More

HuffPost Social Reading

Overscheduled Kids: How Too Many Activities Affect Moms And Dads

Overscheduled Kids And Stressed Out Parents

First Posted: 08/29/2011 4:47 pm Updated: 10/29/2011 5:12 am

Modern dance class. Lacrosse practice. Chinese lessons. With school starting, you may be evaluating your kids' schedules and how much they can manage. But, have you thought about what kind of toll their agenda takes on you?

"We have a generation of mothers and fathers who want to be all things to all people," said Dr. Kenneth Ginsburg, who specializes in adolescent medicine and behavioral issues at the Children's Hospital of Philadelphia. "They are willing to do so much self-sacrificing for their child."

Sound like you? Then it might be time to reevaluate what you're booking this season. Now, no one is suggesting you become a selfish parent and refuse to shuttle your kids back and forth to their favorite activities. But, Ginsburg said, "There's nothing more important for your child than for you to be doing well yourself."

According to a recent article in The New York Times, the number of activities your children are involved in doesn't necessarily have an impact on their chances for academic success later in life. It might, however, have a negative effect on a parent's emotional state, not to mention a family's finances.

On top of that, if you are constantly overstretched, you're probably not hiding it as well as you think: Research shows that kids not only sense it, but take on some of that stress themselves.

According to Betsy Brown Braun, a child development specialist and parent educator, one indicator that you've gone over the top is your physical appearance.

"When you look in the mirror and say, 'Is that me?'" Brown Braun says, that means you're probably doing too much. "When you look tired, you look stressed. You can tell, there are physical ramifications to stress."

Snapping at your spouse and kids more than usual -- enough so that you notice it's out of character for you -- is another clue that you may be over doing it. Also, if you're constantly rushing but never making it to anything on time, odds are you need to cut out some activities. The same goes for eating most of your meals over the kitchen sink. (And, when "meals" are scraps of chicken fingers or PB&J from your kids' plates because you don't have time to eat…that's not good either.)

If any (or all of this) is familiar to you, consider which activities are really worth all the stress they might be causing.

"Ask yourself, is it important that my child do this?" Brown Braun said. "Or am I really doing this for me? Is it because someone else is doing it? Is this something my child has asked for many times?"

You should also calculate whether everything you want to fit in is feasible. Julie Morgenstern, a time management expert, said one of the biggest mistakes parents make is being unrealistic about what they can accomplish in a given time frame.

"People tend to be over-optimistic and underestimate how long things really take," Morgenstern said. "There are hidden time costs to everything."

Take, for example, a simple activity like art class. There's the time it takes to get your kids to the class, to pick them up from the class and to coordinate with other parents on the days you can't drive them there (not to mention, it takes to time to buy supplies and help them with the art projects they'll inevitably be doing). These tasks quickly add up, Morgenstern said.

The good news is that there's nothing wrong with letting your kids enjoy non-scheduled time. Those moments can be productive for your child, as well as for you.

"You'll have more time to actually think, to talk, to listen, to be tuned into what's going on with your kids," Morgenstern said.

When you do manage to free up some time for yourself, you should have a list ready of what you want to accomplish -- or how you want to recharge -- so you can make the most of it.

"It could be a manicure, it could be going for a quick run, it could be talking to a friend," Morgenstern said. "When the time presents itself, you have your go-to options and you're not stopping to figure out, 'What do I do with this time?' You'll waste it trying to decide."

FOLLOW HUFFPOST PARENTS

Modern dance class. Lacrosse practice. Chinese lessons. With school starting, you may be evaluating your kids' schedules and how much they can manage. But, have you thought about what kind of toll the...
Modern dance class. Lacrosse practice. Chinese lessons. With school starting, you may be evaluating your kids' schedules and how much they can manage. But, have you thought about what kind of toll the...
 
 
  • Comments
  • 104
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Bloggers
Recency  | 
Popularity
Page: 1 2 3  Next ›  Last »  (3 total)
photo
On My Way 58
I try to think before posting
07:34 PM on 08/31/2011
Balance...it is all about balance. Kids need strucured time and activities as well as unstructured time and activities.

When we lose balance, things fall out of perspective and are done just to be done. Parents need to give their attention to the children, but only to a point. They need to be involved first in education, and then in recreation...not the other way around. Our educational system is NOT the best in the world, and we are losing our academic edge. That said, there also needs to be time set aside for recreation.

And, parents need to be the adults. It saddens me to see so many children in charge of what happens. "Date night" for parents is as important as any activity they have their chldren in.

Listen to the kids, too. They often leave us clues as to how THEY feel. There are things they ought not be in control of such as educational goals, but there are also things they should be in control of such as which activities make them happy.
photo
TXanimal
Somewhere between Occam's Razor & Murphy's Law
10:38 AM on 08/31/2011
Plus, it makes for overly-anxious kids who constantly need to be entertained. Kids need time to relax and find ways to entertain themselves in constructive ways too. Shuttling them from soccer to dance to taekwondo to guitar lessons makes them think the world revolves around them. They need to understand that their parents need down-time and extra-curricular activities as well.
06:57 PM on 08/30/2011
Parents, generally speaking, have the best intentions but too often it is easy to see the best for our children simply in the frame of spending money. Activities cost money, fuel to transport kids to activities cost money, kids are at greater risk of eating poorly, e.g fast food leading to other health issues and kids begin to think that enjoyment comes from simply spending money. Another poster cited the issue of time as valuable resource that is often overlooked as a great cost to families. We no longer connect in the intimacy of family but through the success or failure in externalities. Kids don't help prepare family meals, partake in the upkeep of the home or simply deal with boredom or engage in self reflection and they enter the world with the expectation that someone will always pat them on the head for a job well done or that they should be entertained.
06:39 PM on 08/30/2011
So much of this comes from the mistaken notion that if you start kids early and keep them involved in activities, they won't have time to get into trouble.

They also won't have time to daydream...to get bored and come up with a new idea about something...to read a book...to watch their favorite movie over and over again...to collect rocks...to watch ants build anthills (my personal fave from childhood)...to color in a meaningless coloring book...to make refrigerator magnets from scratch...to learn how to make cookies...and I could go on forever. These things are cheap and foster creativity as well as bond a family together.
07:18 PM on 08/30/2011
so true....
06:22 PM on 08/30/2011
PARENT'S NEED TO SLOW DOWN AND DO MORE AT HOME! Kid's today do NOT know how to cook, clean, sew or bake. They are not prepared to care of a home. Stop being so restless and spend some time at home. I think people run around so much to avoid unhappiness at home, don't you??
isisreptiles
I make no apologies for being who I am.
05:56 PM on 08/30/2011
I hate the way kids are pushed into one scheduled activity after another with no free time. I truly feel sorry for these overscheduled kids. Whatever happened to kids having lots of unstructured time to play, dream, and just do what they want to do, the way it was when I was growing up. Kids grow up and have stressful, overscheduled lives as adults. Let them be kids and enjoy their free time while they can.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
05:14 PM on 08/30/2011
Kids want to sign up for ANYTHING because the instructors make it sound GREAT. Bah ha ha Mom's need to say NO to somethings. Your kid does not need activities after school more than once a week.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
tomtlbjr7
05:11 PM on 08/30/2011
you yuppie breeder cows think you invented a better mouse trap. try letting your kids be kids. stop trying to impress everyone with your perfect family.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
05:19 PM on 08/30/2011
F& F'd I am a woman and I agree. All there children are 'gifted' bah ha ha I hated the 'school' mothers who sat, watched and gossiped about the children and their families.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
05:20 PM on 08/30/2011
....and the really overachieving mom's are the most completelyfuckedup. Popping the hydro and vodka bah ha ha
04:51 PM on 08/30/2011
I feel sad for the kids today because they just don't have the "free" childhood I had when growing up in the '40's and '50's. I tried to raise my kids the same way, but in the late '70's and '80's it was more difficult. There was more pressure to get kids involved in lots of activities, but my kids weren't really that interested in most of it. They came home from school and since I was home they had time to unwind from school and do what they wanted to do, playing outside, etc. In summer I did not get them involved in anything because we lived 1000 miles from their grandparents and we'd go visit them for several weeks each summer. That was the most important thing, that they have contact with all of their relatives that lived so far away. We had no family where we lived. They did not suffer because they didn't participate in every activity under the son. Both graduated from college and have good jobs and one of them is now a parent, again, trying to raise her children like she was raised - out of the rat race!!
isisreptiles
I make no apologies for being who I am.
06:10 PM on 08/30/2011
I grew up in the 50s and 60, and grew up as you did, and I am forever grateful for having had that experience. My parents encouraged activities, but only if I wanted to do them. I had no interest and wasn't pushed. I think I would have thrown myself off a bridge if I'd been forced into one scheduled activity after another. I would have hated it. The stress would have been unbearable.
06:44 PM on 08/31/2011
I was so thankful that I did have some piano and accordion lessons, but it was not a pressure situation. My piano teacher was a classmate's sister! We lived on the shore of a lake, so did all of the water sports in summer, snow/ice sports in winter, but all were on our own, nothing organized. My mother taught me how to sew, knit, crochet, cook, etc. and I'm very greatful to have those skills. We lived in a small town where friends and relatives just "dropped in" for visits and meals and everyone knew everyone. It was the PERFECT childhood and I feel so sad for kids today who just don't have that. It's go, go, go with both parents working, then off to all of their scheduled activities with no time to just do what they want to do or do nothing at all.
03:45 PM on 08/30/2011
I have a happy, naturally athletic 3rd grader. He takes karate (several years). He tried basketball and baseball last year and the coaches raved. Apparently, he is a also a natural gymnast and his gym teacher literally begged me to get him gymnastics classes. I am far from rich and we don't have time for everything, so he chose karate over gymnastics. I am not saying all this to brag, but it's difficult for me because he genuinely wants to do these things. I'm NOT living through my child. I wanted him to try a few things and pick one or two. I had no idea he would be so good at everything he tried, and now HE wants to do it all. Karate is done as part of an after school program so that is not stressful for us.

My new dilemma is that he was just accepted into one of the world's most prestigious boys choirs. It was HIS idea to audition at school. I honestly didn't even know he could sing, lol. This is a HUGE honor. The problem is that it's a huge commitment, and he won't do it if I make him quit any sport. Thank goodness he does well in school. His only almost weakness is math which he is about average in. I planned our fall menu two months ahead, so at least I won't be stressed about dinner. I know this isn't an advice board, but any advice would be greatly appreciated.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
05:06 PM on 08/30/2011
Wow, don't you just hate parents who think their kids are perfect? And to think, his ONLY AMOST weakness is math.

Unless it's the Vienna Boys Choir, I'm not impressed at all.

My advice? Take a pin and pop that big head of yours. A lot of kids are athletic. In fact, MOST kids who are in good shape do very well in most sports, and I highly doubt the gym coach BEGGED for you to put your son in gymnastics.

You know what I think? I think you're one of those mothers who thrive on compliments, and have a way of wording things so coaches and other people say things to reassure you that your son is normal.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
05:21 PM on 08/30/2011
I wonder about munchousers syndrome with that 'perfect mom'
10:56 AM on 08/31/2011
Wow, such venom. I don't think my kid is the greatest on the planet. I guess my tone came off like I was bragging, so I specifically said I wasn't but that is all you people saw apparently. My point is that he is genuinely great at these things so he wants to do them.

The coaches raves were completely unsolicited, so you are so wrong there it's not even funny. And I only brought that up to demonstrate that he is good, so he wants to continue to play. I never said he was the best ever or even that coaches said that, I just said they raved. And yes, the teacher did beg and used the word "please" several times.

I won't identify the choir because that is too much of my business, but they sing for Presidents and royalty, so yes it is a big deal. It would look great on a college application some day, and he would be able to travel around the world.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
05:08 PM on 08/30/2011
Are you kidding? No child at Third Grade should have so many options. I don't care if he is Bobby Fisher! A child needs down time to develop properly. Up in the morning, off to school, then activities, dinner, homework, shower, bedtime. There is no time for any pleasure in this childs life. He should be able to go outside, sit under a tree and hear the birds, or run and play with other kids. These 'classes' are not a place for children to interact together. All the while Mom running him all over town pushing 'snacks' on him between activities. Do yourself a favor. No 3rd grader singing is a HUGE honor. He can do it at 7th grade and it would still be an honor. You are planning your dinner menus for an entire season? You do not have time to cook? Cook with your child helping you in the kitchen and have some quality time. You sound like one of those over-achieving Mom's that said 'my child could read at 3 years of age' ha ha big deal. All kids learn to read. He can still end up digging ditches or being a druggy. Take a BIG CHILL PILL Mom. geez
09:49 PM on 08/30/2011
I loved cooking with my mum when I was younger...I think you're right it is a great way to spend quality time together and keep your child occupied at the same time.
11:09 AM on 08/31/2011
Umm..he only does Karate year round. The most he has ever done at one time is two activites. You do know that basketball and baseball are two different seasons? HE wants to do these things, and if you actually read my post you would see that I did say no to gymnastics.

And you have no idea how wrong you are about my parenting style. The dinner menus were so I could try to stay organized. I am not super mom, and I need to figure out ways to decrease stress. The choir is world famous and it is a tremendous honor, so yes it is a big deal. And no, he can't start in the 7th grade because he would have to leave when his voice changes. My dilemma was that I DON"T WANT him to be overscheduled, so I was trying to figure out a way to be able do the choir since he says he won't do it if he can't play sports. He is really good at sports, so HE wants to play.

He also plenty of free play time. If you read my post you would have seen that he does karate after school. He would be in an after school program regardless because I work. I was hoping that someone would have advice and not snark and judgement. I guess the moment I said that he is very athletic, no one cared what else I had to say.
03:32 PM on 08/30/2011
I've noticed that lots of people don't consider that time is a resource, just like money and fuel etc. The less open time you have, the more valuable it is compared to your other resources. Keep that in mind.
04:28 PM on 08/30/2011
When you have kids....you, as the parent, lose all your free time to kids. Actually, you lose everything about you because of kids.
05:21 PM on 08/30/2011
No, you're choosing to give all your free time to your kids. You are at their beck and call by choice.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
05:56 PM on 08/30/2011
Why? Who said so? Who wrote the rules that say the kids are the center of their parents' universe? What a dangerous concept. What a dangerous behavior.

Kids are a part of a family. Parents are equally as important as their offspring. There is no reason for parents to make their children the center of their universe. It isn't healthy for the kids, or for the adult relationship between parents, and it's results are kids who think everyone elses world revolves around them. It doesn't.
03:05 PM on 08/30/2011
The other risk with stressing out about your kids' activities is that if they sense you resent having to drive them all over, they may decide to drop an activity they like just to make things easier for everybody.

My daughter started to feel that way about dance class, but I reassured her that it fit in fine with our schedule and that her enjoyment and the rewards of dance were important to all of us. She stayed with it until she decided it wasn't cool (which was code for: My instructor is making me do some really hard moves, I think I'll try chorus with my friends)
photo
Charlotte Reznick
Author, The Power of Your Child's Imagination, chi
03:04 PM on 08/30/2011
As a child educational psychologist, and great believer in kids' imagination (I wrote about that in The Power of Your Child's Imagination) I find so many kids are stressed out and anxious because they don't have enough free down time. Parents are trying to do their best and want to help their kids develop a well-rounded education, are concerned about too much screen time (video games, TV) and that the streets aren't as safe as we'd like them to be (they just can't always say go outside and play on their own), so this is a big question of balance. Please let me know how you are balancing your families life... DrReznick@ImageryForKids.com
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Fran Jaime
My micro-bio is empty but my life is full!
06:38 PM on 08/30/2011
When I started as an ESL teacher, here in Mexico, in the 70's, I had to teach a kids' summer course. I didn't have any kids then but I learned a lot! Most of the kids took not just English but also karate or some other sport and at least two more activities sot that by the time they got home, they just fall into bed! Later on, I taught in a school and saw that the kids were hustled from one activity to another after school and everyone (moms and kids) looked frazzled. I decided to take a different route my children. During summer vacations, we would pack a bagpack, pick a place in the city map and go there or sometimes stay in and watch movies or play games. During the school year, they took one activity after school. The rest of the afternoons were for doing homework, reading, just hanging around and talking. My older daughter is now 34 and a talented drummer. The younger one is in High School has good grades and goes to a theater workshop.
I've said this before, they are kids for a very short time and adults forever. Let them have fun!
02:26 PM on 08/30/2011
to many activities creates ADD children - they never complete one task before they move on to another - i have taught children from 5 and up and have seen this happen. one after school activity and then some quality time with the parents - i have used this as practice in raising my own children and have some very imaginative, responsible and respectful young women.
09:57 AM on 09/02/2011
Sorry that statement about ADD, just isn't true. Ask a neurologist.
02:02 PM on 08/30/2011
Have a brother-in-law who used to "flash card" his kid when he was about a year and a half old. Now the kid, eighteen years old, can hardly walk and chew gum at the same time.
02:09 PM on 08/30/2011
To be fair, most eighteen year old boys can hardly walk and chew gum at the same time. :)
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
12:16 PM on 08/31/2011
Good one.