|
||
Haaretz:
European diplomatic sources said Thursday that kidnapped Israel Defense Forces soldier Gilad Shalit will be transferred to Egypt in the coming hours or coming days.
Gilad shalit - Related stories from Haaretz.com
Israel rejects report Shalit about to be moved to Egypt - Haaretz ...
Egypt News - France asks Syria to help free Gilad Shalit
Gilad Shalit - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
Israel denies Shalit will move to Egypt - UPI.com
Ma an: Gilad Shalit to be Transferred to Egypt - News Briefs ...
FOXNews.com - Egyptian President: Deal for Israeli Soldier Gilad ...
Want to reply to a comment? Hint: Click "Reply" at the bottom of the comment; after being approved your comment will appear directly underneath the comment you replied to
Now Izzie will have to find a new PR reason to commit atrocities against the Pals.
It is not important whether you call it kidnapping, or captured. What is important is that he was not given red cross visits . They didn't allow any contact for the parents to know that or if he was alive. He was in uniform and if he is to be considered a POW , and should be accorded by the rules of the Geneva convention. before any of you say it otherwise, the gitmo prisoners are terrorists not wearing uniforms so that they can be recognized as soldiers. So they should not be treated as such
Are Israeli political prisoners given visits from the Red Cross / Red Crescent?
Doubt it.
Yes.
http://www.haaretz.com/hasen/spages/1095791.html
While I'm not arguing that Israeli treatment of Palestinian prisoners is just or fair, they do get access to the red cross.
It is my understanding that the "Red Crescent", more or less a ME version of the Red Cross has had access to him.
It's a catch 22, isn't it?
How do you fight a guerilla war...while in uniform. Not very reasonable, is it?
Made worse by having the invading powers label your defense of your country..as terrorism.
It was my understanding that he didnt. That is why no one knew for sure if he was alive
All of those conditions are implemented on Palestinian prisoners as well, including children under the age of 16.
The IDF breaks the Geneva concentions every day, and they certainly dont have the moral high ground dictating prisoner welfare.
['The Palestinians in the Occupied Territories live under a Pinochet-like regime. They can and do disappear in the middle of the night. They are blindfolded, cuffed, beaten, humiliated, taken to unknown locations with no information given to them or their families, tortured physically and psychologically and incarcerated indefinitely, often without charges and regardless of whether they are guilty of anything. It is arbitrary and it can happen to anyone.']
http://peoplesgeography.com/2007/07/14/avigail-abarbanel-on-the-israeli-police-state/,
Israel holds 700 child prisoners aged 12-17 in Israel jails. Their treatment of them is illegal.
http://www.dci-pal.org/english/display.cfm?DocId=1162&CategoryId=1,
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=FMb1Ye3qpWE&feature=related,
I went to your links. they were intotal a bunch of lies. And you repeat that garbage as if it were true. It goes to show , people will belive what they want to.
"the gitmo prisoners are terrorists "
What's the proof? Were they tried and convicted. Why were so many of them released after years of tortured? It has been proven that most of them are innocent. The Uyghurs is one such example.
All of the Palestinian in Israeli jails are political-prisoners for resisting the illegal occupation. The are NOT Terrorists. Resisting the occupation is legal under the international law.
All the hot air about this guy. I can well understand that his parents and friends and people who know him well would want for him to come home; that's only to be expected. But the rest of the world jumping on this bandwagon it's just like when Princess DI got killed with all that frantic and unseemly hysteria by people who didn't know her.
It just goes to show how people can be manipulated especially when they can't think for themselves and are gullible with it. This guy was a soldier; Palestine is under occupation; international law and the Geneva conventions state quite explicitly that occupied people have a right to resist and expel the occupiers. He was captured, and as such is a POW until hostilities are over or the combatants decide to strike a mutual deal.
And considering that Israel has over 11000 Palestinian uncharged, untried and unconvicted prisoners in their own Guantanamo Bay several of them underage children, women and elected Palestinian MPs, isn't it a bit of a nerve the west which has colluded in torture and renditions getting up on their sanctimonious high horse? Or is one to conclude that some people and their blood are worth more than others?
Professor Dr. Stanley Collymore.
Israel has a better marketing and publicity department?
Yeah! The United States based media.
Please stop saying he was kidnapped. For the umpteenth time, this soldier is a prisoner.
Thank you!!!
He was not in a mission, he was not in the territories, he was at his home base. If you are to assume now that Israeli soldiers taken from Israel are war prisoners, you are stating that there is in fact a war not a conflict. If that's the case, the claims of the Palestinians about opening the crossings for allowing people and goods are invalid. Blocades and embargos are valid options in a war, correct?
He was occupying Palestine illegally.
Israel insists it's a war. How many "war zones" have they declared in the West Bank? Didn't they declare all those mosques, hospitals and apartment buildings in Gaza to be "military targets?" Israel is certainly talking and behaving as if this is a full scale war.
He was in full uniform as part of a live operations tank unit.
Soldiers are captured, not kidnapped. Unless he was a little boy. But then why was he playing at being a soldier?
Because military service is compulsory in Israel.
to confidance government
Military service is compulsory in Israel for little boys?
I hope Gilad can be a strong force for peace. Perhaps he will have a more balanced possibly pro -Palestinian stance on this issue.
I am glad he is still alive and that he will be reunited with his family soon.
Finally, some good news. Hamas and Hezbollah may see the writing on the wall as to this President meaning business and their friend and financial supporter, the Ayatollahs and crazy President of Iran, are going to go down.
Count your days, babe!
Not bloody likely, Mate.
325 million sympathetic Arabs on the planet...and the Iranians are not evem part of that group.
The group they are part of is 1 billion Muslims.
I hope this man and his family, along with the Israeli people, have to suffer no more. Come home Gilad!
I hope the Palestinians don't have to suffer any more either. May both sides live in peace.
Until Palestine is free, no ones wishes will come true.
there is no such thing as Palestine. it was only a region, colonized by Turks and Brits. Israel will always exist.
I guess noone's wishes will EVER come true!!
Then..noone's wishes will come true!
They suffer least who suffer what they choose...
What the original article fails to mention that it was Shalit's kidnapping that ignited the (ultimately pointless) retaliatory bombings on Lebanon in 2006 (with Israel and Hezbollah both declaring victory.) I had always wondered what had happened to the person in the center of all of that, and I'm glad to hear he's still alive and will be reunited with his family.
Wrong.
The abductions on the Lebanon border was a separate incident.
Nevertheless, there are lots of recriminations by the Israelis against Gaza on account of Shalit. Just yesterday UN supply trucks were blocked from entering Gaza by fanatic Israelis who want to block all aid as long as he is a captive.
Schalit wasn't kidnapped in Lebanon he was kidnapped in Gaza. What happened in Lebananon was first; Hizbullah killed three soldiers. Second; they kidnapped the dead bodies. Third; Led Israel to believe they were still alive. Fourth; Would not return the bodies. Fifth; war. Sixth; Israel pulls our because US asked them to. Seventh:; Bodies returned after long period. Hizbullah is just as guilty as Hamas.
Schalit wasn't kidnapped, period. He was an active duty solder so his capture makes him a prisoner. If you're willing to lie about that, then why should we take the rest of your post seriously?
If you have any military experience, you know soldiers are never kidnapped, they are taken prisoner.
Wrong. Those were 2 different soldiers and a prisoner exchange was made with Israel long ago for those 2 soldiers.
Actually there was an exchange for the soldiers dead bodies. Which Hizbullah kidnapped. They have no honor for the dead.
So what is the exchange ratio?
Soldiers don't get kidnapped. They get captured.
Grown up!
Hopefully, this will be a good step.
This is good news
Prisoner exchanges are usually good
Although I believe the proper word would be arrested, not kidnapped. Unless we are going to start calling people in Israeli prisons kidnapping victims
Gilad was not arrested. He was not even accused of committing a crime. His innocence is not in dispute. He indeed was kidnapped, and Hamas is demanding a ransom for him. Perhaps Israel too readily arrests suspected "terrorists" and holds them without trial and due process. But the two situations are neither moral nor legal equivalents.
Soldiers who are on active duty who are captured are PRISONERS, not kidnap victims.
Seriously, how blatant must Israeli exceptionalism be?
He was not arrested. Gilad was just a soldier doing his Job. The Palestinians that Hamas wants out of Israeli prisons are not innocent prisoners, they are suicide bombing planners, high-level Hamas leaders and Terrorists. They are not for a noble cause of having Israelis release all innocent prisoners. Israel has made many concessions but Hamas has done nothing but shoot rockets at them.
Until they have had a fair trial...they are none of the things you say they are.
So, the women and children they are demanding be released engaged in acts of terrorism?
He wasn't arrested, they crossed the border to take him.
It was kidnapping.
He was a soldier. He was captured.
I believe the common terminology for when soldiers are captured while they are on duty is POW: Prisoners of War. Abducted civilians are kidnapped. Get it straight.
Or call them political prisoners.
And of course, not reported by the Western press was the kidnapping of the two brothers by Israel forces the previousd day. (inside Gaza )
Finally, some good news. I hope the young man is reunited with his family soon. And, I truly hope for resolution and agreement between the Palestinians and the Israelis toward a peaceful coexistence.
How about releasing some 400 Palestinian children under the age of twelve from Israeli prisons.
How about demolishing with fury these despicable institutions of torture especially built for children.
There are no 400 Palestinian children under 12 in Israeli prisons. Nice try.
As Golda Meir said, "there will never be peace until Muslims learn to love their children"Using them as shields and suicide bombers speaks for itself.
Believing all the lies that Hamas is telling you agian?
The "children" in dispute aren't little kids like you think they are they are young adults. 16-19. Quit trying to paint Israel has a ruthless regime. Israel doesn't use its citizens for cannon fodder like Hamas does.
|
||
Loading comments…
Posted: 06-25-09 02:38 PM