NYR More

Merkel Calls For Dismissal Of German Banker, Author Of Controversial Immigration Book For Comments On Muslims And Jews

MELISSA EDDY   08/30/10 12:23 PM ET   AP

Thilo Sarrazin

BERLIN — Germany's central bank distanced itself Monday from a board member who stereotyped Muslims and Jews, saying his remarks were harmful and violated the Bundesbank's code of conduct.

The comments by Thilo Sarrazin surrounding the launch of his new book Monday on immigration issues sparked outrage from German lawmakers and community leaders, and many agreed with Chancellor Angela Merkel that he should be removed from the bank's board.

During the promotion for his book, Sarrazin maintained that Muslim immigrants in Europe are unwilling or incapable of integrating into western societies and that studies have proven that "all Jews share the same gene."

Although Merkel's government condemned his comments, it cannot force his departure due to the Bundesbank's independence.

The Bundesbank said in a statement Monday that its chairman would meet with Sarrazin before deciding on further measures, adding that it is "an institution in which there is no room for discrimination."

Before the central bank could remove Sarrazin from its six-member board, the Bundesbank would have to ask German President Christian Wulff to order it.

This is not the first time Sarrazin has provoked controversy. He was forced to resign part of his duties at the central bank last year, following similarly disparaging remarks about Berlin's Arab and Turkish populations.

"The government views the reputation of the Bundesbank as definitely harmed, domestically and abroad, by Mr. Sarrazin's comments," Merkel's spokesman Steffen Seibert said Monday. "The Bundesbank must be concerned about this."

In his book, Sarrazin maintains that immigrants have taken from Germany's welfare system without contributing enough to the country.

Sarrazin, a member of Germany's left-leaning Social Democrats, urged critics to read his 460-page book before reacting, insisting that his comments were being taken out of context and that his book , "Deutschland Schafft Sich Ab," or "Germany Abolishes Itself," consists largely of "well-documented analysis."

"We could save ourselves 80 percent of all political discussion and the remaining 20 percent would be much more fruitful, if we could first concentrate on the analysis, and then the evaluation and the political response," Sarrazin said Monday at a news conference. "Unfortunately, it usually works the opposite."

In his book, the 65-year-old Sarrazin maintains that "immigrants are not all the same," insisting that "most of the cultural and economic problems are concentrated in a group of the five to six million immigrants from Muslim countries."

Drawing the comparison to other ethnic groups who have immigrated to Germany, including those from Eastern Europe, China and Vietnam, he says Muslims in particular live in parallel societies for many generations.

"Only 3 percent of Turkish immigrants in the second generation marry German partners, as compared with 70 percent of ethnic Germans from Russia," Sarrazin said.

As part of his argument, Sarrazin cites the controversial 1994 book published in the U.S. by Charles Murray and Richard Herrnstein, "The Bell Curve," which claimed that intelligence is a genetically linked characteristic of race. The theories on which that book was based have since been discredited by a panel of Harvard University scholars.

"Even in the second and third generations, the level of participation in education and integration in the job market shown by these groups is far below that of Germans or other immigrant groups and their descendants," Sarrazin said of immigrants from Muslim countries.

Germany's Jewish and Muslim communities condemned his remarks.

"This man is trying to reduce the problem (of integration) to the ethnic origin of people and is then vilifying them on that basis," said Kenan Kolat, a leading member of the Turkish community. "It is pure racism."

The general secretary of Germany's Jewish Community said Sarrazin would fit better in a far-right party rather than in the left-leaning Social Democrats. At the same time, he urged politicians to spend less energy on the banker's remarks and more on the issue he discusses.

"Sarrazin is only the result of other problems, especially the inability of politicians to meet the challenges of immigration and integration and to develop a strategy for the future," Stephan Kramer said in a statement after excerpts of the book were released last week.

Germany has shown little tolerance for anti-Semitic remarks since the Holocaust but many immigrants have complained about being the targets of racist remarks and xenophobic behavior.

Social Democratic leaders launched proceedings Monday that could force Sarrazin from the party, the news agency DAPD reported.

___

Associated Press Writer Geir Moulson contributed to this report.

FOLLOW HUFFPOST BOOKS

BERLIN — Germany's central bank distanced itself Monday from a board member who stereotyped Muslims and Jews, saying his remarks were harmful and violated the Bundesbank's code of conduct. The co...
BERLIN — Germany's central bank distanced itself Monday from a board member who stereotyped Muslims and Jews, saying his remarks were harmful and violated the Bundesbank's code of conduct. The co...
Filed by Amy Hertz  | 
 
 
  • Comments
  • 8
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Recency  | 
Popularity
05:49 PM on 09/10/2010
News today: "Controversial German central bank board member, Thilo Sarrazin, has resigned from his post in the wake of mounting pressure over comments he made which were interpreted by many as being xenophobic."

http://www.dw-world.de/dw/article/0,,5991445,00.html
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Ron Broxted
05:02 PM on 09/03/2010
Herr Sarrazin certainly does not have much of a grasp on genetics with his comments on Jews and genes. Hammer has done research into cohanim ancestry and there is a high correlation of descent. It would be facile (and dangerous) to start assigning biological markers to either Sephardi or Ashkenazi communities based on Sarrazin's views.
03:34 PM on 08/31/2010
Sarrazin, a high official of the German equivalent of the U.S. Federal Reserve, must fired immediately and barred from any future role in German government. The antisemitic sentiment he has expressed (the supposed genetic "otherness" of Jews) is not just any obnoxious opinion. It is right out of Mein Kampf and Goebbels' propaganda. It is the rock bottom basis for the historical demonization of Jews in Germany going back to the 1850s. It is the very essence of the antisemitism of the Nazi State.

If there is one guy in the German government with views like this there are undoubtedly many. For me, the son of a Jewish Holocaust survivor, even one German with such views in a position of power is way too many.
03:45 PM on 08/31/2010
And he didn't just say "all Jews share the same gene". The NY Times reported yesterday that he said "all Jews share a particular gene. That makes them different from other peoples."
http://www.nytimes.com/2010/08/30/world/europe/30iht-german.html
05:26 PM on 09/06/2010
Please do not be alarmed, at least not concerning Sarrazin.

First of, Sarrazin has a craving for smart immigrants, and in his book he states basically that he would love all immigrants to be orthodox Jews from Eastern Europe, cause they display an average IQ of 115. Also the "Jew Gene" comment was actually a comment on genes that ethnicities share. He cited Jews (meaning ethnic, not reformed) and Basques (Northern Spain region) in one sentence.

Meanwhile, most German media elites and the entire political establishement are under fierce attack by the (polled) majority of Germans, who support Sarrazin.
So now, you have two possibilities:
A. All Germans have turned full-blown Nazis over night.
B. Polititians and dreamy social romantics in the media are playing the Nazi card against Sarrazin to discredit his very thorough analysis of 40 years of failed immigration policy by said media and political parties.

Dont fear, and I hope that soon english wikipedia will feature a concise summary of the content of the book, so that you can read for yourself.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
danew13
12:38 PM on 08/30/2010
i fear this is only the beginning...or re start of european racism and the world economy and unemployment remains high...read Islamophobia at.http://www.hard-truths.blogspot.com
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Trina Roach
“Never not broken”
05:12 PM on 09/01/2010
This isn't the "re-start" of anything. Thilo Sarrazin unfortunately represents the same kind of pseudo-grasp on reality that teabaggers in the States do ("He's really a Muslim and was born in Kenya"). Although Jews were mentioned on the periphery of this lunatic rant, Sarrazin's real target is Muslims, as well as non-white Germans. Because of them (us!), German is in danger of "dumbing down" and losing its status as the de facto "Master Race" in Europe.

No mention of the sacrifices "Gastarbeiter" made that contributed - and continue to contribute°! - to German economic progress. No mention, either, of the institutionalized day-to-day prejudice that "other's" non-Aryan Germans and keeps them from successfully fulfilling their full potential and playing a productive part in the continued growth and progress of Germany as a nation.

Here is the English translation of a German-language comment I posted on FB earlier in the day:

"...This indescribable discussion - set off by Mr. Sarrazin - it the greatest motivation AGAINST integration there can be. Everyone who has been successful integrated simply becomes (almost) invisible in public - not worthy of more than a peripheral footnote. Our lives and our accomplishments represent nothing, because they have not weight on the scale of public discourse.

So: If you are incapable of integration, you are unwelcome. If you are fully integrated you are - invisible!

What a choice!..."
05:39 AM on 09/22/2010
The irony is that Jew and many Muslims are related to the same lines of middle-eastern desent.