South Carolina Republican Primaries: Whiff Of Change Or Just Good Timing?
share this story
CHARLESTON, S.C. – South Carolina voters have nominated an Indian-American woman for governor and a black state lawmaker for Congress – developments which, on their face, suggest landmark racial progress in a state that still flies the Confederate flag near its statehouse.
Still, some are asking whether the victories by state representatives Nikki Haley and Tim Scott are a sign of real change or just an aberration of conservative politics.
Haley, the child of Sikh immigrants from India, took 65 percent of the vote in Tuesday's GOP primary runoff, after trouncing three white male opponents two weeks earlier. And Scott, the lone black Republican state legislator, had an even wider victory margin in a 72-percent white coastal congressional district over the son of the late political icon and one-time segregationist Sen. Strom Thurmond.
In a state where voting has previously run along racial fault lines the results do mark a change, said political scientist Merle Black of Emory University in Atlanta.
"It's an interesting shift because it goes against the stereotypes," he said. "It helps the Republican Party become more racially and ethnically diverse."
The elections come in a state where the first shots of the Civil War sounded, and where Jim Crow-era policies and the lawsuit that led to the 1954 landmark Brown v. Board of Education decision outlawing segregation originated.
Fast forward to the past year, and it's where officials have apologized after likening an escaped gorilla to an ancestor of first lady Michelle Obama and referring to President Barack Obama and Haley as ragheads.
But Haley and Scott stressed their message, not their ethnicity or gender.
"They had the right message, and they had the leadership skills to get it done," said state House Majority Leader Kenny Bingham.
Melissa Ervin, a white voter from Mount Pleasant, said race had nothing to do with her vote for Scott.
"It kept coming across that he was very conservative and had traditional values," the 45-year-old interior designer said. "I thought he was the better person for the job."
Ervin, who voted for Barrett in the gubernatorial primary, said she was more surprised that Haley was nominated in a state that consistently ranks last nationwide in the percentage of female legislators.
Endorsed by Sarah Palin and tea party groups, Haley and Scott are social and fiscal conservatives. Although they have served in the state Legislature, they cast themselves as political outsiders, ready to shake things up.
"I'm tired of the good ol' boy system," said Greenville voter Carol Gregory, a 62-year-old dental hygienist. "I think across the board, we're just ready for a change."
Good timing was on their side in other ways too, said state Rep. Gilda Cobb-Hunter, D-Orangeburg. She noted the scandal surrounding Gov. Mark Sanford's secretive trip to visit his mistress in Argentina and the uproar over U.S. Rep. Joe Wilson's "You lie!" heckling of President Obama.
And then there's Alvin Greene, an unemployed military veteran recently nominated by the Democrats to run for U.S. Senate, despite a pending felony obscenity charge.
After more than a year of being "America's whoopee cushion," as comedian Jon Stewart recently put it, South Carolina voters wanted to change outsiders' perception of the state, Cobb-Hunter said.
"Politics is about timing, and their timing has been perfect to seize the moment and capitalize on a real desire to be perceived in a positive light nationally," said Cobb-Hunter, who is black.
Attorney General Henry McMaster, who endorsed Haley after losing to her two weeks ago, said the nominations of Haley and Scott mark a "new day for South Carolina, and it's all positive."
"I think we get a lot of publicity we see on late night talk shows, and all that does not accurately reflect the people of South Carolina or their spirit," he said.
But it remains to be seen whether this road to diversity is real, said Cobb-Hunter: "If, on one hand, Republicans are saying, 'Oh, wow, look at us and how diverse we are,'" she said, the question becomes, "Are they replaced by people of color?"
State Democratic Party Chairwoman Carol Fowler notes Haley and Scott are the only minority Republicans in the state Legislature. Their departure leaves the Legislature, which lacks even a single female senator, even less diverse.
"In South Carolina, any racial progress is better than where we have been," Fowler said. "I think whether the Republican Party is making progress to being a more diverse party is another question."
In Washington, members of the Congressional Black Caucus said Wednesday they don't see Haley and Scott victories as a sign of Republican diversity.
"You know, it takes more than just having a token one African American ... in Congress to say that you have diversity," said Rep. Laura Richardson, D-Calif.
Diversity goes beyond skin color and gender to include opinion, and Scott lacks a different point of view, said Rep. Emanuel Cleaver, D-Mo.
"This gentleman is to the right of many of the members in the Republican Caucus, so he will blend in quite well with them in terms of ideology," Cleaver said. "So I don't know where the diversity is in adding someone who thinks like everyone else."
Glenn McCall of South Carolina, one of just two black members of the Republican National Committee, says he believes more people of diverse ethnic backgrounds will step forward. He cites his own election two years ago as an example of the party's inclusiveness.
"It's not that we have arrived as it relates to ethnic involvement and running for public office," he said. "We're just getting started. And I'm excited about the future."
But David Bositis, a senior political analyst at the Washington-based Joint Center for Political and Economic Studies, doesn't see a fundamental change in the racial politics of South Carolina.
Scott won the nomination in the coastal 1st Congressional District where thousands of newcomers from other states have flocked in the past decade. Haley also ran stronger in several coastal counties than she did in her home Lexington County.
By Bositis' estimate, South Carolina remains a state divided politically along racial lines.
"Most African-Americans most certainly will not be voting for Tim Scott," he said.
___
Adcox reported from Columbia, S.C., and Smith from Charleston. Associated Press writers Jim Davenport in Columbia and Ileana Morales in Washington contributed to this story.
Loading comments… 
SEANNA ADCOX and BRUCE SMITH 06/23/10 06:32 PM ET Associated Press