The Story Behind National Geographic's Viral Chimp Funeral Photo

digg Share this on Facebook Huffpost - The Story Behind National Geographic's Viral Chimp Funeral Photo stumble reddit del.ico.us RSS


First Posted: 10-29-09 08:23 AM   |   Updated: 10-29-09 02:42 PM

What's Your Reaction?
Chimp

Guest post by Jeremy Berlin from National Geographic's Pop Omnivore Blog

The November issue of National Geographic Magazine features a moving photograph of chimpanzees watching the burial of one of their own. Since it was published, the picture and story have gone viral, turning up on websites and TV shows and in newspapers around the world. For readers who'd like to know more, here's what I learned as I interviewed the photographer, Monica Szczupider.

On September 23, 2008, Dorothy, a female chimpanzee in her late 40s, died of congestive heart failure. A maternal and beloved figure, Dorothy spent eight years at Cameroon's Sanaga-Yong Chimpanzee Rescue Center, which houses and rehabilitates chimps victimized by habitat loss and the illegal African bushmeat trade.

After a hunter killed her mother, Dorothy was sold as a "mascot" to an amusement park in Cameroon. For the next 25 years, she was tethered to the ground by a chain around her neck, taunted, teased, and taught to drink beer and smoke cigarettes for sport. In May 2000, Dorothy--obese from poor diet and lack of exercise--was rescued and relocated along with ten other primates. As her health improved, her deep kindness surfaced. She mothered an orphaned chimp named Bouboule and became a close friend to many others, including Jacky, the group's alpha male, and Nama, another amusement-park refugee.

Szczupider, who had been a volunteer at the center, told me: "Her presence, and loss, was palpable, and resonated throughout the group. The management at Sanaga-Yong opted to let Dorothy's chimpanzee family witness her burial, so that perhaps they would understand, in their own capacity, that Dorothy would not return. Some chimps displayed aggression while others barked in frustration, but perhaps the most stunning reaction was a recurring, almost tangible silence. If one knows chimpanzees, then one knows that [they] are not [usually] silent creatures."

The Sanaga-Yong Chimpanzee Rescue Center was founded in 1999 by veterinarian Sheri Speede (pictured at right, cradling Dorothy's head; at left is center employee Assou Felix). Operated by IDA-Africa, an NGO, it's home to 62 chimps who reside in spacious, forested enclosures.

Szczupider had submitted the photograph to "Your Shot," a magazine feature that encourages readers to send in pictures they have taken. The best are published on the website and in the magazine.

Susan Welchman, the Geographic photo editor who sifts through reader-contributed shots looking for winners, was drawn to the candor of the image. "It caught my eye because you just don't see that much emotion--human emotion--with animals," she says. "It couldn't have been posed or faked; there's no way to make an animal look or act like that. It's just so real and true, so pure."

Related:

National Geographic's Photo Gallery
Fongoli Chimps Gallery
Virunga Gorillas Story

Guest post by Jeremy Berlin from National Geographic's Pop Omnivore Blog The November issue of National Geographic Magazine features a moving photograph of chimpanzees watching the burial of one of...
Guest post by Jeremy Berlin from National Geographic's Pop Omnivore Blog The November issue of National Geographic Magazine features a moving photograph of chimpanzees watching the burial of one of...
Filed by Katherine Goldstein  |  Report Corrections
 
Comments
245
Pending Comments
0
iPhone App Promo
Post Comment

Want to reply to a comment? Hint: Click "Reply" at the bottom of the comment; after being approved your comment will appear directly underneath the comment you replied to

View Comments:
Page: 1 2 3 4 5 Next › Last » (5 pages total)
- peacekitten I'm a Fan of peacekitten 638 fans permalink
photo

rest in peace, dorothy.

it is our loss that we have grown so far apart from other animals that we do not see the wonderful things that connect us to the other animals in ourselves very often.

how lucky we are to share this planet with magnificent beings like you.

    Reply    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 12:50 PM on 10/30/2009
- nicole473 I'm a Fan of nicole473 261 fans permalink
photo

This story was so sad. Why do human beings have to diminish other animals?? It just makes me sikkk.

    Reply    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 01:15 PM on 10/30/2009
- dctackett I'm a Fan of dctackett 9 fans permalink

other animals diminish other animals... we are animals... we are just one small aspect of it all.

and we're not all that bad.

    Reply    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 05:10 PM on 10/30/2009
- dctackett I'm a Fan of dctackett 9 fans permalink

Don't say that "we do not see the wonderful things that connect us to the other animals"

Just because some people are like that doesn't mean we all are.

    Reply    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 05:09 PM on 10/30/2009
- unch I'm a Fan of unch 16 fans permalink

rip, also chimps are more humane than those on Wall Street and in Washington.

    Reply    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 12:45 PM on 10/30/2009
- Mickey7 I'm a Fan of Mickey7 29 fans permalink
photo

The fiction that human beings have the corner on emotions is slowly being eroded, but I doubt we will ever see the day when our cruelty towards 'lower' life is treated as the pathology it is (Michael Vick's return to his pre-arrest life as if what he did was simply 'bad judgment,' rather than extreme psychopathology is just one example). We can't even bring ourselves to part with our precious currency in order to make sure other humans have access to basic health care, so concerning ourselves with the plight of other life forms is simply too advanced a concept for general human society in our current state. We have the luxury of conscious choice. Animals do not. That we have squandered that ability and chosen to devolve rather than evolve in terms of our interaction with the rest of life on this planet is our tragedy. It's just too bad that they have to suffer for it.

    Reply    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 12:16 PM on 10/30/2009
- Agent86 I'm a Fan of Agent86 548 fans permalink
photo

fantastic post, mickey.

    Reply    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 12:45 PM on 10/30/2009
- peacekitten I'm a Fan of peacekitten 638 fans permalink
photo

beautiful, mickey, and so true.

    Reply    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 12:46 PM on 10/30/2009
- AtheistUS I'm a Fan of AtheistUS 80 fans permalink
photo

As much as we are starting to realize our faults, I still doubt that any other species that would come on top of food chain instead of us would be any better. Why would this happen?

All species change environment to their advantage as far as they can, and we are not an exception. I cannot agree with your claim that we "...chosen to devolve rather than evolve in terms of our interaction with the rest of life on this planet...".

We just happened to be stronger, and it is time that we realize just how strong we are and take a hard look at what we are doing.

We are counted by billions, and primates of some other kinds are counted by tens of thousands. We secured our niche, and need to leave large wild territories for other species, free from our development. We need to do this for ourselves, for our identity, we define who we are by this as much as by art or science.

Back to your post again - I cannot agree with you and with many others here who single out humans as something so terrible that the planet would be better off without. We happened to be stronger, but behaved so far not much better than other species (or not enough better), and we are coming to a point at which we have to be much better.

    Reply    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 01:27 PM on 10/30/2009
- dctackett I'm a Fan of dctackett 9 fans permalink

yes, relatively speaking we are just coming to understand ourselves and our current place... with plenty of growth ahead of us.

and of course it's so hard for human individuals to see that and they think we are so terrible or society is falling apart... but those people seem to balance out and play their part in our human family.

    Reply    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 05:03 PM on 10/30/2009
- Chip W I'm a Fan of Chip W 18 fans permalink

We are the one animal who has a profoundly negative impact on the ecology of this planet. We're the one who makes it more and more difficult for other animals to survive.
If one values life, this planet would be better off without us.

    Reply    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 04:11 AM on 11/01/2009

To compare our species with other species who might theoretically function as predatory as ours does is part of our weakness as a species. Whether or not other species might do as we have done is quite beside the point. Human expansion has meant displacing and/or destroying other species for short-term gain. Yes, our species is "strong," if you equate strength with predatory and destructive presence. Would that our species were wise.

Isn't it amazing that we are amazed that primates mourn. What might we learn from that about ourselves, that is, if we could set aside our illusion of being strong? But that might mean that we would see ourselves more nearly as we are.

    Reply    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 08:52 AM on 11/01/2009
- dctackett I'm a Fan of dctackett 9 fans permalink

we may not see the day when cruelty towards other animals is treated as the pathology it is... that is, if you mean world wide... Just about everyone I know does see it that way...

keep in mind that growth is a slow process and just because we won't see something in our life times doesn't mean it won't happen.

How long did it take life to reach the state of humanity?

    Reply    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 05:08 PM on 10/30/2009
photo

Thank you. It is true.

    Reply    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 08:16 AM on 11/26/2009
- Lordcron I'm a Fan of Lordcron 29 fans permalink
photo

why are people so amazed at monkeys showing concern over one of there own..... Are human really so arrogant to believe we hold all the card on emotions? What, Other Animal can't feel compassion? We don't corner the market on concern for our own. Yes all in the animal kingdom have feelings....

    Reply    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 11:43 AM on 10/30/2009
- dctackett I'm a Fan of dctackett 9 fans permalink

yes, many humans are so arrogant... especially when they believe they are a special creation by a magical being.

    Reply    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 04:55 PM on 10/30/2009
- HalEBurton I'm a Fan of HalEBurton 23 fans permalink
photo

Just outside of the camera frame is the Phelps family protesting and carrying signs saying God Hates Gay Chimps. B@stards.

    Reply    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 08:12 AM on 10/30/2009

:-DDD

    Reply    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 06:33 PM on 10/31/2009
photo

Would it have been better if they had been able to touch her over an extended time to better understand her lifeless condition?

What do chimps get to know of life and death and when do they get to know it?

    Reply    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 08:03 AM on 10/30/2009

I'd be willing to bet that such an institution would have allowed that to happen prior to burial. For all we know she passed away while with her companions. Plus, a corpse doesn't last long in that environment, so I don't know exactly how good that would have been to "touch her over an extended time".

    Reply    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 08:26 AM on 10/30/2009

Wow. The chimps all look sullen, sad, and respectful. Very similar to the looks one sees at a human funeral.

    Reply    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 02:24 AM on 10/30/2009
photo

Perhaps like children at a funeral.

    Reply    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 08:05 AM on 10/30/2009
- dctackett I'm a Fan of dctackett 9 fans permalink

They are our distant cousins.

    Reply    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 04:53 PM on 10/30/2009

I applaud the management for allowing the chimpanzees to view the burial, but the distance imposed on the chimps bothers me. Wouldn't it have been kinder or more appropriate to allow them past the barricade so that they could get closer to Dorothy? Touch her perhaps?

    Reply    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 12:55 AM on 10/30/2009
- wadenelson1 I'm a Fan of wadenelson1 245 fans permalink
photo

I don't recall if it was this particular one or not but on a TV special I saw they had to forcibly "herd" the others away otherwise they wouldn't allow the humans near the deceased monkey, even after decomp was well started.

    Reply    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 01:06 AM on 10/30/2009
- wadenelson1 I'm a Fan of wadenelson1 245 fans permalink
photo

Chimps are capable of a wide range of emotions. Here's a cute picture of them expresing several:

http://z.about.com/d/politicalhumor/1/0/l/7/bush_chimp.jpg

    Reply    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 12:54 AM on 10/30/2009

Love it!

    Reply    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 01:33 AM on 10/30/2009
photo

Those are great!

    Reply    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 03:20 AM on 10/30/2009
photo

Classic.

    Reply    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 08:09 AM on 10/30/2009

It caught my eye because you just don't see that much emotion--human emotion--with animals

The assumption that human emotion is the standard-I am having trouble with that-

    Reply    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 12:47 AM on 10/30/2009
photo

Elephants toss dirt on their deceased and will come back years later to visit the bones. They may even take a bone with them when they have to move on.

    Reply    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 01:13 AM on 10/30/2009

Emotions are not "human." The physical expressiveness that communicates them is specific to the animal, and chimps happen to have similar faces. All animals have similar emotions. When fish are afraid, they don't widen their eyes and open their mouths. Dogs grin and wag their tails when they are happy. We lack tails, so our "human emotions" are limited.

    Reply    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 08:51 AM on 10/30/2009
- dctackett I'm a Fan of dctackett 9 fans permalink

excuse me dano, but humans are primates and are related to these chimps, these emotions that they show are not "human emotions", they are just emotions... they are just being displayed by a different animal. Humans aren't the one animal with the ability to be emotional.

    Reply    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 04:52 PM on 10/30/2009

I should have put the first part of my post in quotations-I was just commenting on the author's suggestion of the application of human emotion to animals. I do not believe humans have the corner on the market in the emotions department. Thanks for all the comments.

    Reply    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 02:25 PM on 10/31/2009
- jse17 I'm a Fan of jse17 8 fans permalink
photo

Thankfully at least 54% of us set the bar somewhat above the previous vile and repugnant standard! Yes, it may well be hopeless but if we give up, this characteriztion becomes inevitable.

R.I.P. Dorothy.

    Reply    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 11:14 PM on 10/29/2009
photo

Great photo - great story. Thanks for the post. I continue to be awed by the incredible creatures we share this planet with.

    Reply    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 11:13 PM on 10/29/2009

Ditto!

    Reply    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 01:34 AM on 10/30/2009
- dctackett I'm a Fan of dctackett 9 fans permalink

yes, and not just "share the planet with" but grew out of, arose from, the plant with... all animals are our distant cousins, other primates are very close to us.

    Reply    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 04:50 PM on 10/30/2009
- Ric NYC I'm a Fan of Ric NYC 6 fans permalink

Chimps have more feelings than Bush, Cheney, Condoleezza...

    Reply    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 10:17 PM on 10/29/2009

We have all heard of George W. Bush be referred to as a "Chimp", but , I think Chimps are smarter!
Obama might not be doing everything "Right", but at least he is not the dumbest person in the room.

Thank you for the photo and story on Dorothy. There is a link further down where you can make a donation or even go further and sponsor a chimp. Thank everyone for all that they do to help th helpless!

    Reply    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 12:37 AM on 10/30/2009
- mlaiuppa I'm a Fan of mlaiuppa 39 fans permalink
photo

I'm glad her family was allowed to witness the funeral. It gave them closure.

Animals understand death. What they don't understand is the sudden disappearance of a pack member. Allowing them to see the departed gives them closure.

Dog and cat owners know this. I'm sure it holds true for other animals as well.

    Reply    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 09:18 PM on 10/29/2009
- bootooyoo I'm a Fan of bootooyoo 7 fans permalink

The story says that some of them "displayed aggression and others barked in frustration". What makes the workers think that the chimps understand that she was actually dead, and not being buried alive? What happens to a dead chimp in the wild? Maybe that's what should have happened here.

    Reply    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 11:15 PM on 10/29/2009

Chimps in the wild often mourn for days over their dead.

    Reply    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 12:37 AM on 10/30/2009
- dctackett I'm a Fan of dctackett 9 fans permalink

chimps and other primates, including humans (yes, humans are primates too), mourn their dead. I've seen plenty of humans "displayed aggression" and "barked in frustration" over the loss of a loved one.

what happens in the wild would probably cause disease in an enclosed sanctuary... the workers are wise to remove the dead chimp... and it's pretty nice of them (who spend their lives actually working with these distant cousins of ours) to allow them to witness her burial.

    Reply    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 04:45 PM on 10/30/2009
- tanya1111 I'm a Fan of tanya1111 99 fans permalink
photo

Clearly the chimps are democrat. Republican chimps would not have cared.

    Reply    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 09:17 PM on 10/29/2009
- outloudfll I'm a Fan of outloudfll 4 fans permalink

You gave me my morning laugh (or was it a mourning laugh?). :)

    Reply    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 08:08 AM on 10/30/2009
Page: 1 2 3 4 5 Next › Last » (5 pages total)

 You must be logged in to comment. Log in  or connect with 

Connect