EDITION: U.S.
 
CONNECT    

Muntadhar al-Zeidi Beaten For Throwing Shoes At Bush: Iraq Judge

QASSIM ABDUL-ZAHRA | December 19, 2008 04:16 PM EST | AP

Compare other versions »
I Like ItI Don’t Like It
A pile of shoes, seen, dumped in a box outside the US Embassy by demonstrators in London, Friday, Dec. 19, 2008. Stop the War coalition are calling for the guaranteed safety and release of Iraqi journalist, Muntadhar al-Zeidi, who threw his shoes at US President George Bush during a press conference in Baghdad. (AP Photo/Alastair Grant)
?>

BAGHDAD — A judge announced a probe Friday into the beating and bruising of an Iraqi journalist's face moments after he hurled his shoes at President George W. Bush, and said investigators destroyed the shoes in their search for explosives. The statement to The Associated Press by Dhia al-Kinani, the investigating judge, was the first official word that Muntadhar al-Zeidi was hurt after his outburst at a news conference by Bush and Prime Minister Nouri al-Maliki. According to the judge, al-Zeidi suffered a bruised face and eyes.

Al-Zeidi has been in custody since the Sunday attack and hasn't been seen since by relatives or a lawyer.

One of his brothers, Uday, alleged Friday that the isolation indicates he was abused.

"Until now, neither an attorney nor anyone from his family has seen him and this is clear evidence that Muntadhar was under intense torture," he said at a demonstration by about 20 family members just outside the Green Zone. "The investigation process is now under way in mysterious circumstances."

Al-Zeidi was wrestled to the ground seconds after throwing his shoes, and the judge said videotape of the scuffle would be studied carefully.

The journalist "was beaten in the news conference and we will watch the tape and write an official letter asking for the names of those who assaulted him," the judge said. He said al-Zeidi could choose not to pursue charges related to the beating; he did not say why he decided to open an investigation.

Al-Zeidi wasn't the only person who ended up with a bruised eye. White House press secretary Dana Perino suffered an eye injury when she was hit in the face with a microphone during the melee.

State Department spokesman Sean McCormack said Friday that the treatment of al-Zeidi was a matter for Iraqi authorities to deal with.

"Certainly, nobody wants anybody to be mistreated while they're in custody," he said. "I can't attest to these allegations, however."

Al-Zeidi's case has become a rallying point among opponents of the U.S. invasion and military presence in Iraq. A Saudi reportedly offered $10 million for just one of the shoes and an Iranian cleric suggested they should become museum pieces.

The judge, however, said investigators destroyed the shoes trying to determine if they contained explosives. He did not say whether they found any.

Despite widespread sympathy for al-Zeidi among Iraqis, al-Kinani said the case cannot be dropped _ though he noted that neither Bush nor al-Maliki has sought charges. Al-Maliki was standing next to Bush at the time of the attack.

"This case was filed because of an article in the law concerning the protection of the respect of sovereignty," he said. The journalist is expected to face charges of insulting a foreign leader. A conviction could bring a sentence of two years in prison.

The judge also confirmed that al-Zeidi had written a letter of apology to al-Maliki. A spokesman for al-Maliki had said Thursday that al-Zeidi asked for a pardon in the letter. But al-Zeidi's brother Dhargham told the AP that he suspected the letter was a fake.

The prime minister can recommend to Iraq's president that a pardon be granted, but the judge said such a pardon can be issued only after a conviction. There have been no indications whether or not al-Maliki is likely to recommend a pardon.

The judge said the al-Zeidi investigation would be completed and sent to the criminal court on Sunday, after which a court date would be set within seven to 10 days.

Thousands of Iraqis demonstrated again Friday for al-Zeidi's release.

At Friday prayers in Baghdad's Shiite stronghold Sadr City, cleric Mohanad al-Moussawi told worshippers that "al-Zeidi's life must be protected and he must be immediately, immediately, immediately released."

Sadr City protesters also laid down two American flags, hit them with shoes and burned them to protest his detention. And in southern city of Kufa, hundreds raised shoes in support of al-Zeidi and also protested what they said was the arrest by American forces of an official of Momahoudin, a militia led by anti-American cleric Muqtada al-Sadr that was disbanded and turned into a social welfare group. The U.S. military would not comment on the alleged arrest.

In London, about 50 protesters shook their shoes at the U.S. Embassy in a show of support for al-Zeidi.

In the West Bank village of Bilin, Palestinians hurled shoes rather than the usual rocks at Israeli soldiers in the weekly Friday protest against the Israeli separation barrier, which slices through their fields.

And the head of a large West Bank family offered one of its eligible females as a bride for al-Zeidi. Ahmad Salim Judeh, 75, said his 500-member clan had raised $30,000 for al-Zeidi's legal defense.

Many supporters of al-Zeidi hold Bush personally responsible for the tens of thousands of Iraqi civilians who have lost their lives since the U.S.-led invasion of 2003.

On Friday, a Baghdad police official said seven disembodied heads and two complete corpses were found in a deserted building in Sadr City. The victims appeared to have been killed about two years ago, the officer said on condition of anonymity because he was not authorized to speak to reporters.

___

Associated Press writers Jim Heintz and Patrick Quinn in Baghdad and Matthew Lee in Washington contributed to this report.

BAGHDAD — A judge announced a probe Friday into the beating and bruising of an Iraqi journalist's face moments after he hurled his shoes at President George W. Bush, and said investigators destr...
BAGHDAD — A judge announced a probe Friday into the beating and bruising of an Iraqi journalist's face moments after he hurled his shoes at President George W. Bush, and said investigators destr...
Filed by Katharine Zaleski  |  Report Corrections
 
  • Comments
  • 373
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
Page: 1 2 3 4 5  Next ›  Last »  (7 total)
11:23 PM on 12/20/2008
He threw shoes. Shoes. Yes, at a visiting President, but they were shoes. Just shoes. No reason to hold him Gitmo-styl­e over a pair of shoes. They. were. just.shoes­.
03:09 PM on 12/20/2008
This guy is a hero. Too bad he missed.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Manx
02:52 PM on 12/20/2008
Bush said the shoe-throw­ing incident was proof that Iraq is a democratic country, allowing expression­s of dissent. And what does the beating of the shoe thrower prove, Iraq's democratic system of due process?
HUFFPOST COMMUNITY MODERATOR
ohioan73
09:22 AM on 12/20/2008
The shoe-throw­er obviously had no intention of killing Bush with a sandal, it was done to make a statement about the Iraqis he had seen who lived in war-torn areas and had family killed. In their minds, its the USA and Bush's fault. The journalist was only expressing those feelings of desperatio­n and extreme despair that any human being would feel. He should have been arrested and properly charged and tried, possibly given jail time. If they had a fair democracy, that's what should happen. Too bad America doesn't have a true and fair democracy as an example to lead the world. Maybe we will get to the point when we can tell other countries how to be democratic when we fix our own problems.
07:21 PM on 12/19/2008
I am only outraged that the guy got to throw TWO shoes. The Secret Service was asleep. He should have had a bullet hole in his head after the first. Obama will not be President very long if the Secret Service does not improve its game. He should be happy he is alive.

I can laugh now at the stunt, but if you are going to throw things at the US President,­you should NOT expect a long happy life. It is even dumber to expect not to get banged up in the process. TOUGH!
01:09 AM on 12/20/2008
I'm outraged he was only able to throw 2 shoes at GW. I wish he would've been able to throw a whole slew of shoes at the SOB. I would like to buy the man a brand new pair of shoes as a token of my appreciati­on. And if he ends up marrying that Egyptian man's daughter I will be one of the first to send a wedding gift.

Also, have you noticed how everyone is pulling out of Iraq but the U.S.??????­??? Its seriously time to leave and let them handle their own affairs. Bring my husband home NOW! I hope GW, Cheney, Rummy and the rest of the clan go down for war crimes.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
CamJam
01:24 AM on 12/20/2008
Yes, I have noticed that we are still holding the fort and alone. Seems the only reason for the surge really is until Bush is no longer in the WH.

I also want your husband and all our men and women home NOW. IMHO, they have done on and beyond what they were ordered to do. It's time for them to come home NOW.
07:04 PM on 12/19/2008
Why can't they just let the man go!!! Big deal because he through his shoes at an ignorant foolish President Big deal!! This guy is a global hero for what he did and deserve his freedom..
06:17 PM on 12/19/2008
Huffington Post: the home of undue censorship
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
06:07 PM on 12/19/2008
For all the BLAME THE VICTIMS advocates out there, try to understand who put these people in this frustratin­g position to begin.
Also, imagine how you might act in the same circumstan­ce.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
05:42 PM on 12/19/2008
Bush lied, Haliburton profited Cheney , Rumsfeld and Wolfowitz manipulate­d. History will not be kind to them and rightfully so. Bush is a pig headed fool. Who else says "bring it on" and such? Brags about a surge that was 5 years too late after squanderin­g tax payers billions and a good deal of our political and military good will. BUT...that does NOT mean we respond by becoming a pacifist isolationi­st nation....­.If we learned anything from Vietnam, it is that we must win the peace and see this through.

Please read the sad history of SE Asia after our withdrawal­. The betrayal of our friends in the region was one of the lowest points in America's history. Shameful. The enemies we have in Iraq are just that, but more importantl­y they oppose stability and prosperity­.

To the extent that this reporter acts in ways that discourage stability and encourage violence, he should be condemned. That everyone has the right to speak their mind in Iraq is a good thing and a very new thing. What would have the shoe throwers fate if Sadam was in power? I think everyone knows...
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
05:22 PM on 12/19/2008
What responsibi­lty have iraqis taken for their own future? Given the chance, they created immediate instabilit­y, and have until recently used only violece a as a device for power acquisitio­n.
Why arent all arab up in arms about this? Is there agenga strictly anti-ameri­ca or is it pro Iraqi? I suspect that it is the former.
06:26 PM on 12/19/2008
Given the chance? What, with a persistent condition of inadequate security, severely botched and graft-ridd­en reconstruc­tion effort and massive unemployme­nt while cheap labor is brought into the country by human traffickin­g engaged in by American contractor­s? And add to that we left Iraq wide open for al Qaeda to chase our own troops into the country and bring our battle with them to the Iraqi people, who'd had /nothing/ to do with that prior? And you think the Iraqis have had a fair chance at a future.

Don't blame them. Blame the guy /you/ voted for.
09:12 PM on 12/19/2008
Go back to 1st grade, your infantile logic is showing.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
04:04 PM on 12/19/2008
Why is this article buried at the bottom of HUFFPO's main page? I'm hoping it's been downgraded after being featured prominentl­y yesterday.­..

As for many of the comments here condemning al Zaidi's actions--I just can't climb inside your logic. Have you missed the last 5 years of human rights abuses/ murder/ bad policy/ looting/ destructio­n of Iraqi infrastruc­ture/ Blackwater crimes/ torture/ not to mention an ILLEGAL war justified by the LIES of this criminal administra­tion that has killed tens of thousands of innocent Iraqi civilians? What war are YOU watching? If such activity had taken place in YOUR hometown at the hands of a foreign entity--wo­uld SHOE THROWING make you a "hater", too? You people read the HUFFINGTON POST and you're still this uninformed and ego-centri­c?

As for me, I will be joining the protests in London and elsewhere by sending my old size 8 sneaks to the White House, souls up, in peaceful protest for all the above atrocities and more.
photo
HUFFPOST COMMUNITY MODERATOR
Coinyer101
King of Doobiestan....,
03:51 PM on 12/19/2008
the iraqi's apparently are learning well the lessons of the bush administra­tion. the 'training' must be taking affect. time to go,now.
04:26 PM on 12/19/2008
At least he was not lynched publicly as they do in Saudi Arabia!
06:27 PM on 12/19/2008
Hey, there's talk of handing over our responsibi­lities in Iraq to our "trusted allies," the Saudis. Don't speak too soon.
03:46 PM on 12/19/2008
From the daily beast -

"Reports in the Arab media indicate that the Iraqi shoe thrower, Muntather al-Zaidi may have been planning his assault on President Bush for more than a year, helped by Iraqi Baathists seeking to overthrow the U.S,-backe­d government­. One leading Arab website said the al-Zaidi’s handlers may have been funded by Raghad, the eldest daughter of former dictator Saddam Hussein.

The former dictator’s eldest daughter, Raghad, currently lives in self-exile in Jordan and is wanted in Iraq for funding terrorism.­"

So he may not be just an innocent one-man hate machine after all.
03:49 PM on 12/19/2008
Thanks for the laugh.
03:58 PM on 12/19/2008
Indeed. It would go entirely against everything you'd prefer to believe.
05:48 PM on 12/19/2008
Um, that's from "The Daily Beast".... enough said.
03:45 PM on 12/19/2008
Questions for all you legal scholars out there.

Under the current arrangemen­ts imposed by the USA on Iraq, Blackwater employees are exempt from Iraqi law.

If Blackwater hires Brother Al-Zaidi with effect from 1 December 2008, could he be charged with a crime?

Would it matter if the shoe had injured President Pan, a US citizen?

Would the legal ruling be different if the shoe had injured the Iraqi PM, not a US citizen (I'm assuming that even though I haven't yet seen the raised seal on his birth certificat­e).
06:30 PM on 12/19/2008
I can't answer all of those questions, but as I understand it, the Status of Forces Agreement makes contractor­s like Blackwater culpable to Iraqi law. I'm not sure if it's only from that point forward, or retroactiv­ely, however.
03:38 PM on 12/19/2008
Bush and Cheney lied to the Nation and destryed the lives of countless Millions. Thousand of Americans troops dead for a pack of lies. Hundreds of thousand of Iraqis dead and Miliions turned into refugees..­. all for a Pack of Lies.

This reporter is a hero around the world. No one died when he through his shoes... Millions are dead becuase of Bush LIES.
03:53 PM on 12/19/2008
Where did you learn to spell? People might actually take you seriously if you learn how to spell "because", and if you learn the difference between "through" and "threw."