Architects Create American-Style Suburbs Overseas

digg Share this on Facebook Huffpost - Architects Create American-Style Suburbs Overseas stumble reddit del.ico.us RSS

DAISY NGUYEN | December 26, 2008 12:01 PM EST | AP

I Like ItI Don’t Like It
This undated image provided by F+A Architects shows an overview of the "Napa Valley" housing development in Beijing, China. In Asia and the Middle East, new homes are going up in "master-planned" communities resembling those in California, some of them designed by Aram Basenian's firm, Bassenian Lagoni. In China, some developments even bear the names of California suburbs such as Mission Hills or Palm Springs, capturing the dreams of China's growing middle class who are drawn to the Western lifestyle. (AP Photo/F+A Architects)

LOS ANGELES — Architect Andy Feola keeps running into Southern California colleagues in some of the world's most exotic locations _ from the Egyptian desert to China to Azerbaijan.

"We'll scratch our heads and ask 'Why are you here?'" said Feola, president of F+A Architects in Pasadena. "Well, I'm here for the same reasons you're here."

A growing number of architects and urban planners are finding work overseas as the domestic real estate slump persists. An emerging affluent class abroad is drawn to suburbs with U.S. names that mimic the American ideal _ down to the master bathroom and tree-lined sidewalk.

A 2006 survey of American Institute of Architects members shows that large architecture firms with more than 100 employees reported billings from international work doubled in four years. Meanwhile, billings in the U.S. this year dropped to the lowest point in the 12 years the survey has been conducted.

While there's no hard data, more American-made windows, roofing systems, furnaces and other specialized materials are being shipped overseas because projects designed by Americans are built to U.S. construction standards, said Jim Haughey, an economist with Reed Construction Data, which tracks the construction industry.

"The English concept of a man's home is his castle is true in most parts of Asia, the Mideast and Eastern Europe," said Jeff Rossely, a Bahrain-based developer of shopping malls, resorts and residential communities in the Middle East. "If you look at how countries are moving up the socio-economic ladder, some of the things they all want is a car, a house, a nice view and air conditioning."

The trend started during the early 1990s U.S. housing downturn and has intensified in recent years. Firms that ventured abroad since that time say doing so has helped them weather economic slowdowns in certain markets.

It has also created opportunities to design on a grander and more creative scale. At times, architects are creating huge master-planned communities encompassing a mix of single-family homes with high rises, parks and shopping centers. Feola's firm is designing a shopping and entertainment complex for New Cairo, a metropolis built from scratch for roughly 200,000 residents in Egypt. The idea is to avoid some of the mistakes of the past and create a mixed-use environment where people rely less on their car to get to shops and services.

Story continues below
advertisement

American firms are behind an eco-friendly island connected to Shanghai by rail, and a new township in northern Indian loaded with luxury villas, apartments, shops, parks and schools.

Curiously, some of the developments overseas look and sound a lot like California suburbs marketed to affluent customers who have spent time living in the U.S. or attracted to an American suburban lifestyle.

Feola's firm, which does 90 percent of its projects outside the U.S. and is best known for designing a shopping mall in Dubai with an indoor ski slope, was responsible for a development outside of Beijing called Napa Valley that has little resemblance to the winemaking region.

Grassy front lawns and driveways lead to pastel-colored homes that mimic French, Italian or Spanish architectural styles. Customized kitchens, screening rooms and basement wine cellars are very different from Chairman Mao's vision of communal living.

"It's hard to tell you're not in Southern California," Feola said.

Another Beijing suburb is aptly named Orange County, which sold out within days of opening in 2002. Chinese developers hired Newport Beach firm Bassenian Lagoni to make a replica of homes they saw south of Los Angeles. With the eerie resemblance to the American suburb, critics derided the homes as "McMansions."

"It's too bad that we as Americans are turning away from suburban sprawl as Asia adopts it," said Robert Fishman, a professor of architecture and urban planning at the University of Michigan.

Architect Aram Bassenian, whose Mediterranean-style homes have come to define California's ritzy suburbs, contends that architects shouldn't shoulder all the blame. California borrows ideas from elsewhere, and for centuries cities have been designed or influenced by outsiders.

Many advances in green home design that were developed in the U.S. are being introduced overseas, including better insulation or ventilation to rely less on fossil fuels for heating and air conditioning.

To make the homes fit with the local culture, outdoor kitchens are added in Asia for frying food, and trellises are installed to protect Mediterranean homes from intense sunlight.

"We don't create the demand, we respond to people's needs for shelter, for housing," Bassenian said.

Despite criticism, suburban communities are sprouting in Latin America, North Africa, South Asia and Eastern Europe. To promote developments that won't deplete natural resources, land use experts at the Urban Land Institute has been taking foreign groups on "study tours" of U.S. communities and recently opened an education center in the United Arab Emirates.

Developers say they look to American architects because they have a track record of designing successful shopping malls, resorts and other high-end projects.

Bassenian said he doesn't take lightly the task of creating a built-in environment for people millions of miles away.

"It is both a daunting responsibility as well as an incredible privilege to think that what we do here will shape how somebody lives around the world," Bassenian said.

LOS ANGELES — Architect Andy Feola keeps running into Southern California colleagues in some of the world's most exotic locations _ from the Egyptian desert to China to Azerbaijan. "We'll scrat...
LOS ANGELES — Architect Andy Feola keeps running into Southern California colleagues in some of the world's most exotic locations _ from the Egyptian desert to China to Azerbaijan. "We'll scrat...
Filed by Nick Sabloff
 
Comments
116
Pending Comments
0
iPhone App Promo

Want to reply to a comment? Hint: Click "Reply" at the bottom of the comment; after being approved your comment will appear directly underneath the comment you replied to

View Comments:
Page: 1 2 3 4 Next › Last » (4 pages total)

Wow! Just think. In every one of those houses there will be a couple of kids whinging, "Momeeee, I'm BORED. There's nothing to do."

Imagine.

"Mom, Achmed hit me...."
"Did not."
"Did too."
"Did not...."
"Did too...."
"MOM!"

And...

"MING! Clean up your room. NOW."

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 08:06 PM on 12/27/2008

Everybody wants to live in America.

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 03:22 PM on 12/27/2008

It would seem that expatriots are by definition excluded from that "everybody," i.e., UNIVERSE.....?

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 08:04 PM on 12/27/2008

This is your brain.
This is your brain on cul de sacs.

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 03:18 PM on 12/27/2008

ha, ha.....architects are spreading a failing concept like a virus. American suburbs...high cost, high maintenance, a vast illusion.

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 01:45 PM on 12/27/2008

Not to mention, extremely ugly.

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 04:25 PM on 12/27/2008

amen. see my commentary as an architect and urban designer on this article/phenomenon here:

http://carfreeinbigd.blogspot.com/2009/01/been-privately-bitching-about-this-for.html

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 10:57 AM on 01/05/2009

actually, i should add that architects aren't spreading it in so much as they are failing in their responsibilities to steer clients in a more positive (and responsible) direction. they are merely prostitutes providing services to developers who are merely providing product (a heinous product at that).

the underlying battle is an economic one, quantitative growth vs. qualitative. quantitative, in terms of urban development is only responsible with a proportionally growing population. in the US, we quantitatively grew, ie sprawl, without the requisite population density to support it. it was robbing peter to pay paul and calling it economic growth.

http://carfreeinbigd.blogspot.com/

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 11:01 AM on 01/05/2009

Well, I hope they know what they're doing and don't let the subdivision and strip-mall concepts get out of hand. To be honest, though, McMansions in Asia and Europe sounds like one of the signs of the end times.

Let's hope that unlike builders in America, the overseas contractors know how to build a house that doesn't leak like a sieve or get blown apart when the dog sneezes.

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 01:32 PM on 12/27/2008
photo

They build with concrete. Properly designed they are as good as properly designed wood structures.

Cheers,
Jack

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 07:32 PM on 12/27/2008

love it, love it, love it! if you've ever traveled abroad, you would be aware that everything American is still held in reverence, no matter where you are.. the sad thing is that Americans can't see this, and constantly trash everything American.

can you imagine the thrill of being in the Chinese middle class today? most likely, they lived with ten family members in a tiny apartment less than ten years ago, and rode a bicycle for transportation. today, they have a beautiful home like this, and two SUVs in the garage.

perhaps we need some "well-intentioned" Americans to come over, and show them the "advantages" of that tiny apartment, and the "greeness" of that bicycle.

yea, right.

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 12:21 PM on 12/27/2008
photo

Thank you. Some of the comments here are so misinformed, with no perspective whatever. A few Mission Viejos in Asia is not the end of the world. Ferchrissake, let 'em experiment a little. They'll figure it out as time passes.

Cheers,
Jack

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 07:30 PM on 12/27/2008
photo

It should be pointed out that Southern California has some of the most efficient land use in the US. Compared to more rural areas it takes less road, sewer, water line, electrical transmission line, police and fire personnel to connect and operate our homes. McMansions are a phenomenon known to older neighborhoods in desirable areas where owners want what the newer areas have and hence, they over build. And you are right, they are an abomination for the most part. Cities need to take a closer look at their policies regarding remodeling and in-fill, but this is a problem of individuals as much as builders. Kind of like owning a Hummer.

Many of the foreign developers creating these communities attended university in Southern California and are very familiar with our patterns of development and can see the possibilities. Their populations yearn to live like Americans. It is aspirational and understandable. As we discredit ourselves globally with wars and silly economics future foreign developments will probably incorporate some of the better aspects of our built environment along with more indigenous patterns to yield a more sustainable and appropriate environment in these places.

There is good and bad in every built environment, so let's not throw the baby out with the bath water. Adapt, adapt, adapt.

Cheers,
Jack

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 12:01 PM on 12/27/2008

LA is efficient land use? It just one huge city sprawl! It has relatively few sky scrapers and public transit is absolutely horrible! Practically everywhere you go you run into to a traffic jam. LA should be the exact opposite of how a city is planned. Also building on a fault line is a bad idea too.

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 12:21 PM on 12/27/2008
photo

I won't disagree about aesthetics, but the result is efficient in terms of density and the delivery of domiciles. A place like Tennessee, f'rinstance, is beautiful and the homes are spread out, but only so many people can live that way.

I take it from some of the comments here that we should all be living in cramped multifamily urban towers. It reminds me of a visit to the Home Depot in Manhattan and looking at the kitchen cabinet displays and thinking that it is clever how they miniaturized the set ups - and then I realized that these were actually full sized. Re: Mark Bitman's (The Minimalist, NYT) closet of a kitchen. No thanks.

Cheers,
Jack

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 12:30 PM on 12/27/2008

Dude - LA has the WORST planning, if you could call it planning. And endless sprawl of parking lots, asphalt, concrete with virtually zero native land or parks. Rivers and streams turned into flood channels and drainage ditches. City services for fire, police, public works cannot keep up with the rapidly deteriorating infrastructure.

You need to learn that expansion is not necessaril progress. Quality of life is an unheard of phrase in LA. To plan for quality over quantity would sure be a step forward here.

Land speculators have dominated the market and driven growth - not "planners"

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 02:37 PM on 12/27/2008
photo

"You need to learn that expansion is not necessaril progress."

Please tell that to the breeders. They all want to be the king of their castles just as Herr Bush said, "ownership society".

BTW, who do you think builds those hi-rise human warehouses? The Comintern?

Let's try for a little reality.

Cheers,
Jack

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 07:25 PM on 12/27/2008

The fraction of land devoted to asphalt in a suburban setting is higher than in any other type of development. The undesirable results include air pollution from excessive automobile use, a strong heat island effect, and the creation of a huge problem with runoff water.

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 02:42 PM on 12/27/2008
photo

Been to Florence? Pavement as far as the eye can see.

Cheers,
Jack

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 07:34 PM on 12/27/2008
photo

ah yes, if there is one thing the world would benefit from, besides our corrupt consumer "values" I mean, it's the awful mcmansion-style roman columnfests currently polluting our suburbs wholesale and displacing the older, more tasteful houses, which are often knocked down to make room for them. is the faux chateaux in the pic actually located in another country? just awful

in this case, it's "architects"

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 11:46 AM on 12/27/2008

Wow, are YOU warped. MANY people in the world and the USA would LOVE to have homes like this~

What are you, the new GLOBAL ELITE p olice?

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 12:09 PM on 12/27/2008
photo

Rightone:

There's no accounting for taste. Yes, there are people who would love to have one of these homes. There are also people who love to watch American Idol every week as well. This does not negate the idea that both these McMansions and American Idol perpetuate conformity and blandness as the norm.

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 12:31 PM on 12/27/2008
photo

Sorry if this turns out to be a double post.

I don't think you are being fair here, bartonfink. I believe that we are not importing our corrupt consumer values. Remember, there are Chinese people who DESIRE these homes. I daresay that their values are already corrupted. Never underestimate the greed of Asian peoples.

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 12:27 PM on 12/27/2008
photo

Interesting article in NYT today on "passive" houses being built in Germany with no furnaces - can be warmed not only by the sun, but also by the heat from appliances and even from occupants" bodies

http://www.nytimes.com/2008/12/27/world/europe/27house.html?ref=europe

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 11:05 AM on 12/27/2008
photo

Architects may come and
Architects may go and
Never change your point of view.
When I run dry
I stop awhile and think of you

So long, Frank Llloyd Wright.

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 11:02 AM on 12/27/2008

This is NO GOOD. As an Architect that builds here in the US and abroad I will tell you that we will be polluting the rest of the planet (incl. UAE) with our outdated, highly non-green way of building, housing. The construction waste alone impacts the capital costs, environment and carbon footprint of these 'New" homes. The best developments in the Region are based on indigenous or local typologies that are centuries old, yet maximize the way cities a planned and laid out. This has got to stop. everything from the "west" is not necessarily the 'Best'.

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 10:02 AM on 12/27/2008

I agree. Ya notice they copied the McMansion there they totally overlooked the great modernist tract homes of Joseph Eichler and Cliff May, they had a more modest vision, and at the time more green.
Hey all you potential land developers take a look at their work not at the McMansions.

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 10:51 AM on 12/27/2008

I wish I had bought the blueprints for an Eichler when they were selling them for 300 bucks! Why can't someone follow that trend and create a house plans web site for it. HDT2009 that's your cue.

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 11:04 AM on 12/27/2008
photo

hate x3 the awful mcmansion style. nothing says "bloated american consumer" like these domicilic abortions

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 11:49 AM on 12/27/2008

I absolutely agree! I have no training in the field other than a lot of research in the planning stages of building a home I would want to live in. The amount of wood alone in the framing process is astounding! I am opting for cement faced SIPS.

The eastern concept of the courtyard based home plans are beautiful. The market for Eichler's are still red hot 60 years later. There is a reason for it. We need architects to use their craft to teach people how to live better and create an environment of beauty in harmony with the land, culture and resources.

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 10:56 AM on 12/27/2008
photo

Everywhere else they use poured-in-place concrete or block. The US and Canada build with wood. Once you stucco the damn things they all look the same.

Jack

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 11:44 AM on 12/27/2008

Unfortunatly, until the USA develops a significant market for small attractive energy efficient homes within commmunities that are non-automobile oriented, and do not rely on cheap fossil fuels, the vast majority of architects that work within the residential "merchant builder" sector of the industry will continue to do what they do best and have the most experience in. That is, designing structures that are little more than amenity laden "eye candy". The USA home building industry has operated like the auto industry for years. At least with autos, you can go out and buy a Prius or even a Chevy "Volt". Just for fun, do this: Google: "sustainable residential design" and you will find links to thousands of books, achitecture schools, conferences, position papers, consulting engineers, even a few architects. "Experts" have been writing, talking, and in a few small examples even building along these lines for years. Then, open to the weekly residential real estate section of your local newspaper and see how often the words 'green", "energy efficient", "walkable neighborhoods", "close to public transportation", "sustainable construction practices" come up. In most (though I'm sure not all) parts of the USA, references will be few and far between.

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 12:29 PM on 12/27/2008

The light isn't shining here anymore. The story of civilization contines, elsewhere.

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 09:52 AM on 12/27/2008
photo

ouch. a poetic and crushing statement

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 11:50 AM on 12/27/2008

"Bassenian said he doesn't take lightly the task of creating a built-in environment for people millions of miles away"

Huh? Miliions of miles?. Are they still in our solar system?

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 09:44 AM on 12/27/2008

They're talking about the additional planet we're going to have to colonize to support an American level of resource consumption worldwide.

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 11:55 AM on 12/27/2008

spread the cancer.........

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 09:13 AM on 12/27/2008

You still have a house? It's not spread, it's a move.

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 09:53 AM on 12/27/2008
photo

Well here in America, we are being price out of the housing market, homes were over price for the market, now that the housing market has fallen in the reason years. The housing market has not finish falling yet, I suggest very strongly don't be standing under it , when it do finish falling.

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 08:39 AM on 12/27/2008
Page: 1 2 3 4 Next › Last » (4 pages total)
Comments are closed for this entry

You must be logged in to reply to this comment. Log in  or  Connect

 
Right Now on HuffPost
MAYHEM IN HONDURAS

TEGUCIGALPA, Honduras — Ousted President Manuel...

Biden: "We Misread How Bad The Economy Was"

WASHINGTON — The Obama administration "misread" the depth...