More

Iran Uprising: Historic Parallels To Today's Protests

Huffington Post   First Posted: 07/17/09 06:12 AM ET Updated: 05/25/11 02:30 PM ET

Burma

The massive socio-political movement in Iran, following the highly controversial announcement Saturday declaring Mahmoud Ahmadinejad the victor of that state's presidential election, is reminiscent of a number of other such uprisings during the past few decades -- with some being notably more violent than others. However, it should be noted, the situation in Iran is by no means a "revolution" at this junction, and experts and pundits aplenty agree that such an appellation would be both premature and inappropriate. Nevertheless, a look back is merited, given the situational picture painted by images, video and reports that have made their way out of Iran thus far.

An especially violent historical parallel is Rhodesia's (now Zimbabwe) Second Chimurenga, that began in 1964 and lasted until 1979, which began as a civil disobedience movement, but escalated into civil war against the minority white colonial ruling faction. The eventual result was Zimbabwean independence, with Robert Mugabe taking power over the new Republic of Zimbabwe in 1980. Read more here.

Second Chimurenga

2009-06-16-Attrocity1.jpg


A more peaceful example is Portugal's 1974 Carnation Revolution, which saw thousands of civilian dissidents take to the streets to side with military insurgents in the country's two-year-long civil war. The eventual result was an almost bloodless coup whereby an authoritarian regime was supplanted by democracy. Read more here.

Carnation Revolution

2009-06-16-25abril.jpg


A very obvious parallel to Iran today is of course the Iranian Islamic Revolution of 1979, when demonstrators brought the country to a standstill and forced the US-backed Shah to flee. The result was that the monarchy was replaced with the current Islamic Republican system. Read more here.

Islamic Revolution

2009-06-16-Mass_demonstration.jpg


A popular uprising that saw far more bloodshed, however, is the 8888 Uprising in Burma (also known as Myanmar), when on August 8, 1988 student protesters joined with monks, doctors, housewives and even children in a call for democracy. The movement ended with the slaughter of thousands of protesters by the Tatmadaw (Burmese Armed Forces). This is also when opposition leader Aung San Suu Kyi, now on trial, entered politics. Read more here.

8888 Uprising

2009-06-16-8888_Uprising.jpg

Another uprising in Burma came in September 2007, when tens of thousands of monks marched through the streets of all major cities to demand political change and better living conditions. The movement, called the Saffron Revolution because of the monks' red robes, grew to include Burma's former student leaders called the '88 generation as well as a new generation of dissidents. The protesters used new media tools like cell phones and Google Chat to send information on their uprising to the international community. However, like in 1988, the army quickly sent in troops, killing dozens if not hundreds of protesters and arresting thousands.

Saffron Revolution

Perhaps the most well-known (despite government efforts) similar example, however, is China's Tiananmen Square protests of 1989. The protests saw upward of one million people -- many of whom were students and intellectuals -- gather in and around Tiananmen square following the death of pro-democracy, pro-capitalism opposition leader Hu Yaobang. The protests grew into a larger outcry against government corruption and ended in a massacre. Read more here.

Tiananmen Square Massacre

2009-06-16-tiananmen2.jpg


Less violent and also in 1989 was Czechoslovakia's Velvet Revolution against the ruling Communist party. Thousands of students took to the streets, only to be suppressed by armed police. Their suppression, consequently, led to even larger demonstrations and nationwide strikes, eventually forcing the Communist government to step down. Read more here.

Velvet Revolution

2009-06-16-_32620_praguedemo1.jpg


Similarly, what has become known by many as the Colour Revolutions took place in four countries and were characterized by mostly non-violent demonstrations in post-Communist Eurasia. They are: the Bulldozer Revolution in Serbia in 2000; the Rose Revolution in Georgia in 2003; the Orange Revolution in Ukraine in 2004; and the Tulip Revolution (also known as the Pink Revolution) in Kyrgyzstan in 2005.

Bulldozer Revolution

2009-06-16-610x.jpg

Rose Revolution

2009-06-16-roserevolution.jpg

Orange Revolution

2009-06-16-revolution.jpg

Tulip Revolution

2009-06-16-revolution.jpg


It should be stressed that no two "revolutions"/uprisings/mass demonstrations can ever be the same. However, reflecting Mark Twain's insight -- that, though history never repeats itself, it can sometimes rhyme -- there are often notable parallels. The Colour Revolutions shared a mostly nonviolent approach centered around a symbolic color (much as we are seeing now in Iran with Mousavi's "Green Wave"). And Tiananmen and Burma were begun by students and young intellectuals from the universities (also similar to the current Iranian demonstrations, though Iran expert Trita Parsi points out that it is far more heterogeneous than that which is assumed).

Historical examples cannot possibly tell us definitively what will happen in Iran as the demonstrations and consequential crackdowns continue. However, past mass movements to effect social and political change are surely serving as motivation and inspiration now, given the reformist mentality of Mousavi and his supporters. Only the coming days will tell us more.

What protests or uprising had an impact on you? Leave your ideas and reflections in the comments below.




Get HuffPost World On Facebook and Twitter!


FOLLOW HUFFPOST WORLD

The massive socio-political movement in Iran, following the highly controversial announcement Saturday declaring Mahmoud Ahmadinejad the victor of that state's presidential election, is reminiscent of...
The massive socio-political movement in Iran, following the highly controversial announcement Saturday declaring Mahmoud Ahmadinejad the victor of that state's presidential election, is reminiscent of...
 
 
  • Comments
  • 42
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
Page: 1 2  Next ›  Last »  (2 total)
photo
BlackWidowPilot
"Fu! Rin! Ka! Zan!"
05:03 PM on 06/17/2009
To the Iranian people:

"We hold these truths to be self-evident, that all men are created equal; that they are endowed by their Creator with inherent and inalienable rights; that among these, are life, liberty, and the pursuit of happiness; that to secure these rights, governments are instituted among men, deriving their just powers from the consent of the governed; that whenever any form of government becomes destructive of these ends, it is the right of the people to alter or abolish it, and to institute new government, laying its foundation on such principles, and organizing its powers in such form, as to them shall seem most likely to effect their safety and happiness."

--Declaration of Independence as originally written by Thomas Jefferson, 1776. ME 1:29, Papers 1:315

May God grant that you secure the Liberty that is your inalienable right!

Allah o'Akabar!

Leland R. Erickson

Citizen
03:28 PM on 06/17/2009
haha, no two can be the same but you used the same picture for both the Orange and Tulip Revolutions. I guess all Ukrainians and Kyrgyzstanians look alike to you?

lol.
02:37 PM on 06/17/2009
hmmm, wondering why you've left out the fraudulent US elections of 2000 and 2004! Why not put up some pictures or video footage of the MASSIVE protests after the 2000 election and on inauguration day in 2001!!!! The US media is a joke!
02:11 PM on 06/17/2009
I enjoy a historical perspective on current events. However, I am surprised one of the most important revolutions in modern times is not listed. The revolution in Poland that started in a shipyard and led to the collapse of communist rule in the 80s. Lec Walesa, its leader was hailed for his courage and leadership in beating what was perceived as an unbeatable foe, the Soviet Union. All this without war.
01:48 PM on 06/17/2009
Barack Obama is "compelled to speak out" on Iran.

But when Israel broke the cease fire with HAMAS on the very day Obama was elected President and set about pouring flaming white phosphorus on Gazan children, where was Obama's concern then?

Why did he stay so silent while innocent people died?

and frankly, I think it is insulting that so many American warhawks who today weep for Iran's democratic process only months ago were ready to drop bombs on them all and think you are too stupid to see the switcheroo!
01:30 PM on 06/17/2009
No mention of Berlin '89?
01:16 PM on 06/17/2009
Just to add a revolution, today is the anniversary of the June 17 1953 Berlin uprising against the increased worker quotas. The protest was put down. West Germans did little more than watch and give candy to the East Berliners who were brutally treated. Ironically as a result, June 17th became a holiday, "German Unity Day" and remained so until the country was reunited at which time the holiday was moved to October, anniversary of the reunification
12:43 PM on 06/17/2009
We'll have to see how it turns out
But I have a feeling by the end it will resemble the 2002 Failed coup attempt in Venezuela more than any of the events you are comparing it to
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
12:31 PM on 06/17/2009
Please don't mention May 1970,the tanks I imagine they sent to my town are a result of communist brainwashing,

thanks
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Rolf618
They call me Mr. Fahrenheit.
12:18 PM on 06/17/2009
What about Romania 1989?
Week long street demonstrations that started with the arrest of a dissident and ended with the complete overthrow of the government and the execution of dictator Nicolae Ceausescu and his wife.

Not that I hope that happens, but there are some similarities. Especially that the origins of the protests began with a very specific and relatively minor complaint and grew to an unstoppable wave.
12:04 PM on 06/17/2009
http://www.opendemocracy.net/globalization-institutions_government/colour_revolutions_3196.jsp

An essay on the history of color revolutions . . . Interesting who funds and coordinates them.
photo
Margaret Motheral
Cassandra Complex
10:52 AM on 06/17/2009
In Response to Twitter's

Spankymike0910: Wondering why no one in the U.S. is talking about supporting the uprising in Iran regardless of what this current administration says.

I'm supporting by using Twitter , etc to say " Stay Safe" "We want the best for you. " We want you to have freedom and peace." " I pray for you." The Iranians I get through to, appreciate it. They appreciate being seen as human beings. Often they don't know what the rest of the world is thinking and they are scared. One is sending me the lyrics to their song which I will post and blog when it comes through. I'm encouraging reduction of violence yet sympathetic to peace, freedom, human rights and appeal to the common ground in all of us. We all share the same planet and technology gives all of us the ability to be ambassadors and reach out to others. But this is a delicate situation and Obama's lead in supporting the ideals of freedom and human rights is good. So instead of asking WHY- just reach out and make friends with one Iranian who is wants the same thing we all want. Peace, Rights, respect, Food, Safety, Love. We can ALL share in creating Peace and create Common Ground. Just do it, don't ask why someone else isn't.
photo
CigarGod
What is your process?
09:48 AM on 06/17/2009
The 1991 coup attempt in Russia was while Yeltsin was in power, not Gorbechev...I believe.
photo
HUFFPOST COMMUNITY MODERATOR
messy
artist, writer, adventurer
12:04 PM on 06/17/2009
Actually, BOTH were in power. The Soviet Union didn't collapse until December of that year. Russia was then just another "Soviet Socialist" Republic.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
09:46 AM on 06/17/2009
I predict revolutions will occur more frequently in this century, and dictatorships had better heed the message. Communication via the Internet is difficult to stop. What brought the Iron Curtain down was that East Germans could see they were living like dogs compared to the West Germans. Communication has evolved in a huge way since the age of cable tv.

But in the end, any meaningful change has to come from a country's own citizens, not wth outside interference. Look at all the examples above, and add People Power in the Philippines as well.
09:45 AM on 06/17/2009
"It should be stressed that no two "revolutions"/uprisings/mass demonstrations can ever be the same."
Weeell... the Tulip Revolution and the Orange Revolution look pretty the same to me...

Seriously, correct the Tulip Revolution's picture in the article ;o)