Page Six Doesn't Watch Top Chef

In an item trashing "Top Chef" Season 2 contestant Sam Talbot, Page Six may have leveled the biggest insult of all: running a photo of Season 2 winner Ilan Hall instead of Talbot himself. Talbot, who recently got engaged to his girlfriend at the Montauk restaurant where he is working for the summer, was the Season 2 "Fan Favorite" and has gone down in Top Chef lore as one of the show's heartthrobs. Hall, while a master of Spanish cooking and the winner of $100,000 and a Kenmore Pro kitchen, is considerably less attractive than Talbot. See below:

The Page Six photo mistake:

Ilan (L) and Sam (R):

Update: Page Six (online) has corrected the error (see below):

Comments

[situationcritical]

Sam's way hotter with a closely cropped coif.

[CountryBeforeParty]

Great show.

Ilan was excellent, but I really thought Sam was better. He choked

[Eric8869]

Sam was very sexy on top chef but this article is mean. I wouldn't say IIan is "considerably less attractive" than Sam. IIan is a handsome man.

Yes he shouldn't have won for cooking spanish dishes all season long but he is attractive. Jeeez.

I think Harold - the winner from Season 1 is more attractive than both of them.

[bwither]

Since when does throwing Saffron on EVERYTHING make you a master of Spanish cooking?

[Topfeeder]

How true. My mom thinks putting bacon rendering in everything makes her a master chef too, so go figure.

[dagnome27]

If she were cooking in New Orleans, it just might ;-)