More

Stewart Nozette (PICTURE): Scientist Arrested On Spy Charges Worked For Department Of Defense

LARRY MARGASAK and DEVLIN BARRETT   10/19/09 10:29 PM ET   AP

Stewart Nozette
Dr. Stewart Nozette holds a photo of the moon's south pole during a press conference at the Pentagon in 1996 about the discovery of water on the moon.

WASHINGTON — A scientist credited with helping discover evidence of water on the moon was arrested Monday on charges of attempting to pass along classified information to an FBI agent posing as an Israeli intelligence officer.

Stewart David Nozette, 52, of Chevy Chase, Md., was charged in a criminal complaint with attempting to communicate, deliver and transmit classified information, the Justice Department said.

Nozette was arrested by FBI agents and is expected to make his initial appearance in federal court in Washington on Tuesday. Law enforcement officials said Nozette did not immediately have a lawyer.

Nozette worked in varying jobs for the Energy Department, NASA and – in 1989 and 1990 – the National Space Council in the president's office. He developed the Clementine bi-static radar experiment that is credited with discovering water on the south pole of the moon. He also worked at the Energy Department's Lawrence Livermore National Laboratory, where he designed highly advanced technology, from approximately 1990 to 1999.

At Energy, Nozette held a special security clearance equivalent to the Defense Department's top secret and "critical nuclear weapon design information" clearances. DOE clearances apply to access to information specifically relating to atomic or nuclear-related materials.

Nozette also held top offices at the Alliance for Competitive Technology, a nonprofit corporation that he organized. Between January 2000 and February 2006, Nozette, through his company, had several agreements to develop advanced technology for the U.S. government.

An affidavit suggests why FBI agents posed as agents of the Israeli intelligence agency Mossad to conduct the sting operation.

From 1998 to 2008, the complaint alleges, Nozette was a technical adviser for a consultant company that was wholly owned by the Israeli government. Nozette was paid about $225,000 over that period, the court papers say.

Then, in January of this year, Nozette allegedly traveled to another foreign country with two computer thumb drives and apparently did not return with them. Prosecutors also quote an unnamed colleague of Nozette who said the scientist said that if the U.S. government ever tried to put him in jail for an unrelated criminal offense, he would go to Israel or another foreign country and "tell them everything" he knows.

The complaint does not allege that the government of Israel or anyone acting on its behalf violated U.S. law. In Jerusalem, Israeli government officials had no immediate comment.

The affidavit by FBI agent Leslie Martell said that on Sept. 3, Nozette received a telephone call from an individual purporting to be an Israeli intelligence officer. The caller was an undercover FBI agent.

Nozette agreed to meet with the agent later that day at a hotel in Washington and in the subsequent meeting the two discussed Nozette's willingness to work for Israeli intelligence, the affidavit said.

Nozette allegedly informed the agent that he had, in the past, held top security clearances and had access to U.S. satellite information, the affidavit said.

The scientist also allegedly said that he would be willing to answer questions about this information in exchange for money. The agent explained that the Israeli intelligence agency, Mossad, would arrange for a communication system so Nozette could pass on information in a post office box.

Nozette agreed to provide regular, continuing information and asked for an Israeli passport, the affidavit alleged.

According to the court papers, Nozette and the undercover agent met soon afterward in the same hotel, where the scientist allegedly said that while he no longer had legal access to any classified information at a U.S. government facility, he could, nonetheless, recall classified information by memory. Nozette allegedly asked when he could expect to receive his first payment, saying he preferred cash amounts "under ten thousand" so he didn't have to report it.

Nozette allegedly told the agent, "Well, I should tell you my first need is that they should figure out how to pay me ... they don't expect me to do this for free."

About a week later, FBI agents left a letter in the designated post office box, asking Nozette to answer a list of questions about U.S. satellite information. The agents provided a $2,000 cash payment. Serial numbers of the bills were recorded.

Nozette was later captured on videotape leaving a manila envelope in the post office box. The next day, agents retrieved the sealed envelope and found, among other things, a one-page document containing answers to the questions and an encrypted computer thumb drive.

One answer contained information classified as secret, which concerned capabilities of a prototype overhead collection system. Nozette allegedly offered to reveal additional classified information that directly concerned nuclear weaponry, military spacecraft or satellites, and other major weapons systems.

Agents left a second letter in the post office box with another list of questions about U.S. satellite information. The FBI also left a cash payment of $9,000. Nozette allegedly retrieved the questions and the money the same day.

Again, authorities say, Nozette was videotaped leaving a manila envelope in the post office box. FBI agents retrieved it and found a second set of answers. The responses contained information classified as both top secret and secret, on U.S. satellites, early warning systems, means of defense or retaliation against large-scale attack, communications intelligence information, and major elements of defense strategy.

Nozette performed some of this research and development at the U.S. Naval Research Laboratory in Washington, the Defense Advanced Research Projects Agency in Arlington, Va., and the National Aeronautics and Space Administration Goddard Space Flight Center in Greenbelt, Md.

FOLLOW HUFFPOST POLITICS

WASHINGTON — A scientist credited with helping discover evidence of water on the moon was arrested Monday on charges of attempting to pass along classified information to an FBI agent posing as ...
WASHINGTON — A scientist credited with helping discover evidence of water on the moon was arrested Monday on charges of attempting to pass along classified information to an FBI agent posing as ...
Filed by T.J. Ortenzi  | 
 
 
  • Comments
  • 251
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
Page: 1 2 3 4 5  Next ›  Last »  (6 total)
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
bccmeteorites
Don't believe everything NASA says.
10:48 AM on 10/21/2009
Mr. Nozette participated in the Clementine Data Mission project primarily to map the lunar surface mineralogy. This was a very good mission for us personally because we were able to find a good agreement on the Lunar Highlands surface composition, between the data on Iron and Titanium composition and ratio (~10:1) provided by the mission, and confirmation using lab data on a new lunar meteorite. This data was produced by Taylor from the University of Hawaii in 1997-08 but we did not discover this perfect match (Clementine data and our lab data) on the Lunar Highlands until 2002. SO the man produced some good science and but the water-ice thing is more politics than hard science in my view.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
bccmeteorites
Don't believe everything NASA says.
02:13 PM on 10/21/2009
This discovery was important because it pointed to, and means several things.

The moon is not a piece of Earth theorized to have been removed by an impact with a Mars sized solid body. That theory can finally be removed from textbooks. It originated during the early birth of the solar system and the result of capture by planetary dynamics.

The Moon and Earth share no biological material, nor water bearing mineralogy can be found on the Moon.

Confirmed, Eugene Shoemaker said in 1974 after examining Apollo samples, "the Moon is even drier than we thought".

What was NASA's response when we released our match on clementine data in 2002-03, under Sean O'Keefe? Their misinformation machine went into overdrive to change the numbers from the Clementine Data Mission. In mid 2004 they got together and constructed a bogus paper and released it on December 4, 2004. This paper consisted of cherry picking data, smoke and mirrors and moving the goal posts. They brazenly took the data from a less reliable mission, the Prospector Lunar Mission, and massaged it into the Clementine Mission, to water down the numbers and throw us outside the tabulated ranges.

These are reality altering tactics commonly used by scientists in research to advance an agenda. As soon as I read the first paragraph, I declared the fabrication dead on arrival.

Why did NASA scientists wait until 2004 to change a scientific paper constructed in 1998? It was motivated by our discoveries in the lab.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
bccmeteorites
Don't believe everything NASA says.
08:21 PM on 10/21/2009
The correct rang of dates is 1997-1998. Sorry.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
cathleen
10:07 AM on 10/21/2009
Why not have this on the front of Huff Po instead of some of the Hollywood news? I would put a million bucks (if I had it) that if it had been a Muslim man who had just been nabbed for spying for Saudi Arabia it would hold your lead spot for days

We can be sure this will not make it one the corporate evening news between balloon family stories. Probably will not even make NPR. They barely whispered about the Aipac/Rosen espionage investigation , 9 time delayed trial. A few of them mentioned the trial once it was dismissed. Pathetic
04:40 PM on 10/20/2009
I can't understand the surprise people are expressing over this story? Allies spy on each other all the time. Maybe it was so easy for the FBI to get this guy because anyone in a position that requires top level security clearance KNOWS that Israeli recruitment of spies in America is common. For example, what if I am a Mexican-American scientist...would I be shocked to find someone posing as a representative from the Mexican government asking me to spy?
04:52 PM on 10/22/2009
Dream on. What if he was a Saudi? This would be front page.
photo
Passenger57
Keeping Calm And Carrying On...
11:13 AM on 10/20/2009
OK...who wants to 'splain why Israel is spying on us?
How many of the billions we give 'em go towards spying on us?
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
pkafin
11:49 AM on 10/20/2009
K, who wants to explain to Passenger57 that Israel had nothing to do with what this article reports. It was the FBI pretending to be an Israeli.
04:27 PM on 10/20/2009
pkafin, why do you assume this is the first time? Do you know how many times the US has apprehended people spying for Israel in the past say 10 years? It is not an unusual thing for allies to spy on each other. It is actually quite common. That Israel was or was not directly involved in this man's case has YET to be seen.
01:25 AM on 10/21/2009
Several other people working at the same Israeli government owned aerospace firm as consultants were charged with espionage for passing secrets to Israel. He was set up because his travel activities seemed to indicate that he was already selling classified intel.

He is quoted as saying that he already thought he was working as a spy for Israel simply as part of his job with the Israeli Aerospace firm.

So, no, I guess that does not really sound like Israel Is implicated here... NOT.
11:09 AM on 10/20/2009
we don't execute spys anymore?
photo
ibsteve2u
Someone who cares - to his unending regret
02:19 PM on 10/20/2009
Good question. If they have no value as exchanges for our people, fry 'em.
photo
HUFFPOST PUNDIT
den1953
The best politicians are for free!
11:02 AM on 10/20/2009
Does this story make anyone wonder about the old saying my enemy is my best friend? What is up with the Israeli's and there spy machine?
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
pkafin
03:03 PM on 10/20/2009
Nothing is "up with the Israeli's and their spy machine". If you had read the article you would have realized that there is not a single Israeli involved in this story. This is not a story about Israel spying or attempting to spy on anyone. It is a story about the FBI catching a US citizen in a sting by pretending to be an Israeli.
04:25 PM on 10/20/2009
He was a paid consultant for an Israeli defence company, which is were the suspicions began. Hes in it up to his neck, as is Israel.
04:29 PM on 10/20/2009
there is a lot "up" with Israeli intelligence. Mossad is by far one of the best organized most effective intelligence agencies in the world. This is not a secret.
As for allies spying on each other, this is not uncommon. And again, we have yet to see if Israel was involved in this or not. I doubt we will ever know the truth about the story anyway...but regardless, we have dozens of examples of this taking place in America.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
10:35 AM on 10/20/2009
I am amazed to discover that the writers commenting on this thread are incapable of comprehending what they are reading? How strange?

The complaint does not allege that the government of Israel or anyone acting on its behalf violated U.S. law.

Read more at: http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2009/10/19/stewart-nozette-picture-s_n_326447.html
photo
Passenger57
Keeping Calm And Carrying On...
11:35 AM on 10/20/2009
Oh, we can read...we're just frustrated because we know Israel HAS spied on us, and is likely doing so now...we want to know why.
I don't spy on MY friends...!
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
pkafin
03:06 PM on 10/20/2009
If you think the US does not spy on it's allies (with your tax dollars) than you are quite naive.

Still, this story is not, in any way, related to an incident of, suspicion of, or an accusation of Israeli spying.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
11:58 AM on 10/20/2009
the FBI are likely aware that there is a problem with Mossad seeking state secrets... hence the operation against potential conspirators...
09:43 AM on 10/20/2009
It's Bush's , conservatives, christians, capitalisms, the middle class's, Cheney's, McCain's, Palin's, and all non-liberal american's fault. There I said it. Now we can move on.
09:33 AM on 10/20/2009
Excuse me, but isn't Israel our ally?

These Israeli companies and government agents work side by side with our government and corporate folks every single day in the defense industry, blurring the lines of "National Security". We share a TON of information with them, and vice-versa.

Sounds like someone had it in for this guy, and they needed a set up to get rid of him.
06:16 PM on 10/20/2009
Yeah, all US allies should know everything. Makes perfect sense.

No seriously, just because they are US allies doesn't mean they instantly have access to defense secrets. You know, being separate countries and all.

Furthermore, national defense shouldnt be left to the whim of random civilians who happen to be privileged with top secret clearance. US citizens dont even have access to this stuff and you want to implicitly trust foreign nationals.

Israeli and US interests dont overlap.
01:34 AM on 10/23/2009
Very true - now you tell me why on Earth we are serving Israel's interests for DECADES now...?
photo
MajorKong
If the pilot's good, see, I mean if he's reeeally
08:03 AM on 10/20/2009
Back during the Cold War I was always hoping to run into the beautiful spy who would trade me sex for secrets.

Never did find her, damn it!
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
07:56 AM on 10/20/2009
I can only imagine how explosive the reaction of the government would be if he was accused of spying for Russia as opposed to Israel. With the notable exception of Pollard, who the US is correct in keeping in prison, Israel usually gets a pass. It is vile and inexcusable that Israel continues to spy on the US when the US almost singlehandedly bankrolls the country and guarantees its survival. I support Israel's right to exist but it should at least be grateful to the US. Instead, it treats America with contempt.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
pkafin
03:09 PM on 10/20/2009
You are not a big reader, I see. The article says nothing about a guy spying for Israel. He was approached by an FBI agent (not an Israeli) who claimed to be something he was not (an Israeli). To use this story to carry on about how it is "vile and inexcusable that Israel continues to spy on the US..." is nonsensical.
04:31 PM on 10/20/2009
He was a paid defense consultant for Israel with suspicious finances and book keeping.

Thats as far from a rogue traitor or independent chancer as it gets.
04:34 PM on 10/20/2009
You are correct in your statement that Israel "treats America with contempt" - a few days ago, Bibi responded to Hillary's repeated request to halt settlements with the comment "They just don't get it do they?"
Previously, as PM when he kicked out all foreign journalists and closed off the Palestinian town of Jenin (apparently to re-paint it or something) he was quoted in the NYT in response to AIPAC concern of US Government reaction "We own America". As a result, he was the first Israeli PM in history to not be invited to speak in front of AIPAC.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
07:53 AM on 10/20/2009
This chap will be charged with espionage and not treason. Whilst espionage is technically a capital offense in time of war, this sort of alleged behavior is not death penalty qualified. He's look at 10 years not life or death.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
07:25 AM on 10/20/2009
ugh. i hope they make an example out of him.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
DonCosenza
04:59 AM on 10/20/2009
Wait, so the FBI *doesn't* work for Israel?

(I kid, I kid!)
04:35 PM on 10/20/2009
NICE ONE!!!!

I can't understand the surprise people are expressing over this story?
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
OkieIntellectual
Sooo tired of all the irrational idiots in the wor
04:45 AM on 10/20/2009
This man is an affront to the greater scientific community.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
bccmeteorites
Don't believe everything NASA says.
04:15 PM on 10/20/2009
Maybe he's their poster child.