iPhone app iPad app Android phone app Android tablet app More

Family Of Annie Le Sues Yale University

First Posted: 09/08/2011 8:09 am Updated: 11/08/2011 4:12 am

By DAVE COLLINS, Associated Press

HARTFORD, Conn. — The family of a Yale University graduate student killed in a research lab just days before she had planned to get married in 2009 sued the Ivy League school Tuesday, claiming it had failed to adequately protect women on campus for years.

The wrongful death lawsuit was filed in New Haven Superior Court by lawyers for the family of Annie Le, a 24-year-old Placerville, Calif., native whose strangled body was found stuffed upside-down in a wall at the Yale lab building on Sept. 13, 2009. That was the same day of her scheduled wedding and five days after she disappeared. Prosecutors also said there was evidence of a sexual assault.

Yale officials said in a statement Tuesday that the lawsuit had no merit and no additional security measures could have prevented the killing.

An animal research technician who worked in the same building, Raymond Clark III, was sentenced to 44 years in prison in June for murdering Le. He apologized for the crime at the sentencing hearing, but offered no explanation.

The lawsuit claims that before Le's killing, Yale had for years failed to take adequate steps to protect women on the New Haven campus. It also claims school officials should have known that Clark posed a potential danger to Le's safety, because he had previously demonstrated aggressive behavior and a "violent propensity towards women."

In April, the U.S. Department of Education's Office for Civil Rights confirmed that it was investigating complaints by Yale University students that the university had a sexually hostile environment and failed to adequately respond to sexual harassment concerns.

"Yale's persistent tolerance of sexual harassment and sexual assaults on campus caused students to file (the) complaint against Yale University," the Le family's lawyers, New York-based Joseph Tacopina and Stamford, Conn.-based Paul Slager, said in a statement Tuesday. "And, just five days before she was to be married, Annie Le was a victim of that environment."

The lawsuit, which names Yale University and its medical school, only says it is seeking an unspecified amount of money greater than $15,000, which is standard in Connecticut when lawsuits are first filed. The damages and legal fees sought by the plaintiffs could total in the millions of dollars.

The Yale statement said the lawsuit "serves neither justice nor Annie's memory, and the university will defend against it as appropriate."

"Yale had no information indicating that Raymond Clark was capable of committing this terrible crime, and no reasonable security measures could have prevented his unforeseeable act," the statement said.

The building and labs where Le and Clark worked were accessible only to people with security cards that had to be swiped through security boxes.

A spokesman for the Le family didn't return a phone message Tuesday.

Relatives previously have said that what should have been a joyous wedding suddenly turned into mourning the loss of a woman whose research included finding new treatments for chronic diseases. She was a doctoral pharmacology student who worked on a team that experimented on mice as part of research into enzymes that could have implications for the treatment of cancer, diabetes and muscular dystrophy.

Lab workers told police that Clark was controlling and viewed the lab and its mice as his territory.

Clark pleaded guilty in March to murder and attempted sexual assault under an agreement with prosecutors. The sexual assault plea was entered under the Alford doctrine, where the defendant doesn't agree with the allegations but concedes the state has enough evidence to get a conviction.

Prosecutors said there was evidence that Clark tried after the killing to generate an alibi, scrub the crime scene and even fish evidence out from behind the wall. Clark appeared happy in surveillance video taken before the killing, but later he was alone with his face in his hands at a time authorities believe was after the killing, authorities said.

Authorities said Le had broken bones and that her underwear had been disarranged. She was 4 feet 9 inches tall and weighed 89 pounds, while Clark was 5-foot-9 and 190 pounds.

Prosecutors also cited DNA evidence, including Clark's semen and a pen under Le's body that had her blood and Clark's DNA. Court papers describe a bloody crime scene and Clark's efforts to scrub floors. Investigators say Clark tried to hide a box of cleaning wipes that later was found to have traces of Le's blood.

FOLLOW HUFFPOST COLLEGE

Filed by Leah Finnegan  | 
 
 
  • Comments
  • 88
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
Page: 1 2 3  Next ›  Last »  (3 total)
06:04 PM on 10/16/2011
New York Law School's blog, "Legal as She is Spoke," explores the validity of the victim's estate's wrongful death claim that Yale's negligence contributed to the violence that resulted in her death.

Check it out!

http://www.lasisblog.com/2011/10/10/did-yale-university-fail-to-prevent-murder/
09:38 AM on 10/04/2011
They could have installed cameras in every hall, nook and cranny; but NOOOOOOO, they didn't want to spend the...........................MONEY!!!!!!!!!!!!!! EVERYTHING IN LIFE IS ALL ABOUT THE DO RE MI!
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
10:14 AM on 09/10/2011
Whodathunk that Yale, a bastion of white male WASP supremacy, could foster any 'tude about women being treated with respect?
:-/
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
paid troll
i couldn't find an XXXL flag costume
08:46 PM on 09/09/2011
so many here with intimate knowledge of the case. you have it all figured out.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
JustinP213
I dislike all political parties.
04:48 PM on 09/09/2011
Of course. Someone is tragically killed. The person's parents sue. Nothing surprising about this. So predictable.
02:58 PM on 09/08/2011
I honestly don't see how added security could have saved this young lady. Short of being a mind reader no one could have. If someone decides they're going to do something they will do it one way or another. No amount of money will bring her back. They might possibly be lashing out because of the torment they're going thru. That's understandable.
Seems like everybody that stumps their big toe in this day and age are suing for one reason or another. I'm not against it but only if someone is negligent or it's done deliberately.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
10:16 AM on 09/10/2011
Finding your daughter's corpse raped and stuffed behind a wall on the day she was to have been married...v. "stump[ing] your big toe."
Thanks for playing.
02:53 PM on 09/08/2011
"Yale had for years failed to take adequate steps to protect women on the New Haven campus"
.......How can you prove this?........If true, Yale would have been sued allot sooner
02:38 PM on 09/08/2011
A horrible tragedy enhanced by the parents blaming those not involved. It's like blaming a state after a horrible crash on their roadways.
02:34 PM on 09/08/2011
While I understand the family's pain that is driving this lawsuit, unfortunately our workplace environments and even in social settings are safe only up to a point. People working right next to you may be deeply disturbed but not to the point you fear for your safety. In our society stress can also trigger psychological disturbances and how can anyone predict a worst case senario. We all need to be vigilant, but unless someone as acted out and management didn't nothing to monitor or even fire--what else can be done. I just don't think this lawsuit is fair, but I do feel for the family for their terrible loss.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
P Markham72
02:33 PM on 09/08/2011
I agree with most, suing accomplishes nothing, at the same time I can never imagine, nor do I want to the pain and everything else that comes along with such a tragedy for the family. She certainly seemed to have everything going for her and to have to deal with something like that is unimaginable.
02:20 PM on 09/08/2011
All too often lawsuits seek to assign blame to anyone other then the perpetrator. If the school knew that Raymond Clark was dangerous to others then it might be argued they were partly negligent. Unfortunately the article doesn't give enough information to establish what if any liability the college had.

I would respect a lawsuit seeking monetary damages where money awarded in excess of the amount needed to bring the matter to trial was donated to a third party non-profit instead of the grieving family. The sue for big money mentality that accompanies lawsuits may diminish the credibility of why damages are being sought in the name of the victim.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
10:17 AM on 09/10/2011
"Unfortunat­ely the article doesn't give enough informatio­n to establish what if any liability the college had."
Then why continue your pointless POV?
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
lhanderson86
02:19 PM on 09/08/2011
No amount of sexual harassment training and sexual assault awareness will stop a sexual predator from killing a woman. It's a sad truth, but a truth nonetheless. Sometimes there is nothing you can do to stop something horrible from happening. It's easy to blame someone after the fact, but the blame should be on the psycho who killed her, and no one else.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
10:18 AM on 09/10/2011
Convenient.
Any facts to back up your certainly?
02:02 PM on 09/10/2011
These institutions are places of business providing a service to customers. If a cleaning service came to your house to clean, and their employee robbed you or killed you or committed a crime, they would be responsible for the behavior of their employee. That is why they are licensed, insured or bonded. I see no reason why this logic does not apply to the educational system. They should be responsible for the actions of their employees.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Joel Kent Melville
02:08 PM on 09/08/2011
look at that guys face he has no remorse or guilt for what he has done. that woman was innocent hope someone rapes him in prison to see how he likes it....
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
yoyo1900
02:08 PM on 09/08/2011
Yale University is not culpable. There is no way one can predict the behavior of another employee unless there were obvious warnings prior to the death. If this case has a positve outcome then every employee would have to have his or her own security guard.
01:59 PM on 09/08/2011
Sounds like Yale women need to enroll in weapon training.
01:57 PM on 09/10/2011
Yale and Idaho and Georgia and Alabama. When do these institutions begin to take responsibility? They are providing a service to customers; they are not dictators.