More

Ashira: Orthodox Jewish All-Girl Rock Band Refuses To Play For Men

TARA TODRAS-WHITEHILL   05/28/09 12:27 PM ET   AP

Mideast Israel Music

RAMAT GAN, Israel — On a fog-filled stage, as the six women of the Ashira band rocked before their die-hard fans, a man entered the auditorium _ and was promptly asked to leave.

The band has been playing together for three years, and the crowds have grown steadily in numbers. But the band has held fast to one golden rule: No men are allowed.

The band's members are all Orthodox Jewish women, and guided by a rabbinical injunction that says it is immodest for a man to listen to a woman's voice in song, they perform only before other women.

The band's members say they are answering a dire need in the Orthodox Jewish community in Israel, where entertainment options for women are often limited. Orthodox communities sponsor activities like women's-only lectures, swims, dancing or traditional music, but modern day rock is a novelty.

"There's no other band that plays the way we play," Pnina Weintraub, the band's 24-year-old founder, said of Ashira's blend of rock, blues and Irish-style folk songs. "It isn't 'girls' music,' but it is an alternative that allows girls to perform in a kosher and proper way."

So Ashira has booked bars that lock out all men on nights they perform. Their Hebrew songs all revolve around biblical themes. Their forthcoming album will include a warning label against men opening the disc. Their business card says "with the help of God" in one corner and "for women only" on the other. They also decline to be videotaped because of the same religious modesty.

But Weintraub, who plays the violin for the sextet, says "the sky is the limit," and hopes to branch out to draw giant crowds of women.

She said the band represents a "new genre," and the chromosome-X crowd seems to appreciate it. By the end of their 90-minute gig at Bar-Ilan University, a religious-leaning university outside Tel Aviv, women in the audience were dancing, waving their arms over they heads and singing along to the words of the songs.

"Whoever invented rock did it for people to let loose," Weintraub said. "It's not just sex, drugs and rock 'n' roll. Our music is very liberating, and that is very important for our community."

The band also includes a lead singer, a drummer, a bassist, an electric guitarist and a flutist who is in her ninth month of pregnancy.

They are like the Dixie Chicks, with a major twist _ the three married members of Ashira have their heads covered for modesty's sake.

Ashira, Hebrew for "I will sing," has composed eight original songs and performs covers for other Israeli songs. They prayed before taking the stage before some 150 fans.

"It is a new thing, a new concept," said Navea Mashraki, a 29-year-old religious songwriter who came to Tuesday's concert. "What we, as religious girls, have to do is bring something new without breaking tradition."

The band insists it strictly abides by Jewish law, and has faced a surprised, but not disapproving, reaction from their strait-laced community.

"I would feel uncomfortable performing before men," said Inbar Presser, 22, the band's bassist. "I'm glad we can provide a venue for girls to come and sing and dance freely."

___

Associated Press correspondent Aron Heller contributed to this report.

FOLLOW HUFFPOST WORLD

RAMAT GAN, Israel — On a fog-filled stage, as the six women of the Ashira band rocked before their die-hard fans, a man entered the auditorium _ and was promptly asked to leave. The band has be...
RAMAT GAN, Israel — On a fog-filled stage, as the six women of the Ashira band rocked before their die-hard fans, a man entered the auditorium _ and was promptly asked to leave. The band has be...
Filed by Stuart Whatley  | 
 
 
  • Comments
  • 34
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Recency  | 
Popularity
Page: 1 2  Next ›  Last »  (2 total)
09:04 AM on 06/02/2009
Why is this international news alongside the fighting in Pakistan? I've said it before: a hundred international reporters are hanging around Jerusalem, waiting for the next war, and they've got to fill their story quotas. The girls can do whatever they want. But it's stupid that the article is placed next to serious international news, and strange that Israel is the focus of so much news media content that is really not particularly unique to Israel.
HUFFPOST COMMUNITY MODERATOR
JessWonderin
02:28 AM on 06/02/2009
I see a great possibility of a Saudi Tour . . . seems THAT country also practices religious extremism in treatment of the sexes, too . . . . "Rock Da Mosk" . . . can I order a tee shirt?
01:51 PM on 06/02/2009
The difference is that these women CHOOSE to play only before women, as they have the right to do---or not---in Israel, whereas in Saudi the state would make the decision for them.
06:12 PM on 06/02/2009
The distinction escapes me.
12:53 AM on 06/02/2009
Thank God we live in America with the separation of Church and State. Can you imagine a troupe like this trying to make it here?

Disgraceful. Keep them in that backward country.
06:56 PM on 06/04/2009
Backward? Israel is a very modern country. Along with many countries in the Middle East. Don't let stilted views that Americans tend to have get in the way of culture and technology.
12:50 AM on 06/02/2009
why are we men even allowed to know they exist? can we just seclude this sort of close-mindedness inside the closed minds and not bother anyone else with it?

and for crissakes, in a billion years, they'll NEVER be like the dixie chicks...
05:13 PM on 06/02/2009
As far as I can tell, "closed minded" is a synonym for "narrow-minded," which Oxford defines as "not willing to listen to or tolerate other people's views; prejudiced."

What view exactly have these women expressed an unwillingness to tolerate or listen to?

And how do you know that they're not like the Dixie Chicks? They could have very similar musical styles. (Probably very different fashions though.)
10:40 PM on 06/01/2009
just when you think religion cannot find another absurdity!
10:24 PM on 06/01/2009
Ugh. As a secular Jew I'm sick of the whole oppressive extreme crap that has generated from both sides of the Abrahamic family tree. Enough is enough people....get with modern times and stop being an embarrassment.
11:04 PM on 06/01/2009
Amen (no pun intended)
12:54 AM on 06/02/2009
Ditto.
photo
MorpheusXNYC
Web/graphic designer and former freelance writer
10:21 PM on 06/01/2009
Is anyone surprised? Religion = stupidity & intolerance.
10:18 PM on 06/01/2009
But I thought music was the universal language of love.
photo
SpaghettyIrish
ThereWereThoseWhoKnewOnlyTheSoundOfTheirOwnVoices.
09:23 PM on 06/01/2009
Wacky religious people are a bane the world over.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
09:15 PM on 06/01/2009
When rock comes down down to this...fundamentalist christian rock bands and orthodox religious people that exclude ....rock was about freedom, expression, breaking the rules, creating...and now this....sad, very sad...
02:30 AM on 06/02/2009
What is sad? These girls have fun.
08:49 PM on 06/01/2009
how about covering the Arab bands which not only will not perform for women, let alone touch them in public or allow them to show their faces or parts of their bodies?
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
08:41 PM on 06/01/2009
Seriously though, what objective criteria can be used to differentiate religious observance from complete insanity?
08:15 PM on 06/01/2009
Criticism by Israelis of Muslim cultural traditions:
Hypocritical.
12:03 PM on 06/02/2009
Israelis only criticize the violent Muslim cultural traditions.
01:49 PM on 06/02/2009
There is a big difference between a cultural tradition and a narrow religious law enforced by the power of the state. No hypocrisy in criticizing that.
08:04 PM on 06/01/2009
Weird.
photo
LMPE
I connect the most dissimilar things
07:42 PM on 06/01/2009
Hey Newt Gingrich. What do you think of this?