More

Grand Ayatollah Hossein Ali Montazeri's Mourners Protest Against Government

BRIAN MURPHY   12/21/09 05:22 PM ET   AP

Montazeri Funeral

DUBAI, United Arab Emirates — A huge funeral procession for Iran's most senior dissident cleric became a show of defiance against the country's rulers Monday as mourners flashed green protest colors and chanted against the Islamic leadership in Iran's holy city of Qom.

The response by authorities was not as punishing as in recent demonstrations – an apparent attempt to avoid bloodshed and chaos during the cortege for one of the patriarchs of the 1979 Islamic Revolution and the one-time heir to lead the country.

But the major outpouring for Grand Ayatollah Hossein Ali Montazeri by opposition supporters could signal a restive week ahead. Tens of thousands of demonstrators, if not more, filled the main boulevards in Qom, the hub of Islamic scholarship and study in mostly Shiite Iran.

Iran is marking one of the most important periods on the Shiite religious calendar with ceremonies that draw deeply on themes of martyrdom and sacrifice, which could inspire fresh opposition marches. It culminates on Sunday, the same day mourners will gather for the traditional seven-day memorial for Montazeri's death.

Opposition leaders have used holidays and other symbolic days in recent months for anti-government rallies. Montazeri, who died of apparent natural causes on Sunday at age 87, had stunned even hard-core protesters with his scathing denunciations of the ruling clerics and their efforts to crush dissent after the disputed presidential election in June.

His open assault on the highest reaches of the Islamic system helped galvanize the opposition and shatter taboos about criticizing the pinnacle of power: Supreme Leader Ayatollah Ali Khamenei.

On Monday, demonstrators chanted the now-familiar "Death to the Dictator" that's become a catchall slogan against Iran's leadership, witnesses said. Some protesters shouted specific slurs against Khamenei, according to video clips posted on the Web.

The witnesses spoke on condition of anonymity because of fear of arrest and the authenticity of the Web video could not be independently verified. The accounts, however, were consistent with reports from a variety of sources.

Iranian authorities barred foreign media from covering the funeral in Qom, about 60 miles south of Tehran. Communications also appeared disrupted.

Internet in Iran was slow, and cellular telephone service was unreliable. The government has periodically restricted communications in an attempt to prevent protesters from organizing.

But people had been streaming toward Qom since word of Montazeri's death began to spread.

Crowds were packed shoulder-to-shoulder for blocks following the truck carrying Montazeri's body. A single white turban sat atop the vehicle.

Video posted on the Web showed people beating their chests in a sign of mourning before Montazeri's body was buried in a shrine alongside his son, who died in a bomb blast in the early years of the Islamic Revolution.

Some climbed onto winter-bare tree branches for a better view of the procession – which included many mourners holding aloft both black-rimmed portraits of Montazeri and green banners and wrist bands in a powerful show of support for the Green Movement of opposition leader Mir Hossein Mousavi.

Mousavi, who was defeated in the presidential election, attended the funeral along with another prominent protest leader, Mahdi Karroubi, witnesses said. Some reformist sites reported that Mousavi's car was attacked as he left Qom and at least one member of his entourage was injured. The reports could not be independently confirmed.

Both men have faced direct confrontations from hard-line vigilantes and security forces at past rallies.

Some mourners clashed briefly with security forces and pro-government militiamen charged some protesters, opposition Web sites said. The militiamen later tore down mourning banners and ripped up posters of Montazeri near his home, where he spent five years under house arrest, the Hammihan Web site reported.

Thousands of mourners also marched in the cleric's hometown of Najafabad, near the central city of Isfahan.

Web video showed crowds of men beating their chests and chanting, "Oppressed Montazeri, you are with God now." Women in black robes shouted, "Dictator, dictator, Montazeri is alive," and "Montazeri, you who spoke the truth! Your path will be followed."

Montazeri's death left authorities in an awkward spot that could be repeated as more high-profile clerics drift toward the opposition.

They could not ignore Montazeri's role as a guiding force of the Islamic Revolution and protege of its leader, Ayatollah Ruhollah Khomeini, who selected Montazeri to succeed him. But officials also regarded him as a fearsome critic who was too venerable to silence.

State television made only a passing reference to Monday's funeral. It was, however, pouring across the Web with videos, firsthand reports that showed the inability of Iran's authorities to fully control the Internet.

Montazeri broke with the regime in the 1980s after claiming that the ruling clerics violated the ideals of the revolution by taking absolute power rather than serving as advisers to political leaders. He spent five years under house arrest and had only a minor role in political affairs after being released in 2003.

But the outrage after June's election gave him a new voice that resonated with a younger generation. His most pivotal moments came in the summer when he denounced the "despotic" tactics and "crimes" of the ruling clerics.

In demonstrations earlier this month, students shouted "Death to the dictator!" and burned pictures of Khamenei – an act that was almost unthinkable just a few months ago.

Montazeri's grandson, Nasser Montazeri, said he died in his sleep. The Web site of Iranian state television quoted doctors as saying Montazeri had suffered from asthma and arteriosclerosis, a disease that thickens and hardens arteries.

Montazeri helped draft the nation's post-revolution constitution, which was based on a concept called "velayat-e faqih," or rule by Islamic jurists. That idea enshrined a political role for Islamic clerics in the new system.

But a deep ideological rift soon developed with Khomeini. Montazeri envisioned the Islamic experts as advisers to the government, who should not have outright control to rule themselves. He was also among those clerics who believed the power of the supreme leader comes from the people, not from God.

FOLLOW HUFFPOST WORLD

DUBAI, United Arab Emirates — A huge funeral procession for Iran's most senior dissident cleric became a show of defiance against the country's rulers Monday as mourners flashed green protest co...
DUBAI, United Arab Emirates — A huge funeral procession for Iran's most senior dissident cleric became a show of defiance against the country's rulers Monday as mourners flashed green protest co...
Filed by Nicholas Sabloff  | 
 
 
  • Comments
  • 213
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
Page: 1 2 3  Next ›  Last »  (3 total)
10:03 PM on 12/21/2009
RFE: The car of Iranian opposition leader Mir Hossein Musavi was attacked by “plainclothes men” on motorbikes as he was returning to Tehran from the service in Qom and one member of his entourage was injured, one of the websites said…A reformist website, “Kaleme,” said Musavi’s car was attacked while he was returning to Tehran from the funeral and the car’s back window was smashed in the attack. “On the way back from Qom to Tehran before noon…a group of plainclothes men riding motorcycles attacked the car carrying Musavi, as a consequence of which one member of Musavi’s entourage was injured,” “Kaleme” said. “One of the assailants shattered the back window of the car carrying Musavi,” “Kaleme” said, adding that one of the attackers was also injured in the incident.

http://www.rferl.org/content/Car_Of_Iran_Oppositions_Musavi_Reported_Attacked/1910069.html
09:55 PM on 12/21/2009
Video of booing Khameni's message in the funeral:

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=M61NhkeNqzA
photo
HUFFPOST COMMUNITY MODERATOR
Khirad
09:36 PM on 12/21/2009
According to Kayhan, only 5,000 showed up.

http://www.kayhannews.ir/881001/14.htm#other1406

Them, and their parrots here do provide some pretty good satire challenging The Onion, if you can step back from what they represent.

Great obit of Montazeri's life:

http://www.pbs.org/wgbh/pages/frontline/tehranbureau/2009/12/grand-ayatollah-hossein-ali-montazeri-1922-2009.html
09:52 PM on 12/21/2009
I saw that earlier. The hired mercenaries are beginning to sound deranged...
07:51 PM on 12/21/2009
Funeral for Iranian Cleric Turns Into a Vast Protest

BEIRUT, Lebanon — The funeral of a prominent dissident cleric in the holy Iranian city of Qum turned into a vast and furious anti-government rally on Monday, raising the possibility that the cleric’s death could serve as a catalyst for an opposition movement that has been locked in a stalemate with the authorities

http://www.nytimes.com/2009/12/22/world/middleeast/22cleric.html?_r=1
07:46 PM on 12/21/2009
Looks like the revolution is on schedule.

They are following the same successful strategy as in 1979.

Admiral Mullen: You paying any attention to this?

Do you really want to get the legs out from under the Revolution by making vague threats that the hardliners can use to destroy the opposition?
07:53 PM on 12/21/2009
Precisely! The only thing that could save this regime is a war. Hope Admiral Mullen doesn't take the bait.
08:04 PM on 12/21/2009
Maybe internal Israeli politics make sense to keep enemies supplied with ammunition.

But I would hope that the Obama Administration is much smarter than that.
photo
HUFFPOST COMMUNITY MODERATOR
Khirad
08:08 PM on 12/21/2009
Exactly.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Christopher Millsap
07:11 PM on 12/21/2009
Look for this picture of hundreds of thousands of Iranians protesting on the next Fox coverage of Glenda's future Tea Party participants.
photo
HUFFPOST COMMUNITY MODERATOR
Khirad
08:08 PM on 12/21/2009
LOL!
07:08 PM on 12/21/2009
I’m terrified for the Iranian people, because I read in the paper that Khamenei intends to stamp out all protest for the holy month of Muhhram with all the means at his disposal.

Apparently, there is this group called Seyed-ol-Shohada Corps (strategically perched on the northern gateway of Tehran) to move swiftly into the metropolis and occupy all important institutions and buildings, and cut off the Iranian capital from the outside world, all within hours in case of massive uprising. The will bathe in the blood of innocent people if they have to save their neck.

Scroll down to find the comment:
http://www.iranian.com/main/2009/dec/camp-ashraf-stalemate
07:00 PM on 12/21/2009
Interesting Updates from NY Times:

Update | 3:36 p.m. According to an opposition Web site, the Montazeri family told BBC Persian that they had to cancel a funeral reception due to the presence of security forces and “martial-law-like conditions” around the family home in Qum. This photograph of the security forces around the home of Ayatollah Montazeri in Qum on Monday was published on an opposition Web site:



"Update | 2:43 p.m. It is after 11 p.m. in Iran now. About an hour ago, the Iranian-American Web site Tehran Bureau reported on Twitter that the opposition ritual of protesting by shouting the slogan “God is great,” borrowed from the revolution that toppled the Shah in 1979, was particularly intense on Monday night. Tehran Bureau wrote:

Source in Tehran: “People have gone crazy chanting Allah o Akbar from rooftops.”

One of our readers also writes to point to another parallel to that revolution:

One point I would like to make about today’s protests that I have not seen discussed in the media was its location: http://thelede.blogs.nytimes.com/2009/12/21/updates-on-dissident-clerics-funeral-in-iran/?hp
06:51 PM on 12/21/2009
Shiva Nazar Ahari
Equality activist

Interviewed by fellow activist Mahboubeh Abbas Gholi before both were arrested Sunday night:

ساعاتی پیش ( نیمه شب یکشنبه29 آذر به وقت تهران) دو شیرزن مبارز میهن ما: محبوبه عباسقلی زاده فعال جامعه زنان و از بنیانگزاران "میدان زنان" و همچنین شیوا نظرآهاری مدافع حقوق بشر در ایران، دستگیر و به نقطه نامعلومی انتقال یافتند. این گفتگوئی است که هفته گذشته (یک ماه پس از آزادی شیوا نظرآهاری با وثیقه دویست میلیون تومانی از زندان) خانم عباسقلی زاده با او انجام داده بود.

http://www.iranian.com/main/2009/dec/shiva-nazar-ahari
06:35 PM on 12/21/2009
Lates from Iran:

"Montazeri-e mazloom azaadi-at mobaarak":

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=OkuiSkTQh7g&feature=player_embedded


Translation: Innocent Montazeri, Congratulations on your freedom!

Wow!

More videos here:

http://www.iranian.com/main/2009/dec/monatzeri-funeral
06:27 PM on 12/21/2009
Grand Ayatollah Montazeri who opposed Ayatollah Khamenei is dead and now the streets and the blogs are filled with praises for him. Today Shirin Ebadi wrote a letter telling Ayatollah Montazeri how sorry she is for not appreciating him and for not joining hands with him while he was still alive. It is a beautiful Ensha' (essay) which I recommend reading. I call it Nooshdaroo pas az marge Sohrab:

http://www.iran-emrooz.net/index.php?/news1/20274/

As of today another Grand Ayatollah is still in prison after 3 years for promoting separation of religion and government.

He is very ill but still alive. He is not dead, at least not yet.

Here is our chance to make things right this time and not be sorry for not doing the right thing before it is too late

Here is an article about Ayatollah Boroujerdi on Iranian.com: http://www.iranian.com/main/blog/dw-duke/tragic-story-ayatollah-boroujerdi

and here is a petition
http://www.petitiononline.com/Maat2/petition.html
photo
HUFFPOST COMMUNITY MODERATOR
Khirad
08:10 PM on 12/21/2009
Indeed, it is despicable how they dishonor religion, and Boroujerdi is a good example, especially given his pedigree. It is one of the ironies that this rule of clerics has done more to silence and oppress dissident mujtahids than even the monarchy.
08:34 PM on 12/21/2009
True. Many clergies hate the ruling mullahs and don't believe in their brand of Islam.
photo
HUFFPOST COMMUNITY MODERATOR
Khirad
09:00 PM on 12/21/2009
From Ray Takeyh:

Khomeini, who was always contemptuous of the clergy who abjured politics, warned the "turbaned deceivers" who were "infiltrating the clergy and engaging in sabotage." In an even sterner rebuke, he declared, "I warn the clergy. I tell them all that I dislodge myself of my final responsibility to repulse all these mullahs." One of the many paradoxes of the Islamic Republic is that theocracy has been far more effective at persecuting the religious class than all of its monarchical predecessors. A special court for the clergy was established, and hundreds of Iran's most learned and distinguished clerics were defrocked and imprisoned.
photo
Pod-gers
Jeremy Lin = Game Change
04:57 PM on 12/21/2009
A fair discussion of Iran needs less extreemism, and more good faith exchange of ideas.

I am not surprised that my views have come under fire by those extreemists. Extreemists on both sides only polarise the situation. Adding pressure results in tragedy, not freedom.

here is a brief video of Iran from the point of view fo the "opposition." I am not afraid to view and understand all points of view. I do wish others posting here could be more open minded, and more honest. Please try not to barinwash those who stop by to read this thread.

This video does not really address the "issues." There are several other points of view. One thing is certain, US involvement in Iran has hurt the Iranian people. Continued involvement is also hurting the Iranian people.

I am opposed to our current policies in Iran. I am opposed to the constant "opposition" trying to whip up support for regime change. In my opinion there is a better way, but we cannot even explore alternatives when such extreem rhetoric is spewed, and verbal name calling and other attacks are directed at those who post opinions different from yours on this thread. One thing is sure, if your definition of freedom means directing hateful attacks at those who disagree with you, then you are not ready for "freedom."
photo
Pod-gers
Jeremy Lin = Game Change
04:58 PM on 12/21/2009
Ooops, forgot the link...

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=fy3KDYE5KQE
photo
HUFFPOST COMMUNITY MODERATOR
Khirad
02:25 AM on 12/22/2009
So, by saying this is from the point of view of the "opposition", you mean to say you don't agree with any of it? It was b-a-s-i-c Iranian history. And I don't see how you could agree with a pretty reasonable video (though naive on 2-3 minor points), and extrapolate from it the wild conspiracy theories you parrot from IRI media (whether intentionally or not).

And by "issues" you mean "New World Order", "Bilderberg Group", and "Bohemian Grove"? How about reptilian humanoids? I guess if you don't agree with the poster of that video, than that's good, and that I'd be wrong with presuming that. But after all, you've already done enough of presuming our views, so it's only fair.
05:07 PM on 12/21/2009
So you slander the opposition as stooges doing the bidding of US, think IRI is pro women's rights, and laugh at Amnesty International- and then call those who challenge your fantasies 'intolerant' and in the dark re: freedom?
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
ruhaba
04:46 PM on 12/21/2009
I hope we see freedom for Iranian soon.
04:52 PM on 12/21/2009
Gigantic first steps toward freedom have been made, but there's a long way to go. Grand Ayatollah Montazeri on "What are the recent achievements of Iran’s “green movement”?"

http://khordaad88.com/?p=809
This movement is the accurate reflection and representation of the justified demands of the majority that have surfaced over many years. While it has faced a violent reaction and vehement hostility from the hardliner faction of the state, its domestic and foreign achievements are undeniable. Inside Iran, this movement has succeeded in institutionalizing a tolerant culture for demanding the rights of a large number of people, which were ignored during the election [process] and the events that followed. In addition, this movement has also prevailed in exposing the violent nature of the radical and the oppressive. Of course, to achieve this, it has paid a high price, which shows that the people will not be swayed until they attain the rights they are entitled to. Death, intimidation, threats, detainments, arrests, illegal and non-religious trials, heavy and unjust convictions for political activists and freedom seekers, as well as false and misleading propaganda – none of this has influenced the people’s will and determination. Outside Iran, the movement has succeeded in drawing international attention – especially that of developed societies and human rights organizations – to the oppression it faces as well as its rightful demands. From a political [perspective], [the movement] has presented the real power of nationhood to the world.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Middle Blue
What's a micro-bio?
04:53 PM on 12/21/2009
I know people with relatives there.

Don't get your hopes up.

People in Iran just disappear all the time.

Say or do the wrong thing, poof.
photo
Pod-gers
Jeremy Lin = Game Change
04:33 PM on 12/21/2009
Who champions women's rights and an end to hungar in Iran? Who supports food security in Iran, and world wide?

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Pp60sYdG_zo&feature=related

But, here in the US, congress votes to extend santions on Iran, punishing all Iran's people, in the hopes the people will blame their government.

However, contrary to what we are told here in America, the people of Iran are NOT kept in the dark. They know who and why they are the target of the US hungar wor their gas supplies.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
ruhaba
04:39 PM on 12/21/2009
People of Iran know exactly who the goverment is , bunch of tyron mullah. Give it up. Usa does not have any thing to do with this ~ This time~ We say no mullah is allowed to run our country , we want freedeom .
photo
Pod-gers
Jeremy Lin = Game Change
04:47 PM on 12/21/2009
Please define freedom?
04:45 PM on 12/21/2009
You dare to bring up women's rights? That's almost laughable in a country that tells them what to wear and the morality police descend on those wearing makeup. Even a hardline, reactionary woman candidate was turned down by the undemocratic vetting process and couldn't run for President.

As for sanctions, the opposition has practically begged the West to lift the existing ones as it only strengthens the government and hardline elements.
photo
HUFFPOST COMMUNITY MODERATOR
Khirad
09:12 PM on 12/21/2009
As our Mossad masters would say, that took a lot of chutzpah. ;-)
04:17 PM on 12/21/2009
The IRI has dispatched ten thousand IRGC as their cyber warrior. Please don't buy into their propaganda.

Iranians have been struggling to achieve democracy for 100 years now. This is just the continuation of a failed revolution. Will get it right this time. It will take time though.

Iran’s Revolutionary Guards Take on the Internet

http://blogs.law.harvard.edu/idblog/2009/01/08/irans-revolutionary-guards-take-on-the-internet/


The cyber warrior of IRGC recently hacked Twitter too.

http://www.csmonitor.com/Money/2009/1218/Iranian-hacker-attack-What-will-it-cost-Twitter
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Middle Blue
What's a micro-bio?
04:56 PM on 12/21/2009
Solid links.

Thx.
06:43 PM on 12/21/2009
Thank you. The Islamic Republic spends billions on propaganda abroad, including Europe, South and Latin America, even Africa...