Tavis Smiley Tackles Obama And Race

digg Share this on Facebook Huffpost - stumble reddit del.ico.us RSS

KINNEY LITTLEFIELD | July 21, 2008 04:14 PM EST | AP


In this Feb. 23, 2008 file photo, Tavis Smiley raises his hand, just after the benediction at the Ernest Morial Convention Center, during Smiley's State of the Black Union Town Hall in New Orleans. (AP Photo/Carolyn Kaster, file)

LOS ANGELES — Tavis Smiley is all wound up. His voice is rough from too much vocalizing, but the host of public television's "Tavis Smiley" talk show and public radio's "The Tavis Smiley Show" is on an oratorical roll about race, politics, and his fellow African-American, presumptive Democratic presidential nominee Barack Obama.

"There is no such thing in America as race transcendence, and Obama's going to find that out real soon," says Smiley, leaning into his words. As he sermonizes, he sheds suit jacket, tie and belt in succession, getting comfy in his spacious suite at KCET in Los Angeles after taping two installments of "Tavis Smiley" (Monday-Friday in various time-slots on PBS stations).

Despite the peaceful vibe inside his sanctuary, with its African masks and scented candle, Smiley frowns. "There's no such thing as 'post-racial' in America, because if you push the envelope too far, you're going to hear about it."

Smiley should know. For months he has been the object of an Internet firestorm for his perceived negative comments about Obama on commercial radio's syndicated "The Tom Joyner Morning Show."

Smiley found himself between race and a hard place when he criticized Obama on-air for choosing not to appear on Smiley's annual State of the Black Union cablecast on C-SPAN in February. Smiley's remarks sparked a blaze of invective by African-American bloggers, who questioned Smiley's loyalty, motives and ego.

After 12 years as a fixture on Joyner's show, Smiley delivered his final commentary on June 26. Smiley insists his departure was not a reaction to the flak, but rather a decision that he had been on Joyner's show long enough.

"Just because Barack Obama is black, doesn't mean he gets a pass on being held accountable on issues that matter to black people," Smiley says. "I'm not an Obama critic or a McCain critic. The term itself is dismissive and insulting."

For Smiley _ a multimedia entrepreneur who is an important voice in the African-American community, who owns his TV and radio shows, who has authored 11 books and created the nonprofit Tavis Smiley Foundation to empower youth _ the disparagement by black bloggers still stings.

Story continues below
advertisement

His dilemma is also emblematic of the media conundrum of the moment for black and white journalists alike: how to responsibly and sensitively address the issue of race and couch coverage of the likely first-ever run for the White House by a major-party nominee who is black.

"We have an awkward history about how to talk about race in the nation and in newsrooms," says Gwen Ifill, senior correspondent for PBS' "The NewsHour with Jim Lehrer" and author of "The Breakthrough: Politics and Race in the Age of Obama," slated for publication early next year.

"I don't see any hesitancy about addressing it," Ifill says. "But I do think we are all searching for the language."

David Bohrman, CNN's Washington bureau chief, agrees. "It's still a sensitive topic, but I think the door's been opened to the conversation ... Whether or not that conversation will happen in a reasonable or superficial way _ I don't think anyone has a real sense of how it will play out right now."

Smiley will broadcast his talk show live to select markets from the Democratic convention in Denver Aug. 25-28 and the Republican convention in St. Paul, Minn., Sept. 1-4.

"I want to do what I always try to do, which is to be authentic in my coverage," Smiley says. "I'm an advocacy journalist, not a journalist in the traditional sense. I believe my role in the media is to get people to re-examine the assumptions they hold."

That challenge is not always obvious on Smiley's talk show. In its five-year run "Tavis Smiley" has included a stew of both stars and politicos, from Obama, last fall, and Hillary Clinton in February, to Harrison Ford, Dustin Hoffman, and hip, young-skewing musical guests such as Ne-Yo.

But it is Smiley's role as vigilant media inquisitor _ and never mind political correctness _ that he seems to relish most.

"This is what I do _ asking critical questions," Smiley says. "Now some of you regard it as keeping a brother down, holding a brother back. Because you regard it that way, you don't understand that this is the role that I've always played."

___

On the Net:

http://www.pbs.org

LOS ANGELES — Tavis Smiley is all wound up. His voice is rough from too much vocalizing, but the host of public television's "Tavis Smiley" talk show and public radio's "The Tavis Smiley Show" i...
LOS ANGELES — Tavis Smiley is all wound up. His voice is rough from too much vocalizing, but the host of public television's "Tavis Smiley" talk show and public radio's "The Tavis Smiley Show" i...
 
Comments
102
Pending Comments
0
iPhone App Promo

Want to reply to a comment? Hint: Click "Reply" at the bottom of the comment; after being approved your comment will appear directly underneath the comment you replied to

View Comments:
Page: 1 2 3 4 Next › Last » (4 pages total)
photo

Hey, Travis, you better shut your stinking mouth up, mafu!! n i 9 9 e r!

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 07:23 AM on 07/23/2008

I think Tavis just thought he was bigger than he is. Somehow in his own little world, he found himself to be special (I thought he was ok-I liked his show, which I noticed is NO LONGER televised in my area). I never understood his attacks on Obama, in fact at the time of the Black Caucus and his commands that both democratic candidates show up and bow to the audience; too weird, I was really taken aback. All of those people in attendence were nuts for Obama except Tavis and 'maybe' Ms. Ohio, S. Tubbs, who chose to sell her soul and wound up losing it later as we have all witnessed.

Jealousy - something to watch for, icky, wouldn't want it, obviously it is hard to shake. I see Tavis on Christian TV and wonder what he is doing there. Who is Tavis, Where does he belong?

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 05:42 PM on 07/22/2008
photo

Smiley is right, we've not transcended race. The proof is..he is not a well-known personality. I'm a political junkie with lots of left wing friends who have never heard of Tavis. He is fair and lets people talk, just like Bill Moyers. I've been watching Tavis for years, and there aren't many that reach the integrity he has.
I'd be willing to bet most of the people who are putting him down now are white, like me.
There's no way anyone will agree with a journalist (or anyone) all the time.

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 02:27 PM on 07/22/2008

too late, under the bus with him...as if he never existed

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 02:41 PM on 07/22/2008
photo

February 2008 was the first time I heard of and watched his 'State of the Black Union.' Although I understand a need for discussion, I've heard their discussion too many times over the years. At some point, the ball of action needs to get rolling.

IMO, Obama is all about action. Everything they talked about on the 'State of the Black Union,' Obama is addressing in his campaign -- just not for Blacks, but every American. Therefore, Smiley's integrity is where I may be in disagreement with you. My impression of Tavis' remarks about Obama for not making an appearance seemed to come from his ego; he acted as if he was spurned, rejected.

My question to Tavis would be, because you are Black, a writer, a commentator, and political activist, does that give you a "pass?"

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 05:33 PM on 07/22/2008
photo

Pass on what? Doing something? Isn't his job journalism and communication? He works all the time. And action IS needed, but that doesn't mean the discussion ends. I love Obama and I love Tavis, just cuz they differ, doesn't negate everything the one you disagree with has done, or will do.

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 12:31 AM on 07/23/2008
photo

[continued due to word limit ??]

To me, Tavis seemed to disregard that Obama was in a very tight race with Hillary Clinton for the Democratic Nomination for President of these United States. He seemed to disregard that during the time of his Panel, primaries were being held in very racially biased states. During that time, Obama was being hit with anything and everything that everyone he associated with espoused. And there were some very colorful commentators on that Panel.

Hillary had several advocates, Blacks, speaking in her favor at the Tavis event. None of what any of them said would have ever adversely affected her campaign. However, everything, regardless of the intent, would have made HEADLINES against Obama's favor.

Then I watched Hillary stumble over her speech. She stuttered, had to reread lines, and mispronounced many words. Rarely did she lift her eyes from her copy. I felt no connection to her or her rhetoric. And she had the last say. I saw nothing in the news about this or her remarks.

IMO, Hillary needed to be there. She was trying to regain Black support. Obama needed to be elsewhere trying to gain support he never had and may never get. Tavis of all people should get this.

to be continued...

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 05:37 PM on 07/22/2008
photo

[final remark]

However, I agree with almost all you've stated in regards to Tavis. I've watched and listened to him for years. But I believe he has too much going on to continue his spot on Tom Joyner's Show, at least he thinks he does. How long was his spot anyway, 10 minutes? The real deal may be that Smiley's outgrown the TJMS and I believe he would have left regardless of the Obama supporters' backlash.

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 05:39 PM on 07/22/2008

Your right Tavis is a great journalist, but he crossed the line when Barack wouldn't do what he wanted him to do. He talked about Barack being a new kind of leader, trying to transcend race, but the second Barack decided not to come to the State of the Black Union he went off on him just because he was black. Why didn't he do that with McBush or any other leaders. The only reason Clinton went was because she was desperate to get SOME of the black vote back after Bill's foot in mouth action.

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 07:33 PM on 07/22/2008

Tavis ... hear that ticking sound .... You would be better off letting go of the grenade. You are the only one holding it!!!

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 02:21 PM on 07/22/2008

THIS IS ALL ABOUT TAVIS SMILEY AND HIS BRUISED EGO. HE MUST BE SELLING SOMETHING REAL SOON AND NEEDED A LITTLE PR.

BARACK IS NOT A F'ing SAVIOR, WE KNOW THAT AND HE KNOWS THAT. FOR SOME REASON TAVIS NEEDS HIS AUDIENCE TO BELIEVE THAT BLACK FOLK ARE SO STUPID AND NAIVE SO THEY WILL CONTINUE TO BUY HIS BOOKS AND WATCH HIS BORING SHOW.

STOP IT TAVIS, EVERYONE KNOWS WE CAN'T TRANSCEND RACE IN THIS COUNTRY, IT WILL NEVER HAPPEN AND BARACK IS NOT TRYING TO TRANSCEND ANYTHING, HE IS TRYING TO BECOME THE NEXT PRESIDENT.

YOU SEEM TO BE SO AFRAID THAT BLACK PEOPLE WILL BE SO DISAPPOINTED BY BARACK BEING ELECTED PRESIDENT; I THINK YOU ARE PROJECTING YOUR FEARS ON THE REST OF THE BLACK COMMUNITY. YOU WHO SAY YOU LOVE BLACK PEOPLE SO MUCH ARE "TALKING DOWN TO BLACK FOLK" AS JESSE JACKSON WOULD SAY.

GET OVER YOURSELF DUDE!

Be well, CF

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 02:07 PM on 07/22/2008

I was one of those that was "Tavis Tavis Tavis" and then Barack decided to run for POTUS. His tirades against Obama every Tuesday and Thursday became the norm. He was actually contridicting his own message. His passion for reading and Black people doing their homework on candidates was unmatched. Therefore, I was thoroughly shocked when he didn't think Black people had enough sense to determine who they wanted for POTUS. Because Black people went overwhelmingly for Barack Obama there must have been something seriously wrong with us although 75% of the Black vote was initially for Hillary. Could it possibly have been that Black people did do their homework and decided to vote for Barack instead of Hillary in spite of his daily tirades? If Tavis had been unbiased in his commentaries and decided to support Hillary that would have been fine but he wasn't. No matter what Hillary or Bill said or did his commentaries/tirades were all against Obama. Now that he's been put out to pasture on TJ show he's going to do his best to make sure he stays "relevant" by attacking Obama. I expect him to be a commentator on Faux News soon; they love his type!!

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 02:03 PM on 07/22/2008

Tavis wants attention. He can join the ranks of the other blacks, Jessie, etc. that thrive on racial division. Their main income comes from talking and discussion about how blacks and whites will never come together. Tavis is jealous because some blacks can transcend race, but he isn't one of them. As for asking critical questions, who deemed him of relevance to ask any questions of anyone, much less Obama.? He has an over exaggerated opinion of his role. And that is his problem he hasn't got one. He is dying to be a big fish in a little pond but knows deep inside it won't happen. Sad and pathetic.

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 01:49 PM on 07/22/2008

Never liked Tavis or his show. Too phony for me. Yes, there is some jealousy about BO. A few names that come to mind is Tavis, Jesse, Pastor Joe at MSNBC and some others. These are the people who have prospered from the Clinton trough, black people trough (conferences, that offer no solutions), but keep coming back ya'll hear. Obama is not bought and paid for, so therefore, no access. Bob Johnson couldn't threaten even with all his billions. Never liked BET either. There will not be many from the old school at the WH I bet and that's OK with me. We have a lot of sellouts in our community too as do others.

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 11:38 AM on 07/22/2008

Tavis Smiley's next book should be titled "The Audacity of Jealousy." Get over yourself, Tavis!

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 02:30 PM on 07/22/2008

I WAS a frequent viewer of Tavis' tv show, and I do NOT believe that he "should" support Barak, or any other politician. BUT on the day Barak clinched the nomination, Tavis ran his whole program about the RFK assassination. Just putting it out in the universe! I haven't been able to watch him since.

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 10:58 AM on 07/22/2008

I don't like that he says there is no such thing as 'post racial' in America. I think that is being as naive as saying that there will be no more race issues if Obama is elected. There will be racial issues as long as we don't talk about the issues and work on them. They won't be solved that easily, but they aren't impossible to solve either. Both sides must come together, but why would someone say that reconciliation isn't possible. That sounds like youre accepting defeat before even trying.

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 10:49 AM on 07/22/2008

I totally agree with Tavis. As an African American I have already bought my ticket to Denver to see Obama accept the nomination. However Obama should not be given a free pass just because he is black. If his policies are wrong not only for black Americans but for all Americans he should be called out on it. If he is, it's not because someone is "hating" on him, its because he is wrong.

If Obama some how loses this election I think this would be the reason why; his die hard supporters and the Obama campaign come off as if "how can you not support and vote for him". I have my doubts about his experience and him being able to turn things around with so much at stake. This election is bigger than Obama. If you read the newspapers you can see just how much Americans are hurting and how this country is going in the wrong direction, and no one, including Obama should get a free pass or go without criticism, especially when it is deserved.

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 10:29 AM on 07/22/2008

Tavis-I've always known you to tackle any issue but I find it hard to believe at this moment and this time it is solely about the issue more so the person. You see know that everybody and there momma, uncle, daddy and cousin are willing you hand you a mic and watch you go after Obama. You are getting personal. You see IF you would have went after Bush this same way but brotha there is ROOM for you too. There is no need for the HATERATION.

YOU ROCK TOO BECAUSE WE APPRECIATE YOUR WORK.

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 08:46 AM on 07/22/2008
photo

Smiley is the latest in a long line of unprincipled hucksters who attempt to profit on their "supposed" "leadership" of the Black community. He is and always has been a charlatan who is being properly exposed and marginalized for the fraud he is. Good riddance for all of his type.
Tavis, you are irrelevant.

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 08:36 AM on 07/22/2008
photo

Agreed... Tavis is a pretender to a throne that (thank God) no longer exists.

Jesse bloodied himself on a Memphis balcony forty years ago and has kept the faithful riled up ever since. Al saw him self as the heir apparent and invented a rape case to demonstrate his bona fides.

Tavis thought that maybe, just maybe, a younger brother and a non-Reverend might be better suited to the gig. Alas, Obama came along and screwed up the works by insisting that personal responsibility and mutual cooperation are better than grievance and entitlement.

This could herald a new Golden Age for carnival barkers, but the age of gimme gimme gimme is done. Knawha 'msayin?

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 10:41 AM on 07/22/2008
photo

Oh yes, he is such a huckster. Too bad he can't live up to the level of Glen Beck, Michael Weiner-Savage, Bill O'Rielly, etc. ad nausea.
And the only people reading this page stupid enough to think you are black or not republican are the rest of the trolls.
White people like you make it so hard for decent folk.

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 12:25 AM on 07/23/2008
photo

I've seen Tavis's yearly convention of the brightest minds our comunity has to offer,. And granted the theory is well intentioned. Everyone is bsically looking for thier 15 minutes to hoot and hollar with no real solutions after the fact. If tavis would deflate the ego a bit he would know that the issues of the African American community and the nation as a whole has something that has been apart of Obama from day one. Getting on tv to hott and hollar doesn't mena your accomplishing much. When has Tavis hit the streets anf held a voter's registration drive in the community?

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 03:03 AM on 07/22/2008

Most of the comments posted here are ignorant, hateful and comically absurd. You could all give those carnival freaks over at Fox news a good run for their money with your stupid, inane accusations of jealously and your gleeful response to Smiley leaving the Tom Joyner Show. I'm African American, just as many of you here appear to be. I find your comments embarrassing and most of you people ill-informed. Tavis Smiley has done so much for the black community and I doubt very seriously if he's jealous of Barack Obama or anyone else. Support Obama all you want but there is no need to disparage Tavis Smiley for wanting "to ask the critical questions." That's what a real journalist does.

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 02:24 AM on 07/22/2008

I totally agree. Blind lockstep with any candidate while demeaning anyone with a clear-eyed approach to political analysis is an enemy to our freedoms. Democracy requires healthy skepticism, debate. Obama should NEVER be an exception to this fundamental principle of accountabilty. You will be creating a monster if you give him a pass on so many recent triangulations!!!

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 12:10 PM on 07/22/2008

True! However, Tavis wasn't critical of Hillary at all. When I heard she was attending his annual event and I expected to get answers to the hardcore questions the mainstream media was to afraid to ask i.e. does she still support her husbands 3 strike law and all the other drug laws that lead to a 75% increase in black men going to jail? Why did they ignore the Rwanda situation? She ran on her White House experience so these questions are/were fair game. What happened? When she got there Tavis basically rubbed her feet, asking only easy questions that we all already knew the answer to. I agree with Tavis that we must hold ALL our leaders accountable but HE'S the one who got happy-go-lucky just because she showed up to his event to apologize for her husband's stupid comments. It's not about accountability at all, its about seeking his approval.
The reason a lot of people feel Tavis is jealous is because he never has anything positive to say about Obama. And yes, I am happy he left the show, we can no longer allow other people to divide us so, if leaving the village is the only way to save it :so be it!

Tavis was of those in the media pushing for Hillary to stay in the race, every Tuesday & Thursday we heard the same thing. I hope he offered to pay that debt, since staying the race was a great idea.

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 05:30 PM on 07/22/2008

Haven't heard Tavis lately. (Don't do radio or tv much anymore) But what people are criticizing about the Smiley is that he is ranting against Obama constantly. Is that so? Does he ever speak in support of Obama's accomplishments and ideas? Is it all criticism all the time?

My understanding of the SBN broohaha was that it came at a critical time for campaigning in states with pending primaries. Obama was forced to judge whether it was wiser for him to spend his time reaching out to constituencies that were less likely for him to support him. As a black man, he hoped others would understand this and allow him to reach out later. This seemed pragmatic and reasonable, but from the quotes I read Smiley portrayed it as an insult. I haven't heard of other African American leaders who did the same.

I'm Caucasian, so I can't claim any perspective on how the black community sees either Smiley or Obama, except vicariously through my African American friends. When I look at the legislative history of Obama, it seems to me that he's working against the institutionalized racism he sees. Look at what he did in the Illinois State Senate. So, I understand not giving a black man a pass, but does he get credit where credit is due or does he have to be more perfect than any white candidate has ever been? Is there a place for cross-culturally respectful dialog about this?

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 11:15 PM on 07/22/2008
Page: 1 2 3 4 Next › Last » (4 pages total)
Comments are closed for this entry

You must be logged in to reply to this comment. Log in  or  Connect

 
Right Now on HuffPost
YOUR SOCIAL SECURITY NUMBER CAN BE GUESSED

Researchers have found that it is possible to guess many -- if...

Obamas Tour The Kremlin

MOSCOW — Russia's first lady Svetlana Medvedev took...