iPhone app iPad app Android phone app Android tablet app More

Kosovo Independence Declaration Is Legal, UN Court Rules

MIKE CORDER   07/22/10 02:32 PM ET   AP

Kosovo Reaction

THE HAGUE, Netherlands — The United Nations' highest court ruled Thursday that Kosovo's declaration of independence was legal, dealing a blow to Serbia, which vowed never to accept its former province as a separate state and warned the ruling could embolden separatist movements around the world.

Kosovo Prime Minister Hashim Thaci hailed the ruling as a "historic victory" and "the best possible answer for the entire world," while Foreign Minister, Skender Hyseni, said outside the International Court of Justice: "my message to the government of Serbia is 'Come and talk to us.'"

A tiny patch of the Balkans with a population of 2 million, Kosovo declared independence in February 2008 after years of fruitless talks with Belgrade about its desire to break away.

Issuing the nonbinding advisory opinion, International Court of Justice President Hisashi Owada said international law contains "no ... prohibition of declarations of independence" and therefore Kosovo's declaration "did not violate general international law."

In the capital, Pristina, ethnic Albanians honked their horns and waved Kosovo and U.S. flags to celebrate the ruling.

"What happened today is the greatest joy for Kosovo since the declaration of independence," said ethnic Albanian Shpresa Gosalci. "It is something that has sealed our status forever."

Kosovo's independence has been accepted by 69 countries so far. U.N. diplomats say they expect the court's decision to spur recognition of Kosovo as an independent state. After more than 100 countries grant such recognition – more than half the 192 U.N. member states – a senior Western diplomat said it will in effect have achieved "full statehood."

U.N. Secretary-General Ban Ki-moon will forward the advisory opinion to the General Assembly "which had requested the court's advice and which will determine how to proceed on this matter," U.N. spokesman Martin Nesirky said.

"The secretary-general strongly encourages the parties to engage in a constructive dialogue," Nesirky told reporters at U.N. headquarters in New York. "The secretary-general urges all sides to avoid any steps that could be seen as provocative and derail the dialogue."

Serbia's diplomatic campaign to prevent recognition of Kosovo has left the fledgling nation in limbo and cut off from international organizations and European Union membership. Serbia's stance is likely also hampering Kosovo's attempts to join the EU, as the bloc insists member states have friendly relations with their neighbors.

In a statement, EU foreign affairs chief Catherine Ashton said the future of Serbia and Kosovo lies in the EU.

"Good neighborly relations, regional cooperation and dialogue are the foundations on which the EU is built," Ashton said. "The EU is therefore ready to facilitate a process of dialogue between Pristina and Belgrade."

Kosovo had been under international administration for nearly a decade following a bloody 1998-99 war with Serbia, and thousands of NATO troops are still stationed there guarding a tense peace. Some 90 percent of the population is ethnic Albanian; the rest are mostly Serbs.

Serbia argues that Kosovo has been the cradle of its civilization and national identity since 1389, when a Christian army led by Serbian Prince Lazar lost an epic battle to invading Ottoman forces.

"Serbia has its history, Serbia has its roots, Serbia has its faith and they are all related to our policy in Kosovo," Serbian Foreign Minister Vuk Jeremic said.

Serbian President Boris Tadic said Serbia will propose to the U.N. General Assembly in September a resolution on Kosovo that will represent a "compromise" between Serbs and Kosovo Albanians.

"The only sustainable solution is one accepted by all sides," Tadic said.

The United States called the ruling "a judgment we support," said State Department spokesman P.J. Crowley. "Now it is time for Europe to unite behind a common future."

Jeremic warned, however, that the ruling could encourage separatist movements elsewhere around the world who would now be "tempted to write declarations of independence."

"We will never recognize the unilateral declaration of Kosovo's independence," Jeremic told reporters on the steps of the court's Peace Palace headquarters in The Hague.

"Difficult times are ahead ... but it is crucial that our people don't react to any possible provocations," Jeremic said, amid fears that angered ultranationalists in Serbia and Kosovo might become violent. Ultranationalists set the U.S. Embassy in Belgrade on fire when Kosovo declared independence in 2008.

Serbia's ultranationalist Radical Party said the court had "gravely violated" international law, and called on the government to demand an urgent session of the U.N. Security Council to end the EU peacekeeping mission in Kosovo.

And in Kosovo's divided northern city of Mitrovica, Kosovo Serb Tihomir Markovic called the ruling shameful.

"Justice is on our side, God is on our side," he said. "After this it will be hard for us – the Serbs in Kosovo."

NATO-led troops increased their presence Thursday in the Serb-controlled part of Mitrovica.

In Brussels, NATO Secretary-General Anders Fogh Rasmussen said the ruling would not affect the role of the 10,000-strong peacekeeping force in Kosovo, known as KFOR.

"KFOR will continue to implement its mandate to maintain a safe and secure environment in an impartial manner throughout Kosovo, for the benefit of all communities, majority and minority alike," he said.

____

Associated Press Writers Dusan Stojanovic and Jovana Gec in Belgrade, Nebi Qena in Pristina, Edith Lederer at the United Nations and Slobodan Lekic in Brussels contributed to this report.

FOLLOW HUFFPOST WORLD

Filed by Curtis M. Wong  | 
 
 
  • Comments
  • 58
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
Page: 1 2  Next ›  Last »  (2 total)
09:05 PM on 07/28/2010
My public apology to the people of West Papua, my OPM friends asked me to look at the Kosovo decision and I've only done so today. It appears the ICJ opinion confirms any territory has a right to make a declaration of independence. Kosovo only has 69 nations recognising it's independence so far; using UN resolution 1541 as a guide, independence from a dominating government is most suitable if the territory is geographically separate, or if the people are ethnically distinct from the administrating power, or if the cultural of the territory is distinct from the culture of the administrating power. Kosovo's strongest claim seems to be the abuse Serbia inflicted on Kosovo.
But West Papua has been victim of Mitchell bombers (donated by the US to Indonesia), rockets, and the establishment of an oppressive military and militia presence across Papua. It is not part of Asia, it's people are Melanesian (like Australian aboriginals and people from Fiji to Vanuatu); it's culture is Melanesian, it's history is that it supported the US and Australia against the Japanese and Java's Axis forces during the Pacific war. Indonesia has restricted media access since 1963! I hope HuffingtonPost readers will understand West Papua is a "colony", and deserves our support for independence from Jakarta.
photo
LMPE
I connect the most dissimilar things
02:26 PM on 07/23/2010
According to Jon Stewart's "America: The Book", by 2004, every person in the former Yugoslavia had declared an independent republic of himself.

Kosovo can go ahead and secede. Abkhazia and Ossetia can do the same. Hell, when are we going to get rid of the entire southeastern part of the US, so that they stop holding us back?
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
11:45 AM on 07/23/2010
Any word on Texas leaving the Union?
photo
LMPE
I connect the most dissimilar things
02:22 PM on 07/23/2010
Texas can take South Carolina with it.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
chicagomike
11:05 AM on 07/23/2010
Wow -- the Serb nationalists sure showed up on this thread...lol.

Their comments indicate the extreme Serb mentality which is the main reason Kosovars need independence -- and the main reason for the breakup of Yugoslavia. The Serbs have a need to dominate their neighbors, no doubt to compensate for low national self-esteem. And they base their whole national myth (and that's what it is) on an historic catastrophe -- what other nation does that? As for their claim that somehow the Kosovars appeared out of nowhere to occupy Serb lands, all you have to do is look at an ethnic map of Europe in the 19th century to see that Albanians were already the vast majority in Kosovo, and probably had been for many centuries. The Serbs seem to feel that history stopped in 1389. How pathetic is that. The world would be a better place if they would grow up emotionally.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Talossa
Liberal. Pro-Israel. Recovering atheist.
12:10 AM on 07/25/2010
Fanned and faved. Serbian nationalism is right out of another era completely. Where else in Europe is a fascist thug like Milosevic hailed as a national hero in the 21st century? That "need to dominate" is at the heart of it all. It honestly looks today as if Serbia has turned a corner, and that Serbia may be learning to deal with fantasies of recovering lost territory as just that, fantasies -- the same way every other major European nationality has had to learn the same lesson.
07:16 AM on 07/23/2010
The stench of the hypocrisy of US foreign policy grows worse each day. The US supports the independence of Kosovo, yet the breakaway provinces of South Ossetia and Abkhazia of Georgia
are not supported. I was happy to see Putin stomp the heck out of the Israelis and Georgians in the little dustup in the summer of 2008. Of course, the US whined and pleaded with the Russians....to no avail.
What is good for the goose is good for the gander.......
02:08 AM on 07/23/2010
That destroys whatever fig leaf of stature was left of the UN International Court of (IN)Justice. Shows the world that the UN is in the pocket of Western powers. The "principle" upheld: Might Makes Right. US out of the UN! And take that sock puppet of a Secretary General with you as you avoid the door hitting you on the way out!
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Talossa
Liberal. Pro-Israel. Recovering atheist.
12:13 AM on 07/25/2010
Have you ever paused to imagine what the world would look like without the influence of "Western powers"? Yes, by all means -- let Islamic fundamentalism and Chinese capitalist authoritarianism and associated balcony buffoons like Hugo Chavez lead the world into a new age!
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
esp2001
01:27 AM on 07/23/2010
Kosovo is not a Muslim country, the war was not religious one, and the people of Kosovo were oppressed for years because of their ethnicity and not religion. And if we go back to 1300s to claim the origins and ownership of land like Serbia does with Kosovo, the world would look very different today...
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Talossa
Liberal. Pro-Israel. Recovering atheist.
12:28 AM on 07/23/2010
Bravo to the World Court. When Muslims actually are victims, as they were in Kosovo, and when they respond like civilized people (no hijackings, suicide bombers or jihads), the civilized world can and will come to their aid.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
01:18 AM on 07/23/2010
Victims?

You need to read up on your facts on the lengths that that the Muslims in the former Yugoslavia resorted to.

Read Julia Gorin's article here on the Huffington Post titled "The Blackmail of America: How the U.S. is still on the Wrong Side of Serbia."

You clearly don't know about the goings on in the former Yugoslavia.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Talossa
Liberal. Pro-Israel. Recovering atheist.
08:04 AM on 07/23/2010
I majored in Eastern European studies and took Serbocroatian (and several other topical courses) from an expert on Yugoslav affairs. I don't need to take dictation from a right-wing blogger.

I must be doing something right -- I'm getting blasted by Serbs on this thread and getting blasted by Turks on the Cyprus thread. :-)
11:18 PM on 07/22/2010
It is a travesty of justice and history to give Kosovo independence.
Hopefully Serbs take it back.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
11:27 PM on 07/22/2010
Thank-you.
11:18 PM on 07/22/2010
Remember how Kosovo became "independent". NATO attacked Yugoslavia and used aerial bombing to blackmail that country into allowing NATO troops to occupy the Kosovo province. The UN Security Council resolution guaranteed Yugoslavia's territorial integrity and committed NATO to that. The Kosovo secessionists were never a party to that agreement, so I suppose that technically they didn't violate the resolution. NATO however did violate the resolution so the real crime in this case is theirs. They should have directed their lawsuit at NATO.
11:14 PM on 07/22/2010
All it says is that it's not illegal internationally to declare independence. It doesn't seem to take care of the real questions. That is, if some secessionists declare independence, is it aggression for a rival power to recognise that independence? Let's say that the secessionists control a small amount of territory in this so-called state - do they have the right to invite troops of another power into the territory to bolster the independence claim and is the country sending troops committing aggression? Is the presence of troops from the country from which the secessionists are seceding aggression by that country?
10:42 PM on 07/22/2010
Folks, sooner or later separatism will hit our shores.
What will we do, what will we do ?
11:18 PM on 07/22/2010
KiII 'em all, as Americans usually do.
photo
LMPE
I connect the most dissimilar things
02:23 PM on 07/23/2010
If the South wants to secede again, that would be just fine with me.
10:30 PM on 07/22/2010
A lot of fringe righties seethe about another 'Muslim state' in Europe. You know, the kind who think Serbia was set up with that whole 'genocide' thing
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
10:43 PM on 07/22/2010
I am Canadian. I don't have any interest or affiliation with anythiing right wing.

Kosovo is Serbian land. Any history lesson will teach you that.

The fact is that the West did help create a Muslim state in Europe.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Talossa
Liberal. Pro-Israel. Recovering atheist.
12:24 AM on 07/23/2010
Nothing wrong with creating a Muslim state where Muslims have actually lived for centuries. I have a problem with creating Muslim states in Germany, England or Holland.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
esp2001
01:25 AM on 07/23/2010
Kosovo is not a Muslim country, the war was not religious one, and the people of Kosovo were oppressed for years because of their ethnicity and not religion. And if we go back to 1300s to claim the origins and ownership of land like Serbia does with Kosovo, the world would look very different today...
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
11:01 PM on 07/22/2010
I recommend that you read Julia Gorin's article here on the Huffington Post titled " The Blackmail of America: How the U.S. is Still on the Wrong Side of Serbia".

Here is just an excerpt:

"Indeed, toward the end of 1999 several major newspapers deigned to report on findings that mass graves such as the infamous Trepca zinc mine turned up empty, as did the stadium we were told was being used as a concentration camp. Anyone reading this one-time follow-up would have also learned that the "cleansing" of 800,000 Albanians had more to do with NATO bombs and KLA orders than with the outrageous claim that Serbia was trying to empty the province of 90 percent of its population, a myth we titled "Operation Horseshoe."
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
esp2001
01:30 AM on 07/23/2010
Please do not offend this readership with recommending Ms. Gorin's one-sided, ignorant articles.
09:51 PM on 07/22/2010
A good rule of thumb: if the 'host nation' is overwhelmingly hostile to the entire population of the local territorial population (based on ethnicity, religion or language) of an enclave or a region, people there should be free to vote and succeed if voted so. Further credits a strong vote of the local territorial majority (bigger state minority), relative geographical compactness, and for actually fighting against the overwhelming power. Abkhazia, South Ossetia, Karabakh, Palestine, Kurds in Turkey, qualify.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Talossa
Liberal. Pro-Israel. Recovering atheist.
12:25 AM on 07/23/2010
Hear, hear.
09:22 PM on 07/22/2010
It is time for Bittany to declare its independence from France, Catalonia to secede from Spain, Basques to leave as well. There is NO end to all the minorities which can now use violence to get rid of national governments that they don't like. African countries had enough sense to say that national boundaries will remain the same. International LAW also stated in the Helsinki Treaty that NO state can be created out of a signatory nation, which Yugoslavia was one. Thus the ruling is a gross violation of law and common sense. It destroys any respect that a person can have for the court.