EDITION: U.S.
 
CONNECT    

Caster Semenya, South Africa Runner In Gender Controversy, To Receive Big Welcome

DONNA BRYSON   08/24/09 11:19 AM ET   AP

Caster Semenya

JOHANNESBURG — South African runner Caster Semenya, who is undergoing gender testing after questions arose about her muscular build and deep voice, returns home Tuesday to celebrations after her 800-meter win at the world championships.

South Africans have rallied behind the 18-year-old, who is not accused of trying to cheat but of perhaps unknowingly having a medical condition that blurs her gender and gives her an unfair advantage over other female runners.

The governing African National Congress party, unions and other groups were urging their members to come to the airport Tuesday morning to greet Semenya at a rally.

"I'll be there," Semenya's father, Jacob, told The Associated Press Monday. He said his daughter would then return to university in Pretoria.

Jacob Semenya said it was not clear when his daughter would visit the family's village in northern South Africa. But Sammy Molofo, an ANC Youth League leader in the area where the runner grew up, said a weekend homecoming celebration was being planned there.

President Jacob Zuma was to meet Semenya and the two other South African medalists, men's 800-meter champion Mbulaeni Mulaudzi and men's long jump runner-up Kgotso Mokoena at the presidential guest house in Pretoria. According to a statement from his office Monday, Zuma wants "to congratulate them on their sterling performance in Berlin."

COSATU, the country's main trade union federation, said Tuesday's welcome would be for the whole team, but "especially Caster, who has been the victim of such a despicable campaign by international athletics officials to discredit her magnificent achievement by maliciously raising unfounded questions about her gender."

Semenya's family and friends say there is no doubt she is a woman. But it is not always easy to get a clear-cut answer from scientists on the question in some cases.

The IAAF, track and field's governing body, will decide Semenya's case according to whether her "conditions ... accord no advantage over other females" after consulting a gynecologist, an endocrinologist, a psychologist, an internal medicine specialist and a gender expert. Her genes and physiology as well as how she sees herself and how she is seen by her community could play a role in their determination.

South Africans have been outraged not just that questions have been raised, but that they have been made public.

On Sunday, Lamine Diack, the IAAF president, said the affair was handled badly.

"I deeply regret that confidentiality was breached in this case and that the IAAF were forced into a position of having to confirm that gender testing was being carried out on this young athlete," Diack told reporters in Berlin. "It is a regrettable matter and I have requested an internal inquiry to ensure that procedures are tightened up and this never happens again."

___

Associated Press Writer Nqobile Ntashangase in Johannesburg contributed to this report.

FOLLOW HUFFPOST WORLD

JOHANNESBURG — South African runner Caster Semenya, who is undergoing gender testing after questions arose about her muscular build and deep voice, returns home Tuesday to celebrations after her...
JOHANNESBURG — South African runner Caster Semenya, who is undergoing gender testing after questions arose about her muscular build and deep voice, returns home Tuesday to celebrations after her...
Filed by Hanna Ingber Win  | 
 
  • Comments
  • 49
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
Page: 1 2  Next ›  Last »  (2 total)
04:07 PM on 09/11/2009
I think the situation Caster has been placed in is both horrific and beyond comprehens­ion.
I encourage all to blog IAAF on their website.
I suggested to IAAF that they administer gender testing to all participan­ts pre-game, so that no discrimina­tion accusation­s could arise. I also noted that the end result for both organizati­on and entrant would allow an intact integrity.
03:25 PM on 08/25/2009
I agree with you Astell whol heartily. We are in the year of 2009 you would think that this issue would be dead and buried. Let go forward with a positive attitude and not stay in the past.
09:48 AM on 08/25/2009
Leave her alone. She's doing far better than a lot of you slugs.
06:39 AM on 08/25/2009
I think it is unfortunat­e that our humanity has not yet developed into the consciousn­ess of love and acceptance but rather displays this degree of intoleranc­e. This rhetoric of indifferen­ce exposes our need for a paradigm shift in our awareness. It is dirty and shameful that in this new millennium­, with all the technologi­cal advancemen­ts, we are evidently primitive in our thinking. If it is true that as a man thinks, so is he, then we are still wallowing in an archaic era of perception­. Just imagine that chauvinism and stereotypi­ng is the norm rather than the exception. On behalf of a higher state of consciousn­ess and as a citizen of the Kingdom of God, I apologize to Caster Semenya and her family. This is indeed a bitter sweet victory. What is most disturbing is that here in South Africa, the month of August honours women.
06:31 AM on 08/25/2009
I think it is unfortunat­e that our humanity has not yet developed into the consciousn­ess of love and acceptance but rather displays this degree of intoleranc­e. I dedicate my poem for women's month to Ms Semenya

Woman
God’s generosity to man
You are divinity
The essence of our humanity
Your emotional intelligen­ce is superior
And your threshold for pain is inconceiva­bly greater
Chosen as the vessel that transports life from eternity into time
You possess the wisdom to reason and the sense to make up your mind
The magnificen­ce of your beauty bewilders me
For I am your sunshine and your shadow simultaneo­usly
You are my weakness as much as you empower me
Even for my bondages you possess the key
Your love liberates me as it imprisons my attention
Because of you I experience ecstasy in a realm without dimension
I am enlightene­d by the lessons of your sensitivit­y
And humbled by the sacredness of your sensuality
Your elegance intoxicate­s
Your splendour motivates
I am enslaved by your grace and finesse
And seduced by your gentle caress
Your charm mystifies me with enchantmen­t
Rendering me helpless with endless wonderment
Your sophistica­tion captivates
It enthralls, it fascinates
I am blessed with eyes to behold your radiance
My heart pulses acceptance
You are kind, caring and forgiving
Gentle, loving and understand­ing
This is a tribute to your femininity
It praises your strength, your essence, your divinity
Woman thou art Wonderful Opulent Magnificen­t Anointed Nurturing
02:21 AM on 08/25/2009
I'm glad she is being celebrated at home and I hope she is has a long successful sports career.Alt­hough I am not apposed to the testing,I think it was wrong to publically humiliate her and she is NOT a freak.I do wonder if she would do well racing against men.What if she was as good as them>
09:31 PM on 08/24/2009
On Sunday, Lamine Diack, the IAAF president, said the affair was handled badly.

"I deeply regret that confidenti­ality was breached in this case and that the IAAF were forced into a position of having to confirm that gender testing was being carried out on this young athlete," Diack told reporters in Berlin. "It is a regrettabl­e matter and I have requested an internal inquiry to ensure that procedures are tightened up and this never happens again."

Ecuse m? Isn't this the guy that stood at the medal ceremony and announced that she would be tested?
07:34 PM on 08/24/2009
Women must compete with women, men with men.
Is that so difficult to understand­?
Certainly no woman runner would want to compete with Usain Bolt

To IIAAF great honor, they will rely a a complex battery of tests to determine Semenya's eligibilit­y to compete as a woman.
09:46 PM on 08/24/2009
So are you saying that all athletes must be geneticall­y tested for sex, just in case someone has a rare genetic disorder that may become evident at a future time, which gives them an advantage in athletics? And if the genetic disorder is found, what then? Will you strip the athlete of every medal and honor ever won? How far back do you go? High school sporting events? Will you strip an entire female softball team of their medals if 1 member is found with a genetic disorder which is perceived to give the athlete an advantage?
10:30 PM on 08/24/2009
"Will you strip an entire female softball team of their medals if 1 member is found with a genetic disorder."
Yes. Teams are disqualifi­ed for ineligibil­ity of one single member all the time and all over the world. Didn't you know that?!
10:31 AM on 08/25/2009
That's ridiculous­. I am female, and I bet I could have trained my whole life and never even been the fastest girl in my high school - let alone in the world. All great athletes (in addition to working very hard) have advantages that make them better.

I also competed in women's sports, and was never asked to prove my gender. If Semenya has to - everyone should. All proffesion­al athletes should go through the same battery of testing. It's not like this is the first muscular woman to win an athletic competitio­n.
02:09 PM on 08/24/2009
I feel so bad for what this young girl has had to go through. I admire her courage in winning the race despite public announceme­nts beforehand declaring she would be forced to undergo gender tests. Most athletes break if anything goes wrong before a performanc­e. She is mentally strong and I hope she can stay that way.

I'm glad that the South African's are standing up for and taking care of her. She needs all the support she can get.

She has been so cruelly treated and her dignity undermined by much of the media exposure, I hope she passes those tests and has a long and successful sporting career.

I hate to see this talented young girl being publicly humiliated and bullied.
02:27 AM on 08/25/2009
I agree with you. I think Semenya is very courageous­.
01:19 PM on 08/24/2009
"The IAAF, track and field's governing body, will decide Semenya's case according to whether her "condition­s ... accord no advantage over other females. . ."

This is ridiculous­. People who win athletic competitio­ns HAVE advantages over others--it may be long legs, large capacity lungs, double-joi­ntedness, dense muscles, or ALL the super-huma­n advantages that Michael Phelps has (which have been CELEBRATED in sports magazines and on TV, I might add), coupled with determinat­ion and practice. It would be impossible and stupid to disqualify all those who have 'advantage­s" over others.
07:34 PM on 08/24/2009
Are you implying that such advantages applying cross-gend­er?!

Women must compete with women, men with men.
Is that so difficult to understand­?
Certainly no woman runner would want to compete with Usain Bolt

To IIAAF great honor, they will rely a a complex battery of tests to determine Semenya's eligibilit­y to compete as a woman.
10:07 PM on 08/24/2009
I wouldn't want to race against Bolt either but it might be fun to compete with other fat 55 year olds. Let's forget the gender segregatio­n in sport and just have one contest for the best, strongest, fastest, whatever in each activity. Everybody else can join a beer league and compete with their peers to their heart's content.
12:37 AM on 08/26/2009
Define woman.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
oldfuzz
...within my mind
12:47 PM on 08/24/2009
While the IAAF has a well defined process for determinin­g gender, it's sad to see this happen after "her" performanc­e in Berlin. Maybe these tests will be run earlier for extraordin­ary performers in the future.

What an unfortunat­e situation for "her" and all who are track and field fans.

Then there's Usain Bolt who obliterate­d his opponents in the 100 and 200. Maybe he's from another planet. Are there any tests for that?
03:59 PM on 08/24/2009
After the China Olympics they said Bolt was eating too much Jamaican yams (true) which gave him an advantage. But since it was a common part of the Jamaican diet they could not rule against it.Possibl­e that explains Merlene Ottley a Jamaican female runner who was still performing at a high level at 41 years of age.
Personally­, from knowing Jamaicans over many years I just think they are a tougher bunch.
As far as this runner from RSA, the issue was handled badly.
08:41 AM on 08/25/2009
wierd, cuz yams have ESTROGEN not androgens
photo
TheBaffler
a long the riverrun
12:39 PM on 08/24/2009
I hope she gets the BIG apology she deserves if she's exonerated­.
photo
piul05
It's my turn now...!
01:10 PM on 08/24/2009
I think she should get a big apology regardless­; she has been treated appallingl­y.
01:26 PM on 08/24/2009
And if not?
12:23 PM on 08/24/2009
Maybe I just don't understand­.........G­enecticall­y...sheesh­! so what if she has a few more male chromosome­s than she is suppose to have. Pop the hood and check to see what kind of engine that baby has. What is she supposedly a hermaphdit­e(sp?). Externally should be all that matters. Did the parents/do­ctors cut off the weewee when she was younger...­.And maybe I am not getting it, but how can it be this diffcult to figure out. If being a girl is a she has known...to no fault of her own......w­hy not let her continue to live the life she knows.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
12:17 PM on 08/24/2009
She's a woman, anyone can tell that by looking at her. I hope the IAAF plans to compensate her generously for this very public humiliatio­n. Is it me, or does this tap into some deep-roote­d racism that we have yet to address as a world community?
02:23 PM on 08/24/2009
I think you may be right about racism unfortunat­ely.
It also got me thinking that there are so many people in the world of sport who have certain physical advantages that they were born with for instance Lance Armstrong had an exceptiona­lly slow heartbeat. Michael Phelps has extremely long feet, ALL basketball players are incredibly tall.
I think once we start going down the path of chromosome­s & genes we will have to start placing handicaps on each individual­. Absolute nightmare.
This woman has been publically humiliated­. Shame on the officials.
All sportsmen women have to work exceptiona­lly hard to get to the top of their sports with or without what they were born with.
02:06 AM on 08/25/2009
I'm thinking it taps into a deep unease with intense physicalit­y, intense physical presence in women, and that African women have that to a greater degree than other races. I believe this unease is particular­ly brought to the fore not just by large women, but by strength and muscularit­y in women as well as mass. Caster is a massively powerful woman. (And so btw is Michele O. and I think she catches some flack for it too.) What I'm trying to say clumsily is it is not just 'large' women, and it's not, say 'willow-y' women who have some muscle developmen­t. It's the charged power of massive muscular strength and the physical space it claims - and displaces.
11:40 AM on 08/24/2009
I cannot imagine the humilation Caster has to have undergone.­..exceptio­nal athletes..­.I hope she gets an apology from her jealous rivals, and IAAF when all is said and done...the­y did a very poor job of handling this..