Police: Dad killed kids because wife was leaving

digg Share this on Facebook Huffpost - Police: Dad killed kids because wife was leaving stumble reddit del.ico.us RSS

PHUONG LE | April 5, 2009 09:35 PM EST | AP

Compare other versions »
I Like ItI Don’t Like It

GRAHAM, Wash. — A man who fatally shot his five children and killed himself had just discovered his wife was leaving him for another man, authorities said Sunday.

The bodies of James Harrison's children, ages 7 to 16, were found with multiple gunshot wounds Saturday in the family's mobile home, most of them in their beds. Harrison's body had been found earlier in the day with a self-inflicted gunshot wound, behind the wheel of his idling car.

The night before, the father and his eldest daughter went in search of his wife, Angela Harrison. The daughter used a GPS feature in her mother's cell phone to find her with another man at a convenience store in nearby Auburn, said Ed Troyer, spokesman for the Pierce County Sheriff.

The woman told her husband she was not coming home, and was leaving him for the man with her at the store. The father and the daughter left, distraught, Troyer said.

Sometime after the children went to sleep, he shot each of them multiple times. Four died in their beds. The fifth was found in the bathroom, surrounded by signs of violent struggle.

"He wanted the kids dead," Troyer said. "It wasn't like he shot a few rounds. He shot several rounds."

Investigators believe he then returned to the area near the convenience store looking for his wife. His body was found near the store, Troyer said.

"We think he was going to go back to kill the wife," Troyer said. "He probably didn't find her and realized the gravity of what he'd done and shot himself."

Story continues below

Several weapons were found in the home.

Authorities have not released the names of the family. Relatives identified the couple as Angela and James Harrison and the children as Maxine, Samantha, Heather, Jamie and James.

Ryan Peden, Maxine's classmate, had said she told him Friday night that her parents had gotten into a fight and her mother had left. The father followed the mother and tried to get her to return, Peden said.

"Maxine texted me at 11 p.m. Friday. She said: "I'm tired of crying. I'm going to bed,'" he said. His text to her the next day went unanswered.

Candy Johnson, an aunt of the mother, described Harrison as a strict, controlling husband and father who didn't allow his wife to make decisions without asking him first.

"My niece has been so controlled from the time she was young," Johnson said, adding that Harrison had impregnated Angela when she was 13.

State child welfare officials put Harrison on a parenting plan in 2007 after a "minor assault" on one of the children, Troyer said, adding that the father agreed to the plan and the case was closed.

Ron Vorak, who lives across the street from the family's trailer at the Deer Run mobile home park, said he called 911 at about 3:20 p.m. Saturday after one of the family's relatives couldn't get anyone to answer the door.

"He knocked on the door, and knocked on a couple of windows," Vorak said of the relative. "He walked around the side of the house, looked into the window. He could see somebody laying on the bed."

The home, about 15 southeast of Tacoma, became a makeshift memorial Sunday as neighbors left cards and bouquets of flowers. School officials said they were arranging to have grief counselors available when teachers and students returned Monday.

"We're going to try to get through this the best we can given the circumstances," said Jeff Davis, Orting School District superintendent. "In a small community like this, we know these kids. Teachers know the kids. All the kids know the kids."

Davis said the eldest, Maxine, was a 10th grader at Orting High School. Jamie was in the eighth grade and her sister Samantha in the sixth grade at Orting Middle School. The two youngest, Heather and James, were second-graders at Orting Primary School.

The father worked as a diesel mechanic, and the mother works at Wal-Mart, said another of Angela Harrison's aunts, Penny Flansburg. Troyer, however, said the father worked as a security guard at a casino.

One neighbor, Sheree Lund, who lives in the mobile home park, signed a community notebook left in front of the family's house. She wrote: "God Bless the five little ones. God bring peace to Mom."

___

Associated Press photographer Ted S. Warren contributed to this report.

GRAHAM, Wash. — A man who fatally shot his five children and killed himself had just discovered his wife was leaving him for another man, authorities said Sunday. The bodies of James Harrison's...
GRAHAM, Wash. — A man who fatally shot his five children and killed himself had just discovered his wife was leaving him for another man, authorities said Sunday. The bodies of James Harrison's...
Loading...
 
 
Comments
769
Pending Comments
0
iPhone App Promo

Want to reply to a comment? Hint: Click "Reply" at the bottom of the comment; after being approved your comment will appear directly underneath the comment you replied to

View Comments:
Page: « First ‹ Previous 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 Next › Last » (14 pages total)
- thegrifter I'm a Fan of thegrifter 8 fans permalink

You ever been to Graham Washington?

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 09:17 AM on 04/05/2009
- joyf1 I'm a Fan of joyf1 22 fans permalink
photo

No, I live on San Juan Island so I've never been down that way. What's it like?

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 10:40 AM on 04/05/2009
- springsm I'm a Fan of springsm 55 fans permalink

I am glad you said it...I wasn't going too. But it doesn't excuse that 5 youngsters are dead.

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 10:55 AM on 04/05/2009
- AnalyzeIT I'm a Fan of AnalyzeIT 65 fans permalink
photo

Only we can make the difference and by that i mean begin the process now of holding your mayors, your assemblymen/women, congressmen/women, governor's accountable - ANYONE you have help to elect to office. HOLD THEM ACCOUNTABLE and request that they, (The Republicans and Democrats) start NOW to work together. YOU/ME, we have the power and the right to demand this.

Let them know that WE THE PEOPLE are not going to stand idly by and watch America be destroyed. Destroyed simply because of some of their greed and un-willingness to work together.

We as citizens have been lazy. And now we sit by and listen to and watch people like Limbaugh, Hannity, Bachmann, Beck fill people with lies and hate inciting them to violence toward one another.
And we ask "what's happening." You see what's happening.

We are our brothers keeper and it is in part due to us that this happened to this family. There does not seem to be anyone who cares about the "neighbor."

And for those of you who still have hope for goodness sake SHARE IT!!!

What else you can do besides that: SPEAK UP!!!
*
*
With that, sincere sympathy to family and friends of the victims. May the little ones as well as the father rest in peace.
*

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 09:12 AM on 04/05/2009

If social services had been called to the home "several times," and the children had not been removed from the home, then they did not do "all they could."
I know it's hard for them to find the right balance between parental rights and children's needs, but they blew it in this case, and it doesn't do any good to deny it.

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 09:11 AM on 04/05/2009
- Peacein09 I'm a Fan of Peacein09 13 fans permalink
photo

We blew it in every case where a man kills his wife or his wife and kids. Because we don't step up to the plate and make sure that in our city the services are funded well enough to do something meaningful. We blow it every day a woman's shelter goes out of business because they can't afford to stay open. We blow it every day we don't speak up for the rights of women and children to live in a safe, secure environment. We are the government, remember?

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 10:39 AM on 04/05/2009

Moral of the story. If you know of a child being abused don't put it off as "not my problem" ...DO SOMETHING.

It IS your problem. It is.

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 09:10 AM on 04/05/2009

The most heartbreaking thing about this story is that people KNEW that this family was in crisis. Over and over again you hear about stories like this with deadly outcomes and someone admits that Child Protective Services was called in several times.

I don't mind paying taxes but if they are this INEFFECTIVE then I see no need to continue.

PATHETIC response from CPS. PATHETIC!!

I hope everyone in that CPS office and every single neighbor who knew there was an abusive father in the home finds it impossible to sleep for the rest of their lives.

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 09:07 AM on 04/05/2009

Stop blaming this recession or depression for these murderous rampages! There is no excuse for killing innocent children and adults. These people are just plain evil and would kill others for any reason! Otherwise, why wouldn't they just kill themselves?

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 09:03 AM on 04/05/2009
- dct1999 I'm a Fan of dct1999 396 fans permalink
photo

I don't think that any form of gun control would have made a dayum bit of difference in this case. A parent who is determined to kill their children will find a way to do it.

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 08:58 AM on 04/05/2009
- etcetc I'm a Fan of etcetc 5 fans permalink

Disagree. A gun makes it a lot less physical, dragged out, less blood on your own hands, as morbid as this is. Many people would not have the stomach to murder without a gun.

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 10:00 AM on 04/05/2009

Good point.

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 10:05 AM on 04/05/2009
- whatthel I'm a Fan of whatthel 294 fans permalink
photo

Excellent point.

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 10:07 AM on 04/05/2009
- scooperss I'm a Fan of scooperss 75 fans permalink
photo

What about the mothers who have put their kids in the car and then driven the car into water?

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 10:11 AM on 04/05/2009
- dct1999 I'm a Fan of dct1999 396 fans permalink
photo

Possibly. But parents have killed their chldren with knives, blunt objects, by smothering, via arson, etc.

Anyway his rifle was a legal weapon, so gun control still wouldn't have helped.

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 10:45 AM on 04/05/2009
- BDAinVA I'm a Fan of BDAinVA 2 fans permalink

When a story is this bad it is hard to choose the worst part, but the fact that it could have been prevented if authorities had done something with the information.....

"Carolyn and Raymond Bader, a former neighbor of the family, told The Seattle Times they often heard the father yelling at the children. The Baders said they called the sheriff's department and Child Protective Services several times with their concerns."

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 08:38 AM on 04/05/2009

This true.
Until mental health issues are taken care of this wil continue as we have seen in the last few days. The Baders did the right thing but the system failed to assess the situation properly. These killings are avoidable just as was it avoidable in the Andrea Yates case. They couldn't get help for her either to the detriment of her poor children.

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 08:57 AM on 04/05/2009
- liminal67 I'm a Fan of liminal67 3 fans permalink

Bad economic times and the horrors return.

http://pitchbendpost.blogspot.com/

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 08:31 AM on 04/05/2009
- maryyooch I'm a Fan of maryyooch 29 fans permalink
photo

I agree. I'm sure economics played a large role in this tradgedy. We've already seen this happen more than a few times, and unfortunatley, it will probably happen again.
My heart goes out to Family and Friends of all the victims.

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 09:12 AM on 04/05/2009
- VivaZapata I'm a Fan of VivaZapata 64 fans permalink
photo

without dismissing the consequences of an economic-psychological connection, it seems we have waves of mass shootings no matter what is going on financially. At the root seems to be the common denominator of the sociopath feeling small about him/herself. Loss of job, wife, self esteem in general can factor in. Often the killer is taunted and humiliated, as was the case of the Birmingham shooter. Was it one or two years ago that Cho shot up the campus at Virginia Tech? It seems in Spring, instead of a young man's fancy turns lightly to thoughts of love, a loveless man's thoughts turn to thoughts of murder.

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 09:28 AM on 04/05/2009
- Dynamohum I'm a Fan of Dynamohum 62 fans permalink

A curiously NAIVE view of things.

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 10:04 AM on 04/05/2009
- Yves Papa I'm a Fan of Yves Papa 14 fans permalink

This not about guns. This is about a man going crazy. Why did he decide to pick his piece up and destroy everything? Canadian style gun prohibition is not going to do anything about this, he had a legal rifle.
He had 5 children! No one in his right mind would want to die with 5 children. Regardless of his grief, anger or illness, this man should be held responsible for what he did. However, rather than the supposed "gun problem", the problem at hand is what put this man in the situation where he did these horrible things.

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 08:10 AM on 04/05/2009
- TLV I'm a Fan of TLV 123 fans permalink

And yet, in another horror story, a man shot up some people because he said he thought the Obama administration wasgoing to ban guns. Where does one hear such phony stories? On Fox News, on right wing radio, around the tables of local red neck restaurants. That's where!

We are often told that Republicans or those who consider themselves "conservative" voters care about values. No, they do not! They care about keeping what they want to keep even at the expense of others. Period. Even if it includes killing.

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 08:50 AM on 04/05/2009
- Davwbaird I'm a Fan of Davwbaird 24 fans permalink
photo

it was easy knives to gruesome

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 09:04 AM on 04/05/2009
photo

Guns don't kill people.....people with guns kill people. Every time one these stories surfaces, so does the gun apologists who chime in to remind us that this really isn't about guns.....just the horrible things people do with them. I would much rather have some person come at me with a knife than a gun. At least with a knife, there is a chance I might be able to run away. And I would imagine it would be much harder for a person to kill someone with a knife as opposed to merely pulling a trigger.

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 09:17 AM on 04/05/2009
- pfc1369 I'm a Fan of pfc1369 113 fans permalink
photo

It's never about guns for the brainwashed enablers of the arms merchants who make a fortune on this s**t.

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 09:27 AM on 04/05/2009

You are absolutely right. I am not a gun lover but this had nothing to do with gun laws. It had to do with mental health awareness and treatment that was absent. The Baders in this case did the right thing. They called the proper people but the system failed. You are also right that the man should be held responsible. We all have to be responsible for our own actions. If someone is feeling overwhelmed or having thoughts that aren't usual (my family would be better off without me, this world is so terrible, I will save my children from it, or an interior rage that is all consuming) they should seek help. If not for themselves, then for their families.

These terrible murders are avoidable. It didn't have to happen, that is the tragedy.

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 09:31 AM on 04/05/2009
- Libilou I'm a Fan of Libilou 3 fans permalink
photo

I've read all these comments about despair over money causing this and I wonder if people really read the article.

The parents had a fight and the mother left. Neighbors report hearing the father yelling a lot at the kids.

This is a case of domestic abuse. The mother finally got out and the abuser "got her" by killing her children.

This is his way of controlling her for good. He's going to make her life miserable and he's going to win. At least, that's what he thinks.

I pray she gets help, lots of help. I pray she gets healthy because that will be the best revenge.

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 08:09 AM on 04/05/2009
photo

Her 5 children are dead. There's not enough help in the world for that sort of thing.

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 09:18 AM on 04/05/2009
- Libilou I'm a Fan of Libilou 3 fans permalink
photo

Unfortunately, you are probably right.

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 06:33 PM on 04/05/2009

Yes.

Ultimate power & control.

This should be seen for what it is: domestic abuse. It's the true story behind so much violence and tragedy, and in no small part because it's so rarely called out for what it is.

Glad you spoke up!

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 09:38 AM on 04/05/2009
photo

Revenge? Revenge against what? He's dead, and so are her children. How awful...

I think rather than posting pithy comments we should all make a donation to a local battered women shelter. Maybe if one had been available to help her get her whole family out this tragedy could have been avoided. Or maybe she left him for another man. Regardless- the donation wouldn't hurt anyone.

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 09:45 AM on 04/05/2009
- Nanaama I'm a Fan of Nanaama 4 fans permalink

The father is alleged to have shouted at the children, so the wife leaves, abandoning the children . The father kills the children and himself. And from that you have your perfect analysis of domestic abuse story? Or do you know more than we are reading here? Or perhaps you are looking into your crystal ball?

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 09:46 AM on 04/05/2009
- roshni I'm a Fan of roshni 182 fans permalink

It's not domestic abuse to murder your children to get back at their mother?

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 06:45 PM on 04/05/2009

That's exactly how I read the story, Libilou.

How someone can hate their spouse more than they love their children is beyond me, but then again, people can be downright evil.

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 09:54 AM on 04/05/2009

Enough about more Gun Control....how about better Mental Health Counseling, better paying jobs, Less alcoholism (not saying the father was an alcoholic).. I am saying you don't stop insanity by just taking the tools away.

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 08:07 AM on 04/05/2009

You're right.
Mental health counseling could have gone a long way to making sure this didn't happen.

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 09:01 AM on 04/05/2009
- forebode I'm a Fan of forebode 4 fans permalink

Mental health does not have coverage parity with physical health, because the HMOs, PPOs, Health Insurance companies, feel that mental health problems are too easy to fake. They can't see a mental health problem in lab testing, plus it is considered to be a moral weakness by the above organizations, so people can't get help they can afford. Even the mental health agencies that use an income sliding rule are sometimes too high-priced for the down and out family, especially in this economy, an economy CAUSED and brought to you by Bush, Cheney, and their Repug cronies, regardless of what Limbaugh, Hannity, Savage, or any other piece of crap tries to tell their ignorant audience.

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 10:26 AM on 04/05/2009
- Davwbaird I'm a Fan of Davwbaird 24 fans permalink
photo

then why is the death rate 500 times thenwhat it is in the rest of the world?

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 09:06 AM on 04/05/2009
- pfc1369 I'm a Fan of pfc1369 113 fans permalink
photo

That's absurd.

Perhaps you mean murders as a percentage of the population.

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 11:52 AM on 04/05/2009
- MadHeart I'm a Fan of MadHeart 157 fans permalink

Mental Health assistance is a joke. I went through "depression" during my 50s; mostly it was over lack of work but there was no "cure"--lithium, risperdol, prozac--they wouldn't give me, resulting in my being in a zombie state and couldn't even LOOK for the kind of job I had held, winding up in a supermarket making $20K less a year, losing my home, etc. There's nothing but total employment geared to a person's education, talent and drive that will help. I'd bet 90% of diagnosed "depression" is economically related, esp in mature people who've made it over the "But I'm in love" excuse of youth.

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 09:37 AM on 04/05/2009

I'm guessing that you are right and that at least the father, and possibly also the mother, may have been drinking in the past few days. But how do we achieve less alcoholism? Gun control is a cakewalk compared to alcoholism control. I didn't say "alcohol control"----we tried that, with Prohibition, and it was a miserable failure. Reducing the number of alcoholic people would be even more difficult. Do we fine them? Incarcerate them? And do we do it only after their drinking causes problems? Should we incarcerate the person who drinks a little too much and could become a full-fledged alcoholic? Should we put away the kid who has a family history of alcoholism? Having spent years in a home with an alcoholic, I know that you can't reason with them, you can't persuade them, you can't hide the booze well enough, and they don't care about much of anything except getting the next drink. If you manage to prohibit liquor, they'll drink the vanilla extract, the cough syrup, even the rubbing alcohol.

We could come up with some bumper stickers: "ALCOHOL DOESN'T KILL PEOPLE; ALCOHOLIC PEOPLE KILL PEOPLE." Or: 'I'LL GIVE UP DRINKING WHEN THEY PRY THE BOTTLE FROM MY COLD, DEAD HAND." That'll show everyone how much we cherish our freedoms, one of which is arguably the right to drink as we choose.

Meanwhile, as we fret and wonder what to do, the carnage continues. But gun control is evidently off the table.

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 09:43 AM on 04/05/2009
- forebode I'm a Fan of forebode 4 fans permalink

If you manage to prohibit liquor, they'll drink the vanilla extract, the cough syrup, even the rubbing alcohol.

In Siberia, if everything else is unavailable, the alcoholics drank the jet fuel meant for the MIGS. Really. I read that in a book written by a Soviet defector to the United States. Talk about alcoholism, look to the Soviet Union.

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 10:20 AM on 04/05/2009

How about ALL of the above? No guns and better social services?

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 09:47 AM on 04/05/2009
- pfc1369 I'm a Fan of pfc1369 113 fans permalink
photo

Weren't all these latest shooters members of a well-regulated militia, as required by the Second Amendment?

NRA? What's that?

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 08:07 AM on 04/05/2009

lucky for you he didn't kill them with a frying pan or you'd be boiling all your food.

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 08:57 AM on 04/05/2009
- PennLawyer I'm a Fan of PennLawyer 26 fans permalink

The operative term is "WELL REGULATED" - as in government regulations, as in national gun control laws.
It is claimed the father used a hunting rifle, not some assault rifle as was used to kill 3 police officers in Pittsburgh yesterday. Well, one possible regulation would be that if the police are called to a home because of child abuse (as was the case here), all guns on the premises are immediately confiscated. "Rights" carried to extremes may conflict with each other. So if it's the right to bear arms versus a child's right to be free from abuse, society should err on the side of protecting the child. The same should hold true for anyone against whom a Protection From Abuse Order is entered.
Never having killed a living being, I'm speculating here, but in response to those who say the father would have killed his children by some other method if he hadn't had a gun, I argue that it must have been easier for this homicidal control freak to shoot his children sleeping in their beds, then to look into their terrified eyes as he strangled or stabbed them with a knife. For one thing there would have been a lot of screaming to alert neighbors and give the other kids a chance to run for their lives. Did the guy use a pillow to silence the shots? Why didn't the neighbors hear the shooting?

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 09:12 AM on 04/05/2009
- Paul I'm a Fan of Paul 32 fans permalink

At some point there will be a comment suggesting that this tragedy could have been prevented if the kids were armed...

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 09:51 AM on 04/05/2009

It is posted and I have read it. You are correct.

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 01:38 PM on 04/05/2009
- MalloMel I'm a Fan of MalloMel 100 fans permalink
photo

shhh!... you're not supposed to notice that. Over 30,000 people killed a year, in this country, by gun violence. That second amendment, as interpreted by the right wing wackos, is really working out swell.

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 10:04 AM on 04/05/2009

Horrible is what this is and I think there will be a lot more of this happening in the future.I don't know what caused this father to snap but I do know when a nation starts depriving it's population of work and healthcare and a good education the crime rate usually skyrockets.It's time to get to work.

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 08:06 AM on 04/05/2009
- scooperss I'm a Fan of scooperss 75 fans permalink
photo

Yes it is.

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 08:55 AM on 04/05/2009
- forebode I'm a Fan of forebode 4 fans permalink

Amen. The Republicans only see it as voters killing themselves through lack of work, hoping that the population will decimate itself down to few enough voters so the Repugs can actually win an election without cheating, since they hope for low voter turnout for elections at pretty much all levels. The population killing each other will definitely get that low voter turnout. The Repugs have no conscience.
Their success depends on tragedy (mental, financial, and otherwise) for others. They want to keep the health care system and health care nonpayout system, regarding insurance, the way it is. There IS gold in them thar ills, and the Repugs are more than happy to prey on the misfortune of others so they can grub it all up for themselves.

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 10:32 AM on 04/05/2009
- banja I'm a Fan of banja 19 fans permalink
photo

The reign of terror from the NRA continues...... we are all bearing the brunt of the Heller case.

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 08:02 AM on 04/05/2009

Clearly you haven't read the Heller opinions or even the facts of the case. This tragedy has nothing to do with gun control or the lack thereof. It has everything to do with ineffective/unavailable intervention and mental health services, i.e the need for serious and substantive health care reform and more responsive community action. But the bogeyman of the hour seems to firearms..ooohhh scary, scary guns must be the problem.

IMO it's time to offer people in need a hand (give them healthcare including mental healthcare) rather than deprive people of liberty because of fear and scapegoating.

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 09:20 AM on 04/05/2009
Page: « First ‹ Previous 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 Next › Last » (14 pages total)
Comments are closed for this entry

 You must be logged in to comment. Log in  or connect with 

Connect