More

Obama: "John McCain Doesn't Understand" Education


First Posted: 09- 9-08 09:24 AM   |   Updated: 10-10-08 05:12 AM

I Like ItI Don’t Like It
Obama

DAYTON, Ohio — Barack Obama is promising to double funding for charter schools and replace inferior teachers, embracing education reform proposals normally more popular with Republican candidates.

The Democratic presidential nominee says both parties must work together to improve education, according to remarks prepared for delivery Tuesday at a suburban high school gymnasium. The pitch was an appeal to moderate voters in this presidential election swing state, where the fight over education reform has been the focus of a longtime partisan battle.

"There's partisanship and there's bickering, but there's no understanding that both sides have good ideas that we'll need to implement if we hope to make the changes our children need," Obama said in excerpts provided by his campaign before the speech. "And we've fallen further and further behind as a result. If we're going to make a real and lasting difference for our future, we have to be willing to move beyond the old arguments of left and right and take meaningful, practical steps to build an education system worthy of our children and our future."

The federal government spends about $200 million a year on charter schools, privately run institutions that receive public money. Obama's proposal would take that up to over $400 million.

Obama recognized that charter schools have been a source of debate in Ohio. Past Republican administrations used charter schools and private school vouchers to offer families a way out of troubled public schools. But Democratic Gov. Ted Strickland has been trying to scale back the programs to focus taxpayer money on more traditional public schools.

The Ohio Federation of Teachers has complained about the management of some charter schools, which has moved money away from the schools where its members work. The union has asked the Internal Revenue Service to investigate for-profit charter school operator White Hat Management for allegedly violating the terms of the tax-free status assigned to some of its schools.

"I'll work with all our nation's governors to hold all our charter schools accountable," Obama said in the excerpts. "Charter schools that are successful will get the support they need to grow. And charters that aren't will get shut down."

While teachers unions typically oppose the idea of performance-based merit pay, Obama is embracing the idea along with demands that teachers who don't meet standards are removed from the classroom. Obama's campaign said teacher performance could be judged by peer review, student test results, classroom evaluations or other processes.

"We must give teachers every tool they need to be successful, but we also need to give every child the assurance that they'll have the teacher they need to be successful," Obama said. "That means setting a firm standard _ teachers who are doing a poor job will get extra support, but if they still don't improve, they'll be replaced."

At the same time he's calling for bipartisan cooperation, Obama is accusing Republican rival John McCain of failing to do anything to improve the quality of public education during nearly three decades in Washington. "Not one real proposal or law or initiative. Nothing," Obama said.

A new Obama television ad contends that the Arizona Republican voted to cut education funding and voted against accountability standards. "John McCain doesn't understand," according to the ad.

In a response to the criticism, the Republican National Committee issued a similar charge against Obama.

"What has Barack Obama ever done for education reform other than give speeches about it?" RNC spokesman Alex Conant said.

"Sen. Obama wants our schools to answer to unions and entrenched bureaucracies, while Sen. McCain wants schools to answer to parents and students," Conant said. "Unlike Obama, McCain will shake up failed school bureaucracies with competition, empower parents with choice, remove barriers to qualified instructors, attract and reward good teachers, and help bad teachers find another line of work."

___

On the Net:

http://www.barackobama.com

DAYTON, Ohio — Barack Obama is promising to double funding for charter schools and replace inferior teachers, embracing education reform proposals normally more popular with Republican candidate...
DAYTON, Ohio — Barack Obama is promising to double funding for charter schools and replace inferior teachers, embracing education reform proposals normally more popular with Republican candidate...
Filed by Rachel Weiner  |  Report Corrections
 
 
  • Comments
  • 140
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
Page: 1 2 3 4  Next ›  Last »  (4 total)
09:43 AM on 09/15/2008
What?

An academic bottom-dweller from a connected family doesn't understand the value of education?

Big deal! He has solutions! Just hit the bars and find rich women to live off. No edukashun nesisarry.
01:30 PM on 09/14/2008
Children must be taught to value education, starting by increasing performance standards in elementary school. No one should be passed to a higher level without meeting educational standards. Incentives should be provided for educational innovation. We can't penalize teachers for students failure unless we allow them to use innovative teaching methods. Charter schools are likely to be where innovative ideas will originate. Adequate pay for teachers encourages well qualified applicants. Small class size allows children the attention they need.

Higher education should be readily available, with community colleges open to all high school graduates regardless of previous academic performance. Maturity can motivate an underachiever. Working to excel is hard when you know that college is beyond your reach. Financial assistance beyond the community college level can be earned with educational excellence or community service. It should never be denied solely due to inability to pay.

Behavior is influenced through communication. Republicans lauded President Reagan for being "The Great Communicator." John McCain is barely able to keep his audiences awake. Influencing behavior through threats is usually counterproductive. Threats and sabre rattling seem to be BombBomb McCain's forte.

Many people accept being "good enough," never striving for excellence in education. This was the case with both Republican candidates. If America wants to recover its place of honor on the world stage, this will certainly not be rewarded by elevating these people to national office!

Barack Obama is the greatest hope this country has had in decades. Don't waste this opportunity!
01:20 PM on 09/14/2008
McCain has proven that he does not value education, starting with squandering his own educational opportunity and finishing with his choice of an undereducated VP candidate.

America fails to meet its potential by neutralizing the importance of education. This mindset started during the industrial revolution when it was necessary to keep our population ignorant, stifling aspirations beyond being an industrial drone. Ordinary citizens should be satisfied with their "place" in society as servants of corporate interests in manufacturing and service jobs. At one time, a comfortable living could be made in these jobs. Unionization forced the corporations to offer fair wages, safer conditions, limited work hours, and medical and retirement benefits. No longer! Many jobs have now been outsourced or computerized. These positions don't translate well into other opportunities. Unemployent is not born only by the workers. Our social safety nets are strained to the limits.

Other countries have been encouraging education for as many of its citizens as possible. Employees are imported to the US from other countries if qualified US applicants are not available. Companies have international branches in order to circumvent immigration rules. Allowing companies to move overseas rather than allow easier immigration forfeits tax revenue. Allowing companies easier immigration to fill these positions does not help unemployed American workers. If we are taxing corporations that outsource, but not allowing immigration, we must give them another option by educating American citizens to fill these positions!
02:30 PM on 09/10/2008
If education involves both McCain and Obama better read the constitution where it gives the qualifications for being president. Both are not qualified. Natural born means just that. No congressional action can amend it. Panamanian Born or African Born Neither qualify.
09:56 PM on 09/17/2008
Have you been sipping at the Republican Kool Aid trough this evening? For the last time, Obama was born in HAWAII, which if memory serves me correctly, is a bloody state in the Union. DUH!
photo
HUFFPOST COMMUNITY MODERATOR
jemiltd
Writer,author,thinker,creative
02:28 PM on 09/10/2008
Does anyone ever read the positions of each candidate on the issues? If you read McCain's position you will discover that his primary intent is to put the public tax dollars into the private schools, under the guise of if you don't like the school your child is assigned to you can move the associated dollars to the school of your choosing. McCain has no plan for public education, but he does have a plan for his rich friends to get a break on their tuition payments.
11:27 PM on 09/09/2008
McC talks the tallk alright...

but, when it comes to walking the talk he fails misrably....

People out there....

especially you republican trolls.... I am really curious what it is that you want? I have heard nothing but negative attacks and not one thing about your candidate that is good...

Convince me to vote for your guy......
BrighterStar
Let Freedom Ring
04:53 PM on 09/09/2008
This ad seems to be predicated on the idea that if money should be spent on education it should be spent by the federal government. This thinking shows that it is Obama that does not understand education. Local governments are the ones most able to address the needs of the children in their communities. When the Federal government gets involved all it does is add layers of bureaucracies. The department of education should be eliminated and the federal government should get out of the education business.
05:37 PM on 09/09/2008
and your post shows how out of touch you are.. the federal govt is already involved through "No Child Left Behind"...

Obama has laid out in detail how he will meet with state govt's and teachers and their unions on how to determine how to distribute federal funds .... IT IS ALREADY HAPPENING

He just wants to make sure that we are accountable...

Abolish the DOE? How else can we insure that everyone is getting a fair shake?

My question to you.... what do you really want your govt to do? NOTHING? You want a nation state of no unification?

What do YOU want?
BrighterStar
Let Freedom Ring
06:34 PM on 09/09/2008
We have a federal system where we have national, state and local government. Each one has areas where it is better able to address the needs of the people. Education is better when done at the local government level. I agree that the federal government has been getting more involved in education over the years. This involvement has not worked and should be reversed.
04:19 PM on 09/09/2008
Obama has no record of "change" for education reform and is currently not proposing anything worthwhile. Think hard Obama...we need real progress.
09:44 PM on 09/09/2008
Obama, in and of himself

IS CHANGE
03:46 PM on 09/09/2008
Obama understands education alright. He gets to send his kids to a private highly selective pilot primary school at the University of Chicago where tuition is over $20,000 because he is connected, and his wife is on the board of that school. But he doesn't think that the rest of us should have a choice as to where we can send our kids to school. His reasoning is that there "simply isn't enough room" at the elite schools for all the kids. There's just room for his kids, but not your kids. Obama has a wonderful understanding of education. That's is exactly WHY he sends his kids to an elite private school.
09:47 PM on 09/09/2008
Yup yup..

Don't you wish that all schools were that good? That is what he is advocating... we need high quality education for all children...
Don't disparage him because he sends his kids where he thinks is best...

He's NOT using government vouchers like McC advocates.... He believes that we need to upgrade all schools so that Charter Schools aren't necessary anymore And he realizes that in the meantime, we need to support all Charter Schools that are working.
03:19 PM on 09/09/2008
Very good commercial.
03:12 PM on 09/09/2008
I'm liking the new commercials and I feel that CNN & MSNBS & other non-right wing media outlets are starting to ask harder questions on Palin
02:25 PM on 09/09/2008
My comment..
http://www.eyeblast.tv/public/video.aspx?RsrcID=2036
01:39 PM on 09/09/2008
In an ad like the one above, the Obama campaign should used Obama's title as a University professor, in addition to Harvard Law grad.
Such a highly educated leader would understand the value of education to a nation's survival and progress more than a old McCaint who graduated at the bottom of his undergraduate class and wants to abolish Education dept!
tsog
my micro-bio is empty
02:26 PM on 09/09/2008
no point running the risk of seeming out of touch...harvard can do that.
03:10 PM on 09/09/2008
unfortunately, true...

somehow, academic success has become stigmitized in our society - it's like we've become one giant high school
BrighterStar
Let Freedom Ring
04:56 PM on 09/09/2008
Except he was never a professor only a guest lecturer.
09:52 PM on 09/09/2008
Are you simply an idiot?
photo
HUFFPOST COMMUNITY MODERATOR
lisak2008
12:56 PM on 09/09/2008
Of course McCain doesn't understand education. He graduated 5th from the bottom of his class. Duh!
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
filo
We're all Bozos on this bus.
01:12 PM on 09/09/2008
It's like he's proud of being ignorant.
03:04 PM on 09/09/2008
and he's proud that he's keeping the rest of us ignorant by not supporting the public school system..... I'm old, but when I was growing up in the 70's, there was absolutely no question that I was expected to finish highschool.... it was expected that I would go to college, even though I had to go on scholarship and we could only afford the local university system...... This year, in one of my state's counties (South Carolina, re beauty queen) 53% !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! of students did not show up for opening day of classes...

If we don't start ensuring our kids are in school and learning then we will lose all competition in this global economy.... this is real and it is serious folks...
12:30 PM on 09/09/2008
Obama is embracing the Charter School Concept because it works. We've spent years attempting to standardize our educational system. We need to stop producing sheep and instead produce independent thinkers who are self-motivated learners and not students who need to be spoon-fed each concept. We need to embrace the ideas of John Holt, John Taylor Gatto and Alfie Kohn and leave Horace Mann behind. I am betting that Barack Obama will listen. McSame is set on producing more sheep.