"The US Has No Long-Term Economic Strategy"

digg Share this on Facebook Huffpost - stumble reddit del.ico.us RSS

BusinessWeek   |  Michael E. Porter   |   October 30, 2008 05:49 PM


With the U.S. election just days away, it has never been more important to consider what the next President must do to keep America competitive. In this time of crisis, Washington has focused on the immediate and the short term. Lost are the more basic questions we really need to worry about: What is the fundamental competitive position of the U.S. in the global economy? And what must we do to remain strong when other nations are making rapid progress?

The stark truth is that the U.S. has no long-term economic strategy--no coherent set of policies to ensure competitiveness over the long haul. Strategy embodies clear priorities, based on understanding the strengths we need to preserve and the weaknesses that threaten our prosperity the most. Strategy addresses what to do, but also what not to do. In dealing with a crisis, experience teaches us that steps to address the immediate problem must support a long-term strategy. Yet it is far from clear that we are taking the steps most important to America's long-term economic prosperity.

America's political system, especially as it has evolved in recent times, almost guarantees an absence of strategic thinking at the federal level. Government leaders react to current events piecemeal, rather than developing a strategy that unfolds over years. Congress and the Executive Branch are organized around discrete policy areas, not around the overall goal of improving competitiveness. Neither candidate has put forward anything close to a strategy; rather, each has presented a set of disconnected policy proposals with political appeal. Both parties contribute to the problem by approaching the economy with long-held ideologies and policy positions, many of which no longer fit with today's reality.

Now is the moment when the U.S. needs to break this cycle. The American economy has performed remarkably well, but our continued competitiveness has become fragile. Over the last two decades the U.S. has accounted for an incredible one-third of world economic growth. As the financial crisis hit, the rest of the American economy remained quite competitive, with many companies performing strongly in international markets. U.S. productivity growth has continued to be faster than in most other advanced economies, and exports have been the growth driver in the overall economy.

Read the full story here

-OR-

::Responsibility For Saving The Economy Could Fall To This Guy
::The Plan So Far Has Resulted In Loaning $123B To AIG

With the U.S. election just days away, it has never been more important to consider what the next President must do to keep America competitive. In this time of crisis, Washington has focused on the i...
With the U.S. election just days away, it has never been more important to consider what the next President must do to keep America competitive. In this time of crisis, Washington has focused on the i...
 
Comments
99
Pending Comments
0
iPhone App Promo

Want to reply to a comment? Hint: Click "Reply" at the bottom of the comment; after being approved your comment will appear directly underneath the comment you replied to

View Comments:
Page: 1 2 3 Next › Last » (3 pages total)
- PT6 I'm a Fan of PT6 permalink

Can we Afford the BUSH Administration anymore? America is in CRISIS!

On Nov 5 the Bush Team Should be Asked to STEP DOWN!

Refuse? Then there is PLENTY of Evidence to be used in an INVESTIGATION to remove them!

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 02:02 PM on 10/31/2008
photo

No it doesn't and here's one that would revive our economy and nation and strenghten our corporations and create a boom for every American...!

Nationalize all Major Energy, both Oil and Electricity create a national power grid and Federal right of way for lines for Wind and Solar sources as well..

Create a Single Payer Health Care System which will cut costs by 32%...

End Corporate "Personhood" a perversion if there ever was one..

Nationalize our Airlines...!

Use funds from Nationalizing Oil and the Electric power industry to fund and accelerate Alternate and Renewable fuel supplies and sources and New Technologies...this will also create and economic boom that effects every American as well as Nationalization will cut cost 30-35% which will also create and result in an economic boom as well as promote Commerce as well..!

Restore strict regulations upon the financial sector along with the proper real ability to enforce these regulations..

Purge and reform The FDA to save America lives and restore the confidence of every America..

Depoliticize the Justice Dept. and purge all Federalist Society members from it, so it can once again serves and protects The American People along with Our Constitution..!

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 12:23 PM on 10/31/2008
photo

Is it any surprise that the US has no long-term economic strategy when any attempt to plan the country's economic future is branded "socialism?" The crash of 1929 and the recent meltdown clearly show that an unfettered free market is contrary to the interests of the vast majority of citizens. Perhaps this will change now that the era of Reaganonics is collapsing around us.

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 10:48 AM on 10/31/2008

Lack of a long-term policy is painfully obvious. It's a reflection of the imperfections in a political system where different influences come and depart over time. Those with vast sums to be made stay engaged. In bad times the ordinary voter becomes attentive. Flaws in how the economy has been managed have been obvious - be it savings/equity rate, construction, regulation, education, trade, etc. Some solutions are politically unpalatable, especially given a routine of favors handed out like political candy.

Can significant beneficial change can be made in a society so sold on self-aggrandizement - that lacks the discipline (as one commentator noted) to endure changes; when the political discourse centers more upon temporary "fixes" to reduce the clamoring of the population, or ameliorate the writhing of the market and stupid business decisions? The well-being of the people at a particular moment cannot be disregarded. Yet well-being is also a long-term matter, that has been seriously neglected in swings of economic philosophy.

It would be fine if political, business and educational establishments could unify with a program to re-adjust priorities (energy, health care, education, savings). Current upheavals create (temporary) recognition that alterations are necessary. Whether this transpires will be a measure of whether the country is a nation in decline or able to adjust to changing conditions and prosper. This, other than fringe issues that are trotted out during some campaigns, is what everyone should be concentrating upon.

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 10:27 AM on 10/31/2008
photo

A national plan with clear priories and the political force necessary to implement it is absolutely necessary.

New green industries, alternate energy, space exploration, rebuilding the national infrastructure, basic R&D to discover and develop new technologies come to mind. Plus, we need to drastically cut the "defense" budget.

There are a dwindling number of ignoramuses who view any move toward planning as some kind of Soviet policy, but their voices are very loud, and they are well-financed by important business interests, who would rather treat the US economy as their private hunting preserve.

Time to start indicting the K Street crooks, to disable this reactionary mechanism. They can exercise their free-speech prerogatives from federal prison.

We can use the new jobs all this will create to help roll over the opposition.

We need to be relentless and totally crush to opposition once we've gained power, otherwise the criminals will buy their way back into the system.

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 08:38 AM on 10/31/2008

It's been a long time since the focus has been on any term longer than one business quarter. In fact companies that do give long term guidance or have decreased revenue due to R&D investment get killed in this market. For what ever reason companies have been taken over by a kind of CEO and corporate governance that will do nothig that does not help the bottom line in time for the next quarterly report. Where are we now? This most recent event in the financial industry was not something that just happened one day. The only reason that it was "not seen" is because there had been a willfull ignoring of the fact, and blatent misinformation stated, in an effort to get that last sucker in before the thing jumped the tracks.

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 08:37 AM on 10/31/2008
photo

I think it first lacks in a consistent use of vocab. I remember the team of H. Clinton using the word strategy when it was one single short term approach. Strategy in its original meaning is a coherent set of actions that are kept to reach an aim that is out of reach of short actions in a narrow horizon.

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 08:15 AM on 10/31/2008
- Ping I'm a Fan of Ping permalink

Progressives overreach, and conservatives get left behind.

It's time to tell Larry Kudlow that a managed world economy is the best path to prosperity. "Free Market Capitalism" will always fall victim to unbridled human greed and has proven to be a sure path to ruin and failure. The last 8 years of Bush Economic Policy have been tax cuts and a "Belief" that the markets will correct themselves.

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 03:54 AM on 10/31/2008

The right-wingers believe that the world's going to end in 4 years (12/12/12) anyway, so why "bother" with an economic strategy?

Just substitute any adjective for "economic" in the above sentence (like environmental, educational, healthcare, military), and it will apply to their take on the situation.

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 06:45 AM on 10/31/2008

Well, it may have had one under the current regime, that was to bankrupt the middle class and basically enslave them into irredeemable debt. If that wasn't the plan, well, then they were incompetents with no plan. Either way, if we do get regime change and Obama gets elected with a majority of Democrats in both houses, there will suddenly be an intelligible plan which the government articulates to the people and to the world. No surprises, no lies.

You think I'm living in a fantasy? Well, I'm not the one who cannot imagine that the Bush team planned this economic disaster. They knew what they were doing. You fools who bought the ideology are the ones who just couldn't get it. That their opposition was also taken in by their faked ideological positions is no excuse.

Fool me once, shame on you. Fool me .... can't get fooled again.

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 02:54 AM on 10/31/2008
photo

Americans lack the discipline to implement strategic long term goals.

"I want it ALL and I want it NOW!"

Good luck Mr. President. You're gonna' need it.

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 02:49 AM on 10/31/2008
photo

AMAZING, HEARD A CLIP OF MC CAIN IN OH. YESTERDAY AND THEY ARE OUT OF MATERIAL, HE'S SAYING BY EXTENDING THE BUSH TAX CUTS FOR THE RICH, THE TRICKLE DOWN WILL SOLVE OHIO'S PROBLEMS, YEAH RIGHT!

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 07:47 AM on 10/31/2008
- PT6 I'm a Fan of PT6 permalink

We can NOT afford the BUSH Administration anymore!

America is in CRISIS!

On Nov 5 the Bush Team Should be Nicely Asked to STEP DOWN!

If they refuse then there is PLENTY of Evidence to be used in an INVESTIGATION!

This is a D@NGEROUS Bunch out to D@mage America prior to leaving Office!

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 02:35 AM on 10/31/2008

From the article:

"Republicans keep repeating simplistic free-market thinking, even though the absence of all regulation makes no sense. Self-reliance is preached as if no transitional safety net is needed. Some Republicans even argue passionately that the country should have no strategy because that would be "industrial policy." Yet the real issue is not picking industry winners and losers but improving the business environment for all American companies, something we cannot do without identifying our top priorities. Overall, Republicans seem to think business can thrive without healthy social conditions. "

In addition to free markets, we need a strong saftey net and a reinvestment in our nation's infrastructure. We need safe cities where people have access to healthy foods and jobs.

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 01:17 AM on 10/31/2008
photo

Excellent points.

The one thing they cannot do is build 10 million more houses for people who cannot afford them. The house building industry needs to take a back seat until the taxpayers have sold the foreclosures.

Green infrastructure is going to be the engine of the coming economy. Global warming is about to come down on the world like a ton of bricks.

We are competing against countries that have government planning directing their economies. It's a pipe dream to think the brainless free market is going to outwit the best and brightest minds in other countries like India and China.

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 08:10 AM on 10/31/2008

The republicans claim that Obama is a socialist because he "wants to spread the wealth around." Ok. So, I want the republicans out there with their bull horns blasting "WE ARE FOR THE RICH! WE NEED MORE TAX CUTS FOR THE RICH!" Just keep repeating that slogan over and over again in Ohio, Indiana, Michigan, Pennsylvania, Virginia, North Carolina, Georgia, Florida, Nevada, Arizona. I dare them to. Stop the republican alternate universe and vote Obama/Biden 08.

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 12:43 AM on 10/31/2008
photo

FOR NEO CONS WORRIED ABOUT SOCIALISM, YOU CAN TAKE THE GAINS YOU WILL GET UNDER BARACK AND MAIL THEM TO YOUR FAVORITE RICH PERSON!

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 07:54 AM on 10/31/2008

It feels like the wheels are coming off the entire bus, not just off McCain's sorry-a$$ train-wreck of a campaign, but wheels coming off the entire nation. It just feels wrong. Very, very wrong. We need a changing of the guard, and that needs to happen STAT!!! OBAMA -08

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 12:27 AM on 10/31/2008
Page: 1 2 3 Next › Last » (3 pages total)
Comments are closed for this entry

You must be logged in to reply to this comment. Log in  or  Connect