Ich Bin Ein Whatever

Earlier today I wrote a post about all the "Ich Bin Ein" headlines that were springing up around Barack Obama's visit to Berlin, in a callback to the famous speech wherein John F. Kennedy declared "Ich Bin Ein Berliner" which was translated as "I am a Berliner." (You can read it here and watch him do it here.) JFK delivered that speech in June 1963, and the full context of the quote was as follows: "Today, in the world of freedom, the proudest boast is 'Ich bin ein Berliner.'"

Following the speech, there was some confusion about whether he got it right — should he have instead said "Ich bin Berliner" ("I am a citizen of Berlin"), and did "Ich bin ein Berliner" actually mean "I am a jelly doughnut?" (A "Berliner" is a name for a type of jelly doughnut in Berlin.) Many people reported it as a gaffe — including the New York Times and no less an expert than Kennedy speechwriter Ted Sorenson, who wrote the speech in question and who reported in his recent memoirs, abashed, that he had gotten in wrong.

But he didn't! According to actual Germans, Kennedy was totally right. Here's what German professor Michael Jennings told the NYT's Steve Coates:

Certainly the most common and accepted way to say "I'm a resident of Berlin" is "Ich bin Berliner," i.e. without the indefinite article. But, for many speakers, it is by no means incorrect or ungrammatical to say "Ich bin ein Berliner." Some of my respondents in fact applauded Kennedy on his nuanced use of German, since for them the sentence without the indefinite article implies that the speaker is a native Berliner, while the sentence with "ein" suggests either more recent residence in Berlin or even solidarity with its inhabitants (which was clearly Kennedy / Sorenson's intention).

I actually linked to that effect in my original piece, but a commenter was still peeved that I had perpetuated the jelly donut myth (though let's leave aside for a moment whether you can rely on your audience to bring their own foreknowledge to the table). So, now that Obama has made his speech and in order to avoid any further confusion, I wanted to make things absolutely clear:

I hope that clears things up.



Ich Bin What? [NYT]
Ich Bin Ein Obama Headline [ETP]

Related:
The Berliner: In Search of the Mythic Donut [Gridskipper]

Transcript:
Obama Berlin Speech [HuffPo]

Video:
Obama Berlin Speech [HuffPo]

Comments

[ALHayes]

Eddie Izzard makes reference to this supposed gaffe. Interesting that it wasn't a gaffe at all! I'll have to send him a link....

[GayIthacan]

Oh God - No - don't ask him to remove the material! It is among his funniest!!!!!

:)

[comatoast]

I like jelly doughnuts. Jelly doughnuts are yummy. You too, Rachel.

[MPeter]

It took this guy one trip and a great speech to resurrect America from the graveyard where the neocons and Rethugs have burried it for the last eight years. It is a shame some Americans still listen and follow this zombie called MCBush.

[presto]

For once, the Huffpo headline is perfect.

[Bitsko]

Many languages, take Italian for instance, allow one to skip certain words and still be correct and understandable. Much of it has to do with how formal one wishes or is obligated to be.

[misanthropexlife]

Ich bin nicht ein Berliner.

[JiminNC]

me too

[AnotherMcIntosh]

One answer to the jelly donut myth, which did not originate by me, is that if a German citizen came to New York and sought to show solidarity by saying, "I am a New Yorker," no one would legitimately claim that the German speaker was claiming to be a magazine.

[11907281]

game. set. match.

[gretchenart]

Probably since you cannot, indeed, eat a magazine, or at least not digest it properly, whereas the jelly donuts called "Amerikaner" and "Berliner" are ubiquitous in Germany!

[JiminNC]

And you can read a jelly donut? WTF?

[rbdc]

And New Yorker magazines are not ubiquitous in New York? I will concur that it's probably not wise to eat them though!

[UnionJok]

According to German Wikipedia http://de.wikipedia.org/wiki/Amerikaner_%28Geb%C3%A4ck%29
the pastry called Amerikaner may have a connection to Black and White Cookies. It also suggests that the name could instead be a contraction of "Ammoniakaner", which contain ammonium carbonate as a leavening agent.

Good thing he stayed away from that one.

[pizzmoe]

Is there a sandwich at the Carnegie deli called a "New Yorker?

[RobertAndropolis]

Or a boat-sized Chrysler from the '60s.

[CJGibson]

What if our hypothetical German said "I am the New Yorker." It certainly becomes more possible that he's talking about the magazine.

It's funny how getting an article slightly wrong can kind of alter the meaning of the sentence.

[anastasiabeaverhousen]

Thanks for the chuckle.

[jupitor]

Greet the next president of the United States! He's got our standing back in the world for us!