Canadian Leader Shuts Down Parliament In Desperate Attempt To Stay In Power

digg Share this on Facebook Huffpost - stumble reddit del.ico.us RSS

ROB GILLIES | December 4, 2008 07:00 PM EST | AP

Compare other versions »

Canadian Prime Minister Stephen Harper announces, during a snowstorm, that Governor General Michaelle Jean approved his recommendation to suspend Parliament, at Rideau Hall in Ottawa, Thursday, Dec 4 , 2008. (AP Photo/Tom Hanson, The Canadian Press)

OTTAWA — Prime Minister Stephen Harper suspended Parliament on Thursday to avoid almost certain defeat in a confidence vote _ an unprecedented move allowing him to retain power and confront Canada's flagging economy.

The Conservative leader won the approval of the unelected representative of the head of state for the power to shut down Parliament until Jan. 26, hoping to buy enough time to develop a stimulus package.

"Today's decision will give us an opportunity _ I'm talking about all the parties _ to focus on the economy and work together," Harper said.

Harper, whose party won re-election just two months ago, said a budget will be the first order of business when Parliament resumes.

Three opposition parties have united against Harper, charging he has failed to insulate Canada from the global financial crisis. The credit crisis and a global sell off of commodities have slowed Canada's resource-rich economy, and the finance minister said last week he expects a recession.

The parties, which control the majority of seats in Parliament, had scheduled a confidence vote for Monday in which Harper was virtually certain to lose _ a defeat that would have forced his government from power.

Liberal leader Stephane Dion said the opposition would continue to seek Harper's ouster unless he makes a "monumental change" in dealing with the economy and other parties.

"For the first time in the history of Canada the prime minister is running away from the Parliament of Canada," Dion said.

Story continues below
advertisement

The opposition was also outraged by a government proposal to scrap public subsidies for political parties, something the opposition groups rely on more than the Conservatives. Although that proposal was withdrawn, the opposition has continued to seek Harper's ouster, saying he has lost the trust and confidence of parliament.

Governor General Michaelle Jean, who represents Britain's Queen Elizabeth II as head of state, had the power to grant the unusual request to suspend parliament. Had she refused, Harper would have had two choices: step down or face the no-confidence vote.

Both Harper and Jean's spokeswoman declined to comment on the leaders' two-and-a-half hour meeting Thursday.

Robert Bothwell, director of the international relations program at the University of Toronto, criticized the move to suspend parliament.

"Canada looks terrible. It looks ridiculous. It makes nonsense of our constitution," he said, adding that the move set a dangerous precedent, paving the way for any prime minister facing defeat to follow suit.

Opposition politicians also blasted Harper's methods.

"I frankly don't regard his government as legitimate any more," said Liberal Bob Rae, comparing the move to something more commonly expected from a Third World country. "His government is there because he avoided the will of Parliament."

Opposition New Democrat leader Jack Layton called it a sad day.

"He's trying to lock the door of Parliament so that the elected people cannot speak," Layton said. "He's trying to save his job."

Analysts said a governor general has never been asked to suspend parliament to delay an ouster vote when it was clear the government didn't have the confidence of a majority of legislators.

Harper's Conservative Party was re-elected Oct. 14 with a strengthened minority government, but still must rely on the opposition to pass legislation.

The Liberals, New Democrats and Bloc Quebecois, which together control a majority of parliament's 308 seats, signed a pact agreeing to vote this coming Monday to oust Harper and setting the structure for their proposed coalition government.

But infighting among the Liberals is casting doubt on whether the coalition will hold. Liberal Jim Karygiannis called his party's leader a disaster and said Dion should step down.

The opposition was embarrassed by Dion's televised response to Harper on Wednesday. Dion's English is awkward and his address was beset by technical woes. It was delivered almost an hour late and the fuzzy quality of the production had Canadian Broadcasting Corp. anchor Peter Mansbridge cracking: "It kind of looked like they shot it with a cell phone."

Harper needs the support of 12 opposition lawmakers to avoid being toppled in a confidence vote next month and some lawmakers will consider breaking ranks with their party after hearing from angry constituents.

"The issue," Wiseman said, "is whether can the Liberals hang together."

OTTAWA — Prime Minister Stephen Harper suspended Parliament on Thursday to avoid almost certain defeat in a confidence vote _ an unprecedented move allowing him to retain power and confront Cana...
OTTAWA — Prime Minister Stephen Harper suspended Parliament on Thursday to avoid almost certain defeat in a confidence vote _ an unprecedented move allowing him to retain power and confront Cana...
 
Comments
250
Pending Comments
0
iPhone App Promo

Want to reply to a comment? Hint: Click "Reply" at the bottom of the comment; after being approved your comment will appear directly underneath the comment you replied to

View Comments:
Page: « First ‹ Previous 1 2 3 4 5 Next › Last » (5 pages total)
- MaureenS I'm a Fan of MaureenS 2 fans permalink

did my posting get censored? Because your AP reporting of facts is also in correct as why Harper suspended Parliament­...he face a non- confidence vote on Monday.

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 08:25 PM on 12/04/2008
- PSM42 I'm a Fan of PSM42 20 fans permalink
photo

There is v e t t ing of posts on some threads and not on others. And not for posting rules, but for political views, or information sources in the comment. Sometimes one line gets through. Sometimes a sentence that can include a link. Sometimes nothing without v e t t ing. And it seems like it is for some people and not others. Hence the odd spacings, which sometimes avoid it. Let's just say I feel more 'popular' in this respect than I wish.

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 09:24 PM on 12/04/2008
photo

If you're on a Mac, check your operating system. I updated mine and it cured all my spacing and paragraph problems. I'm on an old PowerBook G4, now using Version 10.4.11. It's been my experience that Huffpo doesn't delete comments for political views but for being off topic or for making ad hominum comments. They don't seem to mind links at all, but they're pretty aggressive staying on topic. I'm sure it's a matter of server space.

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 09:47 PM on 12/04/2008

Is this what if felt like when Germany invaded the Sudatedland?

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 08:17 PM on 12/04/2008

Repeat after me: "Because the economy is too important to trust democracy.­"





...East Germany used to be so beuatiful in the winter...

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 08:16 PM on 12/04/2008

I am an american and I dont understand the canadian parliament very much, but why does the governor general get to suspend parliament. I thought only the british queen could do this. Also, they cant suspend parliament indefinently can they? so the coalition should be able to take over in a a few weeks anyways.

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 07:48 PM on 12/04/2008
photo

The Governor General is acting on behalf of the Queen (of Canada, not the British Queen -- though it's the same person). Unless the Queen is in Canada, it's Her Excellency's job to fulfill the role of the Crown. Just as in the British monarchy, the monarch has certain limits on her power and cannot appear to act in a political or partisan manner. Yes, the prorogation has a definite time limit (the end of January) and she could have (perhaps did?) set conditions on the PM's behaviour while parliament isn't sitting.

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 08:03 PM on 12/04/2008

The Queen of England is represented in Canada by the Governor General, whom PM Harper asked to suspend Pariliament. The Governor General as the representative can, upon request of the PM suspend Parliament. In 1967, Pierre Elliott Trudeau, brought a Charter of Rights to Canada but we have kept our relationship to England with the Queen and yes, she opens Parliament, now usually through her representative. Take a look at our system, we can be very proud as Canadians. Our banks are not asking for a bail-out, they are regulated. The auto industry in the US has found it is actually less expensive to build cars in Canada because we have Universal Health Care. We are, I would say the most loyal and supportive to the US and yet few Americans know about us or care. Mostly what we hear from Americans, especially in the media like Rachel Maddow did last night on her show, is them laughing at us, making fun of us but guess what, who's getting the last laugh...al­beit through the pain of the global economic meltdown that yes, the US has brought to the world.

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 07:50 AM on 12/05/2008

It wasn't in 1967, that the amendment to include the charter in the constitution was made; it was made in 1982.

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 11:00 AM on 12/05/2008

By convention, I don't think a GG could actually say no to a request of the PM? If I remember my Canadian history correctly, last time that happened was in the 30s. And no GG would stake his or her legacy by overturning the request of the leader of a democratic elected body.

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 06:59 PM on 12/04/2008
photo

Yes, she can say no to a request from the PM, and she may still if after the next non-confidence vote, Harper asks for an election and the other parties present the possibility of a legitimate alternative government. In the current case, she could have said "I'll grant your request to prorogue if you first establish you have the confidence of the House." The problem is that Harper put her in a very, very compromising situation. Deciding either way is not good for the constitution.

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 08:10 PM on 12/04/2008

I'm not so sure on your final statement. Sounding like a needle caught in a groove, Mr. Harper and his Conservatives only have 37.6% of the vote while the coalition parties have 54.4%. I feel that she has interfered and this is not justice at all, particularly when Mr. Harper has been so blatantly racist towards Quebecers voting the Bloc and thinking that it is he and the Conservatives who should decide which parties have a say in policy formation. As Chuck Stahl tried to parrot, this has been sold as an "unholy alliance." To our American neighbours going through the McCain-Palin diatribes against Obama, does this not sound all too familiar?

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 12:22 AM on 12/05/2008
- S1m0n I'm a Fan of S1m0n 98 fans permalink
photo

The last time it happened was in Brian Mulroney's first term, when he ran on an anti-free trade platform and then immediately started negotiating the FTA. The GG of the day informed Mulroney that the FTA was such a dramatic change, with clear constitutional and jurisdictional consequences, the necessary legislation was going nowhere until his government called an election and got a mandate from the public.

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 11:20 PM on 12/04/2008
- hawkseye I'm a Fan of hawkseye 3 fans permalink

Same thing happened in Australia a few years ago. Gov. General cancelled the election of a progressive and a conservative took over (maybe John Howard?).

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 06:40 PM on 12/04/2008
photo

Harper = West. Majority of Canadians are in the East. Screw Harper and his faciast "leadership.

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 06:36 PM on 12/04/2008
- cowman I'm a Fan of cowman 6 fans permalink

I'm in the west and I hate Harper. Let's not make this a regional issue, that's exactly what Harper's trying to do by pointing a finger at Quebec. Let's follow the coalition's lead and unite in areas of common interest instead of being divided by irrelevant things like geography. Remember one of the pillars of the Reform party was trying to get greater representation of the west against the traditionally important centre/east - the politics of division is where the Conservatives win.

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 06:43 PM on 12/04/2008

Sadly enough this is the reality...­an uncomfortable truth...

I lived in the West for 4yrs and the westerners, particularly albertans are not what you'd call open minded citizens.

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 06:57 PM on 12/04/2008

I'm from Quebec and I agree. Earlier I made comments to the same effect.

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 07:03 PM on 12/04/2008

Ontario here -- and I'm for the coalition which I think is more representative of divergent views across the Canadian spectrum. I find the prospects of 18 months very exciting.

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 12:24 AM on 12/05/2008
- ZoeK I'm a Fan of ZoeK permalink

This is a smack in the face of democracy. The MAJORITY of Canadians are left-leaning and thus our Parliament is as well. We (finally) have 3 parties, united, willing to put aside ideology for the good of the country, but alas, we have a Conservative Bush-like party in control.

They have a ton of money and are launching massive Rove-esque Republican style attack ads and smear campaigns. Unfortunately, it is working. He's literally lying to Canada, saying the coalition is undemocratic (it isn't) and not allowed (it is).

Would love help from Americans, to call and send emails to any and all MPs (members of parliament) showing your support for truth, democracy and our coalition govt.

thank you

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 06:21 PM on 12/04/2008
- cowman I'm a Fan of cowman 6 fans permalink

How about support from Canadians?

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 06:27 PM on 12/04/2008
- Dayahka I'm a Fan of Dayahka 32 fans permalink

Well, what do you know...Isn­'t this a typical third-world, banana republic tactic? This is the sort of thing we expect to find in Zimbabwe or Haiti--but in Canada? The legislature should throw this guy out.

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 06:15 PM on 12/04/2008
- cowman I'm a Fan of cowman 6 fans permalink

Irony of ironies that the GG is from Haiti

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 06:27 PM on 12/04/2008

Well spotted. When Mr. Harper talked about "a banana republic" -- yet more racism from him -- here he is emulating the very behaviour he denounces.

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 12:26 AM on 12/05/2008

Given that George W. Harper has proven himself yet again to be a liar and a scoundrel and not fit to lead, there remains the elephant in the room:

WHAT TO DO ABOUT STEPHANE DION?

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 06:09 PM on 12/04/2008

Canada needs to find its Barack Obama to depose its George W. Bush.

What a pathetic character Harper is.

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 05:56 PM on 12/04/2008
- cowman I'm a Fan of cowman 6 fans permalink

Layton's getting there.

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 06:28 PM on 12/04/2008

I think so too. The coalition was Layton's idea and I'm very proud of him for it and for Mr. Dion and Mr. Duceppe for working to create the framework.

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 12:28 AM on 12/05/2008
photo

I know that alot of my fellow Canadians are angry, but in a way the coalition dodged a bullet. Imagine if the conservatives had been able to force an election with a weak Dion still in place.

Harper is on borrowed time, even his caucaus(sp) is furious at him provoking this fight. Things are only going to get worse and it will be hard for the conservative spin machine (which is truly a tribute to Karl Rove) to dig their way out of it.

Hopefully the Liberals will spring into action and get someone into the top spot will a better political presence(going into a recession I do not think that Ontario will tolerate Bob Rae...too many gut reactions that tie him to the recession of the early 90's)

On a funnier note, and of interest to our American friends, here is a link to the conservative party website, complete with talking points: https://mycampaign.conservative.ca/EN/4936/77265
(For americans that need a postal code- type in L9P 1G1)

WHAT IS SPECIAL...­is that the conservatives provide step by step instructions to call in to a radio station and VOICE THE CONSERVATIVE PARTY line (ie. build consensus or appear to build consensus). Now Americans might correct me, but I find this smacks of the republicans and Fixed News propaganda and fear mongering

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 05:53 PM on 12/04/2008

Fan of Hydro and super fan of Harper and his cronies...

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 06:16 PM on 12/04/2008
- ZoeK I'm a Fan of ZoeK permalink

I hear you.....an­d there is a part of me that really wants Harper to "wear" this recession on his record, until the Liberals have their leadership campaign and get their act together.

I was really just hopeful that the Left had finally united, and we could have done some truly amazing things for this country.


*sigh*

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 06:23 PM on 12/04/2008
- cowman I'm a Fan of cowman 6 fans permalink

I don't think another snap election was ever seriously on the table.

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 06:29 PM on 12/04/2008
- PSM42 I'm a Fan of PSM42 20 fans permalink
photo

Thanks for that, Hydro. Very sharp. Sounds promising on the Liberals getting a better (wo)man. The website stunt is ridiculous. Hope the other side(s) drown them out in an avalanche of outrage.

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 06:33 PM on 12/04/2008
photo

I don't believe that the GG would have called an election with a coalition already in place that had already delivered their intent to govern, I think she would have had no choice but to allow the coalition to govern (given that it is a perfectly legal option).

I'm one of those people that actually *like* Dion, I just think that he is a little bit out of his comfort zone. He doesn't play well to the cameras and he is an intellectual who shouldn't be forced to pander (because, admittedly, he doesn't do it well). And I should probably state that I'm not a Liberal ;) Just to make it have that extra punch.

I'd rather deal with Dion for a few months than Harper. I've had enough of being told that I'm the minority when it is very clear that left-leaning Canadian voters clearly outnumber the right-wing (or Harper would have had his majority, and all this would be moot).

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 11:20 PM on 12/04/2008

Nor do I think that the GG would have either. I have a feeling that regardless of what Mr. Harper comes up with in terms of a stimulus package, the damage has been done with its absence as well as his banning of parliament. He has shown his contempt for accountability to Parliament and this cannot stand. He must be taken down now more urgently than before. I pray that he is now on borrowed time.

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 12:30 AM on 12/05/2008

The problem with the coalition was that the lib/ndp together did not have a majority. They needed the bloc and that is a dangerous precedent. It also makes the coalition unviable. It may be legal but it was not ethical or democratic. It was a power grab, plain and simple.

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 04:54 AM on 12/05/2008
- messy I'm a Fan of messy 37 fans permalink
photo

Harper will be gone on the 27th of January. The next session will last only a few hours.

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 05:52 PM on 12/04/2008

I wish this was true, but I think the coalition will fall apart by then. What they had on their side more than anything was momentum. People were excited about the prospect of an immediate and progressive government to take charge before Christmas and implement some proactive measures against the impending recession. With this 2 month break, Liberal MPs will start to rethink this, especially with Dion as leader of the coalition. I'm afraid Harper has won this and we will be heading into a spring election. Bah humbug!!

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 09:56 PM on 12/04/2008

I don't think that will happen because May will be the Liberal convention for leader which means that they cannot afford to have a leader who has not been in place long enough to establish some connection with the electorate through a performance in parliament as leader. I am hoping that the pressure is still on.

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 12:33 AM on 12/05/2008
photo

Being an expatriate Canadian living in the USA, I feel sadness for my country today. It has been hijacked by the neo-con called Harper. I can't even believe this is happening in Parliament. The vote of no-confidence should go through as planned IMO.

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 05:42 PM on 12/04/2008

Governor General Michaelle Jean has done the Canadian political left a great service by agreeing to Harper'e request to suspend Parliament.

The proposed coalition would not have last more than 8 weeks max. The Libs and the NDP are two distinct political entities who differ far more than they agree on policy. Not 4 days after announcing the coalition , they are already having trouble provising an united front.

Let Harper continue to hang himself. He was the cause of this political crisis and he has further weakened his position by hiding from a vote of confidence.

Best thing for the Libs is to get a new leader and go from there.

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 05:40 PM on 12/04/2008

I agree with this....re­ally ....Libera­ls get your new leader...a­nd after the 27th just swing that Sword of Damocles over Harpers head a few times before you bring him down. He's too darn arrogant not to do something provocative again.

And to my fellow Canadians.­..could a few of you go to civics class and learn the difference between a parliamentary democracy and a republic.

The whole "coup d etat" thing is getting on my nerves.

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 06:04 PM on 12/04/2008
- ZoeK I'm a Fan of ZoeK permalink

Amen!!! Unreal how stupid some are.......­.

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 06:24 PM on 12/04/2008
photo

Living in Alberta, I hear the word "treason" thrown around a lot, along with "coup" and "undemocratic". And I wonder how exactly they actually passed a social studies class.

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 12:54 PM on 12/05/2008
- cowman I'm a Fan of cowman 6 fans permalink

How many Liberal MPs are former provincial NDPers? I can think of 2 former NDP Premiers who are now Liberal MPs without even trying.

I don't think they disagree on policy as much as you claim and I see no evidence of the coalition having trouble providing a united front - Layton and Dion seem to be on the same page, Layton just expresses himself better.

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 06:31 PM on 12/04/2008

In addition to the comments below, the bipartite agreement which was not mentioned in the original article above had set out a Standing Committee for the Accord which would have kept smoothed the functioning of a coalition. They would have been under great pressure to make it work (which I still think is possible) otherwise come the next election, Mr. Harper would have gone to the Canadian public with "See, I told you so"s to gain more seats. Additionally issues of voting on confidence motions were outline in the agreement which would have prevented it from floundering. I am convinced it is the best that we can have and we desperately need the Conservatives out.

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 12:36 AM on 12/05/2008
Page: « First ‹ Previous 1 2 3 4 5 Next › Last » (5 pages total)
Comments are closed for this entry

 You must be logged in to comment. Log in  or connect with 

Connect