iPhone app iPad app Android phone app Android tablet app More

Colin Carlson Sues UConn: Child Prodigy, 13, Claims Age Discrimination Over Study Abroad

Colin Carlson Uconn

STEPHEN SINGER   03/25/10 04:57 PM ET   AP

STORRS, Conn. — Even at 13, Colin Carlson believes he's running out of time.

Colin is a sophomore at the University of Connecticut, seeking a bachelor's degree in ecology and evolutionary biology and another in environmental studies. But he's been knocked off course by the university's rejection of his request to take a class that includes summer field work in South Africa.

He and his mother say university officials told them he is too young for the overseas course. So he's filed an age discrimination claim with the university and U.S. Department of Education, which is investigating.

"I'm losing time in my four-year plan for college," he said. "They're upsetting the framework of one of my majors."

Michael Kirk, a spokesman for UConn, would not comment on Colin's case. But he said that generally, safety is the university's first concern when travel is involved.

The university would not let Colin enroll, even after his mother, Jessica Offir, offered to release UConn from liability and accompany her son as a chaperone at her own expense, she and Colin said.

Colin was 2 or 3 when he began reading on his own, Offir said, and was up to "Harry Potter" by the time he was 4. An only child, he has faced trouble before because of his brainpower. His kindergarten teacher would not allow him to take books with him at nap time, and he was ridiculed by other children who fired math questions at him to entertain themselves, she said.

"You have no idea what kids like this experience," Offir said.

Colin skipped two grades in public school and began taking psychology, history and other courses at UConn when he was 9. He graduated from Stanford University Online High School at age 11, and soon after enrolled full-time at UConn.

"I'm actually like any other student, he said. "The faculty and students have better things to do than worry about a 13-year-old holding his own."

Over the years, Colin, who said he is fascinated by natural ecosystems, has traveled extensively. He has gone sea kayaking off Nova Scotia and Ecuador, hiked in numerous national parks and, with his mother, has traveled across the U.S. by car.

"It's important to have a very wide world view," he said. "Biology is fundamentally about the diversity of life, with a focus across the planet."

Colin says the course in conservation work in South Africa would have been critical to his studies and the rejection has forced him to change his thesis plans.

He said that once he's completed his undergraduate studies, he wants a Ph.D. in ecology and evolutionary biology and a degree in environmental law for a career in conservation science. He intends to earn the two degrees by age 22.

Carl Schlichting, a professor of ecology and evolutionary biology who has taught Colin in two courses, said he is not only an outstanding student, but is unusually certain for a 13-year-old about where he is headed professionally.

"He has very strong ideas about what he wants to do," he said. "His self-confidence is very high. It's a very unusual package to see the intellect and confidence at that age."

To be eligible to study abroad, students may not be on university probation or academic probation and must have earned a grade point average of at least a "C" – no problem for Colin, who's an honor student with a near-perfect 3.9 GPA.

The study abroad office and faculty member leading the trip ultimately decide who may go, Kirk said.

Brian Whalen, president and chief executive officer of the Forum on Education Abroad, a nonprofit member association of 400 schools, agencies and other groups, said he has not heard of another case where a college student Colin's age had tried to study abroad. When accepted into a college or university, a student generally is assumed to have access to academic programs, he said.

Although Colin was barred from the South African field trip course, he will participate in a National Science Foundation-funded research group that also will take him to South Africa to study plant ecology.

Colin and his mother say they would be satisfied if the university ensures that the NSF-funded research trip and a seminar fulfill the academic requirements of the course he originally sought. They also have asked that $5,000 in stipend and expenses be reimbursed.

Their lawyer, Michael Agranoff, said he wants to negotiate a solution. He and a lawyer for the state have scheduled their first meeting Friday, he said.

Colin says he would prefer not to have to fight, but he has no choice.

"When people are drawing lines in the sand, you're going to have to cross them," he said. "I'm not going back."

FOLLOW HUFFPOST COLLEGE

STORRS, Conn. — Even at 13, Colin Carlson believes he's running out of time. Colin is a sophomore at the University of Connecticut, seeking a bachelor's degree in ecology and evolutionary biolo...
STORRS, Conn. — Even at 13, Colin Carlson believes he's running out of time. Colin is a sophomore at the University of Connecticut, seeking a bachelor's degree in ecology and evolutionary biolo...
Filed by T.J. Ortenzi  | 
 
 
  • Comments
  • 721
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Bloggers
Recency  | 
Popularity
Page: 1 2 3 4 5  Next ›  Last »  (11 total)
02:17 PM on 05/10/2010
It's easy to be a genius and have a plan when you are thirteen. The bumpy road is usually paved for you by adults, (mommy) to attend university and skip the 'normal' part of schooling, and your family makes most of the hard decisions. The man who taught him two university courses used the word unusual twice when describing Colin. Perhaps instead of fighting the University the child could problem solve and find his own way to study independently in South Africa, because he is going to S. Africa with the NSF. When his hormones kick in (soon), he may find that life offers other passions, or he may throw his energy totally into getting what he currently wants. How his family handles this age will be crucial for the child. ________________________________________________ How can he learn about diversity of life if he doesn't experience diversity in his own life? Education and life generally need to be balanced for us to be whole.
12:51 PM on 04/09/2010
"It's important to have a very wide world view". He's totally right; he just doesn't want to become a teabagger.
08:49 PM on 03/29/2010
I took a class with this kid. Sure, he's smart as anything, but he comes of as the most annoying little dweeb ever. The sense of entitlement is sickening. I was a smart kid too (obviously not THAT smart), but we all have to wait our turn. Don't go and throw a fit over it.
09:02 PM on 03/27/2010
He is thirteen, and is a minor. Regardless of whether or not he is emotionally and socially ready to take this trip, even with his mom in tow, he's underage, and unfortunately, what comes along with being underage is you have to deal with it. The other students won't necessarily be doing things that are fine for college students but could turn VERY ugly with the inclusion of a barely pubescent child. And based on this lawsuit, who's to bet even if she signs away liability, if something happens she would sue anyway?

Ask any student working on a thesis, and they'll tell you they've been forced to make changes on it. Whining about it gets you no where. Asking for reimbursement is equally ridiculous. Colin's family is obviously privileged and the SA program at UCONN is not free or paid for by the university. All other students would have had to find a way to pay for themselves; the university owes him nothing for being 'gifted'

UCONN will likely accept it for credit, so I honestly don't see what the problem is about. Luckily, there is plenty of precedent, so he will in all likelihood lose, go on the privately run trip on his parents' dime, and that will be that. The real losers will be those of us who have to scrimp to go to UCONN at all, when the tuition is hiked in order to deal with this public hissy fit.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
greysells2
grey cells matter
10:53 AM on 03/27/2010
This is a good place for the badly overplayed "rugged American individualism" to take over. It's his life and if he wants to go, it's his decision. His parent agrees and she will go at her own expense to chaperone. Done deal!
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Phalanxman
Everything in Moderation
06:09 AM on 03/27/2010
Well, isn't he just so special. He and his mother are demonstrating the difference between being "book smart" and "practical smart.' They are long on one, short on the other. Way short.
10:46 PM on 03/26/2010
It's really unfortunate that the writer of this AP story couldn't take the time to read about this specific program on UConn's website. This program accepts three, yes, THREE undergrads. This course is NOT a requirement for the either major, and could be substituted with alternate studies.
Personally, when I evaluate intelligence I look for a level of reality and common sense. This kids was not chosen, the professor was honest for the reasoning behind his decision, and somehow we all think it's discrimination?
Do a little more digging AP, because you left out some pretty important facts in this report. All the info is available online. darwin.eeb.uconn.edu/eeb310/2009/10/summer-research-experience-in-south-africa.html
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Kamen Gullberg
10:05 PM on 03/26/2010
As a pre-law student, I could so understand the whole liability thing. Yes, if he gets accepted to the University he should have full access to the academia he is paying for. And when his mother was willing to go at no cost to the school with the boy and wave liability papers, the school should have just taken that and moved on. Oh well, good luck kid, definitely put my smarts to shame.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
KriTiKiT
Says"play nice"
06:55 PM on 03/26/2010
too all who think this is discrimination. I will ask you, would you put your child in a Polluted, destroyed area, that has Mercury contamination, fuel spills, or other chemicals caused by unregulated industry... this kid is still growing, and developing and all these ecologigal contaminates have a effect on a thyroids and gonads ( of developing children). Field work entails grabbing a shovel, working heavy machinery, being exposed to chemical soup, radon and other toxic gases... Now look at the kid, he would not be able to hang, heat stroke, sun burns, at some point people are going to have to realize that environmental work is more than saying," yup, we gotta change policy", but it's actually taking the places that have been contaminated and fighting local industry that may come after you with hammers and machetes, because what your doing is proving someone caused a disaster that they are going to have to fess up too!
08:14 PM on 03/26/2010
My beloved UConn, accepted this young man as a student, and he should be afforded the fullest academic experience that he can handle including traveling abroad regardless of the risks.
11:17 PM on 03/26/2010
Last I checked, there were millions of people living in LA, New York, and plenty of other smog-ridden US destinations. Lots of people eat fish too, which have high mercury levels.

And given that the kid is majoring in *ecology* don't you think he'd know about it? Also given that he is majoring in *evolutionary biology* wouldn't he also be well-informed about the effects of contaminants on his own development? I say he's in a better position to judge how safe it will be for him than you are. And the only reason you are advocating controlling what he does 'for his own safety' is because he's 13. if he was 20, you wouldn't care - let the dumb shiat kill himself. That's discrimination.

Are you an ecologist or an evolutionary biologist? How do you know what the field work entails? Have you read the course description, emailed the teacher? You have no more idea than I do. Have you heard of newfangled inventions like bottled water, sunscreen, and breaks. It's not like he's on a chain gang.

So yes, if my kid was mart and needed to go to South Africa to finish his work, and we did research on the course, I'd let him go. I actually have neighbors from South Africa - they're Afrikaners - and I think they'd object to the insinuation that their children are developmentally stunted. They both look fine to me, and they moved to the US when they were nine or ten.
09:10 PM on 03/27/2010
First, the article does not give any indication of what exactly the course's fieldwork would entail.

And heat stroke? You should know that when it's summer in North America it will be winter in South Africa.
05:48 PM on 03/26/2010
I was a bit like this boy growing up. Nowhere near as smart but I probably would have been ready for high school since I was 11 or 12 (was ready in mathematics by the time I was 8 or 9) and college when I was 15 or so. Sadly, because of my social issues I was always constantly held back throughout school which figured skipping me ahead one grade in math (only to later hold me back in that same class 2 years later, not because I was doing poorly but rather because they didn't want me to go to middle school early). By the time I finally got to college I was so used to doing good without working, I didn't bother working at all (later years of high school too). Only graduated from a decent college with a 3.2 GPA because I didn't bother working more then absolutely neccessary (about 30 minutes a night). I can see why he is mad about being held back, I would be too.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
05:37 PM on 03/26/2010
here we have a kid who should be permits to bloom but thanks to our nanny state and not child left behind, We end up with no one gets ahead.
photo
redsongia
is not Chicago
03:11 PM on 03/26/2010
Knocked off course at 13? Does he have a terminal disease? If he finished college on his well thought out schedule, what's he going to do with the next 70 years of his life?
07:33 PM on 03/26/2010
Almost all valuable scientific work is done by those under 35 though. Science is a cruel mistress.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
DandaPanda
I am not a republican
02:00 PM on 03/26/2010
gifted schmifted..he seems annoying
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
LaurenJill
12:55 PM on 03/26/2010
American culture can't stand a gifted kid, because "they're all gifted!!

http://tasteslikechicken2me.wordpress.com/2009/03/06/are-some-cultures-more-gifted-than-others/
photo
PathofTotality
Regret serves no purpose
12:47 PM on 03/26/2010
"He and his mother say university officials told them he is too young for the overseas course."

If that the case and the school used this reason then somewhere in their laws / rules / procedures it will state an age limit or requirement. If this does not exist then it's the opinion of the school not the rule. Fight the good fight Colin and if you do get to go to South Africa, be safe.