Ifill On Race And Rightwing Attacks: "I Find It Curious"

digg Share this on Facebook Huffpost - Ifill On Race And Rightwing Attacks: "I Find It Curious" stumble reddit del.ico.us RSS

DAVID BAUDER | October 1, 2008 11:44 PM EST | AP

Compare other versions »
I Like ItI Don’t Like It
In this image released by The NewsHour With Jim Lehrer, PBS correspondent Gwen Ifill is shown at the Republican National Convention in Minneapolis on Aug. 27, 2008. (AP Photo/The NewsHour With Jim Lehrer, Don Perdue)

NEW YORK — PBS journalist Gwen Ifill, moderator of the upcoming vice presidential debate, dismissed conservative questions about her impartiality because she is writing a book that includes material on Barack Obama.

Ifill said Wednesday that she hasn't even written her chapter on Obama for the book "The Breakthrough: Politics and Race in the Age of Obama," which is to be published by Doubleday on Jan. 20, 2009, the day a new president is inaugurated.

"I've got a pretty long track record covering politics and news, so I'm not particularly worried that one-day blog chatter is going to destroy my reputation," Ifill said. "The proof is in the pudding. They can watch the debate tomorrow night and make their own decisions about whether or not I've done my job."

The day before the Joe Biden-Sarah Palin debate, columnist Michelle Malkin wrote in the New York Post about Ifill's book, saying, "She's so far in the tank for the Democratic presidential candidate, her oxygen delivery line is running out."

John McCain, though, spoke highly of the reporter in an interview with FOX News Channel. "I think Gwen Ifill is a professional and I think she will do a completely objective job because she is a highly respected professional," he said Wednesday.

In its online description of the book, Doubleday says that Ifill "surveys the American political landscape, shedding new light on the impact of Barack Obama's stunning presidential campaign and introducing the emerging young African American politicians forging a bold new path to political power."

Ifill said Obama's story, which she has yet to write, is only a small part of the book, which discusses how politics in the black community have changed since the civil rights era. Among those subjects is Colin Powell, secretary of state in the Bush administration.

The host of PBS' "Washington Week" and senior correspondent on "The NewsHour" said she did not tell the Commission on Presidential Debates about the book. The commission had no immediate comment when contacted by The Associated Press. A spokeswoman for John McCain's campaign did not immediately return phone and e-mail messages.

Ifill's resume includes jobs at The New York Times, the Washington Post and NBC News. She moderated the 2004 vice presidential debate between Dick Cheney and John Edwards.

She said it was the publisher, not herself, who set the Inauguration Day release date. It will be released then whether Obama wins or loses.

Although Malkin raised the topic of Ifill's impartiality the day before the debate, the PBS journalist said that Time magazine noted she was writing a book in August, and that it has been available for pre-sale on Amazon.com. The book also is mentioned in a Sept. 4 interview she gave the Washington Post.

Ifill questions why people assume that her book will be favorable toward Obama.

"Do you think they made the same assumptions about Lou Cannon (who is white) when he wrote his book about Reagan?" said Ifill, who is black. Asked if there were racial motives at play, she said, "I don't know what it is. I find it curious."

NEW YORK — PBS journalist Gwen Ifill, moderator of the upcoming vice presidential debate, dismissed conservative questions about her impartiality because she is writing a book that includes mate...
NEW YORK — PBS journalist Gwen Ifill, moderator of the upcoming vice presidential debate, dismissed conservative questions about her impartiality because she is writing a book that includes mate...
Filed by Rachel Weiner  |  Report Corrections
 
Comments
668
Pending Comments
0
iPhone App Promo

Want to reply to a comment? Hint: Click "Reply" at the bottom of the comment; after being approved your comment will appear directly underneath the comment you replied to

View Comments:
Page: 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 Next › Last » (20 pages total)

I love Gwen-- she's a great journalist, a great mind, and a class act.

On a bright note, an unexpected benefit (the only one, from what I can ascertain) of the Palin nomination is that the networks are falling all over themselves to showcase their female journalists-- an offensive move to temper the slime machine, no doubt.

Although I think Gwen great, I have no intention of watching this debate tonight. Too much hype, too much attention already given to Poser-Palin, and I already know where Joe Biden stands on the issues that matter. If Palin can make it through the debate without blurting a racial slur, farting, or falling over drunk-- she will be declared "the winner".

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 02:20 PM on 10/02/2008
photo

If democrats are nervous about Sarah Palin doing well and slinging a lot of mud... just think how the republicans are feeling about Sarah Palin being... errr... gee... found out for the total fraud they know her to be.

At this stage, and I mean this, Biden could show up on rollerskates with a tinfoil hat and a clown nose, juggling bananas... and I'd still think... ok so he's inappropriately dressed for the occasion, but he's still less of a clown than she'll ever be.

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 12:54 PM on 10/02/2008

LOL Just make sure that you are tuned in for the squishing of Biden tonight! I'll check back here tomorrow for all the comments in denial...

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 01:21 PM on 10/02/2008

Democrats nervous about her doing well?

I really doubt that. Even if she's great tonight, the response will be that she just crammed and memorized a bunch of canned answers that she probably doesn't even fully understand.

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 01:38 PM on 10/02/2008
- old lady I'm a Fan of old lady 85 fans permalink
photo

Gwen - TELL IT LIKE IT IS ! AT THE START OF THE DEBATE Let the audience & Ms. Palin know that as an Afrrican American Woman you had to get through a SOLID LEAD CEILING BEFORE getting a try at that GLASS CEILING.

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 12:28 PM on 10/02/2008
- DShawn233 I'm a Fan of DShawn233 5 fans permalink

I know I should not go there, but, at this point of madness in the Mc Gaffe crowd, what the heck. My theory goes this way. Some feel that there is a similarity in the appearance of those of a certain race of people in America, "They all look alike to me."
In this case members of the Mc Gaffe campaign hear the name Ifill and see a picture of Oprah in their minds.

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 12:16 PM on 10/02/2008
- jemiltd I'm a Fan of jemiltd 106 fans permalink
photo

Interesting point of view and not necessarily off the mark. Look, McCain has been nothing if not consistent in creating drama. And he is setting the stage for pointing the finger if tonight does not go well. After all, hamstringing the media over Palin has worked pretty well so far. He knew of the book before she was selected and could have protested then.

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 02:12 PM on 10/02/2008
- BritPatJax I'm a Fan of BritPatJax 14 fans permalink
photo

Looking at Eisenhower on PBS as a President trying to deal with the Russian Sputnik issues and dominance in space it is hard to imagine a Sarah Palin having to deal with those same issues with her experience in foreign affairs and her simple knowledge of world affairs..

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 11:56 AM on 10/02/2008
- MissStorm I'm a Fan of MissStorm 2 fans permalink

Last night Dick Morris said that Bill Clinton was absolutely clueless about foriegn policy when he started running. The only thing he knew was economics. He had to be prepped and prepped and prepped.

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 12:16 PM on 10/02/2008
- MissStorm I'm a Fan of MissStorm 2 fans permalink

Last night Dick Morris said that Bill Clinton was absolutely clueless about foriegn policy when he started running. The only thing he knew was economics. He had to be prepped and prepped and prepped

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 12:19 PM on 10/02/2008
- MissStorm I'm a Fan of MissStorm 2 fans permalink

Am I being censored? I have tried twice to post a resonse here.

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 12:21 PM on 10/02/2008
- BritPatJax I'm a Fan of BritPatJax 14 fans permalink
photo

Question for Debaters:
Mostly pregnancy is a conscious decision between loving couples and a shared experience. Would you really advocate that a teen raped should have to endure the whole nine months result of that despicable act and not get closure from it? Should she have to have her life turned upside down. Have the humiliation in the streets. Have to love the growing result? Have her relationships threatened and her plans disrupted and endure on top of that the trauma and risk of childbirth? Then the guilt/responsibility of what happens to the child? On top of that what about a child not conceived of love having a life bereft of natural desired intention?

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 11:52 AM on 10/02/2008
photo

Why limit the question to just teens? why not include all victims of rape and incest?

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 12:27 PM on 10/02/2008
- LawrenceL I'm a Fan of LawrenceL 3 fans permalink

Another question for debaters: "Describe in detail how your state will be effected by the decrease in tax revenue due to the poor economy" Biden should be able to do this in considerable (if not too much) detail, whereas I expect Ms. Palin would be reduced to generalities.

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 04:23 PM on 10/02/2008
photo

All this cry-baby BS about Ifill is BOGUS! It doesn't matter at all since Palin HERSELF set the bar so low for her that all she has to do is just survive! We don't know what all that debate prep she got crammed in her head will do will help what she already has done, so I'm not expecting nothing more than her just looking like she just got smarter in just a few days.
It's like what Jon Stewart said on THE DAILY SHOW, -it's like the MATRIX, where she got hooked to that cable in the back of her head and she now knows EVERYTHING....

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 11:39 AM on 10/02/2008
- Pragmatus I'm a Fan of Pragmatus 3 fans permalink
photo

The most extraordinary aspect of the entire Sarah Palin brouhaha is how Republicans speak in such glowing terms about Palin's future as one of the leaders of the GOP. "Even if she doesn't win she will be a major player in Republican politics for the future."

Huh???

If Sarah Palin is the best the Republicans can do when regarding the future of their party, they may as well pack it in right now. The circus has already left town.
.

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 11:28 AM on 10/02/2008
- grizhead63 I'm a Fan of grizhead63 16 fans permalink
photo

We should hope and pray she is their future.

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 11:40 AM on 10/02/2008
- kramskoi I'm a Fan of kramskoi 7 fans permalink

i agree but the problem with that assessment is the fact that a good portion of the electorate will be sold on how she makes them "feel" rather than what she knows...her talents at generalization, populism, and deflection guarantees that she'll be on the attack tonight, while Biden must fight with his hands tied behind his back...the McCain campaign has diluted and dumbed down tonights debate sufficiently to allow her to escape anymore than a cursory examination of her OWN understanding of todays domestic and international issues...the assault on Ifill is simply a preemptive strike in the great expectations game that's been played for the past week...forget about the punditry...the focus groups will have the real say on who wins the debate...Biden better eat his wheaties today...

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 12:04 PM on 10/02/2008

Why is this such a big deal??? She is a journalist for Pete's Sake!

NO ONE MADE A BIG FUSS ABOUT GEORGE STEPHANOPOLOUS MODERATING THE DEBATE WITH HILLARY AND BARACK IN THE PRIMARIES!!!!!! AND WE KNOW HE WAS BIASED - TAKING DUMB ASS QUESTIONS FROM SHAWN HANNITY TO AIM AT BARACK!!


Obama/Biden '08

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 11:24 AM on 10/02/2008
- MissStorm I'm a Fan of MissStorm 2 fans permalink

Gwen Ifill needs to recuse herself, although, it may be too late for that now.

It was her responsibility to inform the Commission that she was writing a book in which Obama would be the center piece. It doesn’t look good that she didn’t.

Whichever side you are on, and regardless of how you feel about Gwen, it is the appearance of impropriety that is the problem. This IS a big deal if you believe that debates are an important factor in presidential races.

There is a lot wrong with this. It could possibly have a negative impact on either side of the isle. When the debate is over…there will always be that lingering question in everyone’s minds on whether there was bias or not. That isn’t a good thing for America.

Two examples: If Palin does not do well, people on the right will cry foal. But, those of you on the left need to worry also. Because of the media attention this is now getting Gwen may be harder with Obama to compensate looking unfair.

It really is a no win situation…imho

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 11:20 AM on 10/02/2008
- zenlikejen I'm a Fan of zenlikejen 19 fans permalink
photo

Look, Ifill is a professional and her book is not ALL about Obama - it appears as if he will only have a chapter dedicated to him.

Believe it or not, there are actually quite a few people who can do their jobs and still remain impartial.....

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 11:33 AM on 10/02/2008
- MissStorm I'm a Fan of MissStorm 2 fans permalink

"her book is not ALL about Obama" ~

~His name is on the title.

And their are financial issues here...and the timing...

This isnt a character assasination of Gwen (although her hiding this little tidbit from the commission should even bring her character into question) it is the APPEARANCE OF...(period!)

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 11:43 AM on 10/02/2008
- Ron1951 I'm a Fan of Ron1951 10 fans permalink
photo

This information has been in the public domain since long before Palin was even chosen as VP candidate. If the McCain campaign bothered to read the newspapers or even google Ifill's name, they would have known about her writing a book. To come out one day and say she's fine and then change his tune a day later is characteristic of this grumpy old man who is trying to say everything he can on all sides of each issue hoping to find some traction somewhere.

Frankly, there is no appearance of improprietary. Only the appearance of gross negligence and stupidity by the McCain campaign.

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 11:40 AM on 10/02/2008
- MissStorm I'm a Fan of MissStorm 2 fans permalink

In the legal profession it is incumbent upon the person with the potential conflict to step forward

~not to expect that others (eg debate commission, or the campaigns) will do research to find out

Even if it is out in the open, and others knew about it is no excuse for her not to step forward and point it out.

but, I guess in the 'journalism" professionism...anything goes

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 11:53 AM on 10/02/2008

Last week we had an older white male moderator for the presidential debate, should we assume that he cannot be impartial as well? No one has seen the book yet so no one can say - Ms. Ifill has never said that she supports Obama so we should stop assuming that all blacks support Obama and all whites support McCain. These controversies are only being brought up because you on the right EXPECT Palin to lose and so you're setting the stage for that now. If she is really as prepared as McCain says, she would do well if Obama himself were questioning her. Can you all really be so pleased that Palin is the vice-presidential pick? It's time to really start putting "Country First" and admitting that she's a dud!

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 11:48 AM on 10/02/2008

It has nothing to do with gender or race. It has do do with the bias in her politics. If the Dems were not smart enough to realize there might be questions raised with her as a moderator too bad. At any rate I am a conservative and I want her to ask tough questions to both Biden and Palin. Biden as we all know has been not done well in the past as far as campaigns for positions other than his Senatorial seat goes. As far as I'm concerned the better ticket for you guys would have included Hillary. So we are not concerned with Palin losing to Biden.
He has proven to be as clueless as Palin thus far in this campaign so we shall see. If Palin was really a dud, all this fuss about her wouldn't be being made.

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 12:18 PM on 10/02/2008

Ifill disclosed her book project three months ago; it was also featured in newspapers, etc. She's not being disingenuous in any way. McCain had plenty of time to object if he wanted to. Looks like he just wanted something to complain about.

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 12:29 PM on 10/02/2008

Everyday Michelle Malkin wakes up and looks in the mirror she screams as she sees an immigrant looking back at hear in the mirror instead of the Anne Coulter ideal adams apple shrew she always wanted to be. Malkin hates black people and its no surprises she is attacking Ifill who has always been tough on democratic candidates in debates . So the right wing is trying there darnest to get softballs questions lobbed at there weakest link from Alaska.

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 11:06 AM on 10/02/2008
- cheferic I'm a Fan of cheferic 5 fans permalink

The N.Y Post commenting on PBS News ,Washington Week and Jim Lehrer News Hour -really? -that's like a hot dog cart commenting on Morton's Steak House.Gwen Ifill is the epitome of objective and dispassionate reporting .( I mean dispassionate in the most complementary and professional sense of the word).

I could see where someone could say " oh PBS -Democratic" but every news station has a political bias ,it cant be helped and at least PBS is not owned by General Electric .If they think Ms. Ifill will be biased they simply haven't watched her work. I don't think her book has anything to do with the debate (at least until Ms Bigmouth accused Ms Ifill of bias) ,I don't think this is the "Age of O'bama " ,I hope it's the presidency of O'bama,but you have to do a little more for it to be an age ,and even then in the present condition the distinction is most likely to be for who makes the biggest mess not who does the most good or who is the most rational.It wasn't the " Kennedy age" or the " Martin Luther King age" it was the space age.So the book ,which I'm sure will be good,wont shape the debate ,but the reverse will hopefully not be true either unless people make (more) unfounded and ridiculous accusations,

Maybe the real accusation of bias was that no moderator or crew person will be a senior citizen?

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 11:02 AM on 10/02/2008
- Diplomacy I'm a Fan of Diplomacy 10 fans permalink

WOW!!! Great expectations & great advertising for Gwen Ifill's new book!

I have every confidence in Gwen's preparation & presentation of questions for tonight. She is the ONLY woman moderator of the four debates.

GO GWEN!!!

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 10:50 AM on 10/02/2008
- jay1975 I'm a Fan of jay1975 4 fans permalink
photo

"Do you think they made the same assumptions about Lou Cannon (who is white) when he wrote his book about Reagan?" said Ifill, who is black. Asked if there were racial motives at play, she said, "I don't know what it is. I find it curious." Lou Cannon never moderated one of Reagan's debates. Now she wants us to cry for her because she is claiming racism after McCain called her a professional and had no problem with her. She needs to stop playing the victim and own up to the fact that she has a monetary interest in Obama's winning in November.

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 10:38 AM on 10/02/2008

She has not claimed racism.

Asked if there were racial motives at play, she said, "I don't know what it is. I find it curious."

Get over it the repugs knew along time ago, now they want to interject racism into this.

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 10:55 AM on 10/02/2008

I agree 100%

The issue for me, and hopefully for those that feel as I do, isn't Ifill's race. The issue for me is the financial interest she has in the outcome of the election.

A book about politics in "the age of Obama," would certainly be a better sell if he was elected president.

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 10:55 AM on 10/02/2008
- MoeB I'm a Fan of MoeB 53 fans permalink

Stop playing ignorant. You know exactly what her point was...that conservatives are trying to do another one of those 'paint blacks with a broad brush' bits. The unsaid thing here is that they are trying to make it seem as if SIMPLY because she is black, she is automatically for Obama and will therefore attack Palin during the debate. Which, if you knew anything about her, is garbage.

Second, please show me where she claimed "racism". And it is very ironic that you complain about Gwen playing the "victim" while submitting a post painting conservatives/republicans as "victims".

I'm predicting now that Ifill's debate will be much more even-handed than Brokaw's.

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 11:00 AM on 10/02/2008
- Mij13 I'm a Fan of Mij13 73 fans permalink
photo

Fox and everyone else who's known about her book since last July, looks pathetic and desperate, picking this up the day before the debate.

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 11:09 AM on 10/02/2008
- NetworkGuy I'm a Fan of NetworkGuy 7 fans permalink
photo

Where did you see in the above article that she was claiming racism? I read it twice and I'm having a hard time finding it. Since she's a woman, the sexist meme won't work here, so you fall back on race. Will she ask 'gotcha' questions? Since the McCain campaign characterizes any question Palin doesn't know the answer to as 'gotcha' journalism, most questions asked will probably fall into that category. If she asks a question and both candidates provide answers, how does the choice of moderator matter anyway? Palin has been interviewed by two pros and one FOX hack. She didn't really shine with any of them. Are you going to claim Hannity doesn't have a financial interest in who wins?

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 11:14 AM on 10/02/2008
photo

Sarah has broken a nail and will not be participating in tonight's debate...

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 10:33 AM on 10/02/2008
Page: 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 Next › Last » (20 pages total)
Comments are closed for this entry

 You must be logged in to comment. Log in  or connect with 

Connect