for the cable channels and the Repugs to savagely attack Obama's character. This is why she will have no place in his administration, number two or otherwise. This will back fire on the Repugs the same way, if not; we're sure that McSame and his bashing of women will do it for them

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 09:14 PM on 06/28/2008
- HamletsMill I'm a Fan of HamletsMill 251 fans permalink
photo

I agree belief08. HRC lost my vote in the "60 Minutes" interview with the "as far as I know". Up until then I had kept an open mind and tried to study each candidates position on the issues. I think she lost many in that Interview. It showed how clueless she truly was. I don't care if she was badgered. You don't say that. The Clintons lost many voters on their callowness and pandering to the worst, most ignorant , elements in American society. I live in Pennsylvania and Obama was right. People here are grieving to what has been done to them by holding onto their Bibles and guns. But pompous "Rick Sanatorium" finally got his walking papers. People can only vote against their own self interest for ten years. The spell is now broken across the board. Change must come. Even for the Wal-Mart level of consciousness in the Universe.

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 03:57 AM on 06/29/2008
- noamjunior I'm a Fan of noamjunior 86 fans permalink

Obama's underhanded attacks against Clinton?
you CANT NAME ONE

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 09:53 PM on 06/28/2008
- piul05 I'm a Fan of piul05 57 fans permalink
photo

Part II

The point is, there's nothing wrong in representing a minority under a positive light (as with the Jewish population), but there is a problem in its over-representation (i.e. the proportionality of its representation in relation to the general population) and even more so with the under-repr­esentation and demonization of a equally numerically significant population (i.e. Muslims). Does it matter? I think it does; television not only naturalises behavior but it also defines parameters of inclusion/­exclusion; it shapes perceptions and opinions. And even the supposedly "enlightened" media is not safe from these stereotypes; not long ago the Huff was talking about a "smear” campaign against Obama - meaning he was being called a Muslim. Now, there's nothing wrong in being a Muslim; to call it a smear is comparable to call anyone a felon - but yet, there' is this generalized insensitivity even from those who supposedly should use the words judiciously. Muslims have been some of the most decent, humble, knowledgeable, kind people I've met in my life (I'm a woman, brought up as a "lapsed" catholic and now, an agnostic); there are over a billion of them, so generalizations are a pointless, as it is an unhelpful, exercise.

I hope the US weans itself off the need for an evil Other - at the end f the day, not only do we live in Liquid Times ( paraphrasing the great philosopher Zygmunt Bauman) but that life is played out on the same clump of clay.

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 06:36 PM on 06/28/2008

Wonderful observation -- one which I have been aware of for quite some time. The American Jewish culture has heavily influenced American culture, although American Jews comprise a relatively small percentage of our overall population (2%). They have dominated our entertainment industry for generations, and the American media is 25% Jewish. It therefore stands to reason that they -- especially those with Zionist leanings -- would take advantage of their privileged positions and elevate themselves and their religion while vilifying Muslims, since Arabic countries traditionally at odds with Israel are predominately Muslim.

I find it to be despicable that America (80% Christian) places the Judeo-Christian religion on a pedestal, while at the same time damns Islam to hell. The far right rarely mentions the word "Muslim" without adding "radical" to it. Presidential candidates are encouraged to shun Muslims and avoid being seen or photographed with them, as if they were outcasts or lepers. How utterly insulting to the American Muslim community.

If cowardly Americans are so "skeered" of Muslims because they associate them with terrorism, then they should study the history of Christianity in America, taking particular note of the terroristic attrocities that those Christians committed against Native Americans in the name of their Christian "God." It ain't pretty. If America would stop being so biased in favor of Israel, then perhaps they could have better relations with Muslim countries (duh!).

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 10:24 PM on 06/28/2008
- Chillinout I'm a Fan of Chillinout 125 fans permalink
photo

To thinkbolt:

Agnostics and Atheists are not the same. Learn the definition of the words you are describing.

atheism |ˈāθēˌizəm|
noun
the theory or belief that God does not exist.

agnostic |agˈnästik|
noun
a person who believes that nothing is known or can be known of the existence or nature of God or of anything beyond material phenomena; a person who claims neither faith nor disbelief in God.

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 06:36 PM on 06/28/2008
photo

Chillinout replied:
"To thinkbolt:

Agnostics and Atheists are not the same. Learn the definition of the words you are describing­."

Thanks for posting those. In other words, because I realize that I don't have any idea whether there's consciousness behind the universe, I call myself an agnostic.

Because I don't at all believe a specific set of folktales of a royal/grandfatherly universe creator, certain people call me an atheist. Some of them even say I hate a fictional character. Let me set the record straight: don't hate God, don't hate Jesus. On the other hand, don't like Satan, and do think Leviticus should have had a Twilight Zone episode devoted to him.

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 09:02 PM on 06/28/2008
photo

Uh oh. My father was a banker, that means I'm a banker...

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 06:35 PM on 06/28/2008

The rumor spread because it is politically incorrect to say "I am voting against this guy because he is black." But it is somehow perfectly acceptable in today's America to say "I am voting against this guy because he's Muslim." Bigots are just finding the socially acceptable door and walking right through.

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 06:35 PM on 06/28/2008
- zizi I'm a Fan of zizi 3 fans permalink

You nailed it.

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 11:19 PM on 06/28/2008

It started with the Clinton Campaign and Bob Kerry.

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 06:35 PM on 06/28/2008
- pupbayer I'm a Fan of pupbayer 23 fans permalink

LMAO!!!!

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 09:06 PM on 06/28/2008
- piul05 I'm a Fan of piul05 57 fans permalink
photo

Part I

And if he were a Muslim what's the problem? There are between 3 and 6 million Muslims in the US; in other words, they might have numerical parity with the Jewish population - but, considering the way the Media portraits them, they could be dodos in disguise.

Which brings us to the next point - name a series, a film, anything on TV that doesn't have a overbearing Jewish mother, or the nerdy but highly intelligent Jewish guy, the irritating but lovable Jewish businessman, a passing reference, a Happy Hanukkah, a Bar Mitzvah. From "House" to "Friends" to "Sex and the City" to "Charmed" to "Parker Lewis" to "Frasier" to "Desperate Housewives" to "Entourage" to "CSI" to even the "Third Rock from the Sun"! I could go on... and that is and not even getting started on films. Alternatively, for a similarly numerically significant population (Muslims) can anyone think of anything other than your typical alien, terrorist stereotype? I can think of a couple - a nurse in E.R.; the policeman in a film ("A Perfect Murder") with Michael Douglas and Gwyneth Paltrow... ah, a family in "The Shield" but they were harassed (because they were Muslims); an office in "E-Ring” (also falsely accused of being a collaborat­or)... That's about it, really; unless we're talking about films where they're proven terrorists. The contrast is far more striking when you're abroad, as people's fresh readings are far sharper, and they are quick to point the discrepancies to you.

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 06:34 PM on 06/28/2008
- jadez I'm a Fan of jadez 3 fans permalink

Obama is an AMERICAN CITIZEN.

there is no such thing as a "law" that makes you any religion when born.
period.

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 06:17 PM on 06/28/2008
- Chillinout I'm a Fan of Chillinout 125 fans permalink
photo

Jewish law says that if you are born of a Jewish mother, that makes you a Jew.

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 06:40 PM on 06/28/2008
- Cookie100 I'm a Fan of Cookie100 58 fans permalink
photo

Yup!

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 06:43 PM on 06/28/2008
- Ramirez I'm a Fan of Ramirez 276 fans permalink
photo

"... the heart of the matter is that children born of Muslim lineage will be considered Muslims and according to Islamic law the door of apostasy will never be opened to them. If anyone of them renounces Islam, he will be as deserving of execution as the person who has renounced kufr to become a Muslim and again has chosen the way of kufr. All the jurists of Islam agree with this decision. On this topic absolutely no difference exists among the experts of shari'ah."
-- Sayyid Abul Ala Maududi

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Apostasy_in_Islam#Maududi

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 08:18 PM on 06/28/2008
- Cynth I'm a Fan of Cynth 13 fans permalink

Since you posted this here again, I offer my reply again:

That's a rather selective passage; moreover, wikipedia is not considered an authoritative source (albeit a convenient one). I can easily quote any of a number of Christian theologians past and present and claim that it represents all Christian beliefs. And we know that even religious interpretation evolve over time.

The NYT Public Editor [in addressing Luttwak's op ed piece] consulted a number of practicing, noted experts and wasn't selective about their conclusions. Facts, reason, critical thinking.

But rumor mongers can wear very heavy filters and they can be persistent­....

Let's think about it this way: How does Obama affiliate himself? Isn't up to him to define it? And if a candidate believes in principles that are consistent with what America is founded upon and aims to uphold the Constitution, shouldn't that be OK, regardless of his/her religion or non-religion? Isn't that what our founders intended?

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 10:46 PM on 06/28/2008

So if Obama's dad was an atheist, then how could he be a Muslim according to your explanation? If Obama was born to an atheist how does that make him Muslim?

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 12:11 AM on 06/29/2008

----------­----------­----------­---

FALSE RUMORS….. STOP THE FOX ATTACKS

"FOX is a Republican mouthpiece, not a legitimate news organization. Real news organizations must reject FOX's smears of Barack Obama, not parrot them and distract Americans from the pressing issues of the day."

FOX ATTACKS

CLICK> http://foxattacks.com/

CLICK> http://au.youtube.com/watch?v=ouKJixL--ms

SIGN THE FOX News Petition STOP THEM FROM SPREADING The VIROUS!!

https://pol.moveon.org/pac/donate/foxattacksobama2.html?r=3495&id=12319-7461992-qvY5Rv

ANOTHER PETITION

https://civ.moveon.org/donatec4/foxattacksiran.html/?rc=fox_attacks_iran_frontpage&r=2916

ANOTHER PETITION

http://foxattacks.com/virus

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 06:07 PM on 06/28/2008
- GeoLee I'm a Fan of GeoLee 64 fans permalink

Well, golly gee, I guess the Clinton haters on this site will be unhappy to learn that the rumor did not generate from the Clintons after all and started long before any presidentiual run was considered. I am not surprised about where it seems to have started. I knew darn good and well when hearing him speak in 2004 that he would become a target of the right because he showed such promise the other side got scared of what he might evolve into. They probably have been running a stealth watch for years....a­nd I bet when Karl Rove was still in the WH, and maybe even now, a more formal investigation such as wire taps, phone and email searches have been going on. I am way too cynical to trust they don't' have goods on any potential democratic candidate to spring on us in the fall. I think thqt may be how theyhave kept the democratic leadership in line, frankly. The real big brother moved in in 2000.

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 05:52 PM on 06/28/2008
- Chillinout I'm a Fan of Chillinout 125 fans permalink
photo

I have never heard anyone say this rumor started with the Clintons. Though Hillary did nothing to stop it, and in fact with her "as far as I know" comment she helped propagate that rumor.

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 05:59 PM on 06/28/2008
- Jellybelly I'm a Fan of Jellybelly 5 fans permalink

Every comment against Obama was blamed on the Clintons by Obama supporters. And when you Chillinout knew it, you did nothing to stop it.

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 07:07 PM on 06/28/2008
- pupbayer I'm a Fan of pupbayer 23 fans permalink

You've got to be kidding! Many, many, many posts on here said she started the rumor as well as other rumors she didn't have anything to do with.

As far as her not stopping it, I'm not sure how she could. He didn't stop it either. Her "as far as I know" comment was an honest one. As far as she knew...she doesn't know what is in his heart and mind. She was honest but I guess that's enough for you.

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 07:54 PM on 06/28/2008
- StillIRise I'm a Fan of StillIRise 573 fans permalink
photo

As an Obama supporter, but not a Clinton HATER, I never thought that the rumors started with Senator Clinton, and I don't recall that most of Obama's supporters thought this. I did believe however that Senator Clinton did not do enough, when she had the opportunity, to quell the rumor; and it was also widely known or suspected that it was the Clinton campaign that revealed the picture of Senator Obama in African garb. From this perspective, though they didn't start the rumor, it seems that they did exploit it.

To all of your other points, I agree wholeheartedly.

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 09:18 PM on 06/28/2008
- meanguy I'm a Fan of meanguy 17 fans permalink

are you kidding? accusing the clintons of starting the rumors was a major part of the obama campaign..­.and it was echoed by his supporters repeatedly as an article of faith, especially in this forum. your accusation re: the goofy pic of obama is a case in point. no evidence to support the charge, but evidence doesn't matter to obamanites. and it was not clnton's responsibility to refute rumors about obama-that's purely delusional­...obama needs to grow a set and start standing up for himself, and quit his juvenile pantywaist whining that his political opponents need to defend him

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 07:20 AM on 06/30/2008
- teembee I'm a Fan of teembee 4 fans permalink

Muslims around the world think he is one of them.

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 05:31 PM on 06/28/2008

Actually, no. The only people who think he is Muslim are ignorant Americans. Read the comments to the NYT's infamously false op-ed by neo-con Edward Luttwak: around the world, Muslims write in to say they've never heard anybody in their country say he's a Muslim.

They are hopeful because Obama would be such an improvement over wilfully ignorant, George W.

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 05:42 PM on 06/28/2008
- Cynth I'm a Fan of Cynth 13 fans permalink

Word.

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 08:56 PM on 06/28/2008
- kevenseven I'm a Fan of kevenseven 501 fans permalink
photo

Based on what do you make that statement?

What empirical evidence do you have?

Is that it, floating in your toilet bowl?

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 05:56 PM on 06/28/2008

Yeah, they got the emails too.

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 07:20 PM on 06/28/2008
- StillIRise I'm a Fan of StillIRise 573 fans permalink
photo

Many Christians around the world think that he's one of them also. Senator Obama has universal appeal, and this is what makes him so unique.

He IS one of them. He is one of ALL OF US.

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 09:20 PM on 06/28/2008
- meanguy I'm a Fan of meanguy 17 fans permalink

try reading that out loud WITHOUT giggling..­.'we are the ones he's been wating to con'

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 08:12 AM on 06/30/2008
Moderator's Pick

HuffPost's Pick

The reality is that while the Internet is an information super highway, it is also a misinformation super highway.

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 05:24 PM on 06/28/2008
- mike53 I'm a Fan of mike53 8 fans permalink

Good point. The internet has been very good for Obama.

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 06:30 PM on 06/28/2008
Page: « First ‹ Previous 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 Next › Last » (10 pages total)
Comments are closed for this entry

 You must be logged in to comment. Log in  or connect with 

Connect