iPhone app iPad app Android phone app Android tablet app More

Traditional Doctors, Alternative Treatments: An Intersection?

First Posted: 05/25/2011 8:21 am EDT Updated: 03/28/2013 12:22 pm EDT

Sometimes it can seem as though complementary/alternative treatments and traditional medicine live in two silos -- never the twain shall meet, as the saying goes. We go to the doctor when we're sick or for regular wellness checks. And we go to the yoga studio or a meditation class. Yet we don't talk to our doctors about how one can support the other.

But the tide may be turning -- a recent study in the journal Archives of Internal Medicine has found that three percent of people seeking out mind/body treatments, such as yoga, meditation, tai chi, deep breathing and progressive muscle relaxation, are doing so based on a referral from a medical provider.

And while that number may not seem to be particularly high, consider a yoga or meditation class, of say, 30 people -- on average, one of them is there because their provider told them to be, explains lead author and HuffPost blogger Aditi Nerurkar, M.D., M.P.H, a physician and integrative medicine fellow at Harvard Medical school and Beth Israel Deaconess Medical Center. "We weren't expecting it to be that high," she says. "Forty-one million Americans are using mind-body therapies. Of those, 6.4 million are using mind-body therapies because they were recommended to by their provider."

Looking at a nationally representative sample size of 23,000 survey participants, the researchers found that the most commonly prescribed treatments were deep breathing exercises (84 percent of the respondents), meditation (49 percent), yoga (23 percent), progressive muscle relaxation (20 percent) and guided imagery (14 percent). These numbers were similar to those who sought out the treatments on their own.

"For years and years this has been a patient-driven phenomenon," Nerurkar says. As people discover what works best for themselves and loved ones, yoga studios, for instance, have popped up to fill a need that patients haven't always discussed with their doctors.

So why are some physicians ready to hand out an Rx for a little "Om" time?

One reason may be the relatively recent body of research on how various mind-body treatments can be helpful, healthy additions to traditional treatment programs for certain conditions, including anxiety and depression, headaches, chronic pain, cardiac disease, insomnia and treatment-related symptoms of cancer, Nerurkar says.

The researchers also found that the patients who were seeking out mind-body treatments at the recommendation of a medical provider were those who typically had more diagnosed conditions and used the health-care system more often. Nerurkar says one reason that may be is that providers are referring their more complex patients once other treatments have failed -- and this concept may lead to future research studies about what would happen if these complementary programs were offered earlier on in the treatment process.

Of course, not all complementary and alternative treatments have evidence behind them, Nerurkar points out. But when the research that is out there is coupled with patients' success stories, some providers are opening up to the possibilities. "Ultimately you just want your patients to feel better," she says. "At the end of the day, if my patients are using these therapies and they're feeling good, I encourage them to do it."

Here are some starting points for each of the mind-body treatments most commonly suggested by the medical community:

Deep breathing: Regular deep breathing -- taking slow breaths in and out -- has been linked to regulation of the cardiovascular and nervous systems and easing symptoms of anxiety, among other benefits. To start out a deep breathing exercise, focus on your breath coming in and out as it would normally and then begin deeper breaths, spending longer on inhalations and exhalations, according to the University of Rochester:

Breathe deeply and slowly, focusing all of your attention on each breath. Don't rush it or breathe quickly. As you exhale naturally, allow any tension to leave you with the breath. Imagine the tension draining from your body and mind as you exhale. Notice the feeling of calm and relaxation that comes with exhalation.

Meditation: Studies have linked regular meditation to, among many other benefits, a decrease in fatigue and depression in multiple sclerosis patients, boosts in cellular health and a reduction in the severity of various mental and physical side effects from certain types of cancer treatment. Check out this primer for do-it-yourself meditation from the Mayo Clinic, or find a class near you.

Yoga: Of the many potential benefits of yoga, certain forms have been associated with improving recovery from breast cancer, lessening anxiety and counteracting fibromyalgia. Yoga has many different forms -- you can practice poses alone, attend a local class or even do a yoga video at home.

Progressive muscle relaxation: This technique has been found to benefit people with Alzheimer's disease, patients in the midst of cancer treatment, older people suffering from chronic pain and insomnia sufferers. The basic theory is to focus on groups of muscles in the body, often tensing them up, as you breathe in and then slowly relaxing them as you breathe out.

Guided imagery: Guided imagery has been associated with increased immunity and reduced feelings of depression. This process helps you to relax by taking you through a series of visualizations and direct suggestions, according to the Academy For Guided Imagery. You can find a certified instructor through the academy, practice guided imagery with a therapist or buy a tape to try the technique at home.

Also on HuffPost:

Loading Slideshow...
  • Steve Jobs

    Although pancreatic cancer is often life-threatening, Jobs actually had a rare, treatable form of the disease. But the tech visionary, a practicing Buddhist and strict vegetarian, pursued alternative therapies for nine months before eventually electing to follow a more conventional path. Although he had hoped to avoid an operation, Jobs had surgery in 2004, but by then the cancer had already spread. Some have speculated that had Jobs proceeded with conventional treatment for pancreatic cancer from the start, he may have won the battle. <strong>More from Health.com:</strong> <a href="http://www.health.com/health/gallery/0,,20543333,00.html" target="_hplink">The Biggest Celebrity Health Stories of 2011</a> <a href="http://www.health.com/health/gallery/0,,20466776,00.html" target="_hplink">25 Shocking Celebrity Weight Changes</a> <a href="http://www.health.com/health/gallery/0,,20432752,00.html" target="_hplink">The Hottest Ways Hollywood Lives Healthy</a>

  • Farrah Fawcett

    The <em>Charlie's Angels</em> bombshell was diagnosed with anal cancer in 2006. To complement her chemotherapy treatments, she reportedly traveled to Germany for "natural supplements and also immune treatments" that aren't approved in the United States, according to Access Hollywood. Fawcett lost her battle with cancer in 2009.

  • Gwyneth Paltrow

    A regular proponent of various too-good-to-be-true-sounding cleanses, Paltrow is no stranger to natural remedies. In 2004, the actress showed up to a premiere with circular spots across her back, the telltale signs of a procedure called cupping. The process involves warm glass cups, which are placed on the skin to make a vacuum. It's said to increase blood flow, open pores, and allow toxins to leave the body.

  • Jenny McCarthy

    When the actress's son was diagnosed with autism in 2005, she went looking for answers and came across Generation Rescue, a community of families who believe vaccines and antibiotics are to blame for their children's autism. McCarthy now serves as president of the organization, which promotes "recovery" from autism. Despite repeated debunking of the decade-old study that alleged vaccines cause autism, many parents continue to question vaccine safety and reject the conventional medical practice outright, putting their children at risk of potentially deadly diseases.

  • Oprah Winfrey

    The media mogul has drawn criticism for her promotion of unapproved treatments and alternative therapies. Several natural-medicine proponents have appeared on her TV show, including Jenny McCarthy. Although she said in a statement that she believes viewers understand she is merely presenting information and not endorsing natural medicine or any of the procedures she has discussed, she has, given the widespread affect she has on her audience, undoubtedly convinced many viewers that these treatments can -- and do -- work.

  • Dr. Oz

    No surprise here, given that Mehmet Oz, M.D., was a frequent guest on <em>The Oprah Winfrey Show</em>. The cardiologist-turned-TV-host has integrated alternative treatments into his conventional practice. He has taken flack from the mainstream media for his methods, but he says he continues to use alternative therapies both in his practice and at home. He also regularly practices Transcendental Meditation (a type of concentrative meditation where a person focuses on one sight or sound) and has been doing yoga daily for more than 20 years, a ritual he calls "the most important health practice I have adopted." He recommends to patients other alternative treatments, such as mud baths for people with arthritis or other joint problems and aromatherapy oils to reduce stress and ease muscle aches.

  • Princess Diana

    The Princess of Wales was a regular at an alternative-medicine treatment facility called Chinese Clinic, according to <em>People</em> magazine. She is said to have taken part in reflexology treatments, a stimulation of the feet, hands, and ears that aims to impact other, more troublesome parts of the body. Some of the clinic's most popular alternative treatments included colonic hydrotherapy, electrical stimulation of the facial muscles for an instant "lift" and Australian herbal remedies.

  • Elle Macpherson

    Nicknamed "The Body," supermodel Macpherson spoke with U.K. magazine Fabulous in 2010 about her "Chinese medicine perspective" on health, which she said "promotes and maintains wellness rather than treats illness." She said she has undergone regular acupuncture treatments and seen a doctor who treated many of her ailments with herbal remedies.

  • Tom Cruise

    In 2005, the actor publicly criticized Brooke Shields's treatment for postpartum depression after the 2003 birth of her daughter. Cruise spoke out against the use of antidepressants, saying Shields didn't understand "the history of psychiatry." When Matt Lauer asked him to explain on the <em>Today</em> show, Cruise expressed doubts about the existence of depression, saying, "There is no such thing as a chemical imbalance."

  • Christy Turlington Burns

    The supermodel-turned-documentary-filmmaker told <em>Psychology Today</em> that she started practicing yoga at age 18, and was eventually introduced to Ayurveda, a 5,000-year-old Indian holistic science about discovering individual balance. This ancient theory of medicine emphasizes healthy habits such as massage, meditation, and healthy eating to prevent and treat illness.

  • Kate Moss

    After checking into rehab for cocaine addiction, her career on the line, the supermodel was photographed leaving a friend's house with two bandages on her right ear, thought to be covering the marks of acupuncture treatment, according to the BBC. The therapy may reduce withdrawal symptoms and even prevent relapse in people who are addicted to drugs.

  • Richard Gere

    One of Hollywood's most famous Buddhists, Gere started meditating at age 24 and continues to do so daily. He told PBS that it's a creative process involving finding "the space between thoughts" and that it's different for him every time. The relaxation technique can ease a range of ailments -- including chronic pain, depression and insomnia -- and it may even help smokers quit.

  • Olivia Newton-John

    Along with chemotherapy, the singer and actress used complementary treatments such as herbal supplements, acupuncture, meditation, and visualization to battle breast cancer. When she was first diagnosed in 1992, she even considered forgoing chemotherapy entirely in favor of homeopathic treatments and acupuncture, but eventually "common sense prevailed," she told CNN. Maintaining a positive mindset throughout the experience also helped her heal, she said.

  • Russell Simmons

    The hip-hop mogul may not seem like the typical meditation practitioner, but he's been getting his om on for over a decade. In a 2010 blog on The Huffington Post, Simmons wrote that meditation "has given me energy, strength, health, wisdom, and access to my own inner stillness, inner silence, inner bliss. It is my connection to myself; it is my connection to the universe."

  • Madonna

    After claiming that urinating on your feet is a cure for athlete's foot on <em>The Late Show With David Letterman</em> in 1994, it's not surprising that Madonna has ascribed to some strange natural cures. Today, the buff performer is a fan of more mainstream alternative practices, such as yoga.

  • James Hetfield

    A sex, drugs, and rock 'n' roll-loving guitarist and singer isn't the typical poster boy for natural remedies. But in 2008, Metallica's Hetfield told the <em>Houston Chronicle</em> in order to get through the band's tour to promote that year's <em>Death Magnetic</em> album, he was trying out some alternative treatments, including reflexology, acupuncture, and drinking a "secret vegetable concoction."

  • Steve McQueen

    The bad-boy actor was diagnosed with mesothelioma, a deadly cancer of the lung lining, in 1979. He traveled to Mexico in July 1980 to be treated with pancreatic enzymes, a controversial therapy developed by a dentist who had since been "blacklisted" by the American Cancer Society, the <em>New York Times</em> reported. McQueen is also said to have received 50 daily vitamins and minerals, psychotherapy, coffee enemas, and injections made from sheep and cattle fetuses, all while taking part in healing massages and prayer sessions. After additional treatments with laetrile, a controversial apricot-pit-based injection, McQueen said he was in recovery, but he died shortly thereafter, following surgery to remove cancer from his abdomen and neck.

  • Suzanne Somers

    The actress is no stranger to alternative treatments, having cited unregulated hormone creams, around 60 vitamins and supplements, and estrogen injections directly into her vagina as her personal fountain of youth. But after surgery and radiation treatment for breast cancer in 2001, Somers opted for a drug made from mistletoe extract over chemotherapy, and wrote a book promoting the work of some very unconventional physicians.

  • Nick Nolte

    In a 2000 visit to Larry King Live, the Oscar nominee sat down with well-known alternative-medicine practitioners Andrew Weil M.D. and Eric Braverman, M.D., to discuss the hormonal injections Nolte was receiving. He also said he was undergoing treatments in hyperbaric oxygen chambers, a practice that involves breathing pure oxygen inside of a specially pressurized tank to promote healing.

  • Sarah Ferguson

    The former Duchess of York (and her daughters, princesses Beatrice and Eugenie, now famous Stateside thanks to those unforgettable royal-wedding hats) are said to have undergone bioenergy treatments from a Russian energy healer. Energy healing is similar to Reiki. Both treatments are said to harness positive energy, whether through touch or close proximity, to break negative thoughts and promote the body's natural healing processes.

  • Andrew Weil

    Of course Andrew Weil, M.D., an integrative-medicine specialist, digs herbs and tinctures. But he sees the wisdom in conventional medicine as well. He surprised some when he famously said, "If I'm in a car accident, don't take me to an herbalist. If I have bacterial pneumonia, give me antibiotics. But when it comes to maximizing the body's natural healing potential, a mix of conventional and alternative procedures seems like the only answer." <strong>More from Health.com:</strong> <a href="http://www.health.com/health/gallery/0,,20543333,00.html" target="_hplink">The Biggest Celebrity Health Stories of 2011</a> <a href="http://www.health.com/health/gallery/0,,20466776,00.html" target="_hplink">25 Shocking Celebrity Weight Changes</a> <a href="http://www.health.com/health/gallery/0,,20432752,00.html" target="_hplink">The Hottest Ways Hollywood Lives Healthy</a>

  • Related Video

FOLLOW HUFFPOST HEALTHY LIVING

 
 
  • Comments
  • 66
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Bloggers
Recency  | 
Popularity
Page: 1 2  Next ›  Last »  (2 total)
09:38 AM on 05/30/2011
Nice article ! Most often people are drawn towards alternative medicine techniques, Most of these techniques used to be practiced by the holy saints to keep them fit. Now-a days bits and pieces put together and are put forwards in front of us and hence proper understanding of these techniques are required.If these techniques are learned properly and under a guru or the master ,it becomes really helpful.These techniques are far more than pen and paper works or a degree.The earlier masters used to practice them for years before becoming a guru.These techniques can not be mastered in a course of few years although people who all visits such places gets just a mental satisfaction .
OverseasVet
stuck in a 3rd world country called texas
11:45 PM on 05/29/2011
These type of unsupported treatments are being taught in medical schools. That's right, we are now producing doctors with training in reiki, acupuncture and homeopathy. They should be given the alternative degree title of witch doctor.
MommyMD
MD, Professor, Mom
03:13 AM on 05/31/2011
Sadly, he's right in some cases. When accupuncture was all the rage, we learned about it. Now that rigorous studies are not panning out (beyind "plaecbo" or relaxation"...with the IVF connection still in question), it's time we stopped the PC nonsense. As I have said before, the above article sets up a false dichotomy. Meditation, Yoga, Progressive Relaxation, Deep Breathing are common sense. Most MDs happily recommend them (and use them frequently themselves!) They are good medicine and not "altternative" in any way. Real "alternative" medicine (Reiki, homeopathy) does not belong in a scientific teaching institution until there is science behind it.
04:39 PM on 05/27/2011
There is a fabulous yoga video for breast cancer patients and survivors called "Yoga for Breast Cancer". It's great for beginners and anyone with low energy, but also good as it offers different pose variations as you gain strength. Very calming and instructive, also has a guided meditation to help you through the day, just for cancer so it has poses that are specifically chosen to help healing and restoration. www.yogaforcancer.com, it's also available on amazon, I have really enjoyed it. Peace on your journey, namaste!
09:34 AM on 05/26/2011
This is the only scientific research that I know about alternative treatments with proof of healthy source to support clinical practice in phisicians, the other one is in the order of phisical and psicological help. "Intensive meditation training, immune cell telomerase activity, and psychological mediators"
Tonya L. Jacobsa, , , Elissa S. Epelb, Jue Linc, Elizabeth H. Blackburnc, Owen M. Wolkowitzb, David A. Bridwelld, Anthony P. Zanescoa, Stephen R. Aichelee, Baljinder K. Sahdraa, Katherine A. MacLeanf, Brandon G. Kinga, Phillip R. Shavere, Erika L. Rosenberga, Emilio Ferrere, B. Alan Wallaceg and Clifford D. Sarona, ha UC Davis Center for Mind and Brain, Davis, CA, USA

b UC San Francisco Department of Psychiatry, San Francisco, CA, USA

c UC San Francisco Department of Biochemistry and Biophysics, San Francisco, CA, USA

d UC Irvine Department of Cognitive Science, Irvine, CA, USA

e UC Davis Department of Psychology, Davis, CA, USA

f Department of Psychiatry and Behavioral Sciences, Johns Hopkins University School of Medicine, Baltimore, MD, USA

g Santa Barbara Institute for Consciousness Studies, Santa Barbara, CA, USA

h UC Davis Medical Center M.I.N.D. Institute, Sacramento, CA, USA

Received 22 January 2010; revised 28 August 2010; accepted 17 September 2010. Available online 29 October 2010.
OverseasVet
stuck in a 3rd world country called texas
11:59 PM on 05/29/2011
With no beginning telomerase activity measured it is impossible to assign meditation as the cause of telomerase differences. Also many of the variables were self reported which is notoriously inaccurate. All recruits were gotten from advertisements from meditation sites suggesting the control groups were also meditating although not at the studies retreat. This is the typically fatally flawed type of study that is required to show any efficacy from treatments with no scientific bases. If they showed efficacy they would not have to be labeled alternative medicine.
07:56 AM on 05/26/2011
Any sort of exercise or social activity helps, so bring on the yoga, the medication, the long walks, etc. What is totally worthless is spending $30 on a few homeopathy pills or wrist bracelet. Those do nothing whatsoever.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Joe3245
Now thinking outside of THE BOX.
04:07 AM on 05/29/2011
Except for the ever effective placebo (which does help), even if you know it is a placebo.
01:45 AM on 05/26/2011
I've always preferred to turn to a conventional doctor with a broad vision and an open mind ...
http://www.lifestyle-after50.com/alternative-medicine.html
MommyMD
MD, Professor, Mom
11:16 PM on 05/25/2011
The therapies listed are evidence-based (all shown in rigorous clinical trials to be effective...to various degrees). Many/most docs happily recommend them. But you have set up a false dichotomy. MDs gladly prescribe evidence-based therapies; they're not "alternative" to us. It's the homeopathy, Reiki, herbs, and other "yet-to-be-proven" remedies that we yelp about.
12:20 AM on 05/26/2011
The problem is that many orthodox treatments tested in "rigorous clinical trials", and embraced by "Science-Based Medicine" turn out to be worthless and/or harmful. One recent study conducted by two researchers at the University of Illinois (both female) warned women against the use of bisphosphonate bone drugs. According to them diet and supplements are a better strategy for building stronger, healthier bones:

http://www.wellnessresources.com/health/articles/research_says_take_supplements_of_calcium_vitamins_d_k_for_bones_not_bispho/
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
NadineColbert
Clean house, cook dinner, do dishes, repeat!
04:32 AM on 05/26/2011
Diet, calcium, vitamin D and exercise, all needed to prevent bone loss.
(assuming non-smoker)
Smoking is very bad for just about every part of the body!
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Julia Bailey
11:08 AM on 05/26/2011
Your use of the word 'many' is incorrect. You have one example. There are thousands of examples that show evidence based medicine works.
You should have said 'occasionally'. And I hope you can see the difference. One is not many.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
MagicManDoneIt
When facts are lacking. Just say...
05:42 AM on 05/26/2011
Couldn't have said it better myself, especially as I don't have your qualifications. Thanks for the concise and reasonable comment.
MommyMD
MD, Professor, Mom
08:42 PM on 05/26/2011
Thank you...back at you:)
11:04 PM on 05/25/2011
Really you can be healthy for free, as much as your primary phisician support you, if you practice any kind of excercise every day, eat under your needs healty food, read every day some enligthement literature, poetry, plastic, and listening good music,having a wider circle of friends, the problem is to have a positive culture of life, it does not matter your condition, neither the money,The only alternative practice scientifically aproved, recently, is bhudist meditation.You can see the reference in http://nepabuleici.wordpress.com/2011/04/07/la-meditacion-budista-es-mas-poderosa-contra-el-dolor-que-cualquier-analgesico-conocido/
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Julia Bailey
11:08 AM on 05/26/2011
What on earth does 'scientifically approved' mean? Sounds like some marketing mumbo jumbo.
OverseasVet
stuck in a 3rd world country called texas
12:06 AM on 05/30/2011
Science does not rely on single published papers but on accumulated knowlege. When the media or some individual points out a single artilcle as proof and scientific acceptance it not only shows their lack of the scientific process but you can bet they are selling something.
05:58 PM on 05/25/2011
It is about time! What took them so long.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Waterphoneman
artist, musician, inventor & mouth from the south
05:19 PM on 05/25/2011
Great but will Medicare cover the alternates? Until then these alternate therapies are for those who can afford them.
10:49 AM on 05/29/2011
Last time i checked, sitting quietly in a room (meditation) was free. There are many many great websites for specific techniques. Same for Yoga, guided imagery scripts, relaxation audio (if you have an iphone check out many of the free meditation/relaxation aps) you can google or youtube various yoga workouts or basic poses and voila... free again...good luck
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
chickenNgravy
04:39 PM on 05/25/2011
I know a lot of MD's both primary Care and Specialists. They are all different, just like any people but universally they want the people they treat to get better. If there is a supplement or new treatment that "cures" an ailment they commonly treat they will recommend it, Why wouldn't they?

Sure, there are a lot of Big Pharma drugs out there but aside from a box of tissue or some post-it notes, docs aren't reimbursed in return for prescribing certain drugs.

They main difference between Big Pharma and the Health Supplement Industry is that Big Pharma actually has to spend developing their drugs and then have them rigorously tested. The Health Supplement Industry makes a claim and then makes some money.

Interesting in that MD's can't sell "Viagra" or "Lipitor" over the counter in their office. But go into the office of a Naturopath and they will gladly sell you the latest and greatest with a healthy mark-up.
08:35 PM on 05/25/2011
One of the reasons that doctors do not/cannot sell pharmaceutical drugs from their offices is because they would be robbed. Nobody lining up to steal vitamins and supplements. And I'll bet the markup on Viagra and Lipitor aren't negligible. And why shouldn't items be marked up? I don't work for free...do you?
MommyMD
MD, Professor, Mom
11:11 PM on 05/25/2011
Considering my debt, and my work hours, I actually do work for free.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
NadineColbert
Clean house, cook dinner, do dishes, repeat!
04:36 AM on 05/26/2011
The main reason is that the doctor would favor some meds over others, purchasing the best deal to make the most profit. That may not be in the best interest of the patient, so doctors are not allowed to sell medicines.
MommyMD
MD, Professor, Mom
08:47 PM on 05/26/2011
Thank you for a lovely, well thought out comment and an excellent point. (Naturopaths sell their "cures," yet MDs don't....most academic hospitals don't even allow drug company pens or reps in their hospitals). And, before somebody comments, we ARE NOT allowed to "go to Hawaii" or take kickbacks from Pharma anymore.
04:23 PM on 05/25/2011
I would like to thank you for this article and for bringing attention to integrative medicine. I am a pharmacist that aslo practices Functional medicine, a holistic approach and I wouldn't do it any other way. I think that we can truly help patients when we use traditional and holistic approach together. Inna @ http://www.journey-with-crohns-disease.com/index.html
03:53 PM on 05/25/2011
Between Heaven and Earth...great book
04:04 PM on 05/25/2011
Absolutely...Fanned
08:36 AM on 05/26/2011
ahh you know the book...I was turned on to it by an AP client of mine and it literally opened my eyes. "...your body is like a garden to be cultivated.."
03:22 PM on 05/25/2011
The Symbol for the AMA (the Caduceus) is a Yoga Symbol which means "Not Know."
From Not Know the Doc moves to diagnois & from there a prescribed treatment. There are many types of Yoga that will teach one to "Know Thyself".................
03:08 PM on 05/25/2011
Glad to see doctors are finally looking beyond pills. Surprised pilates was not mentioned.