iPhone app iPad app Android phone app Android tablet app More

More Questions Surround Antonio Calvo's Suicide And Removal From Princeton

First Posted: 04/20/11 08:59 PM ET Updated: 06/20/11 06:12 AM ET

Antonio Calvo Photo

NEW YORK -- The mystery surrounding Antonio Calvo’s abrupt removal from Princeton University and subsequent suicide continues.

Calvo, 45, a senior lecturer and director of the Spanish language program at Princeton, took his own life last Tuesday in his loft-style apartment on West 26th Street in Chelsea.

According to a spokeswoman at the New York City Medical Examiner’s Office, Calvo stabbed himself to death, with “multiple incised wounds of the neck and upper left extremities.”

Last Friday, three days after he died, Princeton issued a formal statement confirming Calvo's death, indicating that a memorial service would be held the following week.

The statement also said that “Calvo was on leave from Princeton at the time of his death.”

While Calvo was technically on leave when he committed suicide on Tuesday -- it was a leave that had been forced upon him by the university four days prior and not a leave of his own choosing.

According to both close friends and former colleagues, Calvo was apparently asked to arrive at his office at 11 a.m. on the morning of Friday, April 8.

At his office, he was reportedly met by a university-appointed public safety officer who informed him that his contract as longtime lecturer would not be renewed. Calvo was then forcibly removed from the premises, with his keys taken away, in addition to being barred access to his personal Princeton University email account.

Marco Aponte-Moreno, who teaches international business at the University of Surrey in the U.K., is a longtime friend and former lecturer at Princeton, where he worked under Calvo. The two men last spoke via Skype about a month ago.

“Antonio wasn’t someone who was going to kill himself,” said Aponte-Moreno. “He was full of life, he had all of these wonderful plans for the future.”

Earlier in the week, Aponte-Moreno started a Facebook group called “Justice for Antonio Calvo.” It gained hundreds of followers after only a few hours. But after receiving negative comments, Aponte-Moreno deleted the page altogether.

For even his closest friends, Calvo’s final days remain shrouded in mystery.

Ana Belén Martín-Sevillano, a close, platonic friend since their undergraduate days in Madrid, stayed at Calvo’s apartment during a recent trip to New York City for an academic conference.

Martín-Sevillano teaches Spanish and Latin American literature at a university in Canada and has known Calvo for nearly 25 years. She last saw him eight days before he died.

Apparently Calvo’s contract had been up for renewal and he was plagued with worry about whether he'd be asked back.

She described Calvo's mood as stable and upbeat, but said he'd grown increasingly anxious. She also noticed that his appetite had recently waned.

During her visit, Martín-Sevillano recalled Calvo as an elegant, distinctive dresser who commuted by train early each morning to campus.

They last parted ways with the understanding that he would inform her just as soon as he received an update about his job.

“He was supposed to call me whenever he learned of something. In the last message, his voice was upbeat and funny -- he sounded positive.”

She described him as a balanced person, who while given to ups and downs, was never prone to bouts of depression.

The university refused to specifically address the cause of Calvo’s abrupt removal, which is considered a personnel matter and, as such, not considered public information.

Cass Cliatt, a Princeton spokeswoman, offered the following by email: "We continue to feel that it's not the University's place to make any statements that might be taken as some type of official determination about the circumstances surrounding Antonio Calvo's passing. While we were given information about the cause, we didn’t have independent verification. This is consistent with how we have approached similar circumstances, and this is distinct from cases that take place on campus where our own Department of Public Safety might be involved and have access to information. We feel it's inappropriate to speak to unconfirmed information when it comes to personal or private family matters.”

Fernando Aran, who's currently a medical student at Florida International University, graduated from Princeton last spring. Calvo was both his senior thesis adviser and junior paper adviser. He visited Calvo's office at least once a week.

Aran, who was shocked at hearing the news of Calvo's suicide, described his former professor as "a strong, fun-loving, good person, who didn't have any apparent issues with depression. If he did, I never knew about it."

Since hearing news of Calvo's suicide, Aran describes Princeton as on "super lock-down mode." Aran's former professors in the Spanish department refuse to discuss it.

Philip Rothaus, a Princeton senior concentrating in Spanish and Portuguese, recently called Calvo’s dismissal into question, issuing an open letter to the university.

Aponte-Moreno remains similarly skeptical. "I think the university is hiding something, I think they did something they weren’t supposed to do," he said.

For now, more questions remain than answers.

Princeton's department of Spanish and Portuguese Languages and Cultures has scheduled a private memorial service for tomorrow afternoon.

Many of Calvo's friends said they refuse to step foot on campus, preferring instead to honor his life in a private ceremony to be held in New York early next week.

FOLLOW HUFFPOST COLLEGE

NEW YORK -- The mystery surrounding Antonio Calvo’s abrupt removal from Princeton University and subsequent suicide continues. Calvo, 45, a senior lecturer and director of the Spanish language pr...
NEW YORK -- The mystery surrounding Antonio Calvo’s abrupt removal from Princeton University and subsequent suicide continues. Calvo, 45, a senior lecturer and director of the Spanish language pr...
 
 
  • Comments
  • 61
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
Page: 1 2 3  Next ›  Last »  (3 total)
09:46 AM on 05/03/2011
It is important to realize that political machinations are more frequently the cause of upper level administrative terminations (including program director positions such as Calvo's) in higher education than personal incompetence. I have observed and experienced this over my long academic career. Character assassination is an insidious part of the process.
A small number of individuals with appropriate connections can undermine the the reputation of a good professional, frequently with the unwitting collaboration of an institution, particularly a private one, that is highly sensitive to its reputation. I have yet to see a university Human Resources department that will provide as much support to the individual being attacked as it does to protect the institutions reputation. I am tremendously saddened by Calvo's death for the enormous loss of a loving vibrant life, for its clear indictment of US higher education administration, and for Princeton's inability to exact high standards of learning from its students.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
deridaa
11:45 PM on 04/25/2011
Political correctness as tool to do what they want.Notice when rich donors kid sexually harasses, physically attacks no one notices. For years Nassau Weekly publishes unfunny racist student quotes as lighthearted fare and nothing happens. This administration pretends community sensitivity with some castration without anesthesia with others and privacy rules to shield The Star Chamber.Deepest sympathy for his family.
08:54 AM on 04/25/2011
Deepest sympathy for family, friends and students.
I can't refrain from responding to Calvo's "political incorrectness" as reported in NYT and on FOX news. What an embarrassing irony that Princeton graduate students in Spanish language would be unable accept the cultural nuances of their own object of study. Either that or the students converted the genitalia reference into sexual harassment, which speaks poorly of their ethics. Ignorance or criminal manipulation at an Ivy league school?
Que triste
11:34 PM on 04/22/2011
The whole 'It gets better' campaign is a lie. People still hate, and drive people to end their lives.
07:30 AM on 04/22/2011
I have never heard of someone stabbing themselves to death - something doesn't add up.
photo
robin360
dog is god spelled backwards
02:28 PM on 04/22/2011
It is unusual, but it happens. Singer/songwriter Eliot Smith died the same way, as did a young performer recently at an open-mic night. If in fact it is a true suicide, it shows self-hate, as that is not a quick way to die. Okay, now I've bummed myself out. RIP.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
deridaa
05:49 AM on 04/24/2011
Good Friday- the crucifixion-the man was ruined by an all powerful administration. The whisper campaign alone was brutal then cutting him off from the people he loved students and faculty. Completely crushing him in silence.After 10 years this beloved man was escorted off campus like a criminal.Take a good look because that is what they are about. Power corrupts imagine the processional on graduation day. All you need is a lot of money a legal department at your disposal and a silver tea service and you can destroy anyone. Disgusting people behind all of this.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
bessielil
trying to organize hummingbirds
01:59 PM on 04/21/2011
Not renewing a contract is quite different from canceling a contract. Certainly, there should have been a show cause hearing and due process instead of a 'perp walk,' UNLESS he was considered a danger by remaining until the end of the semester. If the latter were true, then charges should have been filed with the Princeton, NJ police, as opposed to in house campus security. Something is very wrong here, and Princeton's reputation at the administrative level is in question.
12:13 PM on 04/21/2011
Before there is a rush to judgment, it might be nice to know all the facts.

The sudden departure of Calvo might well indicate actions or conduct that were not acceptable, regardless of one's academic abilities. It is an unfortunate fact of life in academia that contracts are not renewed, but it is unusual for an employee or faculty member to be escorted from an office without justification.

Of course, the true facts may never be known.
photo
southingtonian
"I'm a Capricorn and you can't make me do sh*t.."
06:29 AM on 05/16/2011
based on the actions of the administration, the facts will never be voluntarily revealed.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
cobraxus
Defend The Innocent_Protect The Weak
11:43 AM on 04/21/2011
to quote Our Rachel this sounds hinkey.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
crom14
08:07 AM on 04/21/2011
I would assume being forced to leave a position like this would damage one very much. Sounds like cut backs to me. Very sad.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
07:50 AM on 04/21/2011
People kill themselves for all different types of reasons, but at the same time... I can't help but feel weird about how this all went down! I feel like there is more to the story than the University wants to let on! Either they are protecting him & his legacy... or theirs.

Wanna make a bet it's the latter??
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
02:55 AM on 04/21/2011
Universities are notorious for not talking about these things, which can be mixed. Once a classmate suddenly died and the school wouldn't even indicate the cause of death, like he was erased. Not so good.

Stabbing suicides always surprise me, most recently (but not very recent) the death of musician Elliot Smith. For me, it's hard to believe those could be accidents - so deliberate.

Of course one of the founders of Sociology, Emile Durkheim, noted that although religion matters more, a higher education level correlates with an increase in suicide.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
03:34 AM on 04/21/2011
Is it just the higher education level...or that people with such specific and defined niches back themselves into a corner with a limited and singularly-defined (though rich) knowledge-base or skill set?

Like, once his career is over in his field, at Princeton of all places, there truly is nowhere else to go. Think about starting over after that.

Very depressing. I can see how suicide becomes an option.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
04:13 AM on 04/21/2011
i think the phenomenon of which you speak is very common, even in fields like engineering.

then again, it happens all the time and is nothing new.

though as mentioned, durkheim was more influenced by the religion variable.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Jon Polm
@jonpolm
02:16 AM on 04/21/2011
Sounds like there's more to the story. Til then, my deepest condolences to Mr. Calvo's family and friends.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Dogma
A sense of humor is no laughing matter.
01:54 AM on 04/21/2011
The fact that Calvo was already anticipating being cut loose suggests he did something unethical and/or unlawful.

So there is the possibility that a third party was involved with some incident that got him fired. Then, once Calvo was fired, they were afraid he would 'talk' to authorities to save his job...
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
syntax facit saltum
We do not live in a 2 story universe
02:20 AM on 04/21/2011
Not necessarily. The economy is horrible. Lecturers are the proletarians of academia. They can lose their jobs in a heartbeat even after many years.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
03:47 AM on 04/21/2011
I'm going to agree with you on the suggestion that something he did may have been on the order of unethical and/or unlawful.

I used to work at Smith College, and the human resources department there does not terminate anyone immediately like that unless someone did something that is already defined as a condition for them to do so. HR absolutely has to follow a sequence of procedures in terminations, and their failure to follow their own procedures puts them at risk.

As well, HR should only disclose the reason for an immediate termination to the man's supervisors/department heads. There's nothing here stating that that information hasn't been shared with the appropriate parties.

It may seem that Princeton is being mysterious, but they are probably following everything to the rule. It is NOT their place to reveal as public information the reason for his termination.

If a committee of his peers truly finds this suspicious and want it investigated, they may have to hire a lawyer to be able to find out the answers.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
crom14
08:09 AM on 04/21/2011
With all the state funding being cut, I would think colleges will be forced to cut back.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Dogma
A sense of humor is no laughing matter.
01:25 PM on 04/21/2011
Just curious, considering the bad PR this story could generate for Princeton, on a scale of one to ten, what chance do you think that they would disclose their reason for letting him go? (Keeping in mind that he is now diseased).
01:40 AM on 04/21/2011
Compassion is called for. There is more to this story and it may not be anyone's business. My sincere and deep condolence to his family. Deep suffering. And a deeply sad story all around.
photo
KOisGod
Pay attention, YES-YOU
01:26 AM on 04/21/2011
May he find peace in the next world, the peace that eluded him in this.