More

HBO Battles To Show 'For Neda' Documentary In Iran

DAVID BAUDER   06/15/10 04:33 PM ET   AP

Hbo For Neda

NEW YORK — HBO has aggressively sought to get its documentary on Iranian dissident Neda Agha Soltan seen by as many people as possible within Iran as the anniversary of her death during anti-government demonstrations approaches.

The film, "For Neda," was shown online and through Voice of America in Iran even before its debut on U.S. television this week, an unusual step for a cable network that traditionally guards exclusivity of its material for its paying customers.

The 27-year-old Iranian music student was shot in the heart last June 20 during a Tehran protest. Fellow demonstrators recorded images of her dying on their cell phones, and she quickly became a symbol for the crushed movement to protest Iran's questionable election results.

"I didn't want these brave people who came out on the streets and risked their lives so courageously to feel that the world had moved on and it's been forgotten," said Antony Thomas, who wrote and produced the documentary.

The film shows several times the difficult-to-watch images of Soltan lying in the street, blood slowly streaming over her face and her eyes becoming vacant. Other brutal images of Iranian security officials beating on demonstrators are included.

With the help of a journalist who sneaked into the country, "For Neda" includes interviews with her friends and, most importantly, her family. Soltan's heartbroken mother shows a colorful dress her daughter bought in her final days, a store's price tag not yet removed.

Rather than being frightened about the potential repercussions of appearing in the film, Soltan's family believes that visibility makes them safer, that the authorities would not want to risk reigniting a protest by doing them harm, Thomas said.

The people behind "For Neda" thought it was as important that the film be seen within Iran as it is outside. They worked with Austin Heap, executive director of the Censorship Research Center, a techie who helped develop ways for Iranian protesters to communicate with one another online last year while authorities tried to block them.

They arranged to show "For Neda" on the Voice of America's Persian News Network several times starting June 2. The Farsi-language network, funded by the U.S. government, is reportedly one of the most popular outside networks to be seen in Iran. Voice of America, which also showed the film on the Persian News Network website, received several messages from people inside Iran who had seen it, said Kyle King, Voice of America spokesman.

Some of the people said it was apparent that Iranian authorities were trying to "jam" satellite transmission of the documentary, since there were several examples of the power or the picture going out while it was being aired, he said.

Heap worked to distribute the film through YouTube and other Internet resources. It was put up in three languages – English, Arabic and Farsi – and in 25 different formats so it can be seen on smartphones and other devices, he said.

"The interconnectedness of the Iranian community is kind of astonishing," he said.

They tried to keep a step ahead of authorities who wanted to block them, he said. Thomas said a week ago he received e-mail correspondence he's convinced was a way the Iranian government was trying to hack into his computer to follow his messages.

"It's pretty clear that they don't want this story told in Iran," Heap said. The documentary shows how Iranian authorities have given several different stories to explain Soltan's death, including the claim that she was gunned down by the BBC or by the CIA, that she wasn't really dead or that she was an actress with fake blood.

Heap, who is interviewed in the film, also said that he "fought" to persuade HBO to distribute "For Neda" widely for free before it was shown on the American network.

"They look at YouTube and they look at Twitter as if it was some little thing that their kids use," he said.

HBO spokeswoman Lana Iny said the characterization that HBO initially fought against the idea was wrong and noted the network has a strong presence on social media.

Thomas praised HBO for the attention the network had given its film, including screenings in Atlanta, Los Angeles and Washington. He said the film was the idea of Sheila Nevins, who runs HBO's documentary unit.

FOLLOW HUFFPOST MEDIA

NEW YORK — HBO has aggressively sought to get its documentary on Iranian dissident Neda Agha Soltan seen by as many people as possible within Iran as the anniversary of her death during anti-gov...
NEW YORK — HBO has aggressively sought to get its documentary on Iranian dissident Neda Agha Soltan seen by as many people as possible within Iran as the anniversary of her death during anti-gov...
Filed by Danny Shea  | 
 
 
  • Comments
  • 260
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
Page: 1 2 3 4  Next ›  Last »  (4 total)
12:19 AM on 07/15/2010
What's ironic is the REFORM movement and REFORM parties also want to possess defensive nuclear weapons as parity to Israel (who started the nuclear arms race in the middle east and who refuses to entertain the "nuclear free middle east" proposal).

Therefore, reform or not.....Israel will want the U.S. to bomb Iran.

If you don't understand that truth, you may not understand this situation at all. Is this woman being exploited for war propaganda. The answer is points to a definite YES.

Will the US or Israel sign an agreement that they will not BOMB and KILL AFTER the left wing reformer topple the government and thereafter behave like any rational government including maintaining a string national defense at parity with it's neighbors?

Of course not.

That makes this a diversion.

Did we knock Iraq out of Kuwait because of story of the babies in the hospital (later proven to be fake)? Of course not. We were going IN ANYWAY.

Smell the coffee being brewed. It's called War in Lies. Israel has their hand in another pre-emptive American War. They were at the center of Iraq.

Any American fooled deserves it, frankly. It's too obvious at this point.
12:04 AM on 07/15/2010
It's great that HBO gives up it's intellectual property to show this sooner.

But why? Really why.

I like HBO. I like that they take an interest in human rights. BUT

what's up with their total silence on Gaza? You may ask yourself, are 600 kids dead in one hour as important as one woman.

Is there something else that drives HBO's blackout on Gaza and DRIVE for a single woman in Iran. Obviously, this presents a question to any objective, intelligent person. Anyone.

There isn't a very good answer to this question, unfortunately.

Does anyone remember back prior to the Iraq War and how Bush suddenly had help from the entire force of US media, entertainment and otherwise to generate a war? The drumbeat to war is subtle and suspicious. Here's your chance to notice.

Call HBO and inquire into the number of people it took to decide to invest, create and run this documentary for free. Why? How?

What's you'll learn is it takes very few people.

I like documentaries like this, however I do not like when there is a EFFORT underway by the same people to GO TO WAR, BOMB AND KILL the same people in the same country for reasons that have NOTHING to do with this woman or her internal political dreams. If Iran was a dictatorship tomorrow, and our ally, (made Israel happy), she could be thrown in jail.

We wouldn't care.

Neither would HBO.

This is war propaganda. A favor.
11:51 PM on 07/14/2010
Too bad they can't see in Gaza because Israel jams everything.
12:06 PM on 06/29/2010
The recent challenges in the Middle East cause us to pause for reflection about US involvement in the region. This evening, WGBH and other PBS affiliates around the country will be premiering leading journalist Maria Hinojoa's new interview. Tonight, Maria will be speaking with Haleh Esfandiari. Haleh Esfandiari is the director of the Middle East program at the in Washington D.C. She is the author of My Prison, My Home and Reconstructed Lives. In 2007, after being falsely accused of plotting against the Islamic Republic, Esfandiari spent 105 days in solitary confinement in Evin, Iran’s most notorious prison. In this conversation with Maria Hinojosa, Esfandiari talks about her incarceration, Iran’s women’s movement and the future of her native country.

Tune in tonight to WGBH (Channel 2, Boston) or your local PBS affiliate to catch this exciting conversation on One on One with Maria Hinojosa!
09:58 PM on 06/22/2010
From Persian Cat: meow :)
10:02 PM on 06/21/2010
Nice program about US policy about Iran:
http://www.presstv.com/programs/detail.aspx?sectionid=3510510
08:48 PM on 06/22/2010
Use this link instead! The other link is about Afghanistan!

http://www.presstv.com/programs/detail.aspx?sectionid=3510510&id=130842#130842
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
koroush1336
An human rights activist and totally anti-mullahs,
06:56 PM on 06/21/2010
The GIST OF THE MATTER about our NEDA is shown to the point of excellence in this Documentary. It shows that the MOVEMENT is NATIONWIDE and it embraces all WALKS OF LIFE in Iran and the whole WORLD for that MATTER.
08:44 PM on 06/21/2010
Poor thing,
Please stop watching Fox News and watch http://www.presstv.com/llnw/ so you can be sober again!
09:44 PM on 06/21/2010
What a choice, Fox News or PressTV. Two reactionary, propagandistic, jingoistic messes. I think we can get a better choice than that and HBO has done an excellent job here.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
koroush1336
An human rights activist and totally anti-mullahs,
06:34 PM on 06/21/2010
Escape Goats are not hard to find! But that does not change any reality! The fact of the matter is that the people of Iran are fighting for thier freedom and against the most brutal and backwarded regime in the modern history. This struggle deserves all supports which can get. The SUPPORT for this FREEDOM MOVEMENT IN IRAN means that the WORLD CARES.
06:45 PM on 06/21/2010
Yes, the World DOES care and I'm making it my personal mission to show and tell as many Americans as I can the TRUTH about the brave men and women who are fighting for their lives and their freedom in Iran. PressTV? Can you get anymore pathetic...lolol.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
koroush1336
An human rights activist and totally anti-mullahs,
06:50 PM on 06/21/2010
RIGHT ON BROTHER! That's the way to do it. Those who are "trying" to save this BEAST, are only making themselves tired and HATED by the FREEDOM LOVING people all around the WORLD.
04:11 PM on 06/21/2010
The “experts” who assert election fraud are obviously ignorant of Iran’s electoral procedures. For the ignorant “experts” and the Americans deluded by them, here is the way it works:

There are more than 45,000 voting places, which means less than 1,000 votes per voting place, an easy number to count and report in three hours. At each voting place there are a dozen or more observers, including every candidates’ representatives, representatives of the Guardian Council, and the local police. The votes are counted in the presence of all, and all sign documents attesting to the count.

The vote totals are forwarded to a central office in the region that has representatives of the candidates and the Guardian Council, where they are verified by a dozen or a dozen and a half of witnesses. From here the vote count goes to the Minister of the Interior, where the vote is announced.

Unless these procedures were not followed, and no evidence has been provided that the procedures were not followed, it is impossible to steal an Iranian election. It is much easier to steal an American one, which happens routinely.

There are thousands, indeed tens of thousands of witnesses, perhaps hundreds of thousands of witnesses, to the Iranian vote. Yet, only Mousavi and his corrupt supporters among the high living Iranian elite, who are fighting for personal power in Iran, contest the vote.
01:54 AM on 06/22/2010
No. Here's Noam Chomsky on the Iranian election process. Note that Ahmadi packed the Interior Ministry with his pals from IRGC:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Sk04v2yq4PQ
Mousavi and Karoubi's legal protestations came to nothing. That they were ignored by the opaque, arbitrary electoral oversight doesn't mean that no witnesses complained but rather that none were heard. Immediately after the election, IRI clamped down on an already unfree press- a process that contimues having them the leading jailer of journalists. Then the show trials commenced, one of which was enjoyed by even a former Vice-Prez. Hardly the atmosphere to have stinging exposes come out and detail the abuse going on. For a somewhat different perspective, see http://www.dissectednews.com/2010/05/who-really-won-the-disputed-iran-election.html

IRI has a long and noble legacy of making elections a sham anyway- from the choice of candidates to the lack of power in elected officials in general. Velayat-e faqih is not an abstraction but a living part of the truncated political life of Iranians.

That you consider hundreds of thousands of people in the streets as an elite throws your entire judgment in question. Especially considering how repressed labor unions are by the Ahmadi faction (though it is true the inroads between Green and labor slow and clunky, unfortunately).
11:55 PM on 07/14/2010
I agree that Iran's current government is as twisted as Israel's current government. It's no wonder both right wings play off each other for power.

Yet, very few Israeli's are objective enough to see it. Israel is engaged in a death dance it can't win over time.
05:48 AM on 06/21/2010
How big a shower do you make of Rachel Corrie in Israel HBO? And since the article seems to be aimed at giving a message isn't this whole blog getting a little radical in filtering the 'news', to a point where what you don't say says something? Just curious.
03:25 PM on 06/21/2010
Rachel Corrie and Neda has been killed by the same agents for the purpose of maintaining power of few over many!

In case of Rachel Corrie the truth is not easy to distort, so silence is the weapon of choice!

In the case of Neda, the story could be used to advance Israel's interest in ME, which is destruction of Iran.
04:02 PM on 06/21/2010
Of course you're correct and since we support and have terrorists operating in Iran I question who killed this woman and who is leading the big "Remember Nada" movement. How about "Remember the Liberty" or "Remember the King David" or "Remember the refugee camps" or "Remember Lavon" or "Remember history!"
12:23 AM on 06/21/2010
Now that we have the both videos available please see both of them and judge which one is after finding the truth and which one is an emotional film to make people hate their goverment to facilitate a coup?

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=N6DO9bo4HeI

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=F48SinuEHIk
05:42 PM on 06/20/2010
Press TV video about Neda's murder!

It is 4 parts! Please watch all 4 of them for find the truth!

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=N6DO9bo4HeI
07:52 PM on 06/20/2010
Shame on you. How do you sleep at night?
07:56 PM on 06/20/2010
That poster is perennially half-asleep. I wouldn't worry too much.
06:34 PM on 06/21/2010
Eva... it is simply beyond me how sick and disgusting these people are. I thought I had seen the worst of the worst as far as the IRI apologists but these guys take the cake. I just keep reminding myself that the reason they are coming out in force now is that they KNOW they are coming to the end. The regime knows that their time is just about over. I wonder what the going rate for betraying your country is these days. :-).
03:35 PM on 06/20/2010
Watch the real Documentary about Neda in Press TV now!

http://www.presstv.ir/llnw/
08:05 AM on 06/20/2010
Shame on HBO!
05:32 AM on 06/20/2010
Finally I have seen the Press TV document about Neda.

I will post a link to it once I find a youtube link.

In short Neda was killed by a female demonstrator with a weapon hidden in her purse!

The photo published in western media of Neda was from another women living outside the country.

The doctor that was with her and gave interviewed to BBC later did not followed her to the hospital.

Neda was not killed on spot but in the car on the way to Hospital.

The bullet has entered Neda's body from her back and exited from front. The weapon was probably a 9 mm gun.

I have to see the HBO film to see how much of it is propaganda.

Please post a link to the HBO documentary if you have it!
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
floodberg
Attorney (ret.)
03:18 PM on 06/20/2010
Here you go, and there are others.
www.alluc.org/documentaries/watch-for-neda-2010-online/193109.html
04:15 PM on 06/20/2010
Your link does not work!

I have found the HBO movie in youtube about Neda and watch it!

It is only an sorry excuse for a documentary full of propaganda against IRI and with no real evidences for its claims. The HBO movie wants to play on people's emotion to direct them into revolting against their government in Iran.

I think the Press TV documentary is much more objective.
IMHO it was much better for the truth, if Neda's family were ready to interview with Press TV.

They talks on the phone with the reporter and the guy accused of killing Neda and were convinced that he had killed Neda.

The evidence against the guy is almost non existence and no court in the world would find him guilty.

I understand Neda's family to be emotional and I feel deeply sorry that they have to go through this.

I hope police find the new suspect in the video! I think there might be some hope to find the real killer!
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
floodberg
Attorney (ret.)
03:26 PM on 06/20/2010
Here's another one as well...http://greggchadwick.blogspot.com/2010/06/hbo-documentary-for-neda-streaming.html
07:45 PM on 06/20/2010
Is the same as this link (HBO Documentary)?
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=F48SinuEHIk I couldn't get your links to work, but this is the one you meant, I think.