More

Roxana Saberi's Parents Visit Her In Jail After Iran's Judiciary Chief Orders Full Investigation Into Case

ALI AKBAR DAREINI and NASSER KARIMI   04/20/09 05:02 PM ET   AP

Roxana Saberi

TEHRAN, Iran — Iran's judiciary ordered a full investigation Monday into the case of an American journalist imprisoned for allegedly spying for the U.S. and allowed the woman's parents to visit her for the first time since she was sentenced to eight years in prison.

The developments in the case of Roxana Saberi appear to be the latest signs that some senior Iranian officials want to ensure tensions over the case do not derail moves toward a dialogue with the Obama administration to break a 30-year diplomatic deadlock between the two countries.

In Washington, Secretary of State Hillary Rodham Clinton renewed calls for Iran to release Saberi said she hoped for positive action from the judiciary chief's investigation order.

"We believe she should be freed immediately, that the charges against her are baseless and that she has been subjected to a process that has been non-transparent, unpredictable (and) arbitrary," Clinton told reporters.

Saberi, who was born in the U.S. and grew up in Fargo, North Dakota, was convicted of espionage last week after a one-day trial behind closed doors. Her Iranian-born father, Reza, told The Associated Press that he and his wife visited their daughter in Evin prison north of Tehran.

"She seems to be OK," he said. "She was looking forward for the appeal because she knows that this kind of verdict was too heavy for her."

The judiciary chief's order came a day after President Mahmoud Ahmadinejad sent a letter to Tehran's chief prosecutor urging him to ensure Saberi be allowed a full defense during her appeal. It was a rare request from an Iranian president and came at a time when President Barack Obama has been seeking engagement with Iran's leaders.

However, Iran's Foreign Ministry took a swipe Monday at President Barack Obama, saying "those who studied law" should not comment on the case without seeing the context. It was a clear reference to Obama, who has a law degree from Harvard University and taught constitutional law at the University of Chicago before becoming president.

Some analysts have said the mixed messages emerging from Iran may be an indication of political divisions in the leadership, with hard-liners in the judiciary trying to hamper government moves toward closer relations with the U.S. by pressing the Saberi case.

Saberi had been living in Iran for six years and worked as a freelance reporter for news organizations including National Public Radio and the British Broadcasting Corp. Because Saberi's father was born in Iran, she received Iranian citizenship.

Iran has released few details about the charges. Saberi was arrested in January and initially accused of working without press credentials. But earlier this month, a judge leveled a more serious allegation that she was passing classified information to U.S. intelligence services.

Saberi's father said he hoped officials will heed Ahmadinejad's letter.

"Also, they should be compassionate in their judgment and not be very harsh," he told the AP. Saberi's parents, who live in Fargo, traveled to Iran to seek her release.

"As far as she is healthy and she is taking good care of herself," her mother, Akiko Saberi said. She denied her daughter was a spy, saying "once you know her she is the last person to do that."

The United States broke off diplomatic relations with Iran after its 1979 Islamic revolution and takeover of the U.S. Embassy in Tehran. Iran has been mostly lukewarm to the Obama administration's overtures, but last week, Ahmadinejad said Iran was ready for a new start.

Saberi's conviction came about two months ahead of key presidential elections in June that are pitting hard-liners against reformists, who support better relations with Washington. Ahmadinejad is seeking re-election, but the hard-liner's popularity has waned and he has been trying to draw support away from his top reformist opponent, former prime minister Mir Hossein Mousavi.

Ahmadinejad met late Sunday with Swiss President Hans-Rudolf Merz at a U.N. racism conference in Geneva and Merz pressed Saberi's case. Clinton said the Obama administration is continuing to work with Swiss intermediaries, which have represented U.S. interests in Iran since the 1979 hostage crisis.

FOLLOW HUFFPOST WORLD

TEHRAN, Iran — Iran's judiciary ordered a full investigation Monday into the case of an American journalist imprisoned for allegedly spying for the U.S. and allowed the woman's parents to visit ...
TEHRAN, Iran — Iran's judiciary ordered a full investigation Monday into the case of an American journalist imprisoned for allegedly spying for the U.S. and allowed the woman's parents to visit ...
Filed by Hanna Ingber Win  | 
 
 
  • Comments
  • 59
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
Page: 1 2  Next ›  Last »  (2 total)
04:32 PM on 04/20/2009
It is quite amazing that this forum will defend any human rights abuse in Iran solely because of its antagonism to the US. Iran is a vile dictatorship run by the absolutely most reactionary crypto-fascists in the entire Islamic world.

Yet, because it maintains an anti-US foreign policy and waves its sword in bluster at Israel, it is the darling of the radical left and its blind adherents.

It's time to recognize that mere anti-Americanism isn't the same as good, wonderful, or even decent. Iran, Cuba, Venezuela, and North Korea have evil leaders. Their record in human rights is appalling; and whether the president of the United States is George Bush, Bill Clinton, or Barak Obama, these miserable governments will still be repressive and totalitarian.

Hating the government of the US isn't sufficient cred to be considered a peace loving country. It's about time the lunatic left learned that lesson so that it can make a real contribution to the foreign policy debate.
04:56 PM on 04/20/2009
Point taken. As an example, the left made great points before the Iraq war. I was there at demos where the left made extremely prophetic statements on the what the war would mean for US and Iraq. It amazes me why anyone would want to throw their principles and credibility away by supporting repression, but it's happened since at least making apologies for Stalin back in the 1920's. Please keep in mind though not all on the left have opportunistically abandoned human rights- you can see many posts here that prove that.
05:27 PM on 04/20/2009
Actually, very few people are "supporting repression"; they're merely putting that repression in perspective and in context--which is an essential prerequisite to actually bringing about change, rather than merely pontificating.

Iran's anti-Americanism doesn't justify its human rights issues, but American anti-Iranianism, and naked bias in criticizing their human rights record, goes a long way to explaining why a more open and civil environment hasn't come about in Iran.

If we actually practiced half of what we preached and stopped destabilizing half the world and propping up vile dictatorships in the other half, that would do more for human rights around the world--and in the US--than anything else.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
05:32 PM on 04/20/2009
Having lived and worked in the Middle East it's obvious you haven't or you would be singling out Saudi Arabia ahead of Iran on almost every measurable point. Still good job on picking out the only 4 nations that the U.S. media have told you to. Keep following orders and avoid any of that thinking for yourself nonsense.
05:38 PM on 04/20/2009
Took the words out of my mouth.
01:19 PM on 04/20/2009
Her picture of her in short shorts is probably the reason why she got arrested lol, oh well.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Immhotep
01:02 PM on 04/20/2009
She has not been waterboarded, not held in a no-man's land, not denied due process, and her parents are allowed to visit her. I think America has been taught a humbling lesson by Iran.
03:08 PM on 04/20/2009
Thousands of Iranian citizens have been tortured and executed by the Islamic dictatorship in Iran since 1979. Guantanamo is a 5 star hotel compared to Evin prison in Tehran. Roxana Saberi is an American that's why she is not tortured like Iranian citizens. Iranian students, women activists, dissident bloggers, union activists, etc...have been murdered in Evin and other prisons in Iran, but they don't get coverage, because they have Iranian citizenship, not U.S. or any other western country.
photo
HUFFPOST COMMUNITY MODERATOR
TimeToPunt
I'm an atheist, thank god.
12:42 PM on 04/20/2009
Roxana will be released by the end of the year.
12:30 PM on 04/20/2009
Is she a prisoner now, or a hostage?
photo
Obamalicious
Obama's Kool-Aid is mm, mm, good.
01:16 PM on 04/20/2009
Good question. "Technically" a prisoner, but it seems like more like a hostage situation to me.
yappnmutt
humping legs for liberty
12:22 PM on 04/20/2009
these iranians aren't civilized. why hasn't she been waterboarded?
photo
Obamalicious
Obama's Kool-Aid is mm, mm, good.
01:19 PM on 04/20/2009
You joke about it, but the sad thing is she may have been through worse. I hope she is not being physically abused or raped. I feel really bad for what she is going through. They have no respect for women there.
yappnmutt
humping legs for liberty
01:25 PM on 04/20/2009
you have trouble reading, don't you?
02:26 PM on 04/20/2009
Worse? We're the ones who exonerate confirmed torturers and destroyed the tapes of the interrogation. Our prisoners don't get family visits, and even their lawyers and human rights organizations have been prevented from seeing many of them. Some of them have never been charged; those who have, the cases are rarely credible enough to stick.

James Baker once said, "You know you're know longer in power when your chauffeur speaks Farsi." I would add, "You know your country has fallen when Iran has better due process and prisoner treatment than the US."
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
donklinestiver
Country doctor for 48 yrs
08:49 PM on 04/20/2009
Those Americans with no legs and the dead ones from their shaped IED's civilized ??
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
mono
11:47 AM on 04/20/2009
My first question is "why did she go there". When her parents left the country for good what was for her to go there and dig old grave.

She should have watched the movie "NOT WITHOUT MY DAUGHTER"
12:07 PM on 04/20/2009
yeeeah why did she go there.....

FOX NEWS should have send clowns to do the job.... as usual...

BULL SH.T is the proper answer to your first question..
photo
DFL
Liberal and proud of it.
01:05 PM on 04/20/2009
Go rent the movie "midnight express" and see what foreign prisions can be like.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
01:33 PM on 04/20/2009
You may want to take a look at the statistics which cover your own prisons before you start down that road.
03:23 PM on 04/20/2009
Better than Gitmo
photo
brooklyncitizen
Quaerite primum regnum dei
11:42 AM on 04/20/2009
What a brave woman. Our MSM can learn a lot from real journalists such as Ms. Saberi.
11:05 AM on 04/20/2009
My Prayers go out to Roxana and her family.

I'm curious...Can she get mail from people out here in the U.S.?

I'd Love to write to her..

Torres17
11:30 AM on 04/20/2009
Evin is very known place! NOTORIOUS!

Lets just hope they don't touch her like they did with Zahra Kazemi the Iranian Canadian journalist!

They killed her there...
11:01 AM on 04/20/2009
"President Mahmoud Ahmadinejad asked the chief Tehran prosecutor to ensure she is allowed to offer a full defense in the appeal" but "Some analysts have said the mixed messages emerging from Iran may be an indication of political divisions in the leadership . . .." Maybe they're just playing "good cop/bad cop."
01:24 PM on 04/20/2009
Of course they are. Elections are coming up in June.
10:53 AM on 04/20/2009
She is not a spy! The 8 years sentence just tell you the truth about this conviction.
The sentence for spying in Iran is execution.

One bottle of wine means 20 lashes for girls 40 for boys. (Or maybe the reverse...??? )

No sir! The reason for Roxana's conviction is just an indication for a major POWER STRUGGLE deep inside Iranian leadership! Between those who want a deal with US and those who work against it!

(Actually this also means that the Obama's Iran politic is already working good) ( 7 years of axis of evil bla.. bla...didn't work and a simple new years message from Obama is working)

The 8 year sentence is also very symbolic and typical for Iranian way of thinking: The coming 8 Obama years! (They hope and try to keep her as an issue in all the Obama years!)

The other indication for the Power struggle in Iran is: Just 9 weeks to the presidential elections in Iran but the power holding conservatives are still without an official candidate. Not Ahmadinejad not anybody.. There hase been a new name in Iranian media every week. But as today no one officially is the conservative candidate for the 10th presidential election in Iran. While there are at least 2 reformist candidates out there.

Probably Mr. Ahamadinejads last chance for reelection would be a major deal withe the US.

And I think he knows that very well himself!
10:48 AM on 04/20/2009
Unfortunately the line between journalism and intelligence gathering is pretty gray. If the CIA has anything on the ball they would have tried to cultivate her, possibly under cover of a journalist job. Cut-out agencies are their stock-in-trade (remember Plame) Depending on how the Iranian law is written she probably could be guilty of espionage without even knowing it.
10:48 AM on 04/20/2009
I tell you what Iran. I am willing to hold my hand out to shake it. But if you want to smack Obama's hand away. Then damn you!!
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
LargeJ
10:47 AM on 04/20/2009
For some reason, I kind of believe that she is a spy. She was living there for six years as a "reporter" for various international news agencies....okay, two news agencies. Then again if she was actually a spy, would we have heard of any of this? It's not so cut and dry.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Jeffreygeez
11:33 AM on 04/20/2009
She cannot be a spy. She is a pretty female and American.Is that the logic?

If she was an ugly old man from Iran convicted of spying by the USA there would not be such uninformed rage about this guilty verdict. Are spies supposed to look like spies? Like all of you I have no idea if she is guilty or not. Than again we are not in Iran where they probably know more about this then we do.
11:46 AM on 04/20/2009
Obama is " confident " she's not involved in espionage.

That falls short of 100%
10:41 AM on 04/20/2009
Under the circumstances, is it really wise to have a picture of Ms. Saberi wearing shorts? I mean, she has as much right as anyone else in the U.S. to wear shorts, but this could affect her captors' view of her. Please exercise some caution here!
photo
HUFFPOST COMMUNITY MODERATOR
Quaoar
11:00 AM on 04/20/2009
She was Miss North Dakota in 1997 so it's likely that captors who can google have already seen swimsuit photos of her.
11:35 AM on 04/20/2009
But she has such nice stems!