Joaquin Rivera Robbed While Dying In Emergency Room: UPDATE (VIDEO)

Huffington Post/AP   First Posted: 03/18/10 06:12 AM ET Updated: 05/25/11 03:50 PM ET

UPDATE: Authorities have released footage of the terrible robbery:

********

PHILADELPHIA (Associated Press) - A school counselor suffering an apparent heart attack died in a Philadelphia emergency room after waiting nearly 80 minutes for help – and a trio of homeless drug addicts nearby stole his watch instead of seeking aid, police said.

Joaquin Rivera, 63, died before seeing a triage nurse at Atria Health's Frankford Campus over the weekend, police said.

Rivera, a musician and activist in the city's Latino community, had spent more than 30 years working as a bilingual counselor at an inner-city high school.

"We're all destroyed. A guy like that, for him to leave us the way that he did – and with what happened to him – everybody's destroyed," said Jesse Bermudez, a friend and fellow musician.

Rivera's cruel end was captured on security videotape, much like the June 2008 death of Esmin Green, who died on a hospital floor as staffers at Kings County Hospital Center in Brooklyn ignored her. Green's family recently settled a lawsuit against the city for $2 million.

Rivera had walked to the Northeast Philadelphia hospital late Saturday from his home a few blocks away after pain started shooting down his right side. He registered at 10:45 p.m. and took a seat, chatting for about 20 minutes with two men and a woman nearby.

Based on witness accounts, police believe Rivera passed out about an hour later. Security video then shows one of the men steal his watch and briefly pass it to the other.

"There's no resistance from Mr. Rivera at all, which is why we believe he's probably dead. There's no stirring from him," said Capt. Jack McGinnis, a city detective.

The second suspect is then seen by doctors, and a security guard arrives to ask his sleeping companions to leave. A witness first reports that Rivera may be dead.

At 12:04 a.m., he is pronounced dead.

"You would hope he would have died with dignity," McGinnis said.

Aria Health offered condolences to the family Tuesday but otherwise declined comment, citing patient confidentiality and the pending criminal case.

McGinnis describes the three suspects as homeless drug addicts. Police arrested one of them, 44-year-old Richard Alten, at the hospital and are searching for the others.

Detectives have seen the video footage, but Aria Health had not yet produced a copy for them, McGinnis said. Police hope to publicize it to find the missing pair.

Drug addicts, he said, will steal from family – or the dead.

"It seems despicable, but they would do it," McGinnis said. "(The death) seemed like a perfect opportunity."

Alten remains in custody, and the public defender's office representing him declined comment.

A preliminary ruling suggests Rivera died of hypertension. He is survived by his wife and three children.

Rivera also leaves behind a rich musical legacy that includes local radio and TV appearances in which he shared the music he learned as a boy in the mountains of Cayey, Puerto Rico. He also inspired countless Olney High School students to attend college, Bermudez said.

Bermudez last saw his friend Saturday afternoon, when they played together at Centro Musical, a neighborhood music store that serves as a gathering place for Latino musicians.

"Without him, the traditional folk music of Puerto Rico wouldn't be alive here in Philadelphia," Bermudez said.

*******

Video of Esmin Green's death in June 2008:

FOLLOW HUFFPOST NEW YORK

UPDATE: Authorities have released footage of the terrible robbery: ...
UPDATE: Authorities have released footage of the terrible robbery: ...
 
 
  • Comments
  • 346
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
Page: 1 2 3 4 5  Next ›  Last »  (7 total)
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
BabaLou7
Insignificant, yet eternal God Fractal
10:29 AM on 12/04/2009
The waiting room was EMPTY before the itinerant men entered!!! Why did Mr. Rivera not receive any help???
03:25 PM on 12/04/2009
Agreed.
That is the real story here.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
BabaLou7
Insignificant, yet eternal God Fractal
07:31 AM on 12/04/2009
I've known Mr. Rivera for the last 20 years. He kept traditional Puerto Rican music alive in the city of Philadelphia and passed the knowledge along to his community's youth. It is devastating to think of his last hours being what they were.
11:36 PM on 12/06/2009
i want to say i am sorry for your loss,babalou7,he sounds like a fine man and a tremendose loss for our puerto rican community. i was born and rasied in new york city so i know all to well how disgusting emergency rooms can be,,if there is any more of a reason for a public option this is it. i pray for his family and i hope they sue that hospital for all they can get.that is the only way you can hurt hospital and thats in there pocket..i hope all republicans read this story and heed,,providing republicans have a heart or soul for that matter.

very respectfully yours.

alberto.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
DrCardio
01:42 AM on 12/04/2009
The capitalist infrastructure has taken over government, the senate fails with obstructionism and sellouts, the health insurance companies have too much power, and news networks are run by perspective oriented moguls. We are prisoners of school loans, and particularly graduate school loans (medical); we are indebted to credit cards; our schools are failing; our citizens cant find jobs because the private sector is enjoying the profits they are making by employing less people or outsourcing every conceivable job to China. We are at a crossroads, and I hope we can just wake the F up and do something worthwhile before we do as the Romans did.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
DrCardio
01:41 AM on 12/04/2009
Reprehensible, absolutely disgusting. I can't believe another preventable death. I feel so so bad for this guy, oh my God. The saddest thing is that he died all by himself in the chill of night from a broken heart, all while these thugs grabbed money to buy themselves some drugs. This country fails, and I have been catching myself wanting to move out, and that feeling makes me sooo sad. We had the potential of becoming the pillar of hope and freedom, the guiding light in this darkened world; but we havent even decided if tax paying should cover the healthcare of our neighbors. We are selfish, greedy, cold and emotionless, and we are moving farther and farther away from the ideals that we project. Its absolutely shameful that he didnt feel comfortable enough with his primary care doctor, to call him (if he even had one). And too bad that all the people jamming the emergency room dont have primary care doctors either, and decide to come into the emergency room for everything from diarrhea to a headache. Trust me, I've been there. We are not an example to the world, we have become a laughing stock. We can gloat that we have the fanciest cars, the cleanest streets, and the best military?
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
01:15 AM on 12/04/2009
And yet the Republicans don't think that healthcare needs no change? This video is disturbing on every level. This poor soul's blood is on every anti-healthcare person's hands out there.
11:57 PM on 12/03/2009
80 minutes? And they call that an "Emergency" Room??
11:16 PM on 12/03/2009
It is unconscionable that a person with chest pain can sit in a waiting room for over 60 minutes without being seen. And letting drug addicts wander around unsupervised? No security for the patients?
Sorry, the facility is really at fault. It's just too easy to blame the "drug addicts" as being the only ones at fault here.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
edgarcaycedoc
10:14 PM on 12/03/2009
Rationed healthcare killed him. If he had good insurance, he would probably have been shuffled to the front of the line. National healthcare NOW!
photo
notb observer
Technically it's a micro auto-bio...
10:06 PM on 12/03/2009
This happens every day to many people, and goes unreported, because it it legal for health insurers to rob us and then leave us to die. Of course it's not quite as dramatic as catching someone doing it on tape, but it is just as undignified and barbaric.
photo
TheBaffler
a long the riverrun
09:49 PM on 12/03/2009
Well, at least he di--ed with dignity, without suffering the horror of socialized medicine.
01:07 PM on 12/04/2009
Despicable comment.
photo
TheBaffler
a long the riverrun
11:05 PM on 12/04/2009
How so? It was quite a witty jab at the sickening free-market, for-profit health care loons. You realize that, right?
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
MJinCanada
Safe from zombies until my 2nd cup of coffee
11:02 PM on 12/04/2009
I hope that's sarcasm.

Up here in socialized medicine Canada, a guy having a heart attack normally gets shoved to the start of the line, along with the people going into anephalactic shock or bleeding all over the place. If the triage nurse is being a twit (not every doctor or nurse graduates at the top of the class), another patient will speak up for him.
09:43 PM on 12/03/2009
This is why I admire the Saudis a good hand chopping would do the trick
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Paula Ann
10:48 PM on 12/03/2009
in saudi, they generally don't chop until the third stealling conviction; but i bet they'd make an exception in this case.
09:42 PM on 12/03/2009
I guess I was wrong. I though all along that health insurance companies are the real death panels . Now I learn that the hospitals are in on it too. Death by neglect in the ER. A law suit will surly follow and rightfully so.
09:28 PM on 12/03/2009
This is absolutely sad that this man was left medically unattended in an ER waiting room to die....and it is even worse that someone would rob this dying (or dead) man.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
StrayTalk
09:24 PM on 12/03/2009
Some folks I know (and like!) tell me we have the best health care system in the world.
I think they also believe in the Easter Bunny and the Tooth Fairy.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Paula Ann
10:51 PM on 12/03/2009
many medical facilities in the USA provide excellent health care. it's a matter of being able to afford it.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
09:07 PM on 12/03/2009
Yup. American health care. The best in the world.