Continental Pilot Dies During Flight

ADAM GOLDMAN and VICTOR EPSTEIN   06/18/09 09:08 PM ET   AP

Continental

NEWARK, N.J. — The only inkling passengers had that something was wrong on the Continental Airlines flight over the Atlantic Ocean was when an announcement came over the loudspeaker asking if there was a doctor on board.

Otherwise, flight attendants continued to serve snacks. Passengers read magazines and watched movies. And the flight kept on its schedule.

But in the cockpit, the 60-year-old captain had died of a suspected heart attack and two co-pilots took over the controls. The 247 passengers aboard did not learn what had happened until the flight from Brussels landed safely Thursday and was met by fire trucks, emergency vehicles and dozens of reporters.

"I was shocked," said Dora Dekeyser of Houston. "Nobody knew anything."

"We weren't panicking. I never thought it was something as serious as this. We were relaxed," said Dekeyser's granddaughter, Stephanie Mallis, 18, of Lansdale, Pa.

After the crew of the Boeing 777 asked if there were any doctors aboard, several passengers approached the cockpit, including a doctor who said the pilot appeared to have suffered a heart attack.

Dr. Julien Struyven, 72, a cardiologist and radiologist from Brussels, examined the pilot in the cockpit and tried to revive him using a defibrillator. But it was too late.

"He was not alive," Struyven said. There was "no chance at all" of saving him.

The dead pilot was based in Newark and had worked for Continental for 32 years, the airline said. Continental did not release the name of the pilot. A source speaking on condition of anonymity because he was not authorized to release the information identified him as Craig Lenell.

Tom Donaldson, a former leader of the Continental pilots' union who currently flies Boeing 767 jets for the airline, said pilots must pass an extensive physical every six months to remain qualified to fly. The exam includes an electrocardiogram, blood pressure check and a vision test.

For long routes such as trans-Atlantic flights, a third pilot is aboard to permit the captain or first officer to take rest breaks.

Donaldson said there is no specific training on how to react if a crew member becomes incapacitated, but any one of the three pilots is fully qualified to operate the jet.

"Clearly you want another set of eyes watching when you're going down a checklist, but you're capable of flying the airplane yourself," he said. "You can put the gears down, put the flaps down and carry out your other duties by yourself in an emergency."

Air France pilot Hugues Duval, 29, said his co-pilot training included an exercise in which he had to take off and land without a captain.

"It's not a drama. If the captain is ill or incapacitated, you make sure he isn't blocking any controls or the wheel," Duval said in Le Bourget, France, where he was attending the Paris Air Show.

"After you ask for priority to land, you can also ask in the cabin if there is another pilot on board. In case you need help reading the checklist or taking the radio. I did it in a simulator," said Duval, who flies the Boeing 777 but was at the air show to do stunt flying.

On Thursday's flight, Martha Love of Greenwich, N.J., was sitting in the first row of the plane. She said passengers were not told what was going on.

"No one knew," she said. She only became concerned after the plane landed, when she saw emergency vehicles lined up along the runway.

Simon Shapiro, a passenger from the Brooklyn region of New York City, was also unaware. "I didn't hear anything or see anything," Shapiro said. "I was wondering why there were so many cops."

Passenger Kathleen Ledger, 45, of Bethlehem, Pa., said she learned about what happened when her cell phone rang after landing.

"My husband called me and told me," she said.

She was impressed with the way the flight crew handled themselves and did not think passengers needed to be informed of the death during the flight.

"They did an incredible job," she said. "I would have done the exact same thing."

In 2007, another Continental pilot died at the controls after becoming ill during a flight from Houston to Puerto Vallarta, Mexico. It landed safely with a co-pilot at the controls after being diverted to McAllen, Texas.

___

Associated Press writers Beth DeFalco in Trenton, N.J., David Koenig in Dallas, and Greg Keller in Paris contributed to this report.

FOLLOW HUFFPOST NEW YORK

Filed by Nicholas Sabloff  | 
 
 
  • Comments
  • 175
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
Page: 1 2 3 4 5  Next ›  Last »  (6 total)
02:40 AM on 06/19/2009
This airline incident showed up as a daily new twitter topic at 8:29am PST on my web2express.org digest site. Something is amazing if you compare the time carefully. It emerged as hot topic on twitter while the flight was still in the air. Where did the tweets come from so early? Did someone tweet in the airplane? or people on the ground in Europe got the information early and tweet? Anyway, news travels on twitter fast, very fast!

While this news event was caught early by web2express.org, it was not on other trending applications including twitter search trending topics, google trends, yahoo buzz. A good study case for how twitter is breaking news early.

aj chen
09:38 PM on 06/18/2009
It's a hard life when you cant get enough sleep, yes it would be fun to lay over in exotic foreign cities but you are forcing yourself to sleep when your body is used to staying up.
photo
LMPE
I connect the most dissimilar things
09:37 PM on 06/18/2009
Somehow it seems like I've always been on board the boring flights!
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
isis
I, Robot
08:06 PM on 06/18/2009
"pilots must pass an extensive physical every six months to remain qualified to fly. The exam includes an electrocardiogram, blood pressure check and a vision test."

It's freaky that he has recently had a check up and nothing was noticed. You have to wonder if he had some symptoms but ignored them because he's just had a check up.
10:30 PM on 06/18/2009
Where do you come from? People go to doctors all the time and have great checkup then drop dead. The only question is when will the lawyers begin hounding the family to find someone to sue. When it's you're time to go-that's it. We just don't know when it will be.

What surprised me about so many of these posts is that very few even felt the need to offer sympathy to the family. The pilot died and I'm sure his family is hit very hard with this news. The snickers, jokes are in poor taste and disrespectful. American show some class, at least be mindful this was a person who many people loved is no longer with them. My sympathy to his family and friends.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
mudshark12
Now who are you jiving with that cosmik debris?
01:41 PM on 06/20/2009
I agree, we could use more class (and empathy) here in America. I think we have become callous and indifferent perhaps due to all of the death and violence shown on TV, not forgetting to mention bad news. My condolences to the pilots family during their time of grief.
06:46 PM on 06/18/2009
I'm just trying to figure out why a commercial airline pilot's death is a front page story while the fact that NASA just launched two spacecraft to the moon apparently isn't newsworthy.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Javida
09:44 PM on 06/18/2009
They're both newsworth. Please don't diminish or disrespect the life of this pilot or anyone. Would you appreciate someone saying this about your loved one?
05:34 PM on 06/18/2009
I have read in the last 15 some of the most ignorant comments...First of all, the three pilots in that cocpit are ALL QUALIFIED to fly the B-777 (known as the triple 7). They are trained exactly the same way. Twice a year they go to ground school one day and then they are in the simulator ALL DAY on day two. The pilots go through every possible emergency that there is..The captain flies for half of the day (as the captain) and then the first officer flies (as the captain) for the rest of the day. The third pilot on that plane is known as the IRO (International Relief Officer) and his position is just as important as the captains. Maybe even more. This is an example because of this situation.

The difference in the captain and first officer is seniority. Does the public thik that after Pan Am, Braniff and Eastern no longer existed that the pilots just flew into the sunset? Those pilots went to other airlines...They may only have 20-25 years with their current airline but they could have 35 years (total) of flying experience because of working for another airline or flying in the military....


So before making statements such as 'I am not going to fly international' is so absured...I would also like to thank those who wrote condolances to Captain Lennell's family.
photo
rbenjamin
Rule 5 rules
06:54 PM on 06/18/2009
Right you are, everything worked as it was supposed to under the circumstances, which while tragic, were an anticipated risk of commercial flight.
08:05 PM on 06/18/2009
I work for the airlines on the ground for years and last time I checked pilots were human beings and not immortal so of coarse this will happen from time to time that is why there is always at least two pilots. Its amazing to me how people zone in on any little hickup in the air and pay no attention to the fact that hundreds of thousands die on the roads every day.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Riley Pacheco
Huge Nerd, Former Soldier, Libertarian, Seattle Ar
05:03 PM on 06/18/2009
I find the decision to not tell the passengers about the pilots death to be the only way to go. Years ago, when Seattle had the earthquake, I had family on a flight to Hawaii and the crew did not inform any of the passengers until they landed. Another wise decision.
photo
MajorKong
If the pilot's good, see, I mean if he's reeeally
04:45 PM on 06/18/2009
I fear we'll see more of this. They recently raised the retirement age for pilots to 65.
05:39 PM on 06/18/2009
Why do you think that? There are people in the 20's 30's and 40's that have heart attacks. I don't think that a heart attack discriminates.....it can happen no matter what age, race or gender...
photo
MajorKong
If the pilot's good, see, I mean if he's reeeally
06:47 PM on 06/18/2009
Ask any insurance company actuary. The older you get statistically you have a greater chance for this sort of thing.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
tonewheel
Vote early...and often.
04:25 PM on 06/18/2009
Those required tests and physicals are a good start, but....

I'm 54, and heart problems run in my family. Lost my Dad at 66, my oldest brother had quad bypass at 46, grandparents, everyone has "unfriendly hearts". Because of that, I've had an annual physical with EKG and stress test since I was 45. Every other year it was a nuclear stress test. And every year I was given a clean bill of health. September of 2005, I had chest tightness while exercising...4 days after the "clean" results of my nuclear stress test. I had 95% blocked mid-circumflex artery, which my Cardiologist stented.

The only definitive test to determine if an artery is blocked is an angiogram, which is not done as a routine examination.

They do the best they can, but this can strike at any time.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
rucognizant
05:51 PM on 06/18/2009
WIth a family history like yours I would hope you would opt for another career than pilot!
photo
AnalyzeIT
Full spectrum - attacks facing society - PREPARE!
04:23 PM on 06/18/2009
Condolences to family and friend.......................RIP peace sir..................................
04:01 PM on 06/18/2009
Perhaps the pilot died doing what he loved, fly airplanes...
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
OkieIntellectual
Sooo tired of all the irrational idiots in the wor
03:35 PM on 06/18/2009
I wonder how long it will be before some money-grubbing jerk tries to sue the airline for "mental distress" or something, for not letting the passengers know why there were all the emergency vehicles and such waiting for them on landing.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
ChuckWhite
03:34 PM on 06/18/2009
My wife is Dutch. Her brother-in-law is a petroleum engineer.

A few years back, my wife's sister and her three children, plus her mother, came to visit from The Netherlands to stay with us in Florida. Her brother-in-law flew into the Orlando airport and met us within 1/2 hour of the arrival of the others.

During the visit, we used airlines, autos, boats and trains. I calculated the total mileage logged by all eight of us. Over a period of four weeks, the group racked up something like 250,000 miles of travel (counting each individual trip) using four different methods of travel. In the end, everyone got home safely with no significant "glitches".

Sometimes, we should understand that we only hear about the exceptions.

The "norm" for travel is impressive enough to deserve kudos for everyone involved, government, airlines, traffic safety, road construction, and even tourist attraction planners.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
annis
06:04 PM on 06/18/2009
What a nice post! Thanks!
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
TN60
I Hope You'll Dance
03:28 PM on 06/18/2009
What do they mean a "relief pilot" was on board. I thought those international flights had a capable co-pilot and an engineer in the cockpit who were capable of flying and landing...Traveling internationally will never be the same for me !
03:36 PM on 06/18/2009
Depends on the length of the flight and how many hours the pilots have logged for the month; they aren't allowed to go over 60 hours/month in the US. You should actually feel safer b/c of the use of relief pilots. Wouldn't you rather have a well-rested pilot for the second half of the flight than a fatigued one?
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
03:39 PM on 06/18/2009
They normaly have a pilot resting whilst the Captain and the co-pilot are at controls.
photo
PatA
Pink is a 4 letter word
03:12 PM on 06/18/2009
It is disturbing to find some of the rude and uncaring comments here. I guess I'll never get used to it.
Karma, folks...it will come back to you.

My sympathy to the family and friends.
photo
FZliveson
Beating the Conundrum
06:28 PM on 06/18/2009
PatA--- you're tweaked. On the one hand you come across all "flowers and Kumbaya" and on the other you are sneering down your nose, pretending to be superior.
Lead people to where you are and where you are going. Nobody's going to feel guilty or be transformed by a nasty context.
Thanks