Happy Birthday Brad Pitt (46) & Katie Holmes (31): Who's Aged Better?

William Bradley Pitt and Kate Noelle Holmes were born 15 years apart on December 18. Below are photos of the pair in 1999 and 2009.

Quick Poll

Who has aged better the past 10 years?

Katie

Brad

Tie

Share your vote on Facebook so your friends can take this poll

PHOTOS:

Comments

[ekeil]

12:13 AM on 12/22/2009

Katie used to be so much hotter: http://www.actressscene.com/2008/12/katie-holmes-in-gift.html

[Shzron1946]

11:33 PM on 12/20/2009

What a dim wit. How are you going to compare a man aging from 36 to 46 to a woman aging from 21 to 31? And when did HE give birth to a baby? There is no basis for comparison here. You might come a smidgen closer if you compared Pitt's aging to Jolie's, but as I asked before, when did HE go through childbirth?

I am becoming more and more disturbed at the lack of of logic in the columns on this web site. And I actually WANT to be a fan of it, I really, really do. You are making it so HARD...

[mcantwell]

07:45 PM on 12/19/2009

Jeebus! Brad Pitt is HAWT at any age! YUM-E.

[ruhaba]

12:55 AM on 12/21/2009

He is totally NOT hot.He looks dirty and tired these days .

[Yamster]

07:16 PM on 12/19/2009

Should this not be comparing two people of the SAME age?

[JCCross]

05:31 PM on 12/19/2009

Hmmm, this is an interesting question. I think it's six of one, half a dozen of the other. Which would age you faster? Having children, or being married to Angelina Jolie? Tough call?!

[LovingHope]

03:30 PM on 12/19/2009

Katie is very lucky to be married to Tom. I think he's a great husband. He is always working and seems to be a great father. I'm a Tom Cruise fan. I'm not a fan of action movies, but I usually enjoy a Tom Cruise movie. I'm going to rent "Valkyre" tonight.

[LovingHope]

03:28 PM on 12/19/2009

Brad is gorgeous, although for the last 5 years he's been looking very worn out. I wonder why? My niece and I saw "Troy" in the theater. We loved it!

[lemondade]

12:25 PM on 12/19/2009

LIGHTING HAS SOMETHING TO DO WITH HOW YOU LOOK, BECAUSE OF SHADOWS. WHETHER OR NOT SOMEONE HAS SLEPT THE NIGHT BEFORE THE PHOTO HAS SOMETHING TO DO WITH IT. NO ONE LOOKS THE SAME AS THEY DID TEN YEARS AGO.

ONLY NICOLE KIDMAN DOES BECAUSE SHE HAS HAD SO MUCH PLASTIC SURGERY AND BOTOX AND LIP INJECTIONS.

[JCCross]

05:27 PM on 12/19/2009

Jeeze... you don't have to shout! Unclick your CapsLock button before you post.

[JFaye]

10:27 AM on 12/19/2009

This is an unflattering photograph of Katie Holmes which would necessarily skew the vote ...

[Curandera]

09:39 AM on 12/19/2009

They are both beautiful people. I chose Brad over Katie because I deducted points from Katie for being skinnier now than then.

She seems very busy and looks healthy but I do miss women with curves. Especially as they age, I think the extra curves women movie stars use to have gave them a look of self-satisfaction and allure. I don't mean a lot of fat, just not so much lean. You know, Marilyn Monroe, Eva Gardner, Sophia Loren.

Brad has added a few pounds and he looks all the better for it. It adds to his attraction at 46.

[JFaye]

10:26 AM on 12/19/2009

You're right... as women get older our looks improve with curves.

[freddiefranks]

08:57 AM on 12/19/2009

Dude, Brad Pitt has got a kickass beard.

I rest my case.

[beapancake]

11:48 AM on 12/19/2009

I agree. I'm so sick of people moaning for him to cut it off! HOT.

[shirleyfeeney]

02:32 AM on 12/19/2009

*sigh*........ Brad Pitt.

[termgirl]

02:02 AM on 12/19/2009

The woman is 31 years old and we're supposed to comment on how she's "aged?'
She's beautiful.

[bpafree]

12:58 AM on 12/19/2009

Wow - Brad changed from a smooth California boy look into a Southern Byou looking sort of guy. From surfer to Grisham lawyer.

[Badgirl]

12:05 AM on 12/19/2009

Now, they look as if they are the parent of their younger self.

[freddiefranks]

08:57 AM on 12/19/2009

How incredibly... reasonable.