More

Sakineh Mohammadi Ashtiani, Stoning Case Defendant, Has Not Yet Received Verdict Says France

MISHA DZHINDZHIKHASHVILI   11/ 3/10 04:41 PM ET   AP

Stoning Iran

TBILISI, Georgia — Iran's foreign minister said Wednesday that no final decision has been made about a woman who could be stoned to death for adultery, amid reports that her execution was imminent.

Manouchehr Mottaki's statement follows an international outcry over the stoning sentence against the 43-year-old woman, Sakineh Mohammadi Ashtiani.

"Everyone has to be punished for murder," Mottaki said at a news conference in Tbilisi, the capital of Georgia. "The person has killed her husband and I think this fact will be considered as a crime in every country ... But in this case the final decision has not been made yet."

Earlier Wednesday, French Foreign Minister Bernard Kouchner also said in a statement that Mottaki had told him that a final verdict in Ashtiani's case has not been issued yet and that reports "about her eventual execution don't correspond to reality." But Kouchner said France is "very worried" about the case.

Iran has temporarily suspended the stoning verdict and has suggested Ashtiani might be hanged instead.

The case has further elevated tensions between Iran and the West, already running high over suspicions about Tehran's nuclear ambitions.

The office of Canadian Prime Minister Stephen Harper said his wife Laureen Harper sent an open letter to Iranian President Mahmoud Ahmedinejad calling for Ashtiani's release. Mrs. Harper wrote that she was "deeply troubled by the flagrant disregard of women's rights in Iran" and said Ashtiani's case "is an affront to any sense of moral or human decency."

Iran's official IRNA news agency quoted Malek Ajdar Sharifi, a top local judiciary official, as saying Wednesday that Ashtiani was in good health in a prison in Tabriz, northwestern Iran.

Sharifi didn't say if Ashtiani will be executed or not but said her case "is being investigated and is undergoing administrative procedures."

He accused the media in the West for spreading false news about Ashtiani aimed at discrediting Iran.

The International Committee against Stoning and International Committee against Execution said in a statement this week that Iranian authorities had given the go-ahead for Ashtiani's execution, and that it could happen Wednesday. The group would not provide details on where its information came from.

But its report raised alarm in western capitals. The EU's foreign policy chief, Catherine Ashton, was "deeply concerned" by the reports and "demands that Iran halt the execution and convert her sentence," Ashton's office said in a statement.

Ashtiani was first convicted in May 2006 of having an "illicit relationship" with two men after the death of her husband – for which a court in Tabriz sentenced her to 99 lashes. Later that year she was also convicted of adultery, despite having retracted a confession, which she claims was made under duress.

____

Associated Press reporter Angela Doland contributed from Paris.

FOLLOW HUFFPOST WORLD

Filed by Cara Parks  | 
 
 
  • Comments
  • 1,268
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
Page: 1 2 3 4 5  Next ›  Last »  (16 total)
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
12:52 PM on 11/05/2010
Of course this is no reason for America to consider war with Iran. If it were we would have been at war with China long ago.
From what I can gather from other sites this woman was aquitted of her husbands Murder.
So the Complainant/Victim of the "Adultery" charge is dead. There is no complaining wittness.
If her husband were alive ,he could forgive her for the adultry, and refuse to cooperate with the state in this prosection(in a free society) , HE can't forgive her now as he is dead.
There is NO justice in this Courts finding. It is just a case of 'If we can't get you one way, we will get you another.'

If anyone in the world has ever had the slightest idea that a Church/Court system could be superior to a Secular Court based of Secular statutes, they should review this case.

You could not make up a Halloween House of Horrors scarier than this.
11:35 PM on 11/04/2010
This is the one site on the internet where most posters will side with Iran over the US (and, of course Israel) no matter what the subject at hand.Pathetic.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
sbrannon
thinker, photojournalist, humanitarian
04:28 PM on 11/04/2010
I read an article that she had a conversation with her husbands killer before he killed him. She said that he said that he was going to kill her husband, but she did not believe him. The problem is, she is tried for murder and adultery, after her husbands death. They stone women and men as a normal policy. However, we as Americans should not involve ourselves, nor make this an excuse to go to war to put more money in the corporate pockets and destroy more lives, spend our money on....another war? Augh please no, don't let that happen
Gasparilla
buy your local newspaper
05:16 PM on 11/04/2010
You can't believe anything she has supposedly "said", because she is not free to say anything.
photo
karim banned
A fool's mind is at the mercy of his tongue and a
05:22 PM on 11/04/2010
No just believe warmongers propaganda.
09:04 PM on 11/04/2010
So we should go to war with Iran because you suggest she is lying about her husband's death?
photo
karim banned
A fool's mind is at the mercy of his tongue and a
05:18 PM on 11/04/2010
"However, we as Americans should not involve ourselves, nor make this an excuse to go to war to put more money in the corporate pockets and destroy more lives, spend our money on....another war? Augh please no, don't let that happen"

This is exactly what will happen.

Selective reporting and negative propaganda is a hallmark of western media to create animosities between nations to create news wars for their masters (financiers).

I have heard George Galloway says that %25 of all prisoners in the world are in US.

Isn't it time for US to address its own problems?
photo
karim banned
A fool's mind is at the mercy of his tongue and a
03:47 PM on 11/04/2010
I listen to George Galloway live on Press TV now.

http://www.presstv.com/live/llnw/

He states %25 of all prisoners in the world are in US.

Why US does not concentrate to solve its own problem first before interfering in other countries internal affairs?
04:02 PM on 11/04/2010
Because maybe it just saved Ashtiani from being stoned? Not that your formulation for militant tunnel vision isn't wrong on its own grounds. Enjoy your PressTV, if you're lucky perhaps you can catch the rerun of Ashtiani's 'confession.'
photo
karim banned
A fool's mind is at the mercy of his tongue and a
04:15 PM on 11/04/2010
There was no stoning verdict to begin with and you know about it.

It is all western propaganda to demonize Iran to prepare condition for another invasion in another Muslim country.

This life is short, do not waist it on propaganda, you might not get a break in the other world.
09:06 PM on 11/04/2010
Yeah, nice deflection, you totally missed the point of the comment you were replying to. We have massive internal problems, by far the highest incarceration rate in the world, we too execute people, often innocent people. Lets fix our own problems first, or do you not agree?
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
tiredoftheBS
11:40 AM on 11/04/2010
We have much better values than they do, Christians do not believe in stoning for adultery. But that's the only moderate belief they hold.
01:53 PM on 11/04/2010
Christianity believes in killing adulterers and adulteresses, but it does not specify how to put them to death. The Bible just says that they should be put to death. I listed many verses from both the OT and NT, but the moderators chose not to post them.
photo
GraphicMatt
Somebody make me a sandwich!
03:38 PM on 11/04/2010
The difference is it may be in the book, but as a country we are reasonable enough to not practice it.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
sbrannon
thinker, photojournalist, humanitarian
04:28 PM on 11/04/2010
Agreed
10:45 AM on 11/04/2010
If she was sentenced to life in prisonment for adultery, would we be having this conversation. I'm curious. Is it the death penalty, the method of stoning, or the criminalization of adultery that we are reacting against. If she was sentenced to 2 years house arrest and work in an orphange, how would we feel.

It's far from perfect, but i'm glad I'm in the US of A, even if the Ukraine girls can knock you out.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
sbrannon
thinker, photojournalist, humanitarian
04:34 PM on 11/04/2010
If you look at reality, stoning someone is just as bad as what we do in Afghanistan, and Iraq. As one of the wealthiest countries in the world, we let 70,000 men, women and children rot in skid row, blocks away from Hollywood and do nothing about it, don't think that people have a right to medical care, and don't try our past president for war crimes and crimes against his own people, by lying to us and causing all this mess. Who are we to say anything?
photo
JJovana
Live & let live
10:25 AM on 11/04/2010
Islam, religion of peace. What a joke and a lie. Such a dangerous religion, its mindblowing.
10:49 AM on 11/04/2010
Totalitarian ideology is more like it.
12:29 PM on 11/04/2010
You beat me to it. Thanks.
12:48 PM on 11/04/2010
She committed the murder of her husband. How would the U.S. punish a murderer? If a woman in the U.S. killed her husband, should she walk or get the death penalty? I'm curious about your views.
01:39 PM on 11/04/2010
"She committed the murder of her husband."

Based on what evidence? In any case it was adultery that netted her a stoning sentence.
02:47 PM on 11/04/2010
You are a lying tool recklessly throwing out charges you are unable to back up.
photo
GirlUsingBrain
The most dangerous animal in the forest is man.
09:59 AM on 11/04/2010
You can help. Please sign the petition to help free her and her son who is now imprisoned for helping his mom..

http://freesakineh.org/

It only takes a minute!
09:20 AM on 11/04/2010
It seems funny to me that right wingers, who so vociferously support the death penalty here, are anxious to condemn other countries for having the death penalty on the books - and using it- in their own countries. Hypocrisy, anyone?
10:05 AM on 11/04/2010
It's hypocrisy to be against killing someone for adultery while executing only MURDERERS yourself? Then fine...it's a hypocrisy that's moral and just fine with the overwhelming majority of non-loonies.
09:03 AM on 11/04/2010
It saddens my heart to learn that we as God's people are still carrying
out vicious acts of punishment to humans. This is a Biblical act that Jesus
himself had compassion about. He informed her accusers,if they were without
sins to cast the first stones,how many stones were cast? None ! Think about
what is going to happen here and ask yourself the accusers, Am I sin free!!
09:03 AM on 11/04/2010
GravitonX said; "I think there is more to this story than the headline. I'm not sure that having sex with a couple of men after her husband's death is the real reason. It's not atypical for Western media sources to leave out key details because it doesn't fit into the narrative that "those foreigners are crazy.""

Well then, is there a more complex narrative surrounding the hanging of two gay teens from a crane in a public square? A more complex narrative around the hanging of a 16 year old girl for partying too much? (Atefah Sahaaleh) Sometimes things are as they appear.

No, it's not a surprise to only get a piece of a story from MSM, but to discount the brutality of this justice system in favor of broad skepticism is naive at best.
08:57 AM on 11/04/2010
Well, this thread proves there are people that will excuse anything. Karim and other apologists for Sharia are all over telling us that Iran is doing nothing wrong so I'm curious...do you also think it's ok that Iran executes gay men (I should say kids since that last bunch they executed had a couple of teenage boys who were 14 years old.) Not one of you extremists ever answer when I ask this particular questions so I'm not holding my breath...
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
rougebaisers
08:04 AM on 11/04/2010
Sickening and brutal people.
photo
GirlUsingBrain
The most dangerous animal in the forest is man.
10:02 AM on 11/04/2010
No ... sickening and brutal regime.

The Iranian people are repressed and oppressed and many have been ki||ed and imprisoned for trying to change Iran.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
TaylorSiluwe
02:47 PM on 11/04/2010
Yes, I agree. I feel for Iranians.

But America is no endless party, and our Christians are more often than not far from Christ-like.
Gasparilla
buy your local newspaper
07:15 AM on 11/04/2010
Her lawyer is in hiding and her son who has defended her has disappeared and the Iranians will release no info about him. Two German journalists who tried to interview him were arrested.
06:59 AM on 11/04/2010
Meanwhile Affia Siddiqui, a Pakistani and US national just underwent a farce trial in the US... After disappearing for years with some reports suggesting she was held and reportedly tortured in Bagram, she was finally convicted in 2010 for life...

What was she charged for? Not the original supposed crime that she was picked up for (along with her kids who were also held for a couple of years), of course that couldn't be proven, instead she was charged for shooting a US guard during an interrogation in Afghanistan with HIS OWN GUN!!!!!! The guard in turn apparently shot her back but didn't kill her.

How convenient!

Where is the coverage on her????????
photo
Vlady
Better Late
09:07 PM on 11/04/2010
>>Where is the coverage on her?

Here is CNN about this Al Kaeda thug.

http://articles.cnn.com/2010-09-23/justice/siddiqui.sentence_1_afghan-attack-afghan-police-aafia-siddiqui?_s=PM:CRIME
05:57 PM on 11/05/2010
Thing is she didn't get convicted of what she was picked up for.... It was for shooting a guard during investigation. The charges she was picked up for wasn't a chargeable offense, which basically means u couldn't prove it......