Serena Williams Fined $10,000 For US Open Tirade

HOWARD FENDRICH   09/14/09 12:50 AM ET   AP

NEW YORK — Serena Williams' profanity-laced, finger-pointing tirade at a U.S. Open linesperson drew a $10,000 fine Sunday, and more punishment could follow from a broader investigation into what the head of the tournament called her "threatening manner."

The fine – not quite 3 percent of the $350,000 in prize money Williams earned by reaching the semifinals – is the maximum on-site penalty that can be issued for unsportsmanlike conduct at a Grand Slam tournament.

"The average individual would look at that and say, 'A $10,000 fine for what she did? What are you guys, crazy?' The answer is: the process isn't over," tournament director Jim Curley said in an interview with The Associated Press.

Bill Babcock, the top administrator for Grand Slam tournaments, will review what happened Saturday night, when Williams yelled at a linesperson who called a foot fault with the defending champion two points away from losing to Kim Clijsters in the semifinals.

If Babcock determines Williams committed a "major offense," she could be fined all of her prize money from the tournament.

Williams also was docked $500 for smashing her racket after the first set of the match. Because she was issued a warning then, her later actions resulted in the loss of a point.

The foot fault resulted in a double-fault, which moved Clijsters one point from victory. Williams then was penalized a point for her outburst; because it happened to come on match point, it ended the semifinal with Clijsters ahead 6-4, 7-5.

Clijsters won the championship Sunday night by beating Caroline Wozniacki 7-5, 6-3.

Babcock did not immediately respond to requests for comment. But Curley said the inquiry probably would include reviewing TV footage, checking additional audio feeds from courtside microphones and interviewing Williams, the linesperson, the chair umpire and possibly spectators.

"What she did was unacceptable. It's unacceptable behavior under any circumstances. When you're on the court, and you are waving your racket toward a linesperson and using profanity, it's just simply unacceptable," Curley told the AP. "When you look at the tape, it's pretty clear that the way she approached the linesperson, with her racket and in that manner, it was a threatening manner. It certainly was."

The names of linespersons are not disclosed as a matter of practice at the tournament.

He also said the tournament considered – and decided against – preventing Williams and her older sister Venus from participating in the women's doubles final Monday. Venus put in some work on a U.S. Open practice court Sunday; Serena wasn't with her.

Serena Williams released a statement through a public relations firm, acknowledging that "in the heat of battle I let my passion and emotion get the better of me and as a result handled the situation poorly."

She did not apologize for the outburst, which made the "most viewed" page of YouTube with four different versions that totaled more than half a million clicks as of Sunday night.

After what may be recalled as the most significant foot fault in tennis history, Williams paused, retrieved a ball to serve again and then stopped. She stepped toward the official, screaming, cursing and shaking the ball at her.

"If I could, I would take this ... ball and shove it down your ... throat," Williams said, according to a tennis official who watched a replay Saturday night.

The official also said Williams used the word "kill." The official declined to be identified because the tape was still being reviewed.

Fans began booing and whistling, making it difficult to hear the entirety of what Williams said – and she refused to discuss specifics afterward at a news conference. An AP reporter – provided access to replays – could not verify Williams used the word "kill."

When Williams turned her back, the line judge went over to the chair umpire to report what was going on. The line judge then returned to her seat, and Williams pointed and began walking toward her. The line judge then headed back to the chair umpire's stand. By now, tournament referee Brian Earley was on the court, too.

Earley could be heard asking the linesperson what Williams said.

That's when Williams walked over and said to the line judge: "Are you scared? Because I said I would hit you? I'm sorry, but there's a lot of people who've said way worse."

Earley again asked the linesperson what Williams said. Whatever the linesperson said, her reply seemed to startle Williams, who said: "I didn't say I would kill you. Are you serious? Are you serious? I didn't say that." The line judge then said, "Yes."

The episode dominated conversation at the U.S. Open on Sunday, including whether the line judge should have made the call in the first place. Foot faults are rarely called at this level, particularly in possibly the final moments of such a significant match.

"In my opinion, you can't call a foot fault there. Just out of question. Can't do it. It was so close. Not as if it was an obvious foot fault – it was minuscule," TV commentator John McEnroe said. "I've seen Serena come back from that position a dozen times against top-flight opponents. The match was not over."

The chairman and CEO of the women's tennis tour, Stacey Allaster, issued a statement calling Williams' conduct "inappropriate and unprofessional."

"No matter what the circumstances, no player should be allowed to engage in such behavior without suffering consequences," Allaster said. "I have spoken with the USTA about this matter and I agree with the action they have taken."

FOLLOW HUFFPOST NEW YORK

NEW YORK — Serena Williams' profanity-laced, finger-pointing tirade at a U.S. Open linesperson drew a $10,000 fine Sunday, and more punishment could follow from a broader investigation into what...
NEW YORK — Serena Williams' profanity-laced, finger-pointing tirade at a U.S. Open linesperson drew a $10,000 fine Sunday, and more punishment could follow from a broader investigation into what...
Filed by David Weiner  | 
 
 
  • Comments
  • 75
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Recency  | 
Popularity
Page: 1 2  Next ›  Last »  (2 total)
02:23 PM on 09/14/2009
Until he apologizes for all the stupid shenanigans he pulled during matches throughout his career (which he has never done, to my knowledge), John McEnroe is the very last person on earth whose opinion should be sought on this matter. I hated McEnroe as a player, love him as a commentator and have been waiting for years for him to man up and admit that all of his bull*&^t on the courts was due to his lack of maturity and was totally uncalled for.
10:58 AM on 09/15/2009
I dislike McEnroe intensely though he was a good player. He made millions by his boorish behavior. He will never man up because he benefited from his lack of manners.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
AxelDC
02:19 PM on 09/14/2009
The call was irrelevant. Williams was upset because she was losing. The call happened after she smashed 2 rackets, earning a code violation warning that set up the point penalty.

Williams violated many rules:

1) Smashing your racket (twice)
2) Talking to a line judge -- you address concerns to the chair
3) Using blatant profanity
4) Verbally threatening violence
5) Physically threatening violence with her racket

In 1995, Jeff Terengo blew up at Wimbledon official. He was fined $65,000 and banned from two GS tournaments, including 1996 Wimbledon.

Should Serena Williams get a lesser penalty for more egregious behavior, or does her star power protect her?
03:41 PM on 09/14/2009
Well lets see:

1) Smashing your racket (twice)
So what happens all the time in tennis.
2) Talking to a line judge -- you address concerns to the chair
She made a statement and cursed she wasn't addressing concerns she was expressing anger....again happens all the time
3) Using blatant profanity
happens all the time
4) Verbally threatening violence
She made no threat, she stated that if she could she would shut the lady up. Big difference than "I am going to kill you"
5) Physically threatening violence with her racket
Shook her racket in anger.....happens all the time.

Did she act very angrily? Yes
Happens all the time.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
AxelDC
04:23 PM on 09/14/2009
Happens all the time???

I don't know whether you are watching WTA or WWE, because I've never seen such a scene in 20 years of watching tennis.

1) Smashing your racket (twice)

This is a code violation. Serena was warned after he 2nd throw, which I've seen several times.

2) Talking to a line judge -- you address concerns to the chair

Yelling at a line judge is a code violation. You talk to the chair, otherwise you are just intimidating line judges to get more favorable calls.

3) Using blatant profanity

Again, using the F-word is a code violation. She already used her warning and so the point penalty was enforced.

4) Verbally threatening violence

She said, "If I could, I would shove this f%ing ball down your f%ing throat."
You must live in a tough neighborhood, because if one of my neighbors said that to me, I'd call the cops.

5) Physically threatening violence with her racket

I've never seen a player menace an official with a racket. If that happened in hockey, you'd see automatic fines and suspensions.

Do players get angry? Of course they do, but their are defined penalties for their failure to properly channel their anger. Taking out your inability to beat a player is no excuse for attacking tournament officials, especially a player with the resume of Serena Williams.

She should be heavily fined and suspended and learn from her mistakes. It worked for Martha Stewart.
02:03 PM on 09/14/2009
I saw several male players throw their rackets down in anger during the US Open.
I don't understand why they weren't brought to punishment as well.
I don't condone Serena's behaviour but I do believe there is a double standard.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
AxelDC
02:19 PM on 09/14/2009
How many of them threatened officials?
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
24kgold
03:15 PM on 09/15/2009
Many have thrown balls at fans!
photo
HUFFPOST COMMUNITY MODERATOR
k6007
Obama/Biden 2012!
03:04 PM on 09/14/2009
Excellent point.
When jimC rushed the chair at the 1991 us open, yelling and pointing his racket in the poor guy's face(terrible call, btw!).....**crickets**
photo
HUFFPOST COMMUNITY MODERATOR
k6007
Obama/Biden 2012!
01:21 PM on 09/14/2009
lol!
john mac, was fine $1500. for his antics and there was NO talk of suspensions. Same for jim connors(see him rush the chair ump, pointing his racket in his face at the 1991 us open).

BUT, those "blacks" have to be made an example of! yup, yup.
11:00 AM on 09/15/2009
Agree that McEnroe should have been fined a lot more often. He is a boor.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
AxelDC
01:13 PM on 09/14/2009
Of course McEnroe defends her. He was the king of bad behavior and the rules were largely written because of him.

McEnroe is also the biggest homer in history. He predicted that Roddick would win the Open, that Federer couldn't possibly win, and that Serena was unstoppable.

Sure, Serena COULD have turned things around, but not the way she had been playing to that point. Serena's tantrum was more about the fact she was being played off then court than a silly foot fault.

How can McEnroe not know that intimidating line officials is unacceptable?
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
24kgold
03:17 PM on 09/15/2009
From McEnroe's experience I think that he knows more then you!
01:10 PM on 09/14/2009
I agree with Heckyea. Serena was just very emotional. She is not used to losing. Time to let it go.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
AxelDC
02:21 PM on 09/14/2009
She was upset because she just realized her days of coasting to tourny wins are over now that Mama Clijsters is back! She's going to actually have to work to stay at the top now.

Just wait until that other Belgian decides she wants another GS title to go with her first 7.
06:01 PM on 09/14/2009
OK.. now, I get the previous comments.. and, can write them off to bias. Clijsters was amazing and deserved her win, but it doesn't invalidate the inequity amongst line judges and how code violations are meted out. When was the last time you saw a code violation issued for smashing a racket?.. male players do it all the time.. Safin/ Federer/ Gonzalez/ Roddick andonandon. Or, a call for foot-fault at that point (or, any..really) in a match? "I've never seen a player menace an official with a racket." You never saw Connors or Nastase or McEnroe?

I don't condone Serena's behavior, but I understand it. It was unsportmans-like and equally uncharacteristic. Do you or anyone else really think Serena was threatening that line judge with actual bodily harm? PUH-LEEZE!! The line judge seemed smug and petty and I doubt we will be seeing her at major tournaments in the future...
12:02 PM on 09/14/2009
Joe Wilson is a red-neck racist who can't stand it that 70% of this country elected an African American President. He showed total disrespect and didn't adhere to protocol. Why have rules in a society if they're not followed. Again he has to deal with his demons and Serena needs to deal with hers. Kanye West needs someone to sit him down and have a serious discussion about respecting individual's spaces and protocol. This attitude that today's young people have is reckless and confrontational. HUMM! I wonder where they get it from. Tea Party or Town Hall anyone?
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
juhar
10:38 AM on 09/14/2009
What next - attempted murder charges?
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Hanifah Walidah
09:21 AM on 09/14/2009
Whatever I think most black people, definitely this one has dealt with non-black people misreading and certainly overacting to our intentions. It seems like we will be forever hostile in a racist world.

Its almost like you all were waiting for one of the Williams sisters to slip up so you can unleash your brand of racism. Its not like she has a record of outbreaks. Jeesh. The way Serena reacted tot he line judge accusing her of saying I would kill you said it all for me. For anyone to take "I should shove this effin ball down your efin throat" literally in front of 20, 000 people and the world is ridiculous. But for this "ape-like" (as pointed out by a commenter earlier) black woman to say so means it MUST be taken literally!. Of course black people are violent and threatening by default. We can't talk in jest or the figurative.

This is in no defense of unsportsmanlike behavior. But the tone of most of your comments screams of racism. I think racism within tennis was just waiting for one of these black girls from compton to have an outburst to prove they were unworthy of this traditionally lilly white sport.

RAcism was even apparent in the Semanya case. Alot of comments would alsomention the Williams sisters as if their gender should be under question just because these women have brought the athleticism of the game to a new level.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
24kgold
03:23 PM on 09/15/2009
Thank You Hanifah..........
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
wwoody
Retired fishing for the truth.
09:08 AM on 09/14/2009
Soccer is the number one sport in the world, why ?....because of the bottom line. Soccer is a money maker through out the world, accept the United States why, the advertiser want our entertainment money for football, basketball, baseball. To support their bottom line.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
wwoody
Retired fishing for the truth.
08:56 AM on 09/14/2009
This mean more people will come to see her play the next time, this is advertiser dream, they can smell the money rolling in, hand over fists,in all four pockets. let us not forget, its all about the bottom line.
08:49 AM on 09/14/2009
Way to go Serena. Your ape-like behavior cost you more than you expected right? Keep up the good work all so you can loose again due to your uncontrollable behavior. Bravo!
11:38 AM on 09/14/2009
Just a tad over the top WTFDallasTX. Your hood is showing. Her behavior was terrible, but to describe it as Ape-like implies you are judging more than her actions which are appalling as well.

As an African American female, I was mortified and ashamed because whether she understands and accepts this or not, she is a mentor to many young children of all races, and a standard bearer for the African American Community in this sport like Althea Gibson, Zena Garrison, Chandra Rubin, Lori McNeill not to mention the man whom the stadium is named after Mr. Arthur Ashe.Her actions the other night are not a reflection of and do not represent the African American Community as a whole. I have been proud of the accomplishments of both Williams sisters. However, Serena in my opinion should feel the effect of her actions and be suspended from the game until after the Australian Open in January where she would play to defend her championship title.This also includes Monday's Doubles Final. She should have apologized immediately to everyone concerned inspite of the mistake call made by the lineswoman. Instead she was arrogant through it all, and released a non-remorseful statement through a public relations firm. I think a fine is not enough. This was terrible for the game and on so many other levels.
05:58 PM on 09/14/2009
Thank you for your voice of reason. Arthur Ashe is one of my heroes, too. Not only because of his tennis career and the grace with which he played the game, but also for the kind of man he was in the rest of his life.
I 'd like to add James Blake, Bryan Shelton, Yannick Noah and Ronald Agenor to your list of great black tennis players.
11:31 AM on 09/15/2009
Serena's behavior was shameful and inexcusable, however, I disagree with characterizing her immediate response as "arrogance" as I am certain that she needed a little time to digest her behavior and respond accordingly. An apology was issued yesterday and I feel that it was timely and responsive to her behavior. Suggestions of specific penalties should have some basis. Therefore, I do not believe that the suggestion of a suspension until after January 2010 is necessarily warranted or equitable, but rather progressive disciplinary action should be applied which considers past behavior and the specific penalties meted out to others who have committed similar infractions. Otherwise, it lends itself to unfairness.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
24kgold
03:26 PM on 09/15/2009
That is money for one of Serena's designer purses that she carries, are you serious?
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
05:12 AM on 09/14/2009
Jeez. I just don't understand the people defending her behavior in this.

Idle or not, you don't issue threats to physically harm someone just because a call doesn't go your way. Even if the call had been bad, you shouldn't be engaging in that sort of behavior.
photo
HUFFPOST COMMUNITY MODERATOR
k6007
Obama/Biden 2012!
01:22 PM on 09/14/2009
New to tennis?
11:02 AM on 09/15/2009
No, new to threats of violence to linespeople.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
24kgold
03:27 PM on 09/15/2009
Do you mean old tennis?
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
BigSlick674
Mitochondr­ial DNA has no expiration date
04:39 AM on 09/14/2009
Kanye West and Serena Williams just announced their engagement.
11:25 AM on 09/14/2009
LOL, now that is funny
11:41 AM on 09/15/2009
Kanye West appears to have a narcissistic personality which lends itself to fostering drama, with this occurring on more than one occasion. Serena Williams demonstrated shameful and unprofessional behavior during a singular tennis match, having been on the world stage for approximately 10 years. Aside from inappropriate behavior possibly occurring on or about the same day, I do not see the correlation between Kanye West and Serena Williams.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
wwoody
Retired fishing for the truth.
02:16 AM on 09/14/2009
You're not just going to simply piss on her,... and tell her that it rain.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
AxelDC
01:14 PM on 09/14/2009
Because if you do, she'll shove a #$% ball up your #$%.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
24kgold
03:31 PM on 09/15/2009
D@/m/n right! why the hate? why don't you confront her father with the problem that you have about Serena and lets see if the attitude that you think she has is inherited....