Mixed legacy likely as China's Olympics conclude

digg Share this on Facebook Huffpost - Mixed legacy likely as China's Olympics conclude stumble reddit del.ico.us RSS

DAVID CRARY | August 24, 2008 10:59 PM EST | AP

Compare other versions »
I Like ItI Don’t Like It
Fireworks explodes over the National Stadium during the closing ceremony for the 2008 Beijing Olympics in Beijing, Sunday, Aug. 24, 2008. (AP Photo/Andy Wong)

BEIJING — With help from British star power, China concluded its debut as Olympic host Sunday after 16 days of near-flawless logistics and superlative athletic achievement _ coexisting awkwardly with the government's wariness of dissent and free speech.

A spectacular closing ceremony opened with torrents of fireworks and included a pulsating show-within-a-show by London, host of the 2012 Games. From a stage formed from a red double-decker bus, Led Zeppelin guitarist Jimmy Page played classic rock hit "Whole Lotta Love" and soccer icon David Beckham booted a ball into the surrounding throng of athletes on the stadium floor.

Then more lyrical music returned, and the Olympic flame atop the stadium was extinguished.

To a large extent, China, an emergent superpower, got what it had craved from these long-sought games: a dominant effort by its athletes to top the gold-medal standings for the first time and almost glitch-free organizing that showcased world-class venues and cheerful volunteers to the largest-ever peaceful influx of foreign visitors.

As a bonus, not just one but two athletes gave arguably the greatest performances in Olympic history _ Michael Phelps with his eight gold medals in swimming, Jamaica's ebullient Usain Bolt with three golds and three world records in the sprints.

The International Olympic Committee, whose selection of Beijing as host back in 2001 was widely questioned, insisted its choice had been vindicated.

"Tonight, we come to the end of 16 glorious days which we will cherish forever," IOC President Jacques Rogge told the capacity crowd of 91,000 at the National Outdoor Stadium, and a global TV audience. "Through these Games, the world learned more about China, and China learned more about the world."

"These were truly exceptional games," he said, before declaring them formally closed.

Story continues below
advertisement

The head of the Beijing organzing committee, Liu Qi, said the games were "testimony to the fact that the world has rested its trust in China." He called them "a grand celebration of sport, of peace and friendship."

Rogge and the IOC were criticized by human rights groups for their reluctance to publicly challenge the Chinese as various controversies arose over press freedom and detention of dissidents. Athletes shied away from making political statements, and "protest zones" established in Beijing went unused as the authorities refused to issue permits for them.

But the atmosphere was festive at the stadium as fireworks burst from its top rim _ and from locations across Beijing _ to begin the closing ceremony.

After an army band played the Chinese national anthem, hundreds of gayly dressed dancers, acrobats and drummers swirled onto the field, then made room for the athletes, strolling in casually and exuberantly from four different entrances.

China invested more than $40 billion in the games, which it viewed as a chance to show the world its dramatic economic progress. Olympic telecasts achieved record ratings in China and the United States, and the games' presence online was by far the most extensive ever.

Rogge said these Olympics would leave a lasting, positive legacy for China _ improved transportation infrastructure, more grass-roots interest in recreational sports, a more aggressive approach to curbing air pollution and other environmental problems. Smog that enveloped the city early in the games gave way to mostly clear skies, easing fears that some endurance events might be hazardous for the athletes.

American rower Jennifer Kaido of West Leyden, N.Y., said the games exceeded her expectations.

"We were prepared for smog, pollution, demonstrations, but everything has gone very smoothly," she said.

Rogge acknowledged that China, despite promises of press freedom during the games, continued to block access to numerous politically oriented Web sites, including those related to Tibet and the outlawed spiritual movement Falun Gong.

However, he contended that media restrictions were looser during the Olympics than beforehand, "and so we believe the games had a good influence."

Human rights groups disagreed.

"The reality is that the Chinese government's hosting of the games has been a catalyst for abuses, leading to massive forced evictions, a surge in the arrest, detention and harassment of critics, repeated violations of media freedom, and increased political repression," said Sophie Richardson of Human Rights Watch. "Not a single world leader who attended the games or members of the IOC seized the opportunity to challenge the Chinese government's behavior in any meaningful way."

Led by Phelps and Bolt, athletes broke 43 world records and 132 Olympic records during the games. Yet Rogge, who visited every venue, said the most touching moment for him came after the 10-meter air pistol event, when gold medalist Nino Salukvadze of Georgia embraced runner-up Natalia Paderina of Russia even as their two countries' armies fought back in Georgia.

"That kind of sportsmanship is really remarkable," Rogge said.

BEIJING — With help from British star power, China concluded its debut as Olympic host Sunday after 16 days of near-flawless logistics and superlative athletic achievement _ coexisting awkwardly...
BEIJING — With help from British star power, China concluded its debut as Olympic host Sunday after 16 days of near-flawless logistics and superlative athletic achievement _ coexisting awkwardly...
Filed by Max Follmer  |  Report Corrections
 
Comments
189
Pending Comments
0
iPhone App Promo

Want to reply to a comment? Hint: Click "Reply" at the bottom of the comment; after being approved your comment will appear directly underneath the comment you replied to

View Comments:
Page: « First ‹ Previous 1 2 3 4 (4 pages total)
photo

A 17 year old girl wrote on my blog as she was puzzled why the world (including many bloggers here) condemns China for its efforts to give the best show. She likens it with her mom working hard to prepare a Thanksgiving dinner or Christmas party, even if her food might be too salty or not good to some guests, her mom would only hear 'Thank You!' 'It was a great night!'

After China delivers such a fantastic show, NOT without sacrifices, all China hears is criticism and fault finding. Isn't anybody ashamed? Does anyone behave like this at other people's house as guests?

How much do you know personally about China's brutal government? If you truly care about human rights, why don't you read Chinese people's own approval rating to their own government? Didn't you see people smiling on stage? http://www.chinationreport.com/ for daily balanced China news

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 11:28 PM on 08/24/2008

To that 17 year old, I would write:

Does your mom imprison people who do not agree with the way she thinks? Would your mom throw her guests out of her house if they questioned why she's got armed thugs killing the Johnsons, or why she's got growling pit-bulls snarling at her neighbours across the creek?

In fact, do you think her mom's behaviour would lead to friends coming over for dinner in the first place?

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 11:43 PM on 08/24/2008

In the entire history of China they have never invaded or attacked a sovereign country. Though they themselves have been attacked repeatedly and violently over their history. I am not excusing their human rights abuses, I'm asking you not to impart your own set of values and judgments on another culture. Perhaps more strict discipline is necessary to prevent anarchy in a population of 3 billion with 500 million middle class who want cars and all that oil provides and the West has abused. Perhaps at this given moment in space and time, this is what China needs to be. At least they are peaceful and not wont for aggression. Unlike some other countries I could name.

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 12:15 AM on 08/25/2008
- hillpill I'm a Fan of hillpill 11 fans permalink
photo

>> "why don't you read Chinese people's own approval rating to their own government?"

we did.
also read about saddam's rating in his country when he was king.

the godfathers (i ii iii) have put up some pretty impressive shows too.

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 01:03 AM on 08/25/2008
- gmlaster I'm a Fan of gmlaster 43 fans permalink

You're right. It just smacks of Jim Jones and the People's Temple in Guyana. 900 people were smiling, cheering and clapping, telling Congressman Leo Ryan that Jim Jones was the best thing that had ever happened to them. Hours later, he was forcing them to drink cyanide-flavored Kook-Aid and they all died.

Happy faces mean nothing in a place where repression is known to rule.

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 03:27 AM on 08/25/2008
- motu I'm a Fan of motu 10 fans permalink
photo

Ummm, not to bash china here but ever heard of Tibet?

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 01:12 AM on 08/25/2008
photo

FREE TIBET!!!

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 01:57 AM on 08/25/2008
- mlaiuppa I'm a Fan of mlaiuppa 41 fans permalink
photo

If your Mom bought the entire feast from the local caterer and then passed it of as her own, LIED when confronted with evidence of the deception, should she still be praised? The Chinese Government cheated. Their gymnasts were underage. All the government cared about was gold medals. Then there's the little girl lip syncing during the opening ceremonies. THAT deception was covered up until it leaked. Yet another hurried justification for the lie.

To the 17 year old, I'd say.....grow up.

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 01:41 AM on 08/25/2008
- gmlaster I'm a Fan of gmlaster 43 fans permalink

Is your friend's mom a really bad hostess? Did she cheat and have dinner catered by an expensive restaurant but claim to have cooked it herself? Did she threaten to harm her neighbors if they did anything to disrupt her party? Does her mom steal valuables from her guests?

If she does these things, Mom sucks as a hostess and probably shouldn't expect any thanks. No one in their right mind would ever go to her house for Thanksgiving again, and knowing that she steals from her guests, I doubt she'd get invited anywhere for dinner because now everyone knows she probably steals from her hosts too.

If Mom's psychotic like this, folks are probably more than a little afraid of her and wouldn't dare tell her that her party sucked and they didn't have a good time. They'd smile, act like they were having a great time and do whatever Mom said because they don't want to piss Mom off.

Still, it was a nice plug for your blog.

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 03:19 AM on 08/25/2008
- scottarino I'm a Fan of scottarino 13 fans permalink
photo

its interesting the way our government supports/ encourages the massive imports from China as well as US corporations......both are helping to support (and help flourish) a communist country.

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 11:08 PM on 08/24/2008

As I mentioned before, American technology also supports big brother in so-called "safe-cities" in China (is that an Orwellian term or what?). Surveillance technology is everywhere in these parts of China thanks to the U.S.

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 11:15 PM on 08/24/2008

You obviously have not travelled much, my most learned friend. Until you do so, please don't post these parochial jingoistic blogs. They are embarrassing.

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 12:07 AM on 08/25/2008
- gmlaster I'm a Fan of gmlaster 43 fans permalink

The U.S. Government and corporations may support it, but the American people are getting about sick of it. But we're about to fix that.

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 03:20 AM on 08/25/2008
- McFlipFlop I'm a Fan of McFlipFlop 15 fans permalink
photo

What a show!

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 11:01 PM on 08/24/2008

..

This sums it up pretty well:

"Not a single world leader who attended the games or members of the IOC seized the opportunity to challenge the Chinese government's behavior in any meaningful way."

..

War is Peace
Freedom is Slavery
Ignorance is Strength

Rinse and repeat as needed.

.

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 10:58 PM on 08/24/2008

Hot or cold water?

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 11:27 PM on 08/24/2008

Definitely cold.

I want to wake up from this nightmare!

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 11:52 PM on 08/24/2008

"We were prepared for smog, pollution, demonstrations, but everything has gone very smoothly,"

Yeah. Smoothly. Demonstrations were certainly taken care of by the police state -- with the help of American surveillance technology, I may add..

The Beijing olympics were a spectacle. Nothing more. That's whatt $40 billion will get you. And IOC President Rogge is off his rocker when he thinkis that this will lead to increased freedom and better human rights in China. Get real.

Capitalism in it's ugliest form is taking root in China. Corporatism or fascism mixed with a Communist legacy is the goal.

Shame on the IOC for supporting this shameless and brutal regime that is in Beijing.

Shame on you that do not go beneath the surface of this spectacle to see the ugly reality of China's contempt for those that are not part of the elite few -- or for those who disagree with the corrupt government.

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 10:58 PM on 08/24/2008

I agree with, "shame on the IOC..."
But, the IOC did what it dd, nothing that anyone else can do about it.

These athletes were fantastic, a spectacular event all together! Terrific! Visually exciting and smooth as silk. After surviving the fiasco that was the Atlanta Olympics, this was truly a treat:)

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 11:56 PM on 08/24/2008

Again, that's what $40 billion and authoritarian government will give you.

Smooth silk by the miles.

But if one looks under that silk, it turns out not to be that pretty.

But who wants to think of the ugly side of the games, right? They were SPECTACULAR! A flawless Disneyesque performance!

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 12:08 AM on 08/25/2008

WOW really get hysteric!!
As a non-elite Chinese man I'm pretty happy with the game, everything was nicely done no "wide dogs" with stupid slogans barking on the street, people are quite proud of this Olympic game. The only regret I have for this game is I was expecting too see some dudes running naked in the stadium with the words "Americans get the f**k out of Iraq" on their butts to deliver the strong message to the George Bushs the Americans and the rest of the world on the opening but this never happen.

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 12:57 AM on 08/25/2008

Naked dudes?

Nah.

That would have required some spontanaeity. Something only seen when the state thugs were beating down protesters at Tianamen Square.

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 01:17 AM on 08/25/2008
- ezbreezer I'm a Fan of ezbreezer 7 fans permalink
photo

Kudos to the Chinese gov't for preventing any insult of our glorious leader GWB.

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 08:20 AM on 08/25/2008
- gmlaster I'm a Fan of gmlaster 43 fans permalink

I know. I was thinking I'd see something like that protesting China's treatment of Tibet in those protest zones that no one ever got a permit to use. But it never happened either.

I'll bet people are really super happy with those games. They'd better be. With all the money that's been spent to control the press, put down protest, squash the internet, and rig the games for the sake of national pride, you people had better be real g*ddamned happy...or else.

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 05:58 PM on 08/25/2008
- gmlaster I'm a Fan of gmlaster 43 fans permalink

"Capitalism in it's ugliest form is taking root in China. Corporatism or fascism mixed with a Communist legacy is the goal."

God, what an ugly combination. Talk about a sleeping dragon. I totally agree with your post. Well put, StopGeorge (love the name).

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 03:31 AM on 08/25/2008
photo

I watched it early this morning because I live across the river from Windsor, Canada we get Canadian television stations.....

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 10:51 PM on 08/24/2008
- barriosbabe I'm a Fan of barriosbabe 242 fans permalink
photo

Spectacle has no appeal for me.

My husband (Chinese) says in 20-60 years they will likely bomb the U.S.

WTF.

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 10:45 PM on 08/24/2008

China celebrates the olympics with 10,000 years of eastern culture, and the west celebrates the olympics with a pop song from the 70's.

That part... pretty embarrassing.

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 10:39 PM on 08/24/2008

First of all, it wasn't a "pop" song. It was rock and roll. Rock and roll represents a certain freedom to me, which was quite refreshing after these robotic games in Beijing.

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 11:01 PM on 08/24/2008

So would you say that the closing ceremonies "rocked" ?

I mean in the context of exclamations I see from time to time, such as "Obama rocks!" ?

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 12:32 AM on 08/25/2008

Agree, it fell short, the bus/Page thing. Even though I like Yardbirds/Led Zep.

Didn't work for me.

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 11:31 PM on 08/24/2008

And that "I love Beijing" little ditty with the red druming cheerleaders didn't work for me, either ;>)

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 11:51 PM on 08/24/2008

Hey guys--

it's spelled "Led Zeppelin" ; and Led Zeppelin didn't perform--- it was Jimmy Page who played guitar.

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 10:39 PM on 08/24/2008
- peepeeray I'm a Fan of peepeeray 2 fans permalink
photo

No Led Zep in China, but at least The Beetuls are finally going to do a concert in Israel.

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 10:55 PM on 08/24/2008

"With help from British star power, China concluded its debut as Olympic host Sunday after 16 days of near-flawless logistics ..." With help from British star power? as in, if there were no british stars at the closing ceremony, it would have been less stunning? gimme a brrreak! No matter how much you deny and refuse to notice, the real China is waaaaay ahead of the China in your (and most of West's) head.

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 10:36 PM on 08/24/2008

Did I see the "real" China when undercover police punched, kicked and took down a journalist and camerman filming a peaceful protest in Beijing? It took place in August, 2008. What is your definition of "old"?

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 11:08 PM on 08/24/2008
- Nobrun I'm a Fan of Nobrun 7 fans permalink

The Olympic games were a marvel to the Western world and their allies still caught up in the time warp on certain stereotypes about the Chinese. Refer to the BS about China that was widely circulated in the months and weeks leading to the opening ceremony. They get a thumbs up for their efficiency in security, transport, communication, IT and hospitality. A pop song from the west helped conclude the Olympics? Jeee, thanks.

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 11:09 PM on 08/24/2008

Actually, China lived up to its stereotypes with respect to human rights and freedom of information.

They lived up to their reputation quite well during these games.

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 11:23 PM on 08/24/2008

Led Zepplin? Not only is it spelled wrong, it's also misleading; only Jimmy Page performed.

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 10:36 PM on 08/24/2008
- TN I'm a Fan of TN 28 fans permalink

Damn, I missed Robert and Jimmy, I'm bumbed.

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 10:10 PM on 08/24/2008

Robert had better things to do.

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 11:03 AM on 08/25/2008
Page: « First ‹ Previous 1 2 3 4 (4 pages total)
Comments are closed for this entry

 You must be logged in to comment. Log in  or connect with 

Connect