iPhone app iPad app Android phone app Android tablet app More

10 Local American Economies That Have Changed Forever (PHOTOS)

First Posted: 08/25/10 10:14 AM ET   Updated: 05/25/11 06:25 PM ET

By 24/7 Wall St.: A city does not die when its last resident moves away. Death happens when municipalities lose the industries and vital populations that made them important cities.

The economy has evolved so much since the middle of the 20th Century that many cities that were among the largest and most vibrant in America have collapsed. Some have lost more than half of their residents. Others have lost the businesses that made them important centers of finance, manufacturing, and commerce.

Most of our list of America's Ten Dead Cities were once major manufacturing hubs and others were important ports or financial services centers. The downfall of one city, New Orleans, began in the 1970s, but was accelerated by Hurricane Katrina.

Notably, the rise of inexpensive manufacturing in Japan destroyed the ability of the industrial cities on this list to effectively compete in the global marketplace. Foreign business activity and US government policy were two of the three major blows that caused the downfall of these cities. The third was the labor movement and its demands for higher compensation which ballooned the costs of manufacturing in many of these cities as well.

24/7 Wall St. looked at a number of sources in order to select the list. One was the US Census Bureau's list of largest cities by population by decade from 1950 to 2000 with estimates for 2007. Detroit, for example, had 1.9 million people in 1950 and was the fifth largest city in the nation. By 2000, the figure was 951,000. The city was not even on the top ten list in 2007.

The Census data also describes the shift of much of the population to cities which were not considered large at all in 1950. Most of these are in the southern part of the US. Rising populations in these locations has been driven by the growing number of retired people and a relocation of the nation's workforce. This is how San Diego, Phoenix, and San Antonio have moved onto the list of the ten largest cities in America.

Researchers at the Massachusetts Institute of Technology did a study of what they described as America's 150 forgotten cities. The municipalities on their list were medium-sized and ranked by measurements that included poverty. The reason for their demise largely match the cities on the 24/7 Wall St list. The MIT research work goes beyond a mere list of statistics and points out reasons why some of these cities will never recover. In almost every case, tax bases have disappeared, which has undermined the ability of local governments to spend money on revitalization. Abandoned areas of these cities have high crime rates, which not only keeps people from relocating to these areas but is actually an incentive for them to move away. This in turn, leads to the image of these cities as desolate urbanscapes.

Check out below the 10 local American economies that have changed forever -- and visit 24/7 Wall Street for more information:

Buffalo, New York
1 of 11
In 1900, Buffalo was the eighth largest city in America. It was located on one of the busiest sections of the Erie Canal, the terminus of the canal on the Great Lakes. Thanks to its location, Buffalo had huge grain milling operations and one of the largest steel mills in the country. Buffalo prospered during WWII as did many northern industrial cities. After the WWII, the manufacturing plants returned to the production of cars and industrial goods. The population rose to more than 500,000 in the mid-1950s. It is half that today. Buffalo was wounded irreparably by the de-industrialization of America.
--24/7 Wall St.
Total comments: 945 | Post a Comment
1 of 11
Rate This Slide
Has A Long Way To Go
Will Rebound

  • 1

  • 2

  • 3

  • 4

  • 5

  • 6

  • 7

  • 8

  • 9

  • 10
Transformed American Cities
Users who voted on this slide
loading...



For more, visit our new Third World America section.


FOLLOW HUFFPOST BUSINESS
Subscribe to the HuffPost Money newsletter!
By 24/7 Wall St.: A city does not die when its last resident moves away. Death happens when municipalities lose the industries and vital populations that made them important cities. The economy ha...
By 24/7 Wall St.: A city does not die when its last resident moves away. Death happens when municipalities lose the industries and vital populations that made them important cities. The economy ha...
Filed by Nate C. Hindman  | 
 
 
  • Comments
  • 945
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
Page: 1 2 3 4 5  Next ›  Last »  (18 total)
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
duckzilla
12:10 AM on 09/06/2010
No surprise to see my city, Buffalo NY on that list. The info provided barely scratches the surface on the downward spiral we've had in the past century

In 1901, Buffalo had 60 millionaires, more per capita than any city in the US. Today, we have the 3rd highest poverty rate out of any American city (a few years a go we we're 2nd poorest)

Cheap Chinese steel and foreign cars killed us.
11:06 AM on 08/27/2010
"free trade" .... freedom isn't free right? It costs big time.
10:53 PM on 08/26/2010
For years the nonunion South was happy to pull jobs away from the unionized Northeast and Midwest. For the past couple of decades Mexico and Asia have been pulling jobs away from the South. Maybe Southerners should have recognized that workers need to stick together to lobby congress for progressive trade policies and progressive labor laws.
11:20 AM on 08/26/2010
The right wing offer a modified form of socialism,minimum wage and piecework. No mamby-pamby benefits or that ridiculous social security.Be thankful you have a job and remember your reward is in heven so stop the whining and get back to work or your fired.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
soisay
Angry? Scared? Thank a Republican.
01:12 AM on 08/29/2010
Charles Dickens wrote many volumes on the Republican vision for haves and have-nots, for capitalists and labor.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
rshrink
09:34 AM on 08/26/2010
For those here complaining about the unions, you must be talking about the CEO unions that pay those hundreds of million dollar salaries and bonuses for losing money for the company. Then they have to find cheaper labor to be able to keep giving raises to the CEO's, so that they can continue to lose money.
10:35 AM on 08/26/2010
I am so tired of Union bashing when it's really the wealthy suckling the teet of the middle class.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
04:29 AM on 08/27/2010
I'm tired of union bashing too. At the same time, I'm also not in favor of resting on laurels and job protection for just sitting on your butt and paying union dues. If only unions were also there to protect the quality of performance based on merit rather than just on the fact that you're a member.
I've been living in the Netherlands for 20 years now (just left for Spain permanently yesterday) and I was protected under the equivalent of unionized work for many years while working in the social service sector. I can't tell you how appalling it was to hear from colleagues that I work too hard and should slow down with my American work ethic. This internalize entitlement mentality is what endangers the positive aspect of unionized work. I'm all for unions if the union benefits are based on merit and not just "being".
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
05:33 AM on 08/26/2010
The future of our nation is wrapped up in the quality of life and humanity's opportunity in our great cities.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
03:12 AM on 08/26/2010
Ten years from now this list may be dominated by Gulf Coast cities due to pollution and rising sea levels. Twenty years from now Galveston may be a ghost town.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Ally Meme
02:08 AM on 08/26/2010
Just how much are each of you saving from your monthly paychecks for the future?

This is one issue I can never understand about the US. In Malaysia, there is no social security AT ALL though medical (including hospitalisation/medicines) is basically free for everyone - so one have to save for everything else and that can means up to 30% of one's pay check.

Ally

Ally
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Ladywolf55
Independent Secular Progressive
09:09 AM on 08/26/2010
Why save, when the dollar is going to crash and be just worthless paper? Curses, foiled again by our evil government!
11:31 AM on 08/26/2010
And you really see a wave of people trying to immigrate there as well right
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Cain Lum
01:41 PM on 08/26/2010
Actually a lot of recent graduates are going to Asia and Latin America for opportunities. America is the land to "get out of if you can".
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
spinns17
TEAMSTER
01:23 AM on 08/26/2010
THANK GOD FOR UNIONS
01:40 AM on 08/26/2010
Exactly, if you look at our declining middle class and compare it to our rate of unionization compared to other countries you can make a strong argument for the positive influence of unions in a country.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
spinns17
TEAMSTER
07:55 AM on 08/26/2010
fanned and fav.prices rise on everything today,but our income has gone down.
02:07 AM on 08/26/2010
The decline in Union membership coincides with the decline of the middle class.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
spinns17
TEAMSTER
07:53 AM on 08/26/2010
spot on .f&f
photo
RubalKhali
Philosophy is the stray camel of the faithful
01:03 AM on 08/26/2010
It seems Japan is to blame for a lot of our problems according to the slides. I never realized the G.M and Chrysler had Japanese CEOs making thoses great decisions to scrape efficient cars and electerics that people wanted, and build monster SUVs and Hummers. Or that their buddies the Japanese CEOs of all the major oil companies were encouraging them.
Don't take responsibility for our own idiocy seems a particularly American trait.
11:16 PM on 08/25/2010
Most of these cities are union friendly. See where it gets ya
12:01 AM on 08/26/2010
They are also all democrat run,along with the top ten cities with the highest unemployment /people on welfare. Dems and unions, great team. lol
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
abbyrose86
Business exists to benefit MANKIND, MANKIND does N
12:15 AM on 08/26/2010
Oh brother...ign0rant much? Didn't anyone ever teach you how to determine causation? BTW...correlation does NOT prove it.
01:19 AM on 08/26/2010
Bush did a heck of a job with the economy. But of course you will ignore that so you can feel a moment of smug fantasy repeating something that you think is correct solely because someone else smugly said it was true.

Hey, let me know when that trickle down/supply side thing actually starts to work will you? Because all the evidence points to the fact that it'll ruin a country.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
rshrink
01:37 AM on 08/26/2010
Yah, they were making a good profit when they were operating here with the unions. Their problems began when they moved operations out of the country. Hadn't you noticed they went bankrupt after that? Now, how will you deal with the discrepancy between the facts and your fantasies.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
StevieRae
Neutralize "being primaried" by voting
11:13 PM on 08/25/2010
In the final analysis, is the basic notion of capitalism that motivates one to figure out how to screw another through an economic transaction, the source of our collective decline?

Is this resulting in the loss of social mores, ethics and empathy toward others we see more and more?
12:39 AM on 08/26/2010
Capitalism is a reflection of human nature. I think we all know this don't we?
01:41 AM on 08/26/2010
Wow, you really don't know what you are talking about do you?
You are kinda jumping ship on your conservative ideology here and you don't even know it.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
StevieRae
Neutralize "being primaried" by voting
10:56 PM on 08/25/2010
New Orleans was the first evidence of how some Americans were willing to sit and watch other less fortunate parts of our country slip into economic and social decay; "things are tough all over, too bad."

This growing social acceptance of "I've got mine" what's your problem" will cause other cities, towns, and states to fall into third world equivalency and eventually be our undoing. This "American" experiment will have failed.
12:42 AM on 08/26/2010
I think that is merely a recent example. It serves to illustrate you cannot depend on government to solve all of your problems.
01:28 AM on 08/26/2010
Yawn, if you are just going to repeat dated old tag-lines why bother at all?

It's like you Repubs have to keep repeating them over and over to prevent yourselves from thinking.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
rshrink
01:35 AM on 08/26/2010
They certainly won't solve all of yours. But I have some ideas.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
PG13
10:47 PM on 08/25/2010
Reagan-omics, free trade, globalization...yeah the tenners of Capitalism has slapped American manufacturing cities in the back of the head.

Exceptional-ism? it's outsourced
12:43 AM on 08/26/2010
A 35% corporate tax rate compared to 20% in Asia is no help either.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
hulagirrrl
01:17 AM on 08/26/2010
America's corporate tax rate is the lowest of all industrial democratic countries, so please show us where you got that information. Thanks
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Techboy308
the cake is a lie
07:29 AM on 08/26/2010
If any of them paid it you might have a point...
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
rshrink
10:27 PM on 08/25/2010
It seems that the obvious problem is practically entirely overlooked. We have these deteriorating cities and we have the highest unemployment in the lifetime of the boomers. We have lost our manufacturing base due to bad republican policies, that of pushing big corporations to move to countries with cheap labor and no environmental laws. So now we need to repair our infrastructure and put people back to work. Many know that and have commented about it here on numerous occasions. Obama campaigned on green jobs and new technology. That is a great idea, but we are already quickly falling behind other countries in this new area as well. We seriously need to stop focusing on philosophy and morality in politics, a place where those issues cannot really be addressed and start insisting that our representatives focus on that which is more clearly their responsibility. We need to put morality and philosophy back in the churches and universities where it belongs and put jobs and economy back into our countries policy considerations where it belongs. My last point would be to expose the wealthy, like the Koch brothers, who push religion and fund the tea party for their hidden agendas and connections and start charging them a tax for every tea party they fund. That will help pay for the pollution they caused.
01:25 AM on 08/26/2010
Well said. F&F