More

Bipartisan Group Of Senators Pledges To Work On Revamping 'No Child Left Behind'

Tom Harkin Education

DORIE TURNER   01/26/11 07:26 PM ET   AP

A bipartisan group of U.S. senators pledged Wednesday to work together to revamp the federal No Child Left Behind education law, a day after President Barack Obama called on lawmakers in his State of the Union address to speed up overhaul of the Bush-era policy.

Senate education committee Chairman Tom Harkin, D-Iowa, said he hopes to have a bill to Obama by the end of the summer.

The law has been credited with raising reading and math scores, but it has also tagged more than a third of U.S. schools as failing and created a hodgepodge of sometimes weak state academic standards.

Harkin and the Obama administration say the top priority is to move away from punishing schools that don't meet federal benchmarks and instead to focus on rewarding schools for progress. In a conference call with reporters, Republican and Democratic senators said they want to put partisan politics aside and fix problems with the 2002 law championed by President George W. Bush.

"We need to get away from Washington announcing whether schools are passing or failing," said Sen. Lamar Alexander, a Republican from Tennessee and former U.S. education secretary. "I don't want to make it sound like it's going to be a piece of cake or too easy, but we're off to a good start."

Other changes range from tossing out the term "highly qualified teacher," which is based on certifications and college degrees rather than efficiency in the classroom, to giving rural schools a reprieve from rules that are designed for urban systems. The changes also include making the law less complex and easier to understand and consolidating federal education programs in hopes of saving overhead costs, lawmakers said.

They brushed off suggestions that the partisan atmosphere in Congress would slow the bill's progress, particularly because of infighting among both parties.

"We're always going to have intraparty little squabbles," Harkin said. "I don't believe we'll be distracted by those."

The White House released a blueprint for overhauling the law last March but it stalled amid election-year maneuvering. Now the Obama administration faces a Republican-led House that could stand as a barrier to changing the law.

The senators said they've been working with House education committee Chairman John Kline, a Republican from Minnesota known as a vocal opponent of federal involvement in education. Kline's spokesman Brian Newell said the chairman is "eager to begin an open process that invites members from both sides of the aisle and both the House and Senate to examine the federal role in our classrooms and what reforms are needed to fix what's broken."

Obama's proposal calls for states to adopt standards that ensure students are ready for college or a career rather than grade-level proficiency – the focus of the current law.

Lawmakers also said they want to allow states to use subjects other than reading and mathematics as part of their measurements for meeting federal goals, pleasing many education groups that argued No Child Left Behind encouraged teachers not to focus on history, art, science, social studies and other important subjects.

Federal lawmakers on both sides have been meeting for months in hopes of paving the way for the bill's passage this year. A first step may be dropping the No Child Left Behind name, which both parties agree is tainted by the problems – rather than the triumphs – of the law.

"We've got a lot of options on how we get it done," said Sen. Mike Enzi of Wyoming, the ranking Republican on the Senate education committee. "We just need to make sure we're getting it done and getting it all done.'"

___(equals)

Associated Press writer Christine Armario contributed to this report.

FOLLOW HUFFPOST EDUCATION

A bipartisan group of U.S. senators pledged Wednesday to work together to revamp the federal No Child Left Behind education law, a day after President Barack Obama called on lawmakers in his State of ...
A bipartisan group of U.S. senators pledged Wednesday to work together to revamp the federal No Child Left Behind education law, a day after President Barack Obama called on lawmakers in his State of ...
Filed by Erica Liepmann  | 
 
 
  • Comments
  • 60
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
Page: 1 2  Next ›  Last »  (2 total)
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Tauna Rogers
10:22 PM on 01/31/2011
A great article on why bipartisanship in education reform is not working can be found at Education Week:

http://www.edweek.org/ew/articles/2011/01/27/20wells.h30.html

Given NCLB, Race to the Top, the unwarranted obsession with standardized test scores, etc., I cringe every time I hear politicians hailing bipartisan consensus on education reform.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Tauna Rogers
11:03 PM on 01/31/2011
Sorry, I forgot...I think you have to have a subscription to Education Week to access the article cited above. Here is another link to the same article:
http://www.tc.columbia.edu/newsbureau/article.htm?id=7842
05:09 PM on 01/28/2011
I taught in the States pre NCLB. I then taught in England for the next 12 years. I returned 3 years ago. I cannot believe the difference in American Education! It's pathetic! I'll give a clear example. My first post back in the States was teaching 6th grade English and Social Studies. For English I was handed a huge purple tub and told "there is your curriculum" I opened the teaching manual and it said, "turn to page 98." I did. It then said, "Tell the students to turn to page 37. Now read the first line and ask the following question......" Not only are we producing unimaginative members of society, NCLB has effectively castrated any ingenuity, or relevance in the classroom. Add to that if one teacher is on page 98 and teaches Talented and Gifted students, and the teacher in the other room is on page 96 teaching General Ed classes, there is hell to pay. Students are not an assembly line. And America was founded on the principal of individualism.....sadly, that's not the case due to NCLB...and it used to be...but forgive me, I wax nostalgic.
03:04 PM on 01/29/2011
Thank you. Please keep trying to spread the word. The only people that seem to understand this are the teachers.
02:15 PM on 02/01/2011
I also thank you for bringing this perspective to the discussion. A good teacher is one who engages the students' imagination and curiosity, and does it with respect for the child, the parents and the other teachers. I have a very good friend who started teaching elementary after working another career for years. During the preceding time he and his wife also traveled the world, trekking, getting to know people, cultures, geography, politics, cities and wilderness. He once estimated that, all trips combined, they spent 2 1/2 years travelling. Europe, Asia, Australia.. This can't be learned in school or measured by some metric. But it's the kind of experience that can bring richness and context to any situation, especially to a class of youngsters who can be inspired to see beyond boundaries to wider perspectives and values. I wish he had been my teacher when I was that age.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
03:39 PM on 01/27/2011
NCLB: the near futile attempt to counter the unwanted effects of ECBT?
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
ninetailedfox
banning people.....so childish
02:50 PM on 01/27/2011
Forget revamping it, what about throwing it out altogether? That is what NCLB really needs.
photo
Yorksgal
Until everyone has EQUAL RIGHTS, I will not rest.
01:52 PM on 01/27/2011
And yet the repubs and the baggers are just happy to have NCLB, because then they can continue to criticize the teachers and the school districts without having to actually think about how they can improve anything.
photo
teacher39years
Educational Reformers need to be "Reformed."
05:36 PM on 01/27/2011
Actually, they've thought a lot about Education when they figured out how turn Education into a "Cash Cow" by taking it over with "Charter Schools".

http://ksdcitizens.org/2010/12/22/waiting-for-superfraud/#comment-479

http://www.schoolsmatter.info/2008/12/charter-school-corruption-2009-style.html
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
CarryOn
no matter where you go, there you are
01:23 PM on 01/27/2011
We are reaping the impact of NCLB not doubt about it. What a disaster!

One request ladies and gentlemen...read the full document before signing. Mr. Bush admitted to signing it without rading it, wonder how many who voted on it did the same.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
07:35 AM on 01/27/2011
This has to be careful about the incentives too - don't let a reward meant to encourage schools to improve themselves become part of their day-to-day budgeting (and therefore become an incentive to corrupt the process in order to maintain the reward.)

That ignores the sorry state of support for education. Governments strapped for cash seem always to cut funding for education before funding for police or prisons.

Perhaps the federal government ought to try an end-around most of the layers of bueracracy in between it and the students - and fund teachers using a simple grant process. Of course, that would remove the incentive for local school boards to be responsible for the students ...
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
mrk65
wah, wah, wah...
03:53 AM on 01/27/2011
How about funding the program; otherwise, schools are hamstrung. Of course, that was the Bush administration's intention all along.
03:34 AM on 01/27/2011
"No Child Left Behind" is completely different from the Catholic priests program "Any Child's Left Behind".
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
sf omega man
02:39 AM on 01/27/2011
wait a min.. my comment comparing our education challenges to the bravery exhibited by JFK, banned by HuffPo moderators? What in the world was deemed offensve about that?
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
sf omega man
02:31 AM on 01/27/2011
Can we just replace NCLB with something that people can get behind? (w/ apologies to JFK..)

We believe that this nation should commit itself to achieving the goal, before this decade is out, of educating our children to achieve first in the world status. No single education project in this period will be more impressive, or more important for the long-range stability of our country; and none will be so difficult or expensive to accomplish. We propose to accelerate the development of the optimal school system. We propose to develop alternate programs and appropriate school system boosters, much larger than any now being developed, until certain which is superior.

We propose additional funds for other school development and for needed experimentation -- explorations which are particularly important for one purpose which this nation will never overlook: the survival of our way of life as leader of the free world. But in a very real sense, it will not be for just one generation if we act affirmatively, it will be an entire nation as we start the 21st century. For all of us must work to put our children and their children on the best path that we can.
thekid360
Black, Union and Proud, Booyah
02:19 AM on 01/27/2011
As it took me at least 2 years to convince my mind that yes George W. Bush was indeed the President. I have yet to convince my self that we allowed him to have any say on the matter of education what so ever.
02:11 AM on 01/27/2011
An educated population will not work for third world slave wages. How does this fit into the long range plans of corporate America? An educated population will not believe the propaganda shoved down their throat forever. How does this fit into the long range plans of corporate America. An educated population will stand for a sold out congress only so long. How does this fit into the long range plans of corporate America.
A corporation that sends its jobs overseas and its money offshore probably should not be referred to as corporate America anyway as it has nothing good to do with our country or our people.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Tauna Rogers
01:10 AM on 01/27/2011
Beware the talk of bi-partisan consensus on education reform.

Dump NCLB and Race to the Trough bribery entirely. The very LEAST we can ask of Congress is that it does no more harm. When it comes to accountability, it is high time our legislators were held accountable. A very great deal of harm has been done already.

Members of Congress, do your homework about the "failing public schools" national narrative. Read Diane Ravitch. Read Gerald Bracey and may God rest his soul. Read Stephen Krashen and Susan Ohanian and Marion Brady. Read Valerie Strauss of the Washington Post. Read Anthony Cody. I could go on...

For ONCE, listen to educators rather than billionaires and ideologically impaired think tanks.

I don't give a flying fickle about this bi-partisan nonsense. The No Child Left Behind Act should NEVER have become law and it was overwhelmingly "bi-partisan". Race to the Top? Like NCLB, it has no credible research whatsoever to support it. In fact, quite the opposite, And it has neoliberal "bi-partisan" support.
12:31 AM on 01/27/2011
As someone who's seen the damage caused by No Child Left Behind first hand, I say rather than revamp the law, we just take it out behind the barn and shoot it.