Huffington Post Readers' Picks: 7 Movies That Are Better Than The Book (PHOTOS)

Late last month we showed that the tired saying, "the book is so much better than the movie," doesn't always hold true. "Sideways," "The Princess Bride," and "Psycho" among them, we compiled a list of 15 cinematic masterpieces that surpass their literary counterparts. Nevertheless, you came out in droves with many, many more.

So, here's a list of 7 films that were repeatedly mentioned in the thousand-plus comments left on the last slide show.

Still, are there any more? What other movies are better than the book? Also, did readers miss the mark on any of these picks? Let us know ...

1 of 7

Fight Club

1 of 8

First Slide

Previous Slide

@

Book by Chuck Palahniuk

8 Legendary Same-Sex Couples (PHOTOS)

On the Resurgence of Occupy Wall Street: Five Must-Read Books

Leadership Advice: 9 Things Obama Could Learn From Caesar

gadgets/slideshows/225673/slide_225673_962522_small.jpg

The 9 Craziest 'Bachelor' Contestants (WATCH)

7 Things You Need To Know Before You Get Married

11 People You Don't Want To Be Friends With

Book by Chuck Palahniuk

comments(425)

Total comments: 425 | Post a Comment

1 of 8

This Adaptation

Rank #2  |  Average: 4

Should've Stayed On The Page Burns The Book

• 
  1
• 
  2
• 
  3
• 
  4
• 
  5
• 
  6
• 
  7
• 
  8
• 
  9
• 
  10

Top 5 Adaptations

loading...

Top 5 Adaptations

UserName

 | Become a fan

Picked These as the Top 5 Slides in the Slideshow

loading...

Top User Slides

← Prev|Next →

 | Become a fan

Picked These as the Top 5 Slides in the Slideshow

loading...

Users who voted on this slide

← Prev|Next →

loading...

Comments

[Steve Saragossi]

04:46 PM on 11/25/2010

Disagree with almost all the choices on there, except MAYBE Planet of the Apes. The Godfather is definitely one that should have made the cut. As is Spartacus by Howard Fast, A High Wind in Jamaica by Richard Hughes, Walkabout by James Vance Marshall, The Beguiled by Thomas Cullinen, and Bullitt by Frank L Pike.

[W. Drew Curtis]

10:20 AM on 11/13/2010

The Godfather. Puzo's book was good but Coppola took it to another level with the movie.

[Culture101]

06:46 AM on 11/09/2010

I had to re watch and re read A clockwork orange for a play i had to review, the book definitely tops the films, the review can be found at the link below :)

http://cult101.blogspot.com

[HappyVomit]

08:58 PM on 11/07/2010

I forgot Harry Potter and the...whoops, no.

Although a case could be made for Order of the Phoenix. God that book just went on and on. The movie was only slightly more tolerable.

[HappyVomit]

08:53 PM on 11/07/2010

Children of Men. The movie was phenomenal, the book by P D James which I read some time ago was merely 'meh', though it had, of course, a great concept. The movie, I thought, was pants-wettingly brilliant.

Agree with the earlier poster about 'High and Low'. The book King's Ransom was pretty good, though I'm not a huge fan of crime fiction, but Kurosawa's adaptation was superb, one of his best films up there with Seven Samurai, Ikiru, Yojimbo and Red Beard.

[Culture101]

06:45 AM on 11/09/2010

I totally agree, amazing film, so-so book. :)

http://cult101.blogspot.com

[Culture101]

02:38 PM on 11/07/2010

I agree with all bar Carrie, the film is good, but come on have you read the novel. It takes a lot to beat Stephen King, and i don't think the film does it.

http://cult101.blogspot.com

[Number 6]

01:23 PM on 11/07/2010

Ah.... here's one. The original film version of "Get Carter" with Michael Caine. Considerably better than the Ted Lewis book it was based on "Jack's Return Home."

[JDM73]

06:43 PM on 11/06/2010

"Carrie"? No. Good movie, great book (the indirect way in which King told his story made all the difference).
Actually, I would have put "Naked Lunch" on this list. I'm a big fan of Burroughs but, while "Naked Lunch" is his best-known work, it's far from his finest (that would be "Cities of the Red Night"). My attention wandered when I read the book, but David Cronenberg did a great job of conveying the flavor of Burroughs's writing in the film.

[SvrWx]

01:10 PM on 11/06/2010

Then there are the movies in which they are better than the book but in the same right, the book is better than the movie. Two come to mind:

"All Quiet on the Western Front". The book is amazing but the movie is to. It almost appears that when you read the book it is superior to the movie, but then you see the movie and it seems better than the book.

the next is " To Kill a Mockingbird".

[Culture101]

02:40 PM on 11/07/2010

No!! Just no, come on Harper lee is brilliant. I suppose the film is also amazing but i'm not sure if you can say that

http://cult101.blogspot.com

[SvrWx]

03:30 PM on 11/07/2010

She is brilliant, but the movie is so well made that when I watch the movie, I find it stands on it's own and appears better than the book. But then I read the book and it is so much better.

One book I wish they would make a better movie of is "Lord of the Flies".

[Fran Jaime]

02:58 AM on 11/06/2010

While I like the movie version of "Carrie", the ending is not nearly half as good as the book's.

[NitramNos]

03:54 PM on 11/05/2010

"Clockwork Orange", "2001: A Space Odyssey", and "The Shining". Is there a pattern here?

[Number 6]

01:14 PM on 11/07/2010

The genius of Stanley Kubrick?

[Culture101]

02:40 PM on 11/07/2010

very much so. The film is tonnes better!

http://cult101.blogspot.com

[TweetwFallnFish]

01:18 PM on 11/05/2010

The fact that "LA Confidential" is on this list proves what the inclusion of "Fight Club" and "Carrie" made me suspect - whoever compiled this list didn't read the books. Or at least, needs to refresh their memory with a re-reading.

[BlackJAC]

01:55 PM on 11/08/2010

I would suspect that the choices were made based on the styles of the books in question.  LA Confidential and Fight Club aren't straightforward prose, which is probably why preference is given to the movie adaptations.

[DinaDinaDina]

08:57 AM on 11/05/2010

Every Stephen King movie has been the pits except the first "Carrie."

[SvrWx]

01:06 PM on 11/06/2010

I disagree. The majority have been horrid but the few that weren't are: The Shining, The Mist, Carrie, and Stand by Me.

[Culture101]

02:42 PM on 11/07/2010

King movies are on occasion good, its just that King is so much better.

http://cult101.blogspot.com

[isaidit]

12:27 PM on 11/13/2010

I thought "Misery" was pruty darn good.

[DinaDinaDina]

08:55 AM on 11/05/2010

The movie, "The Firm" had a much cleaner ending than the book. In the book, Tom Cruise's character was left to run from the mob forever - his life was ruined.

[isaidit]

07:17 AM on 11/05/2010

Movie better than the book, says ye? Every Tom Clancy story that was made into a movie.

[W. Drew Curtis]

10:15 AM on 11/13/2010

I totally agree. Clancy books just seem to go on and on and on. Alec Baldwin and Harrison Ford's turns as Jack Ryan were all pretty good, especially compared to the books.