More

Steny Hoyer: Tax Cuts For Wealthy Are 'Ransom'

First Posted: 12/07/10 02:27 PM ET Updated: 05/25/11 07:15 PM ET

Hoyer

WASHINGTON — House Majority Leader Steny Hoyer said Tuesday that if Democrats don't pay the Republican ransom on tax cuts, America's middle class will be forced to foot the bill at the end of the year.

"The president is in a very difficult position," said Hoyer, noting that on Dec. 30 middle-income tax rates are scheduled to go up. "If we don't pay the ransom," Hoyer told reporters at the Capitol Tuesday, "around 118 million Americans are going to pay the price."

At his weekly press availability, Hoyer declined to say whether his caucus would support the tax cut package, expressing concern over the deal the president reached with Senate Republicans.

Hoyer criticized Republicans for holding tax cuts for the middle class "hostage," adding that the bill that reflected the Democrats' true position was the one defeated in the Senate on Saturday.

He blamed arcane Senate procedures for the failure of the legislation.

"I think it reflected the majority of the views in the U.S. Senate," said Hoyer of Democrats' bill. "Unfortunately you need 60 votes."

Pelosi has also tried to draw a clear line between what Democrats want and what Republicans are pushing for, emphasizing intentions over results.

"The tax proposal announced by the President clearly presents the differences between Democrats and Republicans. Any provision must be judged by two criteria: does it create jobs to grow our economy and does it add to the deficit?" said Pelosi in a statement Tuesday.

"The Democratic provisions will create jobs and help 155 million workers through tax cuts for the middle class, helping working families who are struggling and growing the economy. The Republican demands would provide tax cuts to the millionaires and billionaires, fail to create jobs and increase the deficit."

Chris Van Hollen, who will serve as the top Democrat on the House Budget Committee next year, has indicated that Democrats have serious reservations about the tax cut package. And House Democratic Conference Chair John Larson has hinted that Democrats may try to make some changes to the plan.

The House "always likes to put its own imprimatur on everything that we do," he told reporters after Hoyer's press conference was adjourned.

If Congress fails to reauthorize the unemployment benefits, it will be the first time in more than half a century that extended benefits have been allowed to expire when the national unemployment rate is above 7.2 percent.

Even if President Obama manages to reach a deal with Republicans that would extend Bush-era tax cuts for two years and unemployment benefits for one year, as was discussed Saturday, such a deal will fall far short of a Democratic victory.

HuffPost's Arthur Delaney notes that in 1983, a GOP-controlled Senate and White House reauthorized benefits for 17 months.

FOLLOW HUFFPOST POLITICS
Subscribe to the HuffPost Hill newsletter!
WASHINGTON — House Majority Leader Steny Hoyer said Tuesday that if Democrats don't pay the Republican ransom on tax cuts, America's middle class will be forced to foot the bill at the end of th...
WASHINGTON — House Majority Leader Steny Hoyer said Tuesday that if Democrats don't pay the Republican ransom on tax cuts, America's middle class will be forced to foot the bill at the end of th...
 
 
  • Comments
  • 246
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Bloggers
Recency  | 
Popularity
Page: 1 2 3 4 5  Next ›  Last »  (9 total)
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
waynesmyer
06:10 AM on 12/08/2010
SPINELESS GUTLESS COWARDS! WTF is Obama and the blue dog DemoRATS thinking? Caving in to the GOPers on stealing from the poor to give to the rich! Next, they will kill Social Security & Meducare!
10:04 PM on 12/07/2010
The Dem's have no one to blame but themselves. For the past two years with large majorities in the house and senate we have a milk toast health care reform and a financial reform that does not stop the system from continuing their past behavior. Why? Because in every case the democrats caved. Even in the votes this past Saturday, five dem's voted with republicans. These tax issues should have been brought up before the elections and used as part of the platform. Democrats have let Republicans control the message, and they have no one to blame but themselves.
09:00 PM on 12/07/2010
Pass the tax bill through budget reconciliation then, Hoyer. Don't listen to the spineless "Commander in Chief." That is how you lost your majority in the first place.
photo
CanuckistanCommie
I ain't no Commie but Pat Buchanan thinks so!!
08:55 PM on 12/07/2010
309 million American are gonna pay the price if this deal goes through.
Financial analysts claim that this will cost upwards of $900 billion over the next 2 years.
That is $3000 for every man woman and child over the 2 years.
That is $1500 per year. How much of a tax break will you get this year?
A family of 4, that is $6000 they are inheriting annually. Does your tax break offset that amount?
08:54 PM on 12/07/2010
Here's a genius idea, you could have let this go to a filibuster in the Senate, watching public anger mount as Republicans read cookbooks for 3 weeks while America figured out who was the Party of the Plutocracy and how the burden was being shifted to the poor and Middle Class yet again! Or they could have done this by reconciliation in October while there was a budget in place. 50 votes plus Biden. Presto! And why not? Bush passed these tax cuts by reconciliation in the first place!!
08:32 PM on 12/07/2010
Republican senators & congressman love this plan they are all wealthy and their ideology is government should only be for to help the rich & the corporations....NOT for the people, people are just the workers who pay taxes!

The republicans got their huge gigantic tax cuts for the very wealthy - That's what they wanted, filibustered for, held up unemployment insurance for - tax cuts for the rich!

Tax cuts for the wealthiest 2% will raise the deficit and has every year, these humongous tax cuts are not paid for..... but the republicans do not care...they have never cared about the deficit when it comes to the spending for the rich & their corporations and the things the republicans want.

So if the republicans pretend to scream about this tax cut bill that they wanted so badly and used backhanded tactics to receive - and when they start mentioning unemployment insurance will add to the deficit just KNOW it's all BS - The republicans got exactly what they wanted and they couldn't care less about the deficit!

The only thing that bothers the republicans is that middle-class received unemployment insurance and small business also received some money....

Because republican ideology dictates that government should be only for the rich and their corporations not to help people in need with our tax dollars!

This Bush 10-year DEFICIT raising, NO jobs producing, UNPAID for, tax cuts for the wealthiest 2% MUST be allowed to EXPIRE!!
08:58 PM on 12/07/2010
There are 94K 'pretend' black farmers who could help you out with some cash.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Daniel Malo
08:16 PM on 12/07/2010
PREZ FAIL

www.facebook.com/free.the.leaf
cannabis=industry.medicine.peace.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
TheScarletPimpernel
Pimpernelin aint Easy !
07:16 PM on 12/07/2010
Steny and Clyburn could not whip the votes prior to the election to get 218 in the house and the there was no way they were going to get anywhere near 60 in the Senate.If they could they would have bought it to the floor.No question about it.They did not want the debate because the extension was going to cost 3 trillion.. Those are the facts folks.They did not have the votes so rather than be defeated and hand the GOP ammo for the election they took the chance Obama could get them a deal and this is it.
Now the base is standing around bitching well keep bitching.It aint gonna do any good.We dont have the votes.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
xargaw
07:11 PM on 12/07/2010
No Steny, you could go out and make a case to the American people that are already 80% on your side and let them put pressure on the corrupt GOP.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
MmeFlutterbye
Mmeflutterbye
07:03 PM on 12/07/2010
"The president is in a very difficult position," said Hoyer, noting that on Dec. 30 middle-income tax rates are scheduled to go up. "If we don't pay the ransom," Hoyer told reporters at the Capitol Tuesday, "around 118 million Americans are going to pay the price."

President Obama had the choice of fighting this to the bitter end, or saving the Middle Class from a tax increase. The Greedy Old Party is expert at extortion. We've found that out in the last two years if we didn't already know it before. Greed is in the DNA of conservatives. Much as they yell about being more patriotic than the Liberals, they have proven the opposite this week. They do not care about the country and its enormous debt. They care only that their own pockets are full. If Democratic activists abandon the party now, they will be doing just what the Republicans want them to do. This is not the time to forsake the party. This is the time to plan for the future.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
lpenny
09:06 PM on 12/07/2010
Obama Caved on this and he will cave on everything else. Now is the time to form a new party and put forth candidates that will work on our behalf. The Republicans have whipped the Dem's. They have lost their focus. They might talk a good game but talk is cheap, the final product is what matters. Next Social Security will be privatized, the retirement age will rise, unemployment will have to be fought for every 18 months, our rights will be eroded, the banks will be allowed to take your home without proof of ownership (no deed=no owner) this will go on and on until we put into office candidates who will represent our interest. If the Dem's oppose the deal and vote it down than I may think they have a chance. If they go along with it...they will have to cave on everything...The Caveman and the party of Cave ins. We are in deep .....
09:32 PM on 12/07/2010
@Ipenny
Your avatar suits you well because your views are immature. As you know there are real people who's lives hang in the balance when it comes to UI and the tax cuts, tax earned credits etc. Last week I felt just like you do I was yelling at the TV about standing strong against the terrorism of the repubs. "Dont give in to their ransom demands" my cousin said to me that her sister was on UI and was barely hangong on to her home- my stomach sank and I was reminded that their are real lives at stake and we cant get caught up in the rethugs politic games. Im greatful we have a President who can stand strong and due whats necessary to protect the vulnerable among us.
06:57 PM on 12/07/2010
Wait a minute here.....who is in control anyway? I thought Obama was the president. Why are dems suddenly making deals because they are taken hostage. There's something very wrong with this picture.
07:09 PM on 12/07/2010
Dems not taken hostage. Middle Class is held hostage. This is not collaboration, it's a threat. Shut down the Republicans.
12:56 PM on 12/09/2010
catbite, I agree, so how does one shut down and up the repubs?
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
conservicide
I don't play nice.
06:53 PM on 12/07/2010
GDAMIT dems, WE'll put up with the repug.nant stonewalling, YOU grow a pair.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
06:34 PM on 12/07/2010
if somehow something that hoyer is saying here makes sense, can someone please translate it into common american english.

the failure of the democrats to act with conviction is the a problem of the republicans' making. hoyer has failed as any sort of leader.
06:31 PM on 12/07/2010
What Hoyer is saying is absolutely true. But, it's a failure of messaging and persuasion (Mr. President) that the reality of the "ransom" was not more widely known. An effective use of the bully pulpit with a little bit of proactive leadership, would have gone a long way towards NOT being put in the position of "compromise." In effect, by his lack of foresight and fight, Obama allowed himself to be cornered. And, when he comes out swinging, it's at those of us who are pointing out his failures. Unlike the Republicans, I want him to succeed.
MyrtleJune
STOP negotiating! End the American hostage crisis!
06:26 PM on 12/07/2010
There is no excuse for destroying the party like this. NONE.