iPhone app iPad app Android phone app Android tablet app More

China Concubines Return Thanks To Increasing Capitalism

First Posted: 09/26/09 06:12 AM ET Updated: 05/25/11 02:55 PM ET

China

From the Independent

Mao Tse-tung tried to stamp the custom out as a relic of feudalism, but the return of capitalism to China has also meant a major comeback for the concubine. And for the long-suffering Chinese public, the compulsion of rich businessmen and jumped-up party officials to prove their wealth and power by the number and gorgeousness of their mistresses is a major factor in the growth of corruption. The angry gossip online is that behind every corrupt official there is a scheming mistress.

"China's future will be undermined in those corrupt officials' hands," wrote one outraged citizen. Another described the corrupt cadres who keep concubines as "absolutely superfluous, vampires, corrupt scum. They deserve to be killed".

Last month, a former chairman of the oil giant Sinopec, Chen Tonghai, was convicted of pocketing 196 million yuan (GBP17m) in bribes. But what angered Chinese the most was the way he had helped his mistress, Li Wei, to build up her property firm using his business connections. He was given a suspended death sentence.

Concubines are no longer kept hidden away behind closed doors. In modern China's far more open society, concubines can be seen in the shopping malls and cafes of the cities, especially in the south, where there are thousands of what are known as "er nai" or "second breast". By some estimates, more than 90 per cent of the country's most senior officials punished on serious graft charges in the past five years have kept mistresses.

There are lessons from history on the dangers that concubines represent. Concubine Yang was China's most famous mistress, one of the Four Beauties, and Emperor Xuanzong was so besotted with her that he lost his reason. He was forced to execute her to prove that he still had the will to rule. The emperor ultimately lost his grip on power and the glorious Tang dynasty (618-907) went into a decline.

Concubinage has a long history in China and was common right up to the early 20th century. Emperors and warlords kept many concubines as well as wives, and the wives sometimes even presented their husbands with fresh concubines, a practice known as "drinking vinegar".

Young women become concubines today for reasons of money and lifestyle, but also as a way out of poverty. "My son is already two years old, and my son's father is the same age as my father," wrote one anonymous 20-year-old concubine. "I call him 'old man'. He treats me well. Since I gave birth to a son, he bought a 180 square metre house under my name and two shops under my son's name. My days are very comfortable. I never ask him about his business and family, nor press him to divorce. A woman's life is hard and her youth goes quickly, so I cherish the present."

While many successful businessmen also have young lovers, it is the philandering government officials who really infuriate the average Chinese, and when they are found out they often pay a high price. At the very least they can expect the sack, like ex-Shanghai party chief Chen Liangyu, dismissed in 2006 for corruption, and ex-Beijing vice-mayor, Liu Zhihua, fired for taking bribes and helping his mistress "seek profit" while he was in charge of the construction of Olympic venues.

Pang Jiayu, a senior cadre in Shaanxi province, gained the nickname "Zipper Mayor" because of his weakness for the pretty young wives of his subordinates when he was mayor of Baoji. Duan Yihe, former party chief of Jinan, capital of Shandong in the northeast, was given a suspended death sentence in 2007 for killing his mistress with a car bomb after he became tired of her constant demands for money.

Some powerful officials in China have tried to bring the feudal institution up to date. Yang Feng, a senior cadre in Anhui province, was found during his corruption trial to have kept eight mistresses whom he managed using corporate management skills learnt during his MBA programme. He appointed one of them top mistress, to supervise the others, but the arrangement collapsed when a younger member of the team applied for the leadership position and his "manager" turned him in.

The current record-holder for the largest number of mistresses is Xu Qiyao, ex-head of construction in Jiangsu province, who amassed 140. Taking a leaf out of the book of bed-hopping British Tory Alan Clark, they included a mother and daughter.

Nor are the sort of exotic obsessions redolent of the remote Chinese past unheard of: an official in the state textile industry in Hainan kept four steel closets which were found to contain 95 diaries in which he recorded all of his sexual relationships, as well as hair samples from 236 different women.

Read more at the Independent.




Get HuffPost World On Facebook and Twitter!


FOLLOW HUFFPOST WORLD

From the Independent Mao Tse-tung tried to stamp the custom out as a relic of feudalism, but the return of capitalism to China has also meant a major comeback for the concubine. And for the long-suff...
From the Independent Mao Tse-tung tried to stamp the custom out as a relic of feudalism, but the return of capitalism to China has also meant a major comeback for the concubine. And for the long-suff...
Filed by Susan Ryan  | 
 
 
  • Comments
  • 204
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
Page: 1 2 3 4 5  Next ›  Last »  (5 total)
03:37 PM on 09/02/2009
The writer of this story is an ignoramus who doesn't know as much Chinese as he thinks he does.
"Drinking vinegar" simply means being jealous; "er nai" simply means second wife". Moreover, this is not news; concubines have been around China for decades.
07:32 PM on 08/28/2009
As for America's concubines, the "the mistresses foubourg" in New Orleans's French Quarter was well known from the 18th century till today as a riverfront neighborhood where wealthy uptown pater familias kept a boy or a damsel in a Quarter pad, a tradition that went back to the city's founding. Many an uptown moneyed mogul, heir to a bloody banana boat fortune, a gushing oil patch, or a ruined plantation, liked to belong to an edge-of-the-French Quarter sporting club where the better madams of Storyville displayed fresh ingenues.
11:53 AM on 08/27/2009
Boy, is this racist. Here in the U.S., when a man is a sugar daddy for a woman not his wife she is merely called his mistress. But when the women in question are Asian now they suddenly become concubines, a word that had to do more with a kind of servitude than it does for what this is, adults freely entering into an agreement to base their relationship on economic incentives in exchange for sexual favors.

And rich men having mistresses is not news anytime anywhere since it has been going on for millenia. Really, the editors of this site should be ashamed for permitting this kind of orientalist nonsense to be further propagated.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
arachne646
No more hurting people--Peace
12:52 PM on 08/27/2009
Whatever word you want to use for it, this type of "second wife" mistress is a particular kind of relationship in Chinese culture, and in history, and could not exist in this form again until recently. It's not simply "adults freely entering into an agreement" since the concubine is getting an upper class life in return for her youth, beauty, and compliance. What is not the same as 125 years ago? Going back to life on the farm is pretty much the same now as then.

The real outrage is to find out what those beaurocrats who are supposed to be keeping the river clean, or the food pure, or get your license renewed, are using your "extra service fee" to furnish a very plush apartment for someone, just to prove to himself what a bigshot he is, when as a Party Member, he publically shows morality, austerity and hard work. No wonder some of these guys has to be executed every now and then.

There sure are a lot of stereotypes about asians that we have here in N. America, but I think that in this case, the use of the particular word "concubine" is justified, in view of the particular function this type of relationship plays in Chinese society.
03:44 PM on 09/07/2009
No.

The only difference between a mistress and a concubine is a legal one. A concubine is legally recognized by the state and her children are considered legitimate heirs of the father. A mistress is an unofficial arrangement, which exists all over the world. What's the difference between these officials and John Edwards, or any other American politician who keeps his mistress and child on payroll? These sorts of arrangements exist, and are accepted, in parts of Europe as well. France is full of mistresses that are publicly acknowledged.

This whole piece is a lot of sensational bull-isht about nothing. Men with money keep a mistress. Big whoop, it's everywhere. Ancient China, Modern China, right-down-the-street-Georgia, doesn't matter.
09:46 AM on 08/27/2009
Farewell My Concubine directed by Chen Kai Ge released in '93 starring Gong Li is a must see
photo
Hillrick
Still inconceivable...I'm just not smiling anymore
10:42 AM on 08/27/2009
As is "Raise the red lantern"
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Elyriaohio
Stop the Monarchy
08:22 AM on 08/27/2009
I like Asian women.
But not when they look like a combination of Alice Cooper/Elton John.
07:42 PM on 08/28/2009
I know what you mean. When I look at the photos of famous female Hollywood stars without their make up or their DUI arrest mug shots, I am shocked they look like a man. It's amazing what Hollywood's magic can do to an ugly woman.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
vim876
07:15 AM on 08/27/2009
"By some estimates, more than 90 per cent of the country's most senior officials punished on serious graft charges in the past five years have kept mistresses."

This proves nothing without estimates of the percentage of senior officials total who keep mistresses.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
henrypapillon
Put a Psychiatrist in every NRA meeting.
06:36 AM on 08/27/2009
Ah, so. Americanization!!!!
06:05 AM on 08/27/2009
If the Zipper Mayor case had been the other way around, i.e. the mistress killing her lover, I am sure the Chinese government would have executed her in no time.
02:05 AM on 08/27/2009
Holy crow, Concubine Yang was executed because she was so beautiful she caused the emperor to neglect his duties. That'll show her. He was probably smitten with her little feet.

What a soap opera these stories would make.
04:49 AM on 08/27/2009
The original story is even better. The emperor was apparently so enraptured with Yang Guifei that after sending her away from his palace for offending him, he found himself irritable and unable to eat until she returned. She was known for her "full" figure, though not "obese" as some would have you believe ("curvy" would probably be about right--this was "overweight" by the standards of the 8th century), and was apparently so beautiful that the emperor lusted for her like crazy and neglected some of his duties. I seriously doubt that her feet were bound, as she lived in the 8th century and foot-binding didn't really start until the 10th century.
Then, like 10 years later, there was some in-fighting between some of the emperor's military commanders. Eventually one of them provoked another into rebelling, which eventually led to a third general, siding with the provoked rebel, to surround the king and demand that Yang Guifei be executed (he initially refused, but eventually gave in, cried, and spent the rest of his days looking at a painting of her). The common people hated her, thinking she had torn the kingdom apart, but she was probably just a scape-goat for the rebels anyway.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
01:54 AM on 08/27/2009
Oh lordy! Rich men rewarding lovely young women for the pleasure of their company. Who would have thought? I am SO glad that doesn't happen here.
photo
Hillrick
Still inconceivable...I'm just not smiling anymore
10:44 AM on 08/27/2009
Yes, ours is a Christian nation. Such a thing would never be tolerated.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Deli
Life after death, why wait?
01:38 AM on 08/27/2009
The archetype of the concubine is not the archetype of the prostitute or even the courtesan. The prostitute is the least power-holding of these female types. Women who identify with this archetype generally feel powerless and attempt to retain male relationships at the lowest common denominator.

The concubine is in much higher regard for her intellect and allows the male of the species to have both brains and beauty without sacrificing his maleness. But she is "kept". The courtesan, however, runs the show, is not "Kept" but "Keeper", given a near equal seat within the male power circle to actually drive decisions while enjoying arguably greater sexual power and the sexual and educational freedom not given even to wives, who, archetypically speaking, are cast in the more subservient role.

The network of males held by the male partner(s) of the courtesan feared for her decisions about their interests and welfare. True to a lesser extent of concubines. And non-existent with the prostitute. However, the Wife (archetype-wise, anyway) does win the day for securing permanent status and getting to exercise all aspects of that archtypical trifecta of Mother, Temptress, and Queen.

Of course, we would all like to think these archetypes no longer apply. But take a look at your patterns, you may be surprised. (And that goes for the male archetypes, too, which are equally resisted.)
11:58 AM on 08/27/2009
Well, no matter how you want to romanticize such arrangements, it nonetheless still puts a woman in an economically dependent relationship with the male and further reinforces the feminist hypocrisy of women seeing men as economic objects and feeling perfectly entitled to do so while they complain bitterly about men seeing them as sex objects even as they effectively trade their sexual availability for said economic endowments.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
arachne646
No more hurting people--Peace
01:01 PM on 08/27/2009
Thus, the effort to eliminate such relationships post-revolution. "Women hold up half the sky." and so forth. Despite the drawbacks of the Maoist period, women did acheive considerable gains in equality. There was, howerver, Madame Mao. She would probably have risen to power as courtesan or corporate executive.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Deli
Life after death, why wait?
09:06 PM on 08/27/2009
These conflicts occur precisely because archetypes are so deeply entrenched in the human psyche. Nothing romantic, just traits. For instance, the "Street Urchin" archetype, where someone defaults back to hand-to-mouth living regardless of how many good jobs they hold or other successes.

There is no escape to being seen as a sex object when the woman carries "the place" that men biologically seek. And for men, there is no escaping the urge to provide for women. We can certainly intellectualize ourselves into each holding up half the moon, but biology -- animal nature -- will remain.
photo
HUFFPOST COMMUNITY MODERATOR
rf dude
Just an average Man of Bronze - now in Steel!
01:28 AM on 08/27/2009
YOW-ZA!!!
--
12:39 AM on 08/27/2009
Two things:
1) "Drinking vinegar" (吃醋) as I understand simply refers to jealousy in a relationship, typically on the woman's part. The old story is that one Tang dynasty official was so whipped by his wife that he wouldn't accept any concubines offered to him by the emperor, so the emperor sent her some "poisoned wine" (actually vinegar), giving her an ultimatum to let her husband have concubines or drink the "poison". He wanted to see if she was so jealous that she would actually drink it, which she did.
2) Why is that picture included with this story? It's clearly a picture of a Peking Opera performer (could be male lol) or something similar. The original article from the Independent has a similar picture from "Farewell my Concubine", but the concubine only looks like that because the film is based on and about a Peking Opera. No modern concubine would look like that. Ewww.
photo
HUFFPOST COMMUNITY MODERATOR
rf dude
Just an average Man of Bronze - now in Steel!
01:30 AM on 08/27/2009
The med-school equivalent is known as " drinking apple juice",

a well-known rite of passage...
--
04:01 AM on 08/27/2009
Is that because it looks like piss? And you're kidding, right?
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
02:40 AM on 08/27/2009
An interesting explanation of the "drinking vinegar" ritual. Did the wife die in the original story after drinking the "poisoned wine"?
03:58 AM on 08/27/2009
No, she didn't die since it was just vinegar. Basically the emperor just wanted to see if she had the guts to go through with it. After seeing her do it and having his bluff called, the emperor apparently admitted that even he was scared to confront that woman, let alone her husband lol. This was apparently recorded in a Tang dynasty book, though not the official one so it could be a fictional story, but it's at the very least a widely circulated story and the one I've always heard to explain what "drinking vinegar" had to do with jealousy.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Deli
Life after death, why wait?
11:43 PM on 08/26/2009
This is hilarious and would make a great premise for a sitcom: "Yang Feng, a senior cadre in Anhui province, was found during his corruption trial to have kept eight mistresses whom he managed using corporate management skills learnt during his MBA programme. He appointed one of them top mistress, to supervise the others, but the arrangement collapsed when a younger member of the team applied for the leadership position and his "manager" turned him in."

I can just see the "There is no 'I' in Team" lecture, and the young upstart yelling, "Yeah, but there's an "Eat Me!"
HUFFPOST COMMUNITY MODERATOR
TXfemmom
Grandma with eye on the future
11:22 PM on 08/26/2009
Well, if the Chinese started using a small version of the guillotine on these guys, there would be far fewer corrupt public officials.