iPhone app iPad app Android phone app Android tablet app More

Ilan Grapel, Israeli-American, Accused Of Spying For Israel By Egypt, Must Be Released: Rep. Gary Ackerman

By ARON HELLER   06/22/11 05:19 PM ET   AP

JERUSALEM -- U.S. Congressman Gary Ackerman called on Egyptian authorities Wednesday to release a constituent and former intern whom Egypt accuses of being an Israeli spy.

Ilan Grapel was arrested at a Cairo hotel last week and suspected of sedition and inciting Egyptians to clash with the country's military leadership. Grapel's family says he was spending the summer in Cairo as an intern at a legal aid group. Israel has denied the 27-year-old Grapel is a spy.

The arrest came as the military faces criticism of how it is running the country and resonates among Egyptians looking for someone outside to blame.

It has set off new fears in Israel that relations with Egypt will sour now that its longtime president, Hosni Mubarak, has been deposed.

Since Mubarak's ouster, Egypt's military rulers have often warned against unspecified "foreign" attempts to destabilize the country. Egypt, like other Arab states, has a long history of blaming internal problems on Israeli saboteurs.

Ackerman, a Democrat from New York and a member of the House Foreign Affairs Committee, says the accusations are bogus, and a breakdown of Grapel's travels proves Egypt's claims to be wrong. Reports in Egypt have him taking part in demonstrations in February, though his mother and classmates say he was in university until May.

"Someone needs to be a grown-up over there and look at the timeline," Ackerman told The Associated Press. "The quicker they complete their investigation, the sooner they will come to the realization that they don't have what they originally though they had."

Ackerman said he has personally intervened with Egyptian officials on Grapel's behalf. He said Grapel was a U.S. law student and served as his intern in 2002.

"He is not a spy. He is a kid in college, acting like a kid in college," he said. "He is a momentary distraction from what their situation and problems are."

Grapel, a dual U.S.-Israeli citizen, served as a paratrooper in the Israeli army. His parents said he never worked in intelligence.

He appears to have traveled to Egypt under his real name and made no secret of his Israeli links, including his past military service, which are easy to find on the Internet.

Grapel was wounded in the 2006 war between the Israeli military and Lebanese Hezbollah guerrillas. Israeli news websites have published what they identified as wartime pictures of Grapel lying in his hospital bed. Grapel later returned to the U.S. for law school.

Grapel graduated from Johns Hopkins University in Baltimore, Maryland, in 2005 with a bachelor's degree in international studies and was planning to return to Emory for his third and final year of law studies.

"The facts will quickly bear out that this is a young man who is guilty of being a young man and doing silly things," Ackerman said.

"I would describe this as an understandable mistake that should be quickly remedied before it creates the notion that the streets of Egypt are not welcoming to foreigners of any type, even those who are very sympathetic to Egypt," he said.

FOLLOW HUFFPOST WORLD

JERUSALEM -- U.S. Congressman Gary Ackerman called on Egyptian authorities Wednesday to release a constituent and former intern whom Egypt accuses of being an Israeli spy. Ilan Grapel was arrested at...
JERUSALEM -- U.S. Congressman Gary Ackerman called on Egyptian authorities Wednesday to release a constituent and former intern whom Egypt accuses of being an Israeli spy. Ilan Grapel was arrested at...
Filed by Mark Hanrahan  |  Report Corrections
 
 
  • Comments
  • 380
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Highlights
Recency  | 
Popularity
Page: 1 2 3 4 5  Next ›  Last »  (6 total)
12:20 PM on 06/29/2011
Israeli American Spy? Spying for Israel? America? Both?
I would assume that there is no way an Israeli service America but other way is always the norm. So why should US get involved to release an Israeli spy? Let Israel stand on her two feet, for once.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
SPQR1775
10:50 AM on 06/25/2011
IF HE IS A SPY, KEEP HIM. ISRAEL AMERICANS love to tell US Military Recruiters that they will not enlist in the US Military "because they are going to FIGHT for and Join the ISRAELI Military or that they already served their country and IT IS ISRAEL!" Now you should ask, WTF? Who sides are Israeli Americans on are they AMERICANS or ISRAELI'S?
photo
RubalKhali
Philosophy is the stray camel of the faithful
09:11 AM on 06/25/2011
A 27 year old ex- paratrooper who was wounded in battle is hardly a "kid in college, acting like a kid in college". He is an adult male with war experience who was pretending to be a journalist, certainly a little outside of what most college kids do.
Ziegler21WP
My bio is not micro
06:34 PM on 06/24/2011
Dear Grassy Knoll crowd. Why is Representaitve Gary Ackerman speaking up about this? This young man and his family live in Gary Ackerman's Congressional District. And no, based on the available facts, I don't believe this young man is an Israeli spy. I do believe that these charges are motivated by Egytian politics.
photo
Vlady
Better Late
11:02 PM on 06/24/2011
Sure, the new Egyptian leaders have to appease the crowd that has always being ardently anti Israel
05:54 AM on 06/25/2011
Welcome to the new ME.... enjoy your stay
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
austinreid
Cheers, Prost, Campai, L'chayim
08:52 PM on 06/25/2011
Because he does not tolerate a foreign nation lying about and imprisoning one of our nation’s own citizens.
photo
Talab
I tot i taw a putty tat
07:07 AM on 06/27/2011
When an American citizen fights in the army of a foreign counntry they normally lose their citizenship in America ....even when fighting for an ally .... because they have made their allegience clear and it is NOT to America.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Johnny Bomers
04:40 PM on 06/24/2011
When will our representatives in Washington learn to stay out of other country's affairs? If the accused guy had any other nationality than Israeli there would not be any comment out of Washington.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
Nwo2012
Sue me, I boycott products from the settlements
04:54 PM on 06/24/2011
Indeed.

+1
06:30 PM on 06/24/2011
Considering there was no Congressional outcry over the summary execution of an American teenage citizen by Israel in international waters I must concur.
photo
RubalKhali
Philosophy is the stray camel of the faithful
09:13 AM on 06/25/2011
Yes but he was Turkish American and therefore not of the chosen and Turkish Americans do not provide the same funds to politicians. And then Turkey doesn't get billions in aid that can be funneled back to the politicians either.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
austinreid
Cheers, Prost, Campai, L'chayim
09:04 PM on 06/25/2011
I looked it up and only one website has it and it also says the Pope in a Nazi, Helen Keller is a communist, and Bush is a Jew. I did find about 15 results for Palestinians killing Americans.
http://www.jta.org/news/article/2010/07/21/2740156/american-israeli-teens-killer-convicted
http://abcnews.go.com/International/us-tourist-murdered-israel-survivor-claims-arab-attackers/story?id=12438149
Just a few of them.
photo
SamSeven
You're either with Humanity or you're not.
03:31 PM on 06/24/2011
Here's an interesting take on the situation:
http://www.presstv.ir/detail/184507.html

Grabel, which according to some sources is a misspelling of the correct name Grapel, joined Israel's 101 paratrooper brigade and fought in the 2006 Israel-Lebanon war where he was wounded.

Egyptian Supreme State Prosecutor Hesham Badawi ordered his arrest for a 15-day period awaiting investigations into allegedly "spying on Egypt with the aim of damaging its economic and political interests."

According to MENA Grabel arrived in Egypt shortly after the start of the January 25 uprising and has been posing as a foreign journalist covering anti-government protests in Cairo's Liberation Square, the epicenter of the revolution.

The alleged Israeli spy officer was tasked with the destabilization of Egypt and the documentation of all major developments in the post-Mubarak era.
03:02 PM on 06/24/2011
What makes Ackerman so sure that Grapel does not work for Israeli intelligence? Does he think that if Grapel were to work for the Mossad, the kid would be allowed to share this information with him? Stop acting like a kid in Capitol Hill.
03:44 PM on 06/24/2011
I was about to ask the same question, too
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
TheLonelyGod
The oncoming storm
04:42 PM on 06/24/2011
Maybe it's the same way he's so sure that the American hikers weren't spies either.
11:13 AM on 06/24/2011
I guess Ackerman thinks some Americans (Grapel) are more important than others (Furkan Dogan).
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
yonatan c
01:32 PM on 06/24/2011
Dogan left American when he was two, never to return. He was aiding an illegal organization deemed a terrorist organization by our government.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
02:51 PM on 06/24/2011
He was an American citizen.
The organization is not deemed a terrorist organization by the US. Israel added IHH to its terror list after the debacle last year.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
SPQR1775
10:53 AM on 06/25/2011
iT DOESN'T MATTER WHEN HE LEFT, AN AMERICAN IS AN AMERICAN! An ISRAELI AMERICAN IS ISRAELI FIRST!
05:56 AM on 06/25/2011
ding ding ding....... fnf
09:43 AM on 06/24/2011
Just like so many over protected spoiled rich brats, he went there because he could. Some people dont have enough common sense to pour piss out of a boot with the directions on the heel.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
Nwo2012
Sue me, I boycott products from the settlements
10:26 AM on 06/24/2011
I lold
01:10 PM on 06/24/2011
He went there to work for an organization that helps refugees, arccoding to reports.
09:39 AM on 06/24/2011
Someone ask Mr. Ackerman how a U$ citizen can serve in the armed forces of another country and still remain a U$ citizen..... Is that possible?
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
StCuthbert
Anytime the mods are ready...
10:01 AM on 06/24/2011
How is it not possible?
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
courtb
10:27 AM on 06/24/2011
According to the US State Department, yes:

"Military service in foreign countries usually does not cause loss of citizenship since an intention to relinquish citizenship normally is lacking. In adjudicating loss of nationality cases, the Department has established an administrative presumption that a person serving in the armed forces of a foreign state not engaged in hostilities against the United States does not have the intention to relinquish citizenship. Voluntary service in the armed forces of a state engaged in hostilities against the United States could be viewed as indicative of an intention to relinquish U.S. citizenship. "
06:12 AM on 06/25/2011
Your right... Rule of revocation was overturned in the Afroyim v. Rusk in 1967 case by the Supreme court where a Polish immigrant kept his U$ citizenship after almost losing it because of voting in an |$rae|i election, where he eventually moved from the U$..

An earlier precedent set in Perez v. Brownell in 1958, where the citizenship was revoked was in the process overturned by the Supreme court...
08:40 AM on 06/24/2011
Why are there dozens of comments on here saying he isn't a spy because he just isn't? Maybe he is and maybe he isn't but the idea that you can tell from the nonexistent amount of information available about him in news media is kind of warped. Only the Israeli and Egyptian governments know for sure and Egypt has every incentive to say he is and Israel has every incentive to say he isn't and neither of them have provided any real proof to the public to support their claims.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
TheLonelyGod
The oncoming storm
09:20 AM on 06/24/2011
Do you know what the "burden of proof" is?
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
12:01 PM on 06/24/2011
there will be a trial . and if he is then he is. if hes not a spy then hes not. the only thing anyone should concern themselves with is a fair trial.
03:14 PM on 06/24/2011
"Do you know what the "burden of proof" is?"

Yes. I know a red herring when I see one too.

When a sovereign state convicts someone of a crime they aren't required or even often expected to share any of their proof with the public at large. Sometimes they are pressured to do so and very rarely they might toss you a bone and provide some but legally they aren't expected to do so and they often don't - whether there are legitimate or illegitimate questions raised by outsiders or not. Kinda basic, LG.
09:40 AM on 06/24/2011
He isn't a spy because he served in the |df against L3b@non, didn't declare his |$rae|i nationality on getting a visa and coz his family says so!!!!!!

Just like |$rae| isn't an apartheid state because.... well because...... let me get back to u on that....
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
StCuthbert
Anytime the mods are ready...
09:51 AM on 06/24/2011
And you're not an anti-Semite because you hate Israel, apply double standards to Israel, and because you say so.
03:15 PM on 06/24/2011
"and coz his family says so!!!!!!"

That is indeed the sole proof provided by this man's defenders thus far.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
JaneB3
Hillary 2016
12:19 AM on 06/24/2011
I seeriously doubt that Ilan Grapel is a spy just because he service with the Israeli Defense Forces. In Israel military service is compulsory for both sexes at the age of 18. Enlisted men serve for 36 mos., women 21 mos., officers 48 mos., and pilots 9 years. Reserve service for men is usually until 51 years of age, and women 24 years of age.
12:15 AM on 06/24/2011
ROUND UP THE USUAL SUSPECTS, , ,He fits the Description alright!

'Nuff Said
11:43 PM on 06/23/2011
I don't buy into the theory that he is a spy. I am an American who happens to be Jewish. I served in the US Army and I am proud of it. With that being said, I love Egyptian, Roman and Greek history. If I were to go to Egypt, would I be concidered a spy? Probably yes because of my backround. If I said something that ruffled a few feathers I am sure that I would probably be arrested and treated as a spy because of my backround. Certain people will always find a reason to hate you or make you seem like the bad guy even if you aren't.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Johnny Bomers
04:48 PM on 06/24/2011
Here we go again with the pursecution complex.
10:45 PM on 06/24/2011
No... not a complex. It is a fact. Ask people what they think of any of us that are Jewish and they will tell you what horrible people we are and blah blah blah. Of course there are those that don't care about our religion but what I have said is a fact.
02:05 PM on 06/25/2011
That's not right, Egyptians don't have anything against Americans or Jews. As Egyptians we hate your Government because it supported Mubarack's Regime but we don't hate the American citizens. I'm also sure that you wouldn't be picked on in Egypt for being a Jew. Americans should really stop believing that. There's a huge difference between Israelis and Jews. We don't like Israelis but that doesn't mean that we hate Jews. The biggest proof for what I'm saying is how Norman Finkelstein(He's an American and also Jewish) was recieved in Egypt. He actually joined us during our protest infront of the Israeli Embassy and we were really glad about his presence.
04:01 PM on 06/25/2011
Maybe that applies to YOU... but you can't speak for everyone from Egypt. That is like saying everyone here in America has the same thoughts and beliefs. I didn't say I would be arrested for being Jewish but if I were to speak out against something I didn't believe in, then yes I probably would. And as far hating our government for supporting Mubarack's regime, we have different political parties, and not every member of every political party agreed. Yes some members of our government did support him. Were they wrong? That is for them to decide. But that doesn't represent our government completely. There is not ONE governement in the Middle East that does agree with us (outside of Israel) because we #1... give women freedom, #2 let people say what they want, #3 don't hate Christians, and (I can't believe I am agreeing with this) #4... We unfortunately have this stupid habit of sticking our nose where it doesn't belong. Oh and the 5th reason .... we don't think Israel should be bombed to pieces.
11:31 PM on 06/23/2011
Just because he served in the Israeli army doesn't make him a spy. Military service is mandatory in Israel just like it is in alot of countries. He made a bad decision , that doesn't make him any thing more than a person. I wouldn't want to do an internship in Egypt but, just because he has an education doesn't mean that he has common snense. There are alot of people out there that are educated idiots , meaning just because you have a college , or university education doesn't mean that you have any common sense.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
12:04 PM on 06/24/2011
hes american not israeli.
05:27 PM on 06/24/2011
He has DUAL CITIZENSHIP , that is what the article says.
05:29 PM on 06/24/2011
You obviously did not read the ENTIRE article if you did then you would know this. How is an American citizen going to become an Israeli paratrooper without being an Israeli citizen as well.