Creating Urban Agriculture, One Roof At A Time (VIDEO)

Huffington Post   First Posted: 01/18/11 04:25 PM ET Updated: 05/25/11 07:25 PM ET

Traditionally, farmers take it easy in the winter. But urban farmer Ben Flanner has never been so busy. He is trying to get more New York rooftops ready to grow new shingles of Sun Gold tomatoes, salad greens, and carrots before the next season begins.

"We want to see a lot more roofs across the city covered with farms and growing healthy vegetables," said Flanner, head farmer at Brooklyn Grange, New York's biggest rooftop farm located (despite its name) in Long Island City, Queens.

Started last May, in its first season the 40,000 square-foot organic rooftop farm covered with 1.2 million pounds of soil provided New Yorkers with 15,000 pounds of fresh produce that was traditionally shipped into the city from far away, creating pollution and waste.

Almost a year into the project, Flanner has now learned some lessons which he willingly shares.

"In terms of crops, plants in the nightshade family including tomatoes, peppers and eggplants worked very well," he said. "Salad greens, carrots, and radishes also worked. Big cabbage plants don't work quite as well 'cause they are deep, heavy feeders."

Flanner's project was not without its bugs--the animal, not the electronic kind. Insects are a problem of organic farming everywhere. However, reconstructed natural eco-systems like a roof don't harbor natural predators, so the pests can turn out to be even more obnoxious than usual.

"We had some harlequin bugs," Flanner said. "In the next season we'll focus on introducing natural predators to those bugs as well as staying on top of them and literally killing them with our fingers."

How to tackle the wind was another lesson learned.

"You want to minimize the stress on the plant to as low level as possible, 'cause then they grow faster and more healthy," Flanner said. "You have to get creative with bamboo sticks to set up tripods and supports and protect the plants."

Brooklyn Grange products are sold directly to restaurants including Fatty Cue, Vesta and also Roberta's, whose owners, Brandon Hoy and Chris Parachini, are Brooklyn Grange partners.

The rooftop farm products can also be found at markets like the one at the first floor of the Queens building where the farm is located (3718 Northern Boulevard) and at the one in front of Roberta's in Bushwick.

Brooklyn Grange also has a selling system called Community Supported Agriculture (CSA) where members pay a lump sum for a weekly supply of fresh vegetables. For $20 a week, CSA members receive a bag of mixed produce each week of the growing season.

The reaction of the community has been overwhelmingly positive, from the volunteers who helped install the farm to the ones who showed up to donate plants and seeds for the roof.

"We were given strawberry plants, raspberries, peppers, bamboo," Flanner said with a laugh. "It's great that people get involved, it creates a better sense of partnership with everyone in the community."

The Brooklyn Grange has many goals: to create and prove that rooftop farms are a sustainable business, to get the community involved in the project, and to encourage people to eat more healthily.

"There is a lot of interest and a lot of enthusiasm towards the Grange, we've been speaking with a lot of people," Flanner said. "We'd really like to see more rooftop farms around."

Are you interested into starting a rooftop farm in the city or elsewhere? For more information check out www.brooklyngrangefarm.com

FOLLOW HUFFPOST NEW YORK

Traditionally, farmers take it easy in the winter. But urban farmer Ben Flanner has never been so busy. He is trying to get more New York rooftops ready to grow new shingles of Sun Gold tomatoes, sala...
Traditionally, farmers take it easy in the winter. But urban farmer Ben Flanner has never been so busy. He is trying to get more New York rooftops ready to grow new shingles of Sun Gold tomatoes, sala...
 
 
  • Comments
  • 18
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
photo
HUFFPOST COMMUNITY MODERATOR
jl4141
Unless I'm wrong, I'm never wrong.
03:28 PM on 01/20/2011
I'd sure rather have something like this on the roof of my apartment building, rather than the Verizon cell-tower equipment that's there now.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
GameGuru59
BA in Poli-Sci., more qualified than Glenn Beck
11:18 PM on 01/18/2011
Cool. I love the idea and it sounds like a great way to bring healthy vegetables to the inner city where they aren't always available. Plus some much needed jobs as well.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
William50
11:07 PM on 01/18/2011
I was talking to an elderly gentleman who had been born north of Cut Bank Montana and it being a boring day in the bar he was talking about his mother canning for the winter. From the garden, to feed a family of eight and two hands on the ranch the mother needed six hundred pounds of potatoes. Peas, beans, and other canned goods in quart bottles were thought of as needed fifteen jars of each per month. This came out to six to seven hundred jars from the garden. Plus the root vegetables that could be stored In the root cellar. Now, a roof garden is great. I applauder the idea and those doing this. We have a small garden where ever we live and do enjoy the harvest. But to supply a city or a neighborhood or a family the amount of food and the storage area needed is beyond the ability's of a roof garden. Also the equipment and time to do the processing correctly is almost a forgotten art today. Yes they are green, yes the help and have great food, but to feed a nation of 300 million, most who live in towns or cities requires the huge factory gardens we now have. With out them every family would need an acre to produce the food plus more water then a city could supply.
08:03 AM on 01/19/2011
I understand your point but in many ways you're wrong. The concept, on a nationwide scope, makes sense. Basically, there are LOTS of flat rooftops in every city. Look at a city landscape as farms (not buildings) surrounded by streets. You would have to imagine that just about EVERY rooftop could sport a garden. Imagine looking at such a city from a helicopters. Every time you look straight down, there's more green. This is the stuff of the future and what American cities could and probably should resemble.

Then, factor in the advances in agriculture technology. I think that garden in particular is wasteful as far as space is concerned. They should really have gone hydroponic. And, there are organic hydroponic nutrients available. You can stack the plants closer because the roots don't spread out like with soil.

Remember, this way of farming isn't meant to replace the big farms but instead to rely less on them as well as create a net positive effect on the environment. But the more we venture into this realm, the more we'll be able to produce.
09:41 PM on 01/18/2011
Trucked in dirt is NoT as good as living soil.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Majestry
08:22 PM on 01/18/2011
We should have plants on rooftops all over the city. Even if it is just sod. Replacing the black rooftops with green plants lowers cooling costs, helps with drainage, and takes CO2 out of the atmosphere.
photo
artleads
Let's have a national retreat.
10:51 PM on 01/18/2011
Drainage and ability to bear the soil's weight must be tackled first. Sloping roofs need a sort of bleacher-like construction to allow for potted plants. Challenging and expensive, but it can be done. Yes. Let's have rooftop gardens everywhere.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Majestry
11:46 PM on 01/18/2011
Sod requires almost no soil and weighs very little. Additionally, most flat-roofed buildings already have drainage systems and the amount of water sod or moss requires is very low.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Vincent Gormley
Artist, activist, volunteer, compassion lives
10:57 PM on 01/18/2011
gosh I'm glad you're here posting and making sense my friend. It seems others just can't handle it. Anyway I totally agree with you. Rooftops tend to be wasted space otherwise. It is something I have been interested in for about 40 yrs now.
07:57 PM on 01/18/2011
Wasn't Jon Bon Jovi supporting something like this a couple of years ago?? It's still a great idea.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
DonVitoCorleone
Autodidact, and proud of it!
06:16 PM on 01/18/2011
Very cool. I love this sort of stuff. However, I'm bothered by the term "...prove that rooftop farms are a sustainable business." I wish he would have used the term "determine" as opposed to "prove." I would also question whether it is more cost effective to truck in good produce as opposed to growing it on-site, which seems like an extremely costly proposition. I really hope this works out, but I think they have to be more objective on their analysis.
05:45 PM on 01/18/2011
Good for them
I am about as right as you can be, but also grow and raise 98% of my family's food on a small piece of land, I don't care if your to the left or right. Start growing your own food and canning it.
Don't rely on anyone else giving you food. I even barter some of my extra's for things I need.

10 years ago $600 a month grocery bill now less then $25
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
mitzvah
Optimistic Realist
07:16 PM on 01/18/2011
I'm close to as left as you can be but I am in complete agreement with you on this. There are so many benefits - physical, mental and spiritual - that just can't be gotten any other way to the extent that growing and harvesting one's own food can.

Fabulous financial benefits, as well.
photo
artleads
Let's have a national retreat.
10:53 PM on 01/18/2011
Right on!
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Jesse P. Steinberg
est un habitant.
05:32 PM on 01/18/2011
I thought Bill S 510 made this illegal?
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
patrickmcdougal
07:16 PM on 01/18/2011
that is not really what the bill does. In the circumstance of a biological attack on our food source the department of homeland security is the government agency that would be in charge of such problem.. It does not ban you from planting a tomato plant in your back yard.. The ones screaming Conspiracy of a Big Brother take over are the same people that scream that the US is going to switch to the AMERO currency . All this bill did was clarify what agency is in charge of our food source in case of disaster.