EDITION: U.S.
 
CONNECT    

Dispatches From The Displaced: Housing Crisis Is Healthcare Crisis For Many

The Huffington Post   First Posted: 6/18/09 Updated: 5/25/11

Foreclosure

This is our third installment of Dispatches from the Displaced, in which just one of the 10,000 people who lose the their house each weekday shares his or her story. You can read yesterday's story from military mom Carol Ann Smith here.

Today's story comes from Albuquerque, New Mexico, and illustrates the confluence of the mortgage crisis and the health care failure. When one of the 46 million Americans without health care confronts a serious injury or malady, overwhelming medical bills quickly make mortgage payments impossible. Cheryl's entire family faces medical ailments. Lacking health care, their misfortune could eventually rob them of both health and home.

Ours is a story that could happen to just about any family, anywhere at any time. We did not purchase a home above our means. In fact, when we purchased our house 5 years ago, we were approved for more than double the amount we actually bought at. We do not have an adjustable rate mortgage -- we have a 30-year fixed rate at 6%. My husband and I have always tried to plan for life's little misfortunes. We had a small but growing savings account and we tried not to spend foolishly. Of course, life does not always go according to plan -- we know this well. But one can only plan for so much.


Our two adult children live with us. They are both disabled. Our youngest son was 16 years old when, after a head injury from a hockey incident, he was diagnosed with hydrocephalous and associated cognitive issues. He is 24 years old now. Our oldest son, who is 27, was born with mild cerebral palsy and he has recently been diagnosed with depression. He does not have health insurance. We pay his health costs as needed. Neither of them currently work, although they would both like to work and are willing to work, if given the opportunity. Although both boys would probably qualify for SSDI, my husband and I never felt it was necessary or something we wanted to pursue. We both believed, as their parents, we should support them and not rely on the government for assistance. Until now.

In August of 2008, I was fired from my job. For several months leading up to my termination, my family suffered serious health problems: I was needed to provide care and transportation to medical appointments for my mom who consequently died from her condition in October of 2007; my husband suffered a stroke in very early May 2008; 3 weeks later, I was involved in an automobile accident; in August our son needed emergency neurosurgery to replace a malfunctioning VP shunt. I was fired from my job the day after my son's first surgery because I had missed too many days of work by that time. My employer denied me unemployment benefits because they claimed I had "attendance/tardiness" issues.

On 2 separate occasions; during my mom's illness and when my son started to show signs of shunt malfunction, I did ask about using the Family Medical Leave Act (FMLA) but both times was told by my employer that I did not qualify for it because of the size of the company. The company I worked for had over 500 employees in 22 offices in the western half of the U.S.

Immediately after my car accident, my primary care physician suggested I use my short-term disability (STD) insurance, which I paid for through my employer but at the time I did not feel I would need that much time off. To use STD I would have needed to take an entire 6 weeks off of work.

Medical bills are piling up. And our savings account has been wiped out. We have resorted to selling our personal belongings on ebay and Craigs List to raise extra money. Fortunately, from the items we sold, we were able to make a $4,500 payment to US Bank in late December of 2008. That payment got us all caught up. But this was our last payment to them and now we do not have too much left to sell.

My husband's bi-monthly paychecks do not cover all of our current expenses. To make matters worse, on January 1st the premiums for health insurance have increased so his paychecks have decreased. Between the 4 of us, we are spending approximately $500.00 per month on drugs and co-pays for doctor visits. That amount can go up any given month depending on the number of doctor visits and/or prescription medications. Right now we have to pick and choose which doctors to go to, who gets to go, and whose prescriptions get refilled. I quickly reached the limit allowed under the medical portion of my auto insurance so now we have to pay out of pocket, for any care I receive. Yes, that money will eventually be reimbursed but it is a struggle to pay it now.

As things would have it, the person that hit me did not have auto insurance. So, unfortunately, we will have to sue our insurance company to recover the money we have lost. But we cannot -- and will not -- pursue it until all of my treatment is complete.

Our top priority is to maintain my husbands health, as he is the sole-provider at this point. His stroke primarily affected his inner ear. It has left him deaf in one ear and he has daily episodes of vertigo. Unfortunately, we cannot afford to get him a hearing aid and our health insurance will not cover it. Because of the vertigo he cannot drive a car. My oldest son takes him to/from work everyday.

We moved from Minnesota to New Mexico about 5 years ago. We owe approximately $215,000 on our house. Because of the current housing market coupled with the fact that it needs a few repairs, which we cannot afford to do, I do not know if we could sell it anytime soon. In our neighborhood alone there are 4 houses for sale that have been on the market for over 6 months. We have received some phone calls and some letters in the mail from people interested in buying our house but they are very low offers and we would actually lose money if we sold it to any of them. So, of course, we do not want to do that. Besides, we do not want to sell it. We like our house and moving now would be physically difficult for both my husband and myself.

We have been working with our lender, US Bank, trying to get a loan modification. The person I am working with seems nice enough but unfortunately he is so far behind that he has not been able to complete the process yet. The last time I spoke with him was last week. He said that his caseload was backed up about 6-8 weeks and he would try to get back to me within the next few months. In the meantime, he said to "sit tight and send in a payment when you can." He said we should not get 4 months behind otherwise our case would go to the foreclosure department and there would be nothing he could do for us, at that point. I have no idea what he will offer us, if anything, as we haven't gotten that far along in the process. Since we may have a little equity in our house, we are very worried that the bank will not modify our loan and in fact, move forward with foreclose.

Are you facing foreclosure, or have you already lost your home? Share a story of how the housing crisis has affected you by emailing submissions+foreclosure@huffingtonpost.com. And sign up here to receive updates when we publish new stories.

Find out more about Dispatches from the Displaced, HuffPost's Eyes&Ears series of reader-submitted foreclosure stories.
FOLLOW HUFFPOST POLITICS

This is our third installment of Dispatches from the Displaced, in which just one of the 10,000 people who lose the their house each weekday shares his or her story. You can read yesterday's story fr...
This is our third installment of Dispatches from the Displaced, in which just one of the 10,000 people who lose the their house each weekday shares his or her story. You can read yesterday's story fr...
 
  • Comments
  • 39
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Recency  | 
Popularity
Page: 1 2  Next ›  Last »  (2 total)
05:59 PM on 02/24/2009
Renters suffer tragedies. Renters are not allowed to borrow against their shelter to pay for life's misfortune­s.

I am as liberal as they come and believe that government should pay everyone's medical care, but government should get the hell out of the real estate market and let prices drop so we all can afford shelter.
12:25 AM on 02/22/2009
Another story like hers here:
Cassidy: Circle of friends saves West San Jose woman from foreclosur­e

http://www­.mercuryne­ws.com/top­stories/ci­_11751504

"Incredibl­e. Three months ago, Wigness was contemplat­ing suicide. Her trouble started with a breast cancer diagnosis in late 2004. She underwent surgery, chemothera­py and radiation and struggled with a post-surgi­cal infection. She was away from her job as a managed-ca­re administra­tor at the Palo Alto Medical Foundation for eight months. She first started back working part time.

She fell behind on her mortgage payments and began a pattern of defaulting on her loan, then catching up with a lump sum or agreeing to pay more every month.

As the days went on, Wigness felt suffocated by debt and depression­. In November, Litton foreclosed­. She didn't know where to turn and so she turned to May."

Her home was saved by some good people willing to step up and help. foreclosur­es due to medical bills and she worked for a large health clinic.
photo
wonketteRAWKS
Hypocrisy is prevalent in BOTH parties!
11:21 PM on 02/21/2009
I heard that the lady in Florida who spoke up at Obama's speech in Florida, I think her name was Hughes, the one who got the house from a Republican lawmaker's wife, that she was offered a place before hand with 3 months free rent AND both her and her son get $800 a month each from the government­.

Anyone else hear anything on this?
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
wolfgangmo
09:03 AM on 02/22/2009
Either post a link or stop gossiping.
08:25 PM on 02/21/2009
I'm sorry to sound cold hearted, but this woman sounds to me more like someone who has turned down or ignored the help society has to offer for many years and now things have snowballed out of control. Her son was injured in a "hockey incident" that has caused ongoing health problems. That is what lawsuits are for, and as much as they are demonized, personal injury lawyers work on a contingenc­y so not being able to pay a lawyer isn't a barrier. Her sons could have been receiving disability benefits, which may have been enough to pay for health insurance plus build up a safety net for them, but she an her husband didn't want to obtain for their sons what they were entitled to. Her employer "denied" her unemployme­nt benefits, that is something you can appeal if the employer was wrong. I've never heard of having to take a full six weeks to get Short term Disability­. This sounds like someone who did not understand what she and her family was entitled to for many years, and now is in a dire situation, a situation that could have been avoided if she had availed herself of what was available, or fought a little harder for it. i wonder how many other people in her position are there because they didn't avail themselves of what the system offers sooner.
11:52 PM on 02/21/2009
Fighting for what you are entitled to is difficult when you are sick or in crisis. It is easy to think clearly and logically when you aren't involved, but much harder when you are the one suffering. Blaming the victim isn't the answer.
06:05 PM on 02/22/2009
I'm not "blaming the victim" and many choices this person made were not made in times of crisis, such as not pursuing a lawsuit on behalf of her son and not seeking disability benefits for her son. Those were decisions made years ago, the fallout of which she's only feeling now. And yes, it is difficult to know where to turn in times of crisis, but there are resources to help people in crisis. Appealing a denial of unemployme­nt beneits is easy, calling the State Department of Labor if you feel you're being denied FMLA benefits is easy. There are so many services available to people in need in this society, and it seems a lot of people are in alot of trouble because they never availed themselves of the help that is out there. Now society has to pony up even more to help them out. There are so many people who rip the system off for every penny they can get, and then others are clueless, or turn down assistance that is out there. Yes, this woman needs help, I don't think she "deserves" to lose her home, but I don't feel that sorry for her.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Rolanda Ridley
Librarian
10:24 AM on 02/22/2009
Thanks for saying this, I didn't qualify all sorts of aid that attempted to get for my son. However my salary just didn't cover much. Now he needs major dental work which I still don't really have, but hopefully he can get some campus health insurance or maybe I can save up the $8000 to fix his teeth. Or better yet, the dental school will start taking patients again.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
cloudminder
12:51 PM on 02/21/2009
yes, this story gets it exactly.. healthcare is now a luxury

and now employee exploitati­on by employers is getting worse

I personally know of 6 people who were harassed in a concerted effort by a public higher ed employer

the manager wanted to get rid of them so he allowed others in the unit to create a hostile work environmen­t

so the employees quit

they were not the types to fight back and the manager knew it

and I have several friends who are saying the same thing is happening in their workplace
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
ravencalling
My macro-bio is full
11:45 AM on 02/21/2009
What this brings to mind is the help that the octuplets woman is receiving, and the insane lifestyles of the current grifters who are running around outside of jail. The contrast sort of blows your mind and highlights the insanity of what has been created by greed and stupidity in this country. We need to circle back in to help our own in some manner, collective­ly. Waiting around for our society as a whole to change is not going to help this woman. Those who think that anyone falling on misfortune deserve it in some way are in really bad denial about what could happen to them in the future. I only wish karma were more expedient in some cases for these types, but maybe the reason it hasn't been is because one really cannot cure stupid. It's sort of a terminal condition in and of itself. That sort of leaves it up to the rest of us to think of constructi­ve real ways we can help families suffering like this.
11:22 AM on 02/21/2009
This person needs to see a lawyer. First, she needs to get disability for both boys now. To do nothing, when they would probably qualify is just not a good idea. Second, she does not need to complete her medical treatment to sue under her underinsur­ed insurance. By the time her case is ready to be heard (or in many cases arbitrated­) she will have a good estimate of what her future medical bills will be. I'm not trying to blame her, but she needs to take action. She has some viable options here that she is not taking advantage of. A Chapter 13 bankruptcy is also an option.
HUFFPOST COMMUNITY MODERATOR
WorkingClass
07:03 PM on 02/21/2009
Exactly what I was thinking. This family needs legal advise.
01:02 AM on 02/21/2009
This is the type of story I have been waiting for HuffPo to post, someone who actually had things spiral out of control not because of anything that THEY actually did....

I think this family deserves all the help that they can get.... the stimulus and mortgage aid needs to help them....

not the lady who gets an interest only and refi 6months later.... or the refi at 12%....

I am absolutely not for rewarding stupidity.­... but this family does not fall into that category, and they MUST be helped
10:55 PM on 02/20/2009
These cases rarely happen. A quarter of one percent of homeowners have been found to have face foreclosur­e because of medical bills. If you judge by the news reports, you'd think otherwise, but then again, the real statistics don't help to artificial­ly inflate the emotional impact of individual stories, or make people think we need national health insurance.

According to the Census there are 72,265,000 owner-occu­pied homes in the US.

One study (below) says one in 92 face foreclosur­e. That's 785,489 homes.

The same study says 23% of these homes are foreclosed upon due to unmanageab­le medical bills.

That's 180,662 homes, or 0.25% of all homes. What a crisis!

http://wor­ks.bepress­.com/chris­topher_rob­ertson/2/
01:00 AM on 02/21/2009
Here's what that site actually says:

"(49%) indicated that their foreclosur­e was caused in part by a medical problem, including illness or injuries (32%), unmanageab­le medical bills (23%), lost work due to a medical problem (27%), or caring for sick family members (14%)"
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
wolfgangmo
09:05 AM on 02/22/2009
But nice try, Mr. Ed.
photo
Mattie
My Daddy taught me to beware the good Christian
06:53 PM on 02/20/2009
These are the kind of people who need help, people who have lost their jobs, or who have health issues. These aren't greedy people who spent their way into this situation. Life conspired against them, and I hope they get the help they deserve. The problem is, will this plan help people like this, while differenti­ating them from the woman in the story the first night. The one who bought a house they couldn't afford, who got an interest only loan, who took the equity out of her home to pay credit card debt, on and on they made one bad, greedy decision after another. Will it say yes to these people, but no to people like Connie, that was the name in the first story. I hope so!
HUFFPOST COMMUNITY MODERATOR
WorkingClass
07:10 PM on 02/21/2009
I America its better to see everyone starve than risk feeding an "undeservi­ng" person. Thats why we don't have health care for everybody. Thats why this family is in so much trouble.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
wolfgangmo
09:07 AM on 02/22/2009
Bam. Nail on the head.
05:51 PM on 02/20/2009
very sorry to hear this story. It is about time Americans take to the streets and reclaim their country back. No more foreign wars. Universal health care. Nationaliz­e bad banks. More taxes but at least everyone is looked after. I am very glad to be a Canadian.
sonoffestus
Got smart & got out!
06:02 PM on 02/20/2009
I am very happy to have moved here from the States. Unfortunat­ely, the business my wife and I founded, and moved here to Canada is tanking along with our US clients. I'm looking forward to becoming a dual citizen as soon as I can. It's a great country and we have made some wonderful new friends. Now, to find a job!
07:39 PM on 02/20/2009
How difficult is it to become a Canadian citizen? I am so disgusted at blow-hards (my father use to use that term) like Rush L getting blood money for himself while taking the USA down the road to perdition.
sonoffestus
Got smart & got out!
05:28 PM on 02/20/2009
This is a sad situation, unfortunat­ely we will be hearing and reading more about situations such as this. High unemployme­nt will leave many without the means to cover their cobra payments and this will leave even more uninsured. Today Sofie's choice becomes is one of home or health.

The "greatest Nation on earth"....­......we might have to re-think that one.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
wolfgangmo
09:11 AM on 02/22/2009
No, we won't have to rethink it. The statistics about health are clear. We are number 37.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
NABNYC
04:57 PM on 02/20/2009
This family has a healthcare problem. Financial devastatio­n as the result of medical expenses. It's really unrelated to the real estate issue. If they were renting, they'd still be in trouble because they don't have enough money because of medical issues. If we had national healthcare free of charge for all citizens, their lives would apparently be very different.

Of course the second problem is the employment issue, again, not a foreclosur­e problem. The people in charge of this country have passed laws to encourage businesses to take jobs out of the U.S., to eliminate unions and job security, to crush workers, bring in workers from other countries to create more competitio­n and lower wages, and of course eliminate all employer-s­ponsored healthcare and pensions. But again, this is a problem with jobs, not real estate.

We should stay focused on jobs. Without jobs, people will never be able to afford any housing -- owned or rented. Without jobs, no healthcare­. We need jobs.
07:49 PM on 02/20/2009
There has been a huge problem not with real estate as you put it, but with the lenders and bankers. I saw this up close and personal. Choices consistent­ly to lower lending standards and increase the rates and mortgage insurance to try to mitigate the huge risks. More than just the man on "60 Minutes" from World Savings wondered when this was going to explode. Then the lack of liquidity to purchase or loan money to business leading to lost jobs.

We need some angry boys on the other side from the Rush's and Santelly? , to get people angry at the lobby blood money going to banks, health care, pharm, military industrial complex- (like the company that built showers that executed soldiers, I heard they got more money for electrical contract work-- Where is the outrage about these money thirsty thugs?
HUFFPOST COMMUNITY MODERATOR
1dogs2
10:40 AM on 02/21/2009
Trying to compartmen­talize America's economic problems doesn't work. Healthcare and employment problems are NOT unrelated to the foreclosur­e problem; they contribute to it. Hence, no single solution is possible. Rather, all three (not to mention others, such as the credit crisis) have to be tackled simultaneo­usly. The present situation is a perfect storm of economic woes worldwide. The only glimmer of sunshine is our good fortune to have a president who, if he doesn't have the perfect, sure-fire cure to this catastroph­e immediatel­y at hand, at least understand­s the depth, breadth and interrelat­edness of the parts of the problem and the will to deal with it instead of issuing idiotic assurances that "the economy is fundamenta­lly strong." To succeed, he will have to neutralize the "No" party and the demagoguer­y of ill-inform­ed folks who can't see the forest, but only the twigs of their own tree.
photo
HUFFPOST COMMUNITY MODERATOR
MossyOak
04:54 PM on 02/20/2009
All the self-procl­aimed self-relia­nt, "I got mine" people who are screaming "Not Fair!" about the foreclosur­e bailout should read this story. The meanness I'm seeing from some people breaks my heart. No one is immune from illness and everyone should take a walk in this woman's shoes for a day. As my wise father used to say, "There but for the grace of God go I."
07:50 PM on 02/20/2009
Amen.
HUFFPOST COMMUNITY MODERATOR
1dogs2
10:58 AM on 02/21/2009
What the "I got mine" folks don't seem to understand is that if the entire economy continues to collapse, they're going to lose theirs just like everyone else. They don't seem to understand that it is in their SELF-inter­est to support every reasonable effort to stabilize the economy.

That said, the meanness in many of the comments posted in response to these stories is sickening.
04:48 PM on 02/20/2009
Thank you for sharing your story. I hope that things work out for your family. You've stuck together and helped each other through difficult times and that is something that no one can take away from you.