World Series Instant Replay Call Changes Game, Helps Yankees Beat Phillies

digg Share this on Facebook Huffpost - World Series Instant Replay Call Changes Game, Helps Yankees Beat Phillies stumble reddit del.ico.us RSS


First Posted: 11- 1-09 11:31 AM   |   Updated: 11- 2-09 11:45 PM

What's Your Reaction?
Arod

(AP) PHILADELPHIA - Guess who showed up for Halloween dressed as sluggers?

The New York Yankees and Alex Rodriguez, whose double clanked off a television camera in the right-field corner and was ruled a home run in the first instant replay call in World Series history.

It changed the game.

"I think it woke our offense up a little bit," Rodriguez said after the Yankees rallied for a rain-delayed 8-5 victory over the Philadelphia Phillies on Saturday night that gave them a 2-1 Series lead.

Rodriguez and the rest of those dangerous New York bats finally broke loose to back another postseason win by Andy Pettitte.

Game 4 is Sunday night. Joe Blanton pitches against Yankees ace CC Sabathia, who goes on three days' rest for the second time this postseason.

After pitching dominated the first two games in the Bronx, the Yankees and defending champion Phillies flexed their muscles, combining for six home runs at cozy Citizens Bank Park. Jayson Werth connected twice for Philadelphia.

Rain affected the Series schedule in Philly for the second consecutive year, delaying the start by 1 hour, 20 minutes. Once they hit the field in front of their boisterous fans, the Phillies built a 3-0 lead -- but it was squandered by a struggling Cole Hamels, last year's World Series MVP.

Story continues below
advertisement

A slumping Nick Swisher and pinch-hitter Hideki Matsui also went deep for the Bronx Bombers, while Johnny Damon hit a tiebreaking, two-run double.

"This was my first time coming to this ballpark. It just seems like you're going to have a slugfest a lot," Swisher said. "It was a great day for us."

Pettitte settled down after a shaky start and even helped himself at the plate with a tying single. His six-inning outing was enough to earn his 17th postseason win, extending his major league record.

"He closed off our left-handed hitters," Philadelphia manager Charlie Manuel said.

Especially slugger Ryan Howard. The NL championship series MVP is 2 for 13 with nine strikeouts in the Series.

"Go home and go to sleep. I'm a simple guy," he said. "We're not going to panic by any means just because we're down in the Series."

Some fans were dressed in Phillies red, others in full costume for the second-ever World Series game on Halloween. They whipped around white rally towels, but the trick was on them -- their team got whipped when the Yankees rallied.

Carlos Ruiz homered for the Phillies in the ninth off Phil Hughes. Mariano Rivera finished up at 12:42 a.m. in a non-save situation.

"It was an absolute grind tonight, that's for sure," Pettitte said. "I can't remember winning a game where I've struggled like I did tonight. So it's very gratifying."

With the Yankees down three runs, Mark Teixeira walked in the fourth and Rodriguez hit an opposite-field drive into the right-field corner. He cruised into second base after the ball ricocheted back onto the field.

Video replays, however, showed the ball struck the lens of a television camera positioned just above the fence at the 330-foot sign. New York manager Joe Girardi came out to talk with right-field umpire Jeff Nelson as Phillies pitching coach Rich Dubee visited the mound.

While Rodriguez chatted with Howard at second base, umpires huddled in the infield. Four of the six went under the stands for a look at the replay and emerged about a minute later.

The signal: home run.

Baseball adopted instant replay for boundary calls during the 2008 season and Rodriguez homered the first time it was used last year.

"It's only fitting, right?" he said.

Rodriguez's first hit in nine World Series at-bats was his sixth homer this postseason, tying Bernie Williams' club record from 1996. It also was the 17th postseason homer this year for the Yankees, setting a franchise mark.

The call seemed to give the Yankees a boost and help them break out of their Series slump -- the team that led the majors in runs (915) and homers (244) during the regular season scored only four times in the first two games at home.

"Tonight I was a lot more disciplined, and better results," Rodriguez said.

New York kept hitting in the fifth and chased Hamels. Benched in Game 2 at home, Swisher opened with a double and slid home with the tying run when Pettitte looped a one-out single to center on a first-pitch breaking ball.

It was Pettitte's third hit in 18 career postseason at-bats, second in World Series play.

Who needs a designated hitter?

The Fox broadcast caught Derek Jeter saying to plate umpire Brian Gorman: "We're going to have to listen to Pettitte now. He's been bragging about his hitting all year."

Jeter fisted a soft single and Damon cracked a two-run double to right-center for a 5-3 lead. Hamels was lifted after another walk to Teixeira and walked off the mound to a mix of boos and cheers.

The lanky left-hander, who was 4-0 with a 1.80 ERA in the postseason last year, fell to 1-2 with a 7.58 ERA in four outings this time around.

Swisher homered off rookie J.A. Happ in the sixth and took a long look at his solo shot to left.

Werth answered leading off the bottom half with a mammoth drive off the facing of the second deck in left. After connecting, he slammed his bat to the ground and glared into the Philadelphia dugout as if to urge on his teammates.

It was Werth's seventh home run this postseason, one shy of the major league record held by Carlos Beltran (2004) and Barry Bonds (2002).

Jorge Posada's RBI single in the seventh gave New York a three-run cushion. Matsui added an opposite-field solo shot to left in the eighth, his second homer in two games.

Matsui was on the bench because World Series rules don't permit a DH in National League parks.

Pettitte fell behind 3-0 in the second. Werth reached down for a breaking ball and hit a leadoff homer to left, setting off fireworks and lighting up the Liberty Bell in right-center.

With the bases loaded, Jimmy Rollins walked to force in a run and Shane Victorino added a sacrifice fly.

Pettitte avoided further damage by striking out Chase Utley, then settled in and held Philadelphia in check. That gave the Yankees a chance to come back.

The Phillie Phanatic was wearing a rain-slicker and fisherman's hat when he high-fived Mike Schmidt as the Hall of Famer walked to the mound to throw out the first pitch to Howard.

The grounds crew was still drying puddles on the warning track as the Phillies took the field.

Last season, Game 5 of the World Series between the Phillies and Tampa Bay was suspended for two days because of rain. Once it resumed -- in the sixth inning -- the Phillies went on to a 4-3 victory that clinched the championship.

Last year's Game 3 started at 10:06 p.m. because of rain and didn't end until 1:47 a.m. It was the latest start in Series history.

NOTES: The Phillies dropped to 11-2 at home the past two postseasons. ... Nine of the last 10 teams to win Game 3 when the World Series was tied 1-all went on to take the title. The exception was the 2003 Yankees, who lost the next three games to Florida.

(AP) PHILADELPHIA - Guess who showed up for Halloween dressed as sluggers? The New York Yankees and Alex Rodriguez, whose double clanked off a television camera in the right-field corner and was rule...
(AP) PHILADELPHIA - Guess who showed up for Halloween dressed as sluggers? The New York Yankees and Alex Rodriguez, whose double clanked off a television camera in the right-field corner and was rule...
Filed by Nick Graham  |  Report Corrections
 
Comments
146
Pending Comments
0
iPhone App Promo
Post Comment

Want to reply to a comment? Hint: Click "Reply" at the bottom of the comment; after being approved your comment will appear directly underneath the comment you replied to

View Comments:
Page: 1 2 3 Next › Last » (3 pages total)

Whine, whine,whine. Would you like some cheese with that? The rules are the rules and the umps stated beforehand that if the ball hits a camera, it's a homer. Umpiring has been horrible all year long, so don't complain when things aren't going your team' s way now. Yankees up 3-1! Go Yanks!

    Reply    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 12:37 AM on 11/02/2009

Bwaaahahahaha Yankees lead series 3 - 1. Philly lost both games at home, what a glorious weekend this has turned out to be. Hey tell me again how the umps are against Philly, I never get tired of hearing that.

    Reply    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 11:49 PM on 11/01/2009
- jingles32 I'm a Fan of jingles32 86 fans permalink
photo

Hehehehehe!!! No replay needed tonight, was there??? Woo hoo! ARod clutch, great, GREAT game by Johnny and hey Mr. Manuel, maybe you'll one day you'll (as you said you already had) "figure out" Mo, but I doubt it!!!

    Reply    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 12:38 AM on 11/02/2009

Awww another sore loser posting his wittle youtube video. This is all you have little Philly fan, your rancid town and its third rate team will always be a collection of losers.

    Reply    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 07:13 AM on 11/02/2009
photo

I am unbiased and clearly saw that the ball hit by A-Rod was a home run, have a good day.

    Reply    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 11:25 PM on 11/01/2009
- Democrab I'm a Fan of Democrab 19 fans permalink
photo

Teixeira was awarded 1st base on strike three, then Arod hits a ball that's trajectory would have carried it into the front of the fence, not over. Instead of Arod on second with two outs, the Yankees get a two run gift from the umpires. The original call was a double and no-one seemed to have figured the ball's trajectory into the equation of whether or not there was enough evidence to reverse the call on the field.

    Reply    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 10:59 PM on 11/01/2009
- jingles32 I'm a Fan of jingles32 86 fans permalink
photo

The ball's "trajectory" took into the lens of the camera...mounted above the wall...w/o the camera? Would have landed in one of the Philly fan's big, arrogant, mouths. Today we shut all your mouths, no replay required.

    Reply    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 12:45 AM on 11/02/2009
- austin4 I'm a Fan of austin4 240 fans permalink

I guess if a sea gull is flying over and A-rod,,hits the bird,,,they will give him a home run for that....

    Reply    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 09:51 PM on 11/01/2009
- austin4 I'm a Fan of austin4 240 fans permalink

The empires,,,gave that game to the Yankees,,,for a better word,,,,,,they stole that game.

    Reply    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 09:48 PM on 11/01/2009
- x27 I'm a Fan of x27 34 fans permalink
photo

its not over

    Reply    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 11:26 PM on 11/01/2009

LOL, yea they stole that game. For what its worth the umpiring in this world series has been horrible. There have been bad calls on both sides. Eventually the team that has a better pitching staff will win - that team just happens to not be the Phillies.

    Reply    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 11:52 PM on 11/01/2009
- jingles32 I'm a Fan of jingles32 86 fans permalink
photo

Minus the HR, we STILL WON! And tonight...­delicious, delicious, delious!!! THAT is how a championship team, in a class town, gets it done!

    Reply    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 12:47 AM on 11/02/2009
photo

the time has come to widen the scope of instant replay in mlb. there are plenty of times the umpires get the call wrong. the strike and ball issue being the point. a strike out that should not have been, the ball called and then a walk that should not have been. come on baseball, get with the program and the times.

    Reply    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 09:18 PM on 11/01/2009
- Mandan I'm a Fan of Mandan 4 fans permalink
photo

Time to stop the twirling of the handkerchiefs or whatever they, are in the stands...looks stupid...just watch ..cheer ..yell, whatever but enough with the handkerchi­efs...!...­no?

    Reply    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 08:50 PM on 11/01/2009
- jingles32 I'm a Fan of jingles32 86 fans permalink
photo

I think at this point they call it a "crying towel."

    Reply    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 12:48 AM on 11/02/2009
- DarkStarr I'm a Fan of DarkStarr 2 fans permalink
photo

Go Phillies!!!

    Reply    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 08:22 PM on 11/01/2009
- GO-BAMA I'm a Fan of GO-BAMA 7 fans permalink

To all you envious cows ripping on the Yankees - you can't deny that when the Yanks are playing at their best, when they're in the playoff's and make it to the series, it's great for all of baseball. This has been a great series so far. There have been bad calls throughout this post season - some have worked for the Yankees, and some against.

    Reply    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 07:23 PM on 11/01/2009
- pflickner I'm a Fan of pflickner 6 fans permalink
photo

I personally don't care -- they're the best team that money can buy and the Phils outshine them any day. That aside, this was a correct call. They do need to create a rule for any future camera-tips to avoid all of the rigamarole around this. But the call was correct, as much as I hated seeing it. I want my Phils to win and have been "threatened" while wearing my Phillies World Series cap (really, more mocked than anything). Just don't make fun. Our boys were unshaven bums while the Braves prided themselves on being clean-shaving, neat, and pretty. Too bad the braves didn't spend as much time practicing; might've helped their game to get a little scruffy. ;-)

    Reply    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 07:42 PM on 11/01/2009

Really, baseball as a major contender for our interest? It is more like which corporation should you support more. Sure, these are great athletes but their strings are being pulled by the "bottom line" considerations and there is definitely no loyalty to the fan beyond lip service or raking in sales dollars. So go ahead and paint your body or face red, or green, or whatever and cheer or yell till tears stream down your face. Just remember, you are merely a customer. Let us see it for what it really is.

    Reply    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 06:21 PM on 11/01/2009

yawn......

    Reply    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 07:22 PM on 11/01/2009
- Harry Lowe I'm a Fan of Harry Lowe 4 fans permalink
photo

Last I checked, everything is corporate. If you want to be cynical about everything, that's up to you, but you're making a mountain out of a molehill.

And, believe it or not, some BASEBALL players play because they like BASEBALL. The money helps, yes, but most of them genuinely love the game. They weren't born into MLB, they had to play 16, 17 hard years to get there. One more thing: there are players who like where they play too, just like in every other profession.

    Reply    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 07:25 PM on 11/01/2009
- pflickner I'm a Fan of pflickner 6 fans permalink
photo

Don't watch and don't comment. If you don't like baseball, who cares?

    Reply    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 07:43 PM on 11/01/2009
- oldfuzz I'm a Fan of oldfuzz 2 fans permalink
photo

If this was tennis we might say they are "on serve". To stay on the Phillies must win two of the remaining four and the Yankees the same.

Yes, I'm a Yankee fan (since 1948... somethings never change), but I'd be happy to see the Series go seven Games two unknowns relieving in the 23rd inning.

Both teams are great and the umps are, have always been human.

    Reply    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 05:33 PM on 11/01/2009
- annie0107 I'm a Fan of annie0107 19 fans permalink
photo

right on, sir.

    Reply    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 05:55 PM on 11/01/2009
- pflickner I'm a Fan of pflickner 6 fans permalink
photo

Yep, and as a Phillies fan, I can attest that the umps made the right call. That ball would have been over the fence had it not been for the camera.

    Reply    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 07:45 PM on 11/01/2009

I'm glad the Phillies lost. I wanted the E-gals to beat the Gnats which they did. But I hate Philly so the fans there can continue to be miserable losers. Cry little Philthadelphia fans cry.

    Reply    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 05:22 PM on 11/01/2009

Grow up tough guy

    Reply    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 07:18 PM on 11/01/2009
- pflickner I'm a Fan of pflickner 6 fans permalink
photo

Awww, does baby want a lollipop? Will that make widdle baby feel better?

    Reply    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 07:44 PM on 11/01/2009

Baseball needs to look at how they use instant replay in cricket. None of the umps go under the hood to look at the replay.

    Reply    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 05:21 PM on 11/01/2009
photo

Not picking sides, here, but instant replay in baseball is just plain blasphemy.

First the DH in the American League killed the science of manufacturing runs and transformed the art of baseball management into the two dimensional mechanical task of game-day coaching. Then they threw in the wild card team and destroyed the beauty of the marathon pennant race. Then steroids sullied the most legend laced history in all of professional sports. Then they robbed my Expos of a World Series run in 1994 with a lockout, and robbed me of my Expos a decade later. And now they're making calls by replay, thereby mutating the judicial profession of the baseball umpire into that of the coldest of automatons, the mere referee? Well count me out. I'm done.

Where have you gone, Joe DiMaggio? Joltin' Joe has left and gone away.

The era of sport is a bygone age. R.I.P.

    Reply    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 04:41 PM on 11/01/2009

The only reason you are saying this is because your team lost. If the shoe was on the other foot you would be screaming like a little girl for instant replay. This is right, they got the call right and the game was decided on the right call.

    Reply    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 05:19 PM on 11/01/2009
photo

Nope. My team was 'disappeared' a half a decade ago by the powers that be. I've gone from being a rabid ball fan who watched 50 - 100 GAMES per year every year since I was 12 years old (24 years ago) to a man who watches maybe 15-20 regular season INNINGS, total, and 20-30 playoff INNINGS, total, per year. Sick of guys like Bonds and McGwire breaking near sacred records with the assistance of drugs, tired of all the tinkering with what was always, to me, the most beautiful game ever conceived. Although they are not my team, I appreciate the Yankees as much as any true ball fan. I like the Phillies because they represent the National League East Division that I fell in love with as a young boy, but aside from that I have no horse in the race. And like any true fan, I don't ever blame a loss on one arbitrary call concerning one random bounce of the ball. It's the aesthetics of replay itself that has me disgusted. Baseball is more than a game. It's sport, art, and philosophy all rolled up into one. While MLB has been wise enough to resist the shifts like aluminum bats, it took thirty years for the baseball world to concede that Astroturf and retractable roof domes cheapened the game. I just hope it doesn't take so long for them to come to their senses with replay.

    Reply    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 07:59 PM on 11/01/2009
- Grabit I'm a Fan of Grabit 5 fans permalink

I agree that instant replay is (mostly) blasphemy for baseball, but not for close home run calls. It's a long way to the outfield wall, and the human eye can only absorb so much in so little time.

But replay for everything? No way. I'll never watch baseball again myself if every 9-inning game takes 6 hours to finish.

    Reply    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 06:48 PM on 11/01/2009

Oh please...

Nothing like those "marathon" races where one team runs away from the pack, and the race is over by early August.

The wild card is the best thing that happened to the sport in 30 years. More teams have a chance, more fans interested until the very end

And I'm sure Joe DiMaggio would have liked to have the replay a few times. I don't know if he would have liked the expansion teams, Expos fan.

    Reply    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 07:53 PM on 11/01/2009
- pflickner I'm a Fan of pflickner 6 fans permalink
photo

I can understand your point of view -- baseball has not been the only holdout. Soccer doesn't have instant replay and no one is upset about that. However, I can understand the desire for the instant replay. I remember several times where there was a bad call, KNEW they made a bad call, and didn't care because they wee the umps and no one could say a word because, as far as they were concerned, they were god. Now, not so much. At least in soccer, the refs don't act as though they're above the rules and can make them up as they go.

    Reply    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 08:36 PM on 11/01/2009

What exactly are you going to replay in soccer? Did the ball cross the goal line? That happens how many times in a year? Usually soccer goals are pretty clear.

    Reply    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 06:57 AM on 11/02/2009
photo

See, I don't consider Baseball a mere athletic competition. A baseball game, season, and career are works of art. Success isn't defined by athletics alone. Other factors are involved, one being the art of playing the umpire. For instance, casual fans ask why managers throw fits on bad calls; everyone knows the Ump won't change the call so why risk getting ejected? The answer is there's a 162 game season to consider. The manager knows his fit will be replayed, along with the controversial call, over and over on the sports highlights. What happens next time there's a close call? Does an Ump rule against the manager who's likely to expose him ad infinitum on national TV if he's wrong, or the manager who's likely to let the controversial play fade away quietly by game's end? That's art, baby. Ditto for pitchers and catchers who are in the dugout before the Ump's made a call on a close third strike to end an inning, or the batter who's halfway to first before the Ump's called a close ball four. Things like instant replay slowly transform the game from one that transcends boundaries of space and time with it's imaginary and mutable strike zone, foul lines that extend into infinity, and a final inning that can continue on indefinitely until the final out's been recorded, making no deficit insurmountable, into a sport of sharp lines and stop-watches, a la pro football.

    Reply    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 08:32 AM on 11/02/2009
Page: 1 2 3 Next › Last » (3 pages total)

 You must be logged in to comment. Log in  or connect with 

Connect