More

American Knox: A "Crescendo" Of Police Pressured Me To Accuse An Innocent Man

MARTA FALCONI   06/13/09 05:00 PM ET   AP

Amanda Knox

PERUGIA, Italy _ An American student who denies murdering her British roommate testified Saturday that she was shocked by the death of a woman she considered her friend, and said a "crescendo" of police pressure led her to accuse an innocent man.

Amanda Knox of Seattle had already told the court on Friday that she was not in the apartment she shared with Meredith Kercher on the night in 2007 when the British woman was slain.

Knox, 21, and Italian co-defendant Raffaele Sollecito, her ex-boyfriend, are accused of murder and sexual violence in the slaying of Kercher, who was found in a pool of blood Nov. 2, 2007 in the shared apartment in this central Italian town.

Knox took the stand for the first time Friday and said she spent the night of the killing at Sollecito's apartment. Prosecutors believe Knox, Sollecito and a third suspect convicted in a separate trial went to Kercher's home the night of the murder and killed the British woman in what began as a sex game.

Knox on Friday repeated accusations that she was beaten by police and confused when she was questioned in the days after the killing. Police have denied any misconduct.

She said it was the pressure that led her to accuse Diya "Patrick" Lumumba, a Congolese man who owns a pub in Perugia, of the killing. Lumumba was jailed briefly but was later cleared and is seeking defamation damages from Knox.

Police have denied any improper behavior, but Knox repeated her claim Saturday when questioned by lead prosecutor Giuliano Mignini.

"It was always a crescendo," she said recalling her early questioning sessions. "When I said I was with Raffaele all the time they told me I was a liar. I was scared, I thought: maybe they are right."

Knox said that interrogators "wanted a name" and that a policewoman hit her twice on the head.

"Do you remember? Do you remember? And then boom! On the head," Knox said, mimicking the slap in court. "I went: mamma mia! And then again, another boom!"

She said it was that pressure that made her come up with Lumumba's name and her initial story that she was at home during the murder and covered her ears against the victim's screams.

"It didn't hurt, but it frightened me," she said of the slaps.

When asked if she had suffered after Kercher's death, Knox said: "Yes. I was very shocked, I couldn't imagine something like that."

She said she considered Kercher "a friend." This contrasted with previous testimony by other witnesses that Kercher had complained about Knox's bathroom habits and had expressed surprise at her apparent promiscuity.

Knox said she felt sorrow over her roommate's death.

"I am very sorry for what happened, sometimes it seems to me it cannot be real," she said.

Knox answered questions confidently and in a steady voice for about five hours, sitting at the witness stand with a prison guard behind her. Though she had an interpreter next to her, the American spoke in fluent Italian, which she mostly learned in the year and a half she has spent in jail.

Prosecutor Mignini said he was satisfied with how Knox's testimony went, adding that he did not consider her credible.

Kercher family lawyer Francesco Maresca said the American was well prepared. "She answered quite satisfactorily, but didn't bring anything new," he said.

Later Saturday, Andrew Seliber, a friend of Knox and a fellow student at the University of Washington, also took the stand, called by the American's lawyers.

In Perugia, "she was having the happiest time of her life," Seliber said. "She worked three jobs responsibly so she had the money to come here."

Knox appeared moved when Seliber walked into the small, frescoed courtroom and she listened carefully to his testimony.

More of Knox's family members and friends are scheduled to take the stand in upcoming sessions. Her mother, Edda Mellas, will testify at the next hearing, Friday.

Knox and Sollecito have been jailed since shortly after the slaying. Sollecito, 25, has said he was at his own apartment the entire night of Nov. 1. He said he does not remember if Knox spent the whole night with him or just part of it. The two have said they could not remember events clearly because they had taken drugs.

Prosecutors allege Kercher came home after an evening with friends on Nov. 1, and soon after opened the door to Knox, Sollecito and Rudy Hermann Guede, who was convicted of murder last year and sentenced to 30 years in prison. Guede, who denies wrongdoing, was given a fast-track trial at his request.

According to the prosecutors, Sollecito held Kercher by the shoulders from behind while Knox touched her with the point of a knife. They say Guede, an Ivory Coast national, tried to sexually assault Kercher and then Knox fatally stabbed her in the throat.

Prosecutors maintain a kitchen knife found at Sollecito's apartment is compatible with Kercher's wounds, and has the Briton's DNA on the blade and Knox's on the handle.

The trial began in January and a verdict is expected after a summer break. Knox and Sollecito could face Italy's stiffest punishment, life imprisonment, if convicted of murder.

FOLLOW HUFFPOST WORLD

PERUGIA, Italy _ An American student who denies murdering her British roommate testified Saturday that she was shocked by the death of a woman she considered her friend, and said a "crescendo" of poli...
PERUGIA, Italy _ An American student who denies murdering her British roommate testified Saturday that she was shocked by the death of a woman she considered her friend, and said a "crescendo" of poli...
Filed by Hanna Ingber Win  | 
 
 
  • Comments
  • 79
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
Page: 1 2 3  Next ›  Last »  (3 total)
08:10 PM on 07/06/2009
The evidence presented at trial (Jan to June):

1. Amanda's DNA is on the handle of a knife. The victim's DNA is on the tip. The knife was not part of the cutlery at the cottage the two girls shared. It was found in the home of Amanda's boyfriend (a "collector" of knives).

2. The DNA of Amanda's boyfriend is on the clasp of the victim's blood-stained bra.

3. Amanda intentionally accused an innocent black man (her boss) in order to exculpate herself.

4. Amanda's boyfriend has repeatedly lied to police. He has changed his alibi 3 times and is now refusing to give Amanda an alibi.

A third suspect, co-accused Rudy Guede, has already been convicted in a separate trial. He, too, has repeatedly lied to police but is now claiming both Amanda & her boyfriend were at the murder scene.

Amanda's US lawyers & PR team initially told CBS News that Amanda had "never met Rudy Guede" and "didn't not know him." However, at trial it was revealed that Amanda had, in fact, not only been introduced to Rudy, but had gone on several 'nights on the town' with Rudy as part of a group.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
ashleelisbeth
06:51 PM on 06/14/2009
The Radar article from a few makes back was pretty interesting.
photo
goddessNdiva
Internet surfer extraordinaire.
03:48 PM on 06/14/2009
Guede, another African was convicted. Sure no racism.
06:53 AM on 06/14/2009
Just wondering.....what's the motive? And why do prosecutors think that Sollecito held Kercher while Knox stabbed her? Where did they get this scenario? I don't believe Guede has implicated them yet.

I'm not interested in the peripherals of this story, i.e. Foxy Knoxy, zealous judge etc.

I want the Who, What, When, Why, Where and How!!

Please offer some legitimate theories with "Just the facts, Maam."

Thanks in advance.
12:25 AM on 06/14/2009
I don't know if she is guilty or not but the blame the black man defense is nothing new to Americans, I highly doubt the Italians had to pressure her too hard on that one.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
11:34 PM on 06/13/2009
All the knives in my kitchen have my DNA on their handles, too.
07:48 PM on 07/06/2009
Do they also happen to have the DNA of a murder victim on the tips?

Are they also hidden in your boyfriend's apartment & washed down in bleach?

And did your boyfriend lie to police when asked why the victim's DNA is on a knife in his home - a home the victim had never seen?

(Amanda's boyfriend - of just SIX DAYS - told police that the victim, Meredith, had once visited his home wherein he "pricked" her while making a salad for her & Amanda, but Meredith had NEVER been to his home. He's caught. The fact that his DNA has been found on the bra clasp of poor Meredith's blood-stained bra has eliminated any 'reasonable' doubt.)
11:16 PM on 06/13/2009
Wow... I am just appalled at the vitriol here against that young woman. Honestly, people. It makes for a juicy and intriguing story, I suppose, so is that why people want her to be "pretty poison" as one person said here? Let's do a reality check. This looks like a crime that was committed during some sort of moles tation of the poor British woman. The man who was tried and convicted already was certainly the most likely perpetrator of the murder.
Some of the comments here assume that Amanda is a rational and mature adult. I would argue otherwise. And I certainly wouldn't maintain that I would have acted in the most mature way at that age and state of innocence. Amanda may be self-absorbed and immature (as most girls her age are - believe me, I am a college professor and deal with this age group constantly), but why oh why would anyone here even imagine she would have any reason to brutally stab her roommate? The Italian court system is notoriously chaotic. Let's presume she's innocent until proven guilty, even if the Italians see that the other way around.
You vitriolic folks here should keep Patsy Ramsay in mind, while you rail against Amanda. Wasn't she also tried and convicted in public opinion because it made for a tawdry and nasty story: Stage mom kills beauty queen toddler. Get a grip folks!
08:47 PM on 06/13/2009
Italy is DEEPLY CORRUPT. Justice is very questionable in Italy, especially it is run by a dictator and the Mafia.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
mrfreeze
A Disciple of Nietzsche
11:39 PM on 06/14/2009
Gee, and you're an expert in Italian law and the criminal justice system there? I doubt it.
12:11 AM on 06/15/2009
Corruption in italy is pretty much a fact of life. I saw a bus driver pay off a moto cop when I was at Rimini Beach area in the late 80's
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
bayarea000
07:47 PM on 06/13/2009
on cnn rick sanchez kept referring to her as an "american beauty". what the hell kind of reporting is that. we americans have some nerve to criticize other western governments on how they handle trials etc. until we clean up our act we should let THEIR system do its work. folks when you are in a foreign country you are subject to their laws.........end of discussion
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
07:39 PM on 06/13/2009
What I don't understand is why they think she had anything to do with the murder when they already tried a guy, found him guilty, and he didn't implicate her.

Having a loose lifestyle isn't enough to prosecute a person for murder over.
03:49 AM on 06/14/2009
Having a loose lifestyle isn't enough to prosecute a person but if that person is constantly changing her version of what happened that night and even implicates an innocent man, then that person begins to look suspicious.
photo
robXdion
Because someone has to say it.
12:34 PM on 06/14/2009
Maybe you should actually inform yourself on the case and stop relying on social stereotypes of all suspects involved.
07:30 PM on 06/13/2009
Anyone nicknamed "angelface", will get a better shake than a plain jane, in court.
06:58 PM on 06/13/2009
Don't know if she did this or not. How can we be sure, either way?

But I do know this is a street-smart girl, charming the media to her advantage.
I do know a beating could make a story change.
No interrogation will make you "unsure" of what really happened, weed smoking or not.

Lastly, anyone nicknamed "angelface", is more likely to be acquitted in a trial, than plain-jane.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
06:35 PM on 06/13/2009
She and her guy friend may have been on some LSD kind of drugs and murdered her without really knowing what they were doing.

In my town there was a guy leaving a party, totally zapped out on drugs. He saw a woman entering her apartment, followed her and butchered her.

They found him walking down the highway holding body parts. He was so high he did not know what was going on.

He had never even gotten a speeding ticket before that and now remains in jail forever.

Why does anyone do drugs?
06:30 PM on 06/13/2009
Liar Liar Pants on FIRE!
06:00 PM on 06/13/2009
Wow... I am just appalled at the vitriol here against that young woman. Honestly, people. It makes for a d@mn good and intriguing story so if people want her to be "pretty poison" as one person said here. Let's do a reality check. This looks like a sex crime. The man who was tried and convicted already perpetrated the murder. Amanda may be self-absorbed and immature (as most girls her age are - believe me, I am a college professor and deal with this age group constantly), but why oh why would anyone here even imagine she would have any reason to brutally stab her roommate? The Italian court system is notoriously chaotic. Let's presume she's innocent until proven guilty, even if the Italians see that the other way around.
You vitriolic folks here should keep Patsy Ramsay in mind, while you rail against Amanda. Wasn't she also tried and convicted in public opinion because it made for a tawdry and nasty story: Stage mom kills beauty queen toddler. Get a grip folks!
02:35 PM on 06/15/2009
She did it. She bought bleach to clean up the blood. Was found by police with the bucket and mop. She said she was in the apartment but held her ears so she couldn't hear the screaming. Changed her story, was inconsistent. She lied to the police -- many times.
01:18 AM on 06/16/2009
And you know that how????